@7antifahooligan You definitely can't compare them, but only because theyre completely different styles. Tarja was GREAT, no question about that. However, Annette is very good too, just different.
@ETL19 It's a remake of the principal song of the musical comedy "The phantom of the opera" composed by Andrew Lloyd Webber. The original is the best version.
EPIC!!! Shame she had to become an uber bitch. Annette does well, put on an amazing show here in VA a few years back, but she does not have the range that Tarja had, but gives Nightwish the female folksy sound they were originally looking for.
@Korgon2013 Awh come on don't call her a bitch. A story has two sides and the band had five members. So you can't just put all the blame on one person, that wouldn't be fair. We will never no what happened. The whole thing happened over 6 years ago, people need to stop hating on Tarja or Anette ;)
I fucking love Nightwish but some of it's fans like the weeping crying emo retards (0:29) who make up for a lack of never experiencing actual non-superficial childish emotions by whining and trying to find something "deeper" in everything for the mere sake of overcompensation, make me hate Nightwish "fans" - it's literally like the whole Janeite "phenomenon" (ok probably not best example - but you get the point, pop-tards can spoil a classical broth if they like it)
My own honest opinion is that this one's almost as good as any other version, and that's mainly 'cos of Marco's voice. To me he sounds like a phantom should sound.. A bit "scary" and a bit mysterious. What comes to the female voice, I have to say I prefer Brightman. This version is not "THE WORST EVER", not even close. The composition as for "a heavier version" is as good as it can get. Fortunately people are different, otherwise they'd be no civilized arguments :)
Sarah Brightman can't even compete with herself these days- her voice has gone downhill horribly so much so that she (sarah) has resorted to lip synching. How sad!
@ThunderTigers No.. they r crying because they r fucking fags. I mean come on guys, this is an excelent band and all that shit but there's no reason to cry. "Oh my god I peed in my gothic pants cause I saw some good music".
Their lifes gotta be realy bad if they get as happy as they seem.
@ramezmn Don't tell me you've never expected the awesome moment when the music you're listening to is so fucking good you get shivers running up your spine, tears rising to your eyes...
I'll agree, they kinda overdo it. But it's not totally absurd either.
hell yeah! i love the combination of Tarja's opera voice with the heavy metal voice of Marco. so amazing, especially for a phantom of the opera fan like me. the band and the fans looked like they were having so much fun.
Ты с песней тьмы ночной, пришел во сне. И имя музыка шептала мне. Порой мне кажется, что наяву Сказал мне призрак оперы слова – в тебе живу. Споем дуэтом мы, как ночь и день. Пусть ярче свет горит – сильнее тень. Взглянув, ты, может быть, смогла понять Что призрак оперы внутри должна принять. Не только образ, но и сумрак свой Под маской из меня от них сокрой. Пусть голос мой идет из глубины Я дам талант свой музыке твоей - едины мы.
Yes. really the best version of this song. Marco sounds much more "manly" than any other guy performing it. His voice is just a little too scratchy which makes the low notes sound quite grunty, other than that he is simply amazing.
This version is better that anyone's else because Tarja has a very feminine voice, and Marco a very powerful and truly masculine one. He makes Antonio Banderas look like a pussy (in boots).
No offence, Antonio Banderas, you did a great job in Shrek but you can't mess with this guy.
those 1086 people should listen to bieber less
YGiro 1 day ago
@YGiro They SHOULD NOT listen to him. There's good music abound after all...
tumppu1975 20 hours ago
i will never get bored watching this.
vvvvkamilvvv 2 days ago 2
I like this better than new Nightwish, but new nightwish is fine.
GamingWithStatoke 2 days ago
thumbs up if you're watching this video in 2012!
gulobru 2 days ago
doesn't matter how many times I hear this song. I get goosebumbs when she hits that high note at the end. \m/
JoeyFNFingers 2 days ago
RRRRREEEESSSSPEEECCCCTTT!!!!!!!
NakisDrummer 4 days ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This band is so epic live . Amazing sound amazing music
daffri1 6 days ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ρε γαμωτο!
eargasm
deathcomenearme19 6 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I also hate all these comparisons between Tarja and Anette, but still...when Tarja sings with Marco, it kinda' gives you shivers.
rehabuca 6 days ago 14
i am speechless
cartooniloony 1 week ago
can somebody tell me the names of these two fantastic singers??
4jimaras 1 week ago
@4jimaras Tarja Turunen and Marco Hietala
DittaKruspe 1 week ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Nightwish
@DittaKruspe thanks
4jimaras 1 week ago
Tarja was AWESOME, Anette is also good, but Marco is jsut GODLIKE
MrDeadMan4 1 week ago
so fuckin epic!!!
moskuseater 1 week ago
Tuomas is so hot ! *__* <3
cynthia97420 1 week ago
i'm not exactly sure why those girls in the beginning were soo emotional haha
ricoa283 1 week ago
WOW! Magical!
Sailboatsx 1 week ago
nightwish con tarja y marco era lo maaassss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
isiti993 1 week ago
pésimo publico realmente.. tienen que aprender del público ARGENTINO! tiembla hasta el escenario... ahi solo aplauden.. :P
isiti993 1 week ago
@isiti993 Eso ella dijo en una entrevista en Argetina! Y en espanol. Ella digo que Europa solo aplauden.
MrFenderguitar08 1 week ago
Annete SUCK'S
Tarja RULES
Joovoor 1 week ago 4
@Joovoor Tarja's GONE
Deal with it
FreddyMercry 1 week ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Nightwish
@Joovoor i totally agree with you...you can't compare them...
7antifahooligan 1 week ago
@7antifahooligan You definitely can't compare them, but only because theyre completely different styles. Tarja was GREAT, no question about that. However, Annette is very good too, just different.
soasertsus 1 week ago
1:00 girl got orgasm
ofekagr 1 week ago 28
Comment removed
kapidark 6 days ago
EPIC!!!!!! <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3
Frost894 1 week ago
Hello from Israel
Love this song its so dramtic with Tarja voice
adartzt 1 week ago
huge orgasm.
btw, I'm a girl
a7xrules95 1 week ago
@3:30 Marco, come here and take me....!!! That voice is soooo sexy for me.
YouAreMyDreamLove 1 week ago
Tarja please come back, Nightwish is not the same without you u_u
YouAreMyDreamLove 1 week ago 66
@YouAreMyDreamLove no its not your right about that
LordAkronos 1 week ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@YouAreMyDreamLove Sucks what Tarja turned into, seen any of her new stuff? Eesh, I'm kinda glad Nightwish got rid of her.
mario11168 3 days ago
@YouAreMyDreamLove Tarja never left, she was fired by the rest of the band in an open letter.
combatgong 2 days ago
@vodkaskateteam because of fuck u
xxfaterxx 1 week ago 3
why that gay people are crying?
VodkaSkateTeam 2 weeks ago
1:14 I can feel the organ's fume inside my body...
ThePedrodarigan 2 weeks ago in playlist Classic Music
END OF THE ERAS REST IN ROCK
KIRILRR 2 weeks ago
This is a very good song, but they deliberately massacred it!!! This is a crime to ALW!
Duxblah 2 weeks ago
@Duxblah this is a remake of another song? which one is it?
ETL19 2 weeks ago
@ETL19 It's a remake of the principal song of the musica
Duxblah 2 weeks ago
@ETL19 It's a remake of the principal song of the musical comedy "The phantom of the opera" composed by Andrew Lloyd Webber. The original is the best version.
Duxblah 2 weeks ago
siempre amare esta cancion cantada por Tarja Turunen
ItsJehs 2 weeks ago
Wow... i'm sweating right now, too epic :'D
XcrunkXloverX 2 weeks ago
I get so worked up... Her voice makes my palms sweat and my heart thud <3
SarcasmicSweetie2013 2 weeks ago
Chills And Shivers Everytime Tarja COME BACK.!!! D'x
KiwiTropicalBlast 2 weeks ago
1,083 fans of the whore with bitchy voice Anetee :@ Tarja we want you back!!! :'(
AntraxKruspe 2 weeks ago
This song proves two things:
1. Tarja isn't a "mediocre" soprano. She's great
2. Listen to Marco. Is it really "the new girl" the member that cant sing?
Dimitrendy 2 weeks ago
Muitos fãs diriam uma heresia á música metalizar ela dessa forma....
mas sinceramente... o/ Eu Gostei ^^
rafamg12 2 weeks ago
@rafamg12 gosto? essa musica e perfeita e simplismente uma das melhores do night
Venthoso 2 weeks ago
i need money to buy a new computer,so I'll dress like Tarja and make a porn with a nutria
MrFrederico150 2 weeks ago
i still think 1:05 is Jukka's regret for wanting Tarja out...
dingetje 2 weeks ago
1:04 orgasm !
Un6aBe3ii 2 weeks ago
Hermosa Tarja en el minuto 1:19 xD.... wow!!! que voz! que grupo!!
alessita1 3 weeks ago
the voice witch calls to me......
dede19891 3 weeks ago
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, fuck
MarianoMoralesR 3 weeks ago
i've watched this countless times, and my reaction is ALWAYS the same: teary eyes, shivers, the hairs on my arm all standing, and headbanging.
raphasmr 3 weeks ago
Spectacular!!
As always, Tarja.. luv yah..
MsBem23 3 weeks ago
240p, we meet again....
Ravenq222 3 weeks ago
hot girl....... nice fuch...she has
logaritme 3 weeks ago
YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3
CosplayCore 3 weeks ago
they sound so good live! not with anette though, lol
ILikePwningNoobs 3 weeks ago
1078 people have really fucking bad music taste x(
xxxxxXJiraiyaXxxxxx 3 weeks ago
I don't really like Nightwish but this is epic!
oi565 3 weeks ago
GREAT VOCAL!
C00lorWhat 3 weeks ago
LMFAO.
briannezenel 4 weeks ago
Comment removed
HuuDsoulL 4 weeks ago
<3
JonnyWolff1 4 weeks ago
@iosonodella2i trolololololol :D
dkgang211 4 weeks ago
Piękny utwór, ale zdecydowanie nie w wykonaniu Nightwish
Lilith67015 1 month ago
MELHOR VERSÃO
braianbuttner 1 month ago
FODAAAA
braianbuttner 1 month ago
FUCKING GOD MUSIC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
misterkurt89 1 month ago
marco's going lemmy on that bass
aswesee 1 month ago
Tarja!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AskaCloud 1 month ago
marcos é melhor que a tarja
MrJodaias 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Nightwish
Tarjaaa (*≧▽≦)
baguskartika 1 month ago
EPIC!!! Shame she had to become an uber bitch. Annette does well, put on an amazing show here in VA a few years back, but she does not have the range that Tarja had, but gives Nightwish the female folksy sound they were originally looking for.
Korgon2013 1 month ago
@Korgon2013 Awh come on don't call her a bitch. A story has two sides and the band had five members. So you can't just put all the blame on one person, that wouldn't be fair. We will never no what happened. The whole thing happened over 6 years ago, people need to stop hating on Tarja or Anette ;)
charici 4 weeks ago
Andrew Lloyd Webber would despise this
timcullen31 1 month ago
:epiccry:
quilombero83 1 month ago
at 1:05 the girl on the right is having an eargasm
Kimmichan36 1 month ago
what is she saying at the end of the song?
Gothicapped20 1 month ago
@Gothicapped20 Kii tos. It's Finnish for Thank you.
randomchaoticmadness 1 month ago
i think i saw brad pit at 3:52
balbaltikful 1 month ago
@balbaltikful no its whats his name who plays obi wan
DeadKold 1 month ago
this song is beauty.
LilReaper608 1 month ago
L<3VE this track:))))
alexcanond500 1 month ago
Marco is Zakk Wylde's lost brother XD
MaGicSb3 1 month ago 39
@MaGicSb3 I love this^^
COMISKEY23 1 week ago
ohh marco <3
georgiasnipper 1 month ago
This is truly a beautiful song, re-done by very talented artists. AWESOME!
1000Demons 1 month ago
at the end she calls the peeps from jersey shore: GUIDOOOSSS!
kukishop 1 month ago
NIESAMOWITE!
dodsab 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Nightwish
idę zabić 1072 osoby
Werciolatka 1 month ago
To all of you: THIS IS AWESOME!!!
1000Demons 1 month ago 2
240p here we meet again ...
g0r3z5 1 month ago 2
excelente
escorpio519 1 month ago
epic song by epic band is epic
Technographie 1 month ago
me gusta
conrad2006a1 1 month ago
Usually I don't listen to such music but this is simply AMAZING !!! Goosebumps...
gasiorify 1 month ago in playlist Liked videos
This is what people hear when they claim to have heard the voice of God.
MrHeavenThunder 1 month ago
damn Tarja is so hawt......
FatesDenial 1 month ago
4:44 bigos !
Damson19 1 month ago
are those truly humans?
akoularas 1 month ago
@akoularas
pumawsroda0 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I fucking love Nightwish but some of it's fans like the weeping crying emo retards (0:29) who make up for a lack of never experiencing actual non-superficial childish emotions by whining and trying to find something "deeper" in everything for the mere sake of overcompensation, make me hate Nightwish "fans" - it's literally like the whole Janeite "phenomenon" (ok probably not best example - but you get the point, pop-tards can spoil a classical broth if they like it)
nietzscheprime 1 month ago 5
Comment removed
nietzscheprime 1 month ago
Me Emcanta NigthWish mi papa Me Deja Ver las geabaciones de conciertos
LinkinCris1 1 month ago
I had a oragasm.Lol
belindasierra 1 month ago
Thumbs up for gothic metal! Because it makes girls look hot!
TheLordOfCoal 1 month ago
fucking epic!!!!!!!!!
jasperhale1864 1 month ago
This version send chills down my spine, specially on the final session of notes that Tarja perfectly does <3
jaaojf 1 month ago
Comment removed
bruna21914 1 month ago
4:15 WOW
Avramopoulos1 1 month ago
This woman has an outstanding voice!!!
Love it!!
TheDanseren 1 month ago
holy fuck this is one of the most epic songs
DeadKold 1 month ago
AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!
Zvezdopadik 1 month ago
Marco simply the best !!!!!
jaducca73 1 month ago
Tarja is better just a word than Anette and Tuomas. her difference is that the others, she sings songs by heart...
Greetings from Azerbaijan
MrDavid6984 1 month ago
1:13 oh wait!
hsto1 1 month ago
2:48 --> "The Phantom of the Oprah"?!
KathlynDeathEater 1 month ago
Co ja pacze ?;o
bizonek76 1 month ago
@bizonek76 Wypierdalaj na kwejka.
Sutek222 1 month ago
tarja we miss you with nightwish :(
Gunter1748 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Nightwish
Love this version!
KillyDQ 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
Every man and women in the audience just came
sniperofdeath 1 month ago
No words.......just enjoy.....
KathlynDeathEater 1 month ago
keedos? kudos!
fenrirgg 1 month ago
@fenrirgg kiitos its mean thank you
adisthebeast 1 month ago
@adisthebeast Alright. Thanks for teaching =P
Kiitos? Kudos!
fenrirgg 1 month ago
End of an era, but start of even more awesome era
MrSorsis 1 month ago
My own honest opinion is that this one's almost as good as any other version, and that's mainly 'cos of Marco's voice. To me he sounds like a phantom should sound.. A bit "scary" and a bit mysterious. What comes to the female voice, I have to say I prefer Brightman. This version is not "THE WORST EVER", not even close. The composition as for "a heavier version" is as good as it can get. Fortunately people are different, otherwise they'd be no civilized arguments :)
tespiii 1 month ago
That girl cannot compete with the great Sarah Brightman, that high notes are nothing beside Sarah.
macabrojavier 1 month ago
@macabrojavier
Sarah Brightman can't even compete with herself these days- her voice has gone downhill horribly so much so that she (sarah) has resorted to lip synching. How sad!
DarkWingsAscending 1 month ago
the guy in 2:57 !! <3 :3
MarkoSkeleton 1 month ago
0:29 they're crying! because its so fucking EPIC!
ThunderTigers 1 month ago 64
@ThunderTigers No.. they r crying because they r fucking fags. I mean come on guys, this is an excelent band and all that shit but there's no reason to cry. "Oh my god I peed in my gothic pants cause I saw some good music".
Their lifes gotta be realy bad if they get as happy as they seem.
ramezmn 1 month ago
@ramezmn Don't tell me you've never expected the awesome moment when the music you're listening to is so fucking good you get shivers running up your spine, tears rising to your eyes...
I'll agree, they kinda overdo it. But it's not totally absurd either.
Shaltinanwenor 1 month ago 55
@Shaltinanwenor way over did lol she looks like she just got a really good orgasm lol
metalkingdom100 1 month ago
@Shaltinanwenor you left out the part where your nipples get hard :]
DeadKold 1 month ago
@Shaltinanwenor couldnt agree more. nicely said
Borosanac 1 month ago
@Shaltinanwenor eargasm B| fuck yea
Purkotant 4 weeks ago
@Shaltinanwenor Maybe when an actual good part starts, but not when the song just starts and is still basically in the 'intro' stage.
PS: Nightwish's version is this song is utter crap, so I don't see why people are crying over it.
dexluther 2 weeks ago
@ramezmn : Hmm... let's examine your statement.
a) People cry for various reasons. One day, you may learn that.
b) Excellent is spelled differently than you wrote.
c) Emotion affects people differently. "Fag" is not the word you need to use here.
1000Demons 1 month ago
@ThunderTigers emo
danieljuliolanyon 1 month ago
@ThunderTigers Captain Obvious
Suriner1 1 month ago
awesome
BeeHietalo 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
2:25 Evil professor!!!
Cioskar 1 month ago
2:27 Evil professor!!!
Cioskar 1 month ago
I love this version Tarja and Marco really nailed it :)
JaxxieToxic 1 month ago
Only Emmy Rossum can hold a candle to Tarja in this video, and it's a dim light.
TimelapsedArk 1 month ago
this is so freaking amazing! <3
Souseiseki2000 1 month ago
hell yeah! i love the combination of Tarja's opera voice with the heavy metal voice of Marco. so amazing, especially for a phantom of the opera fan like me. the band and the fans looked like they were having so much fun.
kaitoukatsumi 1 month ago
PavelKrycekLV 1 month ago
OMG they will be at the gibson amphitheatre on 1/21/12...my birthday weekend!!!
HardangelfanLP 1 month ago
Is true, Nightwish "the end of an era" ;s
pedroocaaa 1 month ago
como cagan los comerciales!!!!!
baxterlp 1 month ago
DUDE I SWEAR I GAVE THE REPLY BUTTON AN ANNAL SEX i raped it .respect for tarja <3
patourza 1 month ago
This was cool! love the video.
january14n 1 month ago
Yes. really the best version of this song. Marco sounds much more "manly" than any other guy performing it. His voice is just a little too scratchy which makes the low notes sound quite grunty, other than that he is simply amazing.
arangor82 1 month ago in playlist Nightwish+The Phantom Of The Opera.
I LOVE TARJA <3
vampirexgirlxd 2 months ago
oh yeah, by the way, that was really good!!
oomwillem10 2 months ago
strange combination, grunting and the opera-thingy at 3:40 and so on :O
oomwillem10 2 months ago
Tarja sing very good. but the real talent is Marco and Tuomas
yurigoncalvesaraujo 2 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
so Im a young girl with the most incredible smile
angelbabe197 2 months ago
Nightwish nyt ja aina!
MrNaah 2 months ago
JOHNNY DEPP!!!!
TweetMyFaceOnUtube 2 months ago
Comment removed
noctrl208 2 months ago
Comment removed
noctrl208 2 months ago
This version of The Phantom of the Opera is SICK AS FUCK!
SorafiLynn 2 months ago
Damn. This is the business lol.
phxHLsuns 2 months ago
the old Nightwish is THE BEST NIGHTWISH.....
crusaderofhell 2 months ago 9
@crusaderofhell thumb up for him is right please :)
i love old nightwish
BFVScreamAimFire 1 month ago
უძლიერესია ეს ლაივი :X
QeeTsooNaa 2 months ago
un descanso para mi corazon esta cancion me escapa de mi realidad
yurenisilva26 2 months ago
amo a tarja . nightwish sem ela naum pe nada!
666justiceira666 2 months ago
This version is better that anyone's else because Tarja has a very feminine voice, and Marco a very powerful and truly masculine one. He makes Antonio Banderas look like a pussy (in boots).
No offence, Antonio Banderas, you did a great job in Shrek but you can't mess with this guy.
Alinner27 2 months ago 121
@Alinner27 dude, Marco's beard would kick Antonio Banderas' ass and not wake Marco up :P
angrynordicmidget 2 months ago
@Alinner27 Marco and Antonio don't even sing in the same style dude. Trying to compare them like that is just stupid.
brakoify 1 month ago