HATE this performance so much. I love the original by Melissa, but Kimberly sounds like a drunk girl at karaoke that is way ahead of the music, she also has the lyrics wrong. That's not "making it" her own either, that's ruining it.
One of the best American Idol Videos ever taken or done ... Kimberly Caldwell was (and still is) a great singer, and I am waiting for her new album to be released this summer in 2010.
she sounded pitchy here. But I totally love Kimberly's big vocal voice tone
nikaledesma 10 months ago
HATE this performance so much. I love the original by Melissa, but Kimberly sounds like a drunk girl at karaoke that is way ahead of the music, she also has the lyrics wrong. That's not "making it" her own either, that's ruining it.
BMPmama698 1 year ago
@BMPmama698 Don't hate her because she's not a lesbian.
18andONEGIANTLOSS 9 months ago
@BMPmama698 I completely agree!
FM897 4 months ago
wow old school idol when there was no audience making them more scared before the big stage
HERBLANDZ 1 year ago
One of the best American Idol Videos ever taken or done ... Kimberly Caldwell was (and still is) a great singer, and I am waiting for her new album to be released this summer in 2010.
CornStoveIowa 1 year ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what was cook thinking hooking up with her???
Parkette1 2 years ago
This is still one of the most memorable Idol performances, for me personally. I LOVED her take on this song. So great.
skylarandmoose 2 years ago 19
I Love this performance
chadebeterraba 2 years ago 12
I am not a fan of her at all, but I LOVED the vocals here
DragonSlayer1500 3 years ago
haha i guess so.. i jsut dont like her (kim) at all, sorry
fruitx4yay 3 years ago
She reminds me of Sally from Third Rock From the Sun. lol
TheaterMarine88 3 years ago