Since when did the Constitution mean anything to these people? Why don't we say this, as long as they're stripping the Bill of Rights, we'll reciprocally strip the parts of the Constitution endowing the Executive with any power.
ADDINGTON: Sir, perhaps the best that can be said is that the vice president belongs neither to the executive nor to the legislative branch, but is attached by the constitution to the latter.
So according to Addington, the Vice President is his own branch of government, or part of the Executive and the Legislative, but not, well sort of. This hack certainly can do the legal dance.
But things have been changed in the constitution since 1961.
Clearly the constitution (sec 3) says "The Vice President of the United States shall be President of the Senate" and thus belongs to the legislative branch. He only becomes part of the executive branch when taking over the President's job according to the 25th amendment.
You would think Dick Cheney should not be able to claim "Executive Priviledge."
Further proves the stupidity and arrogance of the members of congress (both parties). These set of hearings are nothing more then a Democrat led witch hunt for as many high level Bush administration as they can. None of this is even about whether or not human beings may have been illegally harmed. They do not care...
It is about human beings that have been illegally harmed. Call it a witch hunt, but all of these stupid hearings are necessary to define terms and legalities which the current administration is using to weasel out of subpenas to congressional hearings. They can't even come straight and testify in front of congress and present why they did certain things. Watch the video where John Yoo wastes at least 7 1/2 minutes dancing around the term "implemented". They all know they are playing games.
yes ... the constitution stands in the way for them to further their empire. I wonder how many of this cast of characters we'll see again under McCain or Obama. Hopefully Obama will have the guts to try these people as felons and war criminals.
Bush will go down as the worst president ever - by a wide margin - and isn't fit to wipe Cohen's ass. Nor is five-deferment Dickhead Cheney or that piece of shit Addington.
Anyone who still supports that bastard and his band of bootlicking cronies is a blind fucking moron, and ought to be corralled and sent to Iraq to find the WMD and not be allowed to return until they do. Idiots. Fucking idiots.
Rep. Steve Cohen (D-TN) is a lilly livered pissant and Addington pwned him and yes I support GWB as I supported Bill Clinton while he was POTUS. He(Bush)will go down in history as a visionary. His ratings are well above the rating of Congress.
You Libs never gave the guy a break after the 2000 election and for this you will be remembered as defeatists and miserable thumb sucking cry-babies.
You're not going to get me to defend the Democratic Congress. They have a higher approval rating among Republicans than Democrats. I'm not a partisan prick like you, so don't go there.
the bilderberg group stands behind these politicians from both sides and this whole election thing is just a circus to make us believe there`s a choice and democracy, but no, it is a bilderberg group set up. please america pay attention, the bilderberg group is something very real and means no good with you or your family, killing you and your love ones is only a side effect for them to achieve there goals. dont believe your tv, get informed, look up the Biderberg group
Yes. I love how he twists this stuff around. Section 1 says "All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States, which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives." and then in section 3, the Vice President is defined to be part of the Senate: "The Vice President of the United States shall be President of the Senate, but shall have no Vote, unless they be equally divided"
He's part of the legislative branch and cannot claim Executive Privilege
Addington has explicitly voiced his hope for another terrorist attack. He excitedly said we are only "one bomb away" from the point where he can eliminate FISA -- that is *all* checks and balances of the executive branch, so that the president can be elevated entirely above the law.
It figures the only Jew in Alabama would be radical Leftist US Congressman. He's also a member of the "Out of Iraq" caucus with the socialist, Maxine Waters, and every other black in the House.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Yeah, that's hilarious, Rep. Cohen--a "barnicle." You must have left your Cliff Notes version of Con Law at home. Addington's brilliance emphasizes your stupidity.
I watched this last night and when they have no evidence they waxed hypothetical. I thought this was supposed to be an investigation. What it is is a bunch of B.S!
I propose a new amendment to the Constitution, saying, in whatever the appropriate legal terms are: "Every person employed by or attached to the Government of the United States of America IS A MEMBER OF ONE OF ITS BRANCHES."
It's really not this complicated. The constitution starts with Article 1 defining the legislative branch. Section 1 defines both houses, Section 2 defines the house and Section 3 defines the senate. The first time Vice President is mentioned is right there in section 3.
Obviously, this legal dance is all about protecting Addington's Job and VP Dick Cheney.
Well, yeah :P. But the point is to be explicit. That's the best way to get around loopholes IMO. (given you can't have everyone just be reasonable and uncorrupt)
So I guess the Supreme Court was wrong when they rules that VP Cheney could enlist Executive Priviledge when he witheld the informaiton about secret meetings with energy executives?
If VP isn't Executive but Legislative, it can't claim Executive Priviledge.
Sec 1 says "All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States, which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives." and then in sec 3, the Vice President is defined to be part of the Senate: "The Vice President of the United States shall be President of the Senate, but shall have no Vote, unless they be equally divided"
He's part of the legislative branch and cannot claim Executive Privilege
Do you not see the evil through his arrogance? Fearful of nothing or any law.
Watch him speak. His arrogance is of an entity with disdain for human life. Its in his eyes. Can you all not see the evil which pierces your computer screen, and challenges your intellect and attempts to mentally torture your soul?. Look at his eyes when he speaks. You are watching a demon who has escaped hell and is in the flesh, and walks among men.. I'm not making this up.. Look at him! Watch him speak!
Imagine being held at Guantanamo, and being beaten, tortured, sodomized, and water boarded for six years based on the demented and warped mind of Lucifer's 1st Lieutenant.. Mr. David Addington-Beelzebub!
You are looking at those which have escaped through the open gates of hell, and are in positions of immense power at the surface of earth.
Imagine an innocent person who has had to endure this. How can you argue that we indeed are not witnessing evil?
By title alone *Vice-President of the USA puts him in the Executive branch. Addington and Cheney are perverting the Constitution as usual. Treasonous crooks that should be put on trial for numerous counts against the Constitution and the people of the United States.
Attached to the constitution . . . like a parasite. Yes, that describes Cheney well. Addington, for that matter.
dennis345 1 year ago
"plum book"
remember?
78booby 1 year ago
"He's not fish nor fowl" - LOL
jbryant13 3 years ago 3
Since when did the Constitution mean anything to these people? Why don't we say this, as long as they're stripping the Bill of Rights, we'll reciprocally strip the parts of the Constitution endowing the Executive with any power.
jakewayd 3 years ago 2
ADDINGTON: Sir, perhaps the best that can be said is that the vice president belongs neither to the executive nor to the legislative branch, but is attached by the constitution to the latter.
So according to Addington, the Vice President is his own branch of government, or part of the Executive and the Legislative, but not, well sort of. This hack certainly can do the legal dance.
bogon5dot 3 years ago 5
No, according to legal precedent. He was not quoting himself, he was quoting a legal document from DOJ form March of 1961.
jfallas 1 year ago
But things have been changed in the constitution since 1961.
Clearly the constitution (sec 3) says "The Vice President of the United States shall be President of the Senate" and thus belongs to the legislative branch. He only becomes part of the executive branch when taking over the President's job according to the 25th amendment.
You would think Dick Cheney should not be able to claim "Executive Priviledge."
bogon5dot 3 years ago 2
The vice president is not a barnacle, though other types of light-shunning creatures have not been ruled out.
Kev95682 3 years ago 2
Further proves the stupidity and arrogance of the members of congress (both parties). These set of hearings are nothing more then a Democrat led witch hunt for as many high level Bush administration as they can. None of this is even about whether or not human beings may have been illegally harmed. They do not care...
Freakshow712 3 years ago
Perhaps true - but does that designate this a witch hunt? Is it cool for you to torture the children of SUSPECTS?
Addington has eviscerated the constitution. He's a war criminal and a traitor. Yu should hang as well - and I mean literally.
ayebretwalda 3 years ago
It is about human beings that have been illegally harmed. Call it a witch hunt, but all of these stupid hearings are necessary to define terms and legalities which the current administration is using to weasel out of subpenas to congressional hearings. They can't even come straight and testify in front of congress and present why they did certain things. Watch the video where John Yoo wastes at least 7 1/2 minutes dancing around the term "implemented". They all know they are playing games.
bogon5dot 3 years ago 2
Bush, Cheney, and their advisers and supporters hate the Constitution, and they hate America and everything it stands for.
camipco 3 years ago 4
yes ... the constitution stands in the way for them to further their empire. I wonder how many of this cast of characters we'll see again under McCain or Obama. Hopefully Obama will have the guts to try these people as felons and war criminals.
bogon5dot 3 years ago
LOL! Great Highlight!
Question1981 3 years ago
Barnacle is a polite term for what Cheney is!
TheRagingCelt 3 years ago 2
Bush will go down as the worst president ever - by a wide margin - and isn't fit to wipe Cohen's ass. Nor is five-deferment Dickhead Cheney or that piece of shit Addington.
Anyone who still supports that bastard and his band of bootlicking cronies is a blind fucking moron, and ought to be corralled and sent to Iraq to find the WMD and not be allowed to return until they do. Idiots. Fucking idiots.
taterdaddy9 3 years ago
You are obviously a dumb fuck.
Minionuup 3 years ago
Rep. Steve Cohen (D-TN) is a lilly livered pissant and Addington pwned him and yes I support GWB as I supported Bill Clinton while he was POTUS. He(Bush)will go down in history as a visionary. His ratings are well above the rating of Congress.
You Libs never gave the guy a break after the 2000 election and for this you will be remembered as defeatists and miserable thumb sucking cry-babies.
TuskAmerica 3 years ago
Addington- 1
Libtards- 0
TuskAmerica 3 years ago
Are you one of those 22% of Americans who still thinks Bush is wonderful? ha ha ha
Nominay 3 years ago 4
Are you one of the 14 percent of Americans who thinks the do-nothing, Dem-led congress is doing a good job?
patsagainstrats 3 years ago
You're not going to get me to defend the Democratic Congress. They have a higher approval rating among Republicans than Democrats. I'm not a partisan prick like you, so don't go there.
Nominay 3 years ago
Crook and Thug branch
GroovyVideo2 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the bilderberg group stands behind these politicians from both sides and this whole election thing is just a circus to make us believe there`s a choice and democracy, but no, it is a bilderberg group set up. please america pay attention, the bilderberg group is something very real and means no good with you or your family, killing you and your love ones is only a side effect for them to achieve there goals. dont believe your tv, get informed, look up the Biderberg group
JOIN THE REVOLUTION!!!!
garylandy 3 years ago
addington is a prick...
kac56 3 years ago
Question--
Did anybody notice how much his hand was shaking when he adjusted his glases at 1:00 ?
todnyc 3 years ago
"Did anybody notice how much his hand was shaking when he adjusted his glases at 1:00 ?"
Funny. I suppose it is because he is making stuff up.
buddjas1 3 years ago
yea i just noticed that
romance923 3 years ago
Yes. I love how he twists this stuff around. Section 1 says "All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States, which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives." and then in section 3, the Vice President is defined to be part of the Senate: "The Vice President of the United States shall be President of the Senate, but shall have no Vote, unless they be equally divided"
He's part of the legislative branch and cannot claim Executive Privilege
bogon5dot 3 years ago 2
Cheney and this ass tool belong to the shit for brains branch.
blair227 3 years ago
Addington has explicitly voiced his hope for another terrorist attack. He excitedly said we are only "one bomb away" from the point where he can eliminate FISA -- that is *all* checks and balances of the executive branch, so that the president can be elevated entirely above the law.
LeoTheBoy 3 years ago 3
It figures the only Jew in Alabama would be radical Leftist US Congressman. He's also a member of the "Out of Iraq" caucus with the socialist, Maxine Waters, and every other black in the House.
patsagainstrats 3 years ago
Cohen is from Tennessee. Memphis, to be exact.
You're a dumbass -- gee, I wonder who you support?
taterdaddy9 3 years ago
Gore country, I should've known.
patsagainstrats 3 years ago
Addington is an arrogant, mendacious, criminal. I'm disgusted that he gets paid with our taxes.
grimjc 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yeah, that's hilarious, Rep. Cohen--a "barnicle." You must have left your Cliff Notes version of Con Law at home. Addington's brilliance emphasizes your stupidity.
CaliBeach0007 3 years ago
Liars and morons! Attached to a pigeon brain!
SeekTruth77 3 years ago
You're my (Memphis') hero Cohen
deltaqueen 3 years ago
I don't know, he is pretty fowl.
jthomp3120 3 years ago
I watched this last night and when they have no evidence they waxed hypothetical. I thought this was supposed to be an investigation. What it is is a bunch of B.S!
Dianesdaughter 3 years ago
this fucker's a pro at the game
washmytoes 3 years ago 3
Douchebag.
rrioux 3 years ago 4
Will he take it in prison with such an air? This is a man in complete denial of the serious trouble he is in.
1000orsowords 3 years ago 4
"I don't consider the constitution a barnacle"
Addington's instinct is to pretend to misunderstand.
bzemky 3 years ago 3
I propose a new amendment to the Constitution, saying, in whatever the appropriate legal terms are: "Every person employed by or attached to the Government of the United States of America IS A MEMBER OF ONE OF ITS BRANCHES."
schmiggen 3 years ago
It's really not this complicated. The constitution starts with Article 1 defining the legislative branch. Section 1 defines both houses, Section 2 defines the house and Section 3 defines the senate. The first time Vice President is mentioned is right there in section 3.
Obviously, this legal dance is all about protecting Addington's Job and VP Dick Cheney.
bogon5dot 3 years ago
Well, yeah :P. But the point is to be explicit. That's the best way to get around loopholes IMO. (given you can't have everyone just be reasonable and uncorrupt)
schmiggen 3 years ago
So I guess the Supreme Court was wrong when they rules that VP Cheney could enlist Executive Priviledge when he witheld the informaiton about secret meetings with energy executives?
If VP isn't Executive but Legislative, it can't claim Executive Priviledge.
chimab 3 years ago 5
I really don't get this legal dance. Neither?
Sec 1 says "All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States, which shall consist of a Senate and House of Representatives." and then in sec 3, the Vice President is defined to be part of the Senate: "The Vice President of the United States shall be President of the Senate, but shall have no Vote, unless they be equally divided"
He's part of the legislative branch and cannot claim Executive Privilege
bogon5dot 3 years ago
Do you not see the evil through his arrogance? Fearful of nothing or any law.
Watch him speak. His arrogance is of an entity with disdain for human life. Its in his eyes. Can you all not see the evil which pierces your computer screen, and challenges your intellect and attempts to mentally torture your soul?. Look at his eyes when he speaks. You are watching a demon who has escaped hell and is in the flesh, and walks among men.. I'm not making this up.. Look at him! Watch him speak!
LandOfTheBrave01 3 years ago 8
Look who he works for. The most arrogant jerk in government. Dick Checkey who has no respect for the rule of law or the Constitution.
cungar 3 years ago 4
i see a brazen fool.
intarwebzz 3 years ago 2
@LandOfTheBrave01 you ever see the back of a 20$ bill on weed?
keeperofconundrums 8 months ago
Imagine being held at Guantanamo, and being beaten, tortured, sodomized, and water boarded for six years based on the demented and warped mind of Lucifer's 1st Lieutenant.. Mr. David Addington-Beelzebub!
You are looking at those which have escaped through the open gates of hell, and are in positions of immense power at the surface of earth.
Imagine an innocent person who has had to endure this. How can you argue that we indeed are not witnessing evil?
LandOfTheBrave01 3 years ago 4
By title alone *Vice-President of the USA puts him in the Executive branch. Addington and Cheney are perverting the Constitution as usual. Treasonous crooks that should be put on trial for numerous counts against the Constitution and the people of the United States.
qantmrckr 3 years ago
neither fish nor fowl ....
Amazing how addington et al blatantly redefine the COnstitution before our very eyes.
Geee, i wonder if President Obama will have these understandings codified in some kind of executive order, or Congressional legislation.
I am mno longer in any way shocked by their arrogance and complete disregard for rule of law --- unless it is their OWN LAW or legal finding.
Personally, I doubt Obama is going to reverse all of this. And that makes me truly sad.
quicksite 3 years ago 5