Added: 2 years ago
From: Lisasz09
Views: 12,985
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (113)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i like it because it washes off so thoroughly. i don't mind a few applications if it means easy removal ( comes off all the way with little effort) and no flaking and very little smudging at the end of the day. this is the first "expensive" mascara i have bought since dior show which left me a flaky mess.

  • i am in love with this mascara :)

  • Is it easy to remove? Some mascaras take out lashes during removal, so I won't use waterproof mascaras anymore because of lash loss.

  • @MyTimeinWorldHistory I didnt have any issues removing it

  • i always go to you when I am deciding which mascara to get. They are right on point!

  • just got this, it's wonderful. clump free, lengthening, and volumizing for me :) i highly recommend it!

  • i really like this mascara also the waterproof one has a smaller brush and gets more mascara on it

  • i really like this mascara

  • I liked this mascara, it was good. :) But it gave me a headache...Idk why...

  • lol the dogggy ;p

    I was going to buy this, love the new dior extase it gives me a natural false lash effect in 1 coat.

  • I went to Benefit asking for a mascara, and the Bad Gal one is what the recommended to me, and I bought it for £15.50. I agree that the size of the wand is pretty huge, so what I did was use the wand from the Max Factor Colossal mascara, which was the one I'd been using prior, and it worked really well, as the size of the Colossal wand worked amazingly with the Bad Gal formula. :)

  • i love that mascara it's my favorite! It volumizes, lengthens, and is clump-free for me!

  • did you happen to know if this mascara is sold at certain drugstores? if so, how much- I live in the u.s ;)

  • no it is not a drugstore brand- it is sold in Ulta and sephora! :o)

  • @Lisasz09

    I felt like there wasnt enough product on the wand too!! I love this after like 3 coats!!!!

  • @allthatglamer - its sold in shoppers drug mart, but i think these are only in Canada!

  • in canada shoppers drug mart carries it

  • you are so beautiful in this video. :o

  • i love the formula on this .. but also didnt like the brush .. so what i did was once i had run out of my covergirl lashblast i sanitised the brush and used that for the benefit one .. worked amazing .. :) ..

  • How about Maybelline Great Lash Curved Mascara Blackest Black? Is it better than the benefit one?

  • I have not tried that one yet so I am not sure- sorry! :o(

  • Thanks for reviewing this mascara. I experienced the exact same thing! Great formula in general, but hardly any went on the lash, and the wand is insane! I am not real experienced with mascara yet, but I'm trying to give them a go to see what effect I can get from them I am going to try a bit more, and see. But I'm glad I had the same conclusion--I just lack experience.

  • I agree with your opinion 100 % it is not something I would ever purchase again but it was alright.

  • Have you tried Lancome Hypnose? So far that's my favorite along with their vibrating lash primer.

  • I have not yet tried that- Thanks for the idea!  :o)

  • hey, i have the full size and the sample too. The sample was very different, personally i like the brush. I do not like the rubber. i really like it all around. Stays great does not flake or fade.

  • request-can you make a video about how to know a good mascara i mean like try it on your hands or say how it should be thx

  • most mascara is a personal opinion. It is a lot of trial and error. I suggest trying different ones to find out what works for you- I prefer plastic brushes so I tend to look for those- I also buy drigstore ones so I can try multiple different ones for less cost! :o)

  • you should show your dog in a video! i love dogs :)

  • he has been in a few videos and I show him on my blog! :o)

  • I have tried the small version which I received from sephora and the full size version. I noticed that the small sized one was much more dry and didnt apply half as well because there isnt enough product in the sample size,

  • too dry for me too, I do love a nice wet mascara - avon plump is great I got it this morning. beats my dior show one

    great review girly

    x

  • i much prefer the brissle mascaras compared to the plastic/rubber mascara brushes too! :)

    plus the mascara brush was huge as you said.

    i loved it.

    have you tried mac's plush lash mascara. thats quite a big brush too x

  • i have this in the plum and blue when the girl at the benefit counter put it on me i was already wearing mascara and over that you could see the plum , but i have used nearly all the plum and just dont seem to be getting the same effect , i am going to try the blue soon , i agree lisa its ok but there is just something about it that is not great cant put my finger on it :o)

  • I agree that this mascara is nothing special. I also received a sample and I wouldn't buy it.

    As Lisa says it has a very dry wand and needs quitea few coats which even then don't give a great result. I'll stick with Dior Iconic.

  • I feel like this mascara is too drying or that it hasn't enough inside the tube. I put on my lashes and it seems they stay the same. I have to try to pull something out from inside the tube and apply several coats, however I don't like to put on too many coats because then I always experience flaking. I think this mascara is a big "meh".

  • hey lisa try the buxom by bare essentials it is really good mascara. and i ordered the other one that she as is called flawless and i will be getting that this week. so if you have time do a review on these products thanks lynette.

  • I dont own it but if I buy it I will do a review! :o)

  • haha. Diesel's crying cue. haha. "I did four coats." aww...That dog rules. You should show him again! :-)

  • yay for the review!

  • hi lisa,

    I want to get a mascara and im so overwhelmed by all the reviews, products and stuff so... :'(

    and i dont no which one to get !!

    wat do u recomend ? oh and also i live in france so i cant get stuff like covergirl (but i can find loreal, all high-end brands, maybelline)

  • Some of my favorites are the Rimmel Sexy Curves, maybeline define a lash! I hope this helps you!

  • I purchased this same mascara with a gift card and although it gave me volume, my eyelids were just as much mascara as my eye lashes. By the time I got the hang of it, it was 2 1/2 months into use and it was time for me trash it for I don't keep mascaras 3 months.

    Personally, I stay with my beloved L'Oreal Voluminous Waterproof Mascara in Carbon Black. Thanks, as always, for your honest review. Blessings.

  • yikes, thanks for the heads up, have you tried the cover girl lash exact? or have you reviewed that one?

    good evening ^_^

  • I do have a compairison video on the three CG mascaras! :o)

  • im in LOOOVEEE with this mascara <3 <3 <3

  • before i discovered faux cils, this was my favorite mascara but when you brought up how many times you have to layer it, you hit the nail on the head. i seriously love your reviews because the things you point out are always so well thought out.

  • what is the best primer (eye base)? that is pretty cheap what do you recomend?

  • a cheap eye shadow base is Loreal de crese! :o)

  • i totally agree with u, it's nice but i never have quite enough product on the wand!

  • your skin looks really pretty like this. not very tan.

  • Check out the size of the "FireBird Mascara" by Fresh Cosmetics. The brush is absolutely huge, much like the Bad Gal Lash.

  • I personally really liked this mascara but then again i already have long, dark, thick, somewhat curly lashes.

    do you mind doing a review of the urban decay big fatty or dior diorshow mascara??? i want to compare those three since they all have pretty big brushes and claim to do the same thing.

  • I dont usually buy high end mascaras- I will get samples but i dont want to waste my money on high end when i throw them out every 3 months and I really like my drugstore ones! :o)

  • i like both kinds of brushes and HATED this mascara, hatred.

  • I agree with lack of mascara on the brush. I feel like it just darken my lashes and not enhancing my lashes dramatically, just subtly. For ppl who don't want dramatic lashes, forget this, but if you want natural looking lashes, go for it.

  • i hate this mascara. i received it as a sample too and it's horrible.. the brush is huge and there's barely any product on the brush. the only nice thing about it is that it comes off really easily when i cleanse my face.

  • did it clump your lashes at all?

  • yes it did! :o(

  • ok i know this is not related to this video lol...but ive been tryin to decide on foundations..im almost out...i use the mac blotting powder with studio fix..i stopped using my sculpt cuz it longer matches..question is the hd makeupfoever better? i hear a lot of hype about it..and they have like a white finishing powder..idk if i should try it...i wanna know if the finish would be better..idk if im making sense lol

  • Comment removed

  • I did not like MUFE HD at all- I actualy returned mine. i would suggest Dior Nude or Girgio Armani! :o)

  • what other mascara would you reccomend not waterproof but holds the curls..... i have straight lashes i mean downward lashes.. help!

  • I really like sexy curves and I like Lash Blast! I would suggest always using a lash curler if your lashes are supper staight! :o)

  • i cant BELIEVE that this mascara did not flake on Lisa. that is probably because it takes so much product to get it to work in the first place..... sorry just thinking out loud. !!

  • Does it uncurl you lashes? Were your lashes naturally straight to begin with?

  • I curl my lashes first then I put my mascara on and it doesnt keep the curl!

  • Your reviews are super! So detailed and helpful!! I love 'em all.

  • Personally I was VERY disappointed by this mascara. The brush is too big to work with, it didn't lengthen or thicken, it rubbed off my bottom lashes and it dried up within the month. SAVE YOUR money. I am currently using a sample of Stila mascara & it works great. I especially love it w/MACs mascara primer. By the way Lisa, you look beautiful!

  • Thanks for the tip!

  • yeah maybelline is okkay :) but it's drugstore

  • who cares if it just a drugstore item

    dont be a

    label/brand whoree

  • I like this because it doesn't put a lot of product. It looks pretty natural (I have lots of lashes already).

  • LISA! you should do a review on my fave masacar of ALLLLLL TIME which is victoria secret "very sexy" Mascara in blackest black you will LOVE it

  • Thanks for the tip!

  • I love her eyes... I wish I could lick them... Yes you heard me right.

    :)

  • can you show us your dog? i know it's random... but i wanna see him! =)

  • I have shown him in a few videos- I think he is in my foundation routine one! :o)

  • your skin this color looks so pretty! :)

  • hi lisa,

    glad u did a review on this as i got this mascara FREE with hlamour mag last month still not opended it as still using the rimmel sexy curves mascara and givency phenomons eye :) Xxx

    ps ur dog is funny! X

  • i m hearing it cou;ld be comparable to Neutrogena's healthy volume. which i m complete in love....suuuuper

  • It is very comparable to neutrogena's healthy volume. I have both and love 'em, then again.. my preference is that I love the big wand.

  • to test how good the brush pics up the mascara get a peice of paper and swipe it down, if it coats evenly then it good but some barley effect the paper, i did this with my bad gal and some parts had huge clumps and some were barley touched, so thats why the mascara clumps.

  • My sephora sample dried up very quickly and wasn't as good as the full sized mascara. They were totally different.

  • I agree with you that either the actual formula dries-up quickly or the brushes are not coated enough with the formula;;;however, I did love the big brush I think it was because it did give my lashes a tapered/natural look but with several coatings you can make it more dramatic. Do you have any recomendations of a good mascara which has a BIG brush? I've tried the collosal but I it does sometimes clump....thanks so much for the video always love watching your reviews (=

  • try DiorShow

  • Dior Iconic has a big brush and it's a lovely mascara too

  • I love Cover Girl Lash Blast! It is one of my favs! :o)

  • Thank you for replying unfortunately Cover Girl products are hard to get a hold of in the UK;;I've never heard of the dior iconic before though I'll look it up. Thanks everyone =)

  • aww.. i hear youre puppy in the background* =)

  • yeah he doesnt like the rain! :o(

  • i had the same problem with the sephora sample. the full sized bad gal is very different. i would suggest trying the full sized before posting a review.

  • i really dont like this mascara i felt it didnt do any thing for me i got mine free in a mag so no harm done to my purse.

    you give great reviews thanks x

  • I really didn't like this mascara and it seemed to dry out really quick too!

  • it looks like the Dior Show:d

  • I feel like theres no mascara on the brush also! C:

  • so when i was @ the benefit counter today, the lady told me that this mascara is the exact same as Diorshow (made by the same folks) but is $10 cheaper. I am still considering trying it...but yea, i agree, the rubber wands are love.

  • oo the brush looks similar to the dior diorshow mascara wand

  • I got this as a Beauty Insider gift, but it was all dried up! I was so disappointed. :(

  • Thanks Lisa, I got this as my Beauty Insider freebie and haven't tried it yet.

  • They now have a waterproof one and the wand is soo much better much thinner and i think it is rubber :)

  • i know the water prook one is amazing..

    though it has synthetic bristels not rubber..

  • I love this mascara. I have noticed that the normal size wand works MUCH better than the travel size. Its my HG

  • Excellent...you should intro your doggie :O)

  • he has been shown in a few videos! :o)

  • i felt the same way about the 2faced lash injection ...huge brush with not enough product on it

  • I had this mascara and I did not like it at all. In general I prefer the rubber wands versus the little bristles..didn't really curl my lashes that much.

  • totally have the same opinion.

  • Yes I totally agree! I had the same problem with the mascara. It doesn't seem like it has any produst on the brush. I thought it was just my tube that was dried out but maybe not! On the other hand, it means that it doesnt clump upon application...... But I just dont wanna spend ten minutes applying Bad Gal when Lash Blast takes me two minutes to apply!

  • Awesome review, I couldn't agree more!

    It is a very very good mascara, gives a great effect, but, as you said, the wand is huge, so makes the application to the inner corner tricky...and...yes...I too find it takes me more coats to create the look I want....but then again, for that price, it's not that bad!

    xoxo

  • I think the prblem is the size of the sample. Because this so little product in the travel size its not enough to coat the bristles. Your more likely to get the right amount of product if it was the full size asthe brush is immersed in the pigment.

  • I LOVE THIS MASCARA!

    It seems to be really good for me

    i have very lengthy lashes so im not looking to make them HUGE becuase they already are.

    i apply this mascara from about halfway in from the root and bring to the tip

    it really blackens my lashes without ANY clump and help my lashes keep a ccurl

  • I already suggested you to try YSL faux cils mascara.... it's incredible I will not use anything else... I had received so MANY compliments even asked me if I'm wearing faux lashes... try it and then review it...

  • I know I need to get my hands on that sometime soon!

  • great review COLASSAL VOLUME EXPRESS'S WAND IS LIKE THE BAD GAL can you do a comparisonn? pleaseplease!!!

  • maybelline's colossal is not like the bad gal or the too faced lash injection because the bristles are thinner and less densely packed together. you can look for images of these two products and see for yourself. then the consistency of maybelline colossal is much more liquid compared to the bad gal, which is creamy. after all, a maybelline is 8 dollars while a too faced is almost 20, and a bad gal as well. so i dont think a comparison is appropriate. hope i helped you.

  • i dont think I am going to buy Colassal mascara- I do not have good luck with Maybelline mascaras! :o(

  • Hey, loving your videos. You might find the full size a lot easier to apply. There's something annoying about the stubby little wands of sample size mascaras. I'd love to see some reviews of NARS stuff if you have some. Other than that anything from Benefit, UD, TF or MAC. :)

  • thanks for the great review!

  • i have this mascara and i bent the brush and it seemed to coat all my lashes evenly  at the same time :D

  • Can I take a look at your dog? He sounded so cute.....

  • he has been shown in a couple of my videos! :o) he doesnt like the rain! :o(

  • I was really dissapointed in this mascara. I had heard so many raves about it, and I thought it would give me the biggest lashes ever but even after 2 coats it just didnt do it for me. The best I have tried is the Loreal Voluminous carbon black one it lasts ages as well x

  • Me, personally, I love this mascara. It's the only mascara I use every single day. I go for it when I want long, full lashes. I don't even use my Plush Lash anymore.

    I don't curl my lashes, and this seems to give me a nice, natural curl, with a ton of volume and length. I do maybe 2-3 coats. And I'm good.

    Thanks for doing a review on this!

  • I have tryed this mascara,be honest didnt had any problem with that,but in some month i found that it is realy difficult to put one or 2 coats of mascara that it will be done,so meiby it was old one???

  • Lisa, try Loreal Voluminous. Drugstore brand but great!!!! You will be surprised ;-)

  • have you ever tried the eyeko mascara? its amazing, love it as much as my rimmel sexy curves :)

  • I have not tried it since it is difficult to get where i live! :o(

  • could you do a review on mac whirl liner please?

    love your videos!

    x

  • sure i will put it on my list to review!

  • Just discovered your videos and love them..you do really helpful, thorough reviews :)

  • please can u do a review on sexy curves mascara :) x

  • I do have a reviewon Rimmel Sexy Curves already loaded.

  • it could be compared to dior black out x

  • good mascara

  • omg i love that mascara its really good i think it lengthens my lashes :)

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more