Goddamn i never thought i hear an american or a westerner speak truth and kind words about us Turks .. shit i want to invite this man to my house and let him give me some history lessons to .. although i alreadt knew we turks where the greateast fighters and soldiers in the world ( we come directly from Ghengis Khan and Atilla The Hun)
@TurkishMujahid You realize that citing "Atilla The Hun" and "Ghengis Khan" who were vicious tyrants you support the notion that Ottomans were vicious killers? Don't worry, he's American, but Turkey pays his bills -- why else would he spew these lies? Money money money. Also, he's not smart enough to be a real academic -- listen to the way he talks.
Thank you doctor for saying turks are the toughest ppl on the planet and we are indeed after all we dont have the wordls oldest wrestling festival just cause we wanna be popual lol.
Come on man, didnt you listen Dr. Justin McCarty. No body denies that bad things happened but dont forget 5-7 million Turks forced to move to Anatolia from Balkans, millions of Turks were dead and after Balkan wars, Turks lost 1/4 of the population. Those people were mainly murdered by Greeks and Armenians used by Russia and western European countries. Millions of Turks were murdered and millions of Turks forced to move to Anatolia. Thats why war is bad.
Pride is a good thing for one to have . . . but when it blinds you . .one cant communicate or listen to others around them. The problem is not the common people, but it's a government issue. It takes a lot for one to admit guilt - although it is commending, but very difficult. Both government need to take proper steps to reconcile this issue . . . if not, it will never end.
One will not see the truth if you only look at your own opinion, etc. Have to look at both sides of the story (eye witness, physical evidence, motive etc) then at only then one will reach the truth. This was not a casualty of war . . . when you bring harm to elderly, young children, taking them to the desert to starve and die . . . no matter who takes this kind of actions.
Thank you Justin McCarthy for exposing the long tradition of Turcophobia and prejudice against Turks. And thnx to miracc for uploading this video 5*****
As far as Turkey wanting to meet with Armenia-Why? Look at their timing? - Yes I do agree with you that both sides should meet front of UN with all documents, witnesess, historical authors, yes even Dr Justin is welcome :)
well i wonder why though that the armenians have not taken their case to an international court ? they keep pressuring western govournments to support the genocide claims despite this! im sorry but armenia is not the country in question sufferring prejudice from the west.
If either side prideful of their heritage, history etc. Now, if one feels that the evidence, the judge, the jury etc are subjective . . . then why would anyone agree to go to that court. Also, most eye witnesses, Armenian or not, Military or not have been deceased . . . now one can easily dispute their eye witness. Since the beginning Armenians wanted justice . . . since their case was not taken seriously . . . till now? Why?
Turkish Historical Society recently offered $20M to open the Armenian Archives in Boston, USA. Turkish Government suggested to study every historical documents available in both sides but Armenian side is not willing to do that because that way their genocide lie will come to an end.
@miracc Turkey has kept the archives closed for the last almost 100 years. Why does Turkey want to open them now? Could it be that they were busy destroying the incriminating documents and fabricating other ones? It doesn't matter, because Armenians have documents from Armenians but also Scandinavians, Germans, Americans, and Brits who were there and witnessed the genocide with their own eyes and ears.
Sad that a PhD professor is not stating the facts, but his opinion. There are over 100 literatures and documentations that show that Turkey was an ally with Germany, in which wanted Armenians out of way and any other threats Greeks.
this man is a scholar for gods sake , he is an expert in demography , and ottoman history he has studeid all the infrmation there is available , he has no reason to be pro turkish , he is just givimg a lecture based on the conclusions he has reached , which is what we expect from every historian , you obviously have not read deep enougnaside from the armenian propaganda , because thats all it is only engrained into their identity and mind.
great orator, fantastic teacher, in 20 minutes i have learned more about Turkish history then i have in 18 years of american academics, 5 years of turkish education and 32 years as a turkish-american. I have been skeptical of turkish history taught by turks as well as by westerners, this was refreshingly neutral and descriptive. Fantastic work!
I loved it , i love people that puts an effort to wake the world up from lies and bad politic..
thank you all great people who provide us with knowledge..
regards to you all..
teomina82 3 days ago
Goddamn i never thought i hear an american or a westerner speak truth and kind words about us Turks .. shit i want to invite this man to my house and let him give me some history lessons to .. although i alreadt knew we turks where the greateast fighters and soldiers in the world ( we come directly from Ghengis Khan and Atilla The Hun)
TurkishMujahid 9 months ago
@TurkishMujahid You realize that citing "Atilla The Hun" and "Ghengis Khan" who were vicious tyrants you support the notion that Ottomans were vicious killers? Don't worry, he's American, but Turkey pays his bills -- why else would he spew these lies? Money money money. Also, he's not smart enough to be a real academic -- listen to the way he talks.
PrepeiNaSasPw 7 months ago
masallah what a great dr
CeaNer 10 months ago
Thumbs up for a world with one country and one language, peace.
sa4ir 11 months ago
this was great, thank u so much dr. its so gd to hear gd things about the turkish
sy1504 1 year ago
Thank you doctor for saying turks are the toughest ppl on the planet and we are indeed after all we dont have the wordls oldest wrestling festival just cause we wanna be popual lol.
LORDMEHMOODPASHA 2 years ago
thank you dr.
caner544 2 years ago
Come on man, didnt you listen Dr. Justin McCarty. No body denies that bad things happened but dont forget 5-7 million Turks forced to move to Anatolia from Balkans, millions of Turks were dead and after Balkan wars, Turks lost 1/4 of the population. Those people were mainly murdered by Greeks and Armenians used by Russia and western European countries. Millions of Turks were murdered and millions of Turks forced to move to Anatolia. Thats why war is bad.
ncroc 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
. . hepinizin anaisi sikim.amina kodugum turkleri.koymus beton mustafayi anaisini siktiklerim.ataturku okadar seviyorlarki bunlarin analarini . ataturk sikmis hepsi ayni babadan . ben Königswinter de oturuyorum . merak etme Pezeveng senin sülaleni üst üste koyup öle sikiyim
Fuck Azerbaijan ibne
zograp8 2 years ago
Pride is a good thing for one to have . . . but when it blinds you . .one cant communicate or listen to others around them. The problem is not the common people, but it's a government issue. It takes a lot for one to admit guilt - although it is commending, but very difficult. Both government need to take proper steps to reconcile this issue . . . if not, it will never end.
DrummerDaddy2000 2 years ago
One will not see the truth if you only look at your own opinion, etc. Have to look at both sides of the story (eye witness, physical evidence, motive etc) then at only then one will reach the truth. This was not a casualty of war . . . when you bring harm to elderly, young children, taking them to the desert to starve and die . . . no matter who takes this kind of actions.
DrummerDaddy2000 2 years ago
the best history lesson
ozziturk 3 years ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
4 million Ottoman civilians died as a result of the turmoil of World War One.
Only about one fourth were Ottoman Armenians!
3 million Ottoman-Turkish civilians were slaughtered when Armenian guerillas & Russian troops held the Eastern Ottoman region!
barbaros1passa 3 years ago
Thank you Justin McCarthy for exposing the long tradition of Turcophobia and prejudice against Turks. And thnx to miracc for uploading this video 5*****
sickuntodeath2 3 years ago 13
Armenian-Nazi Collaboration
AvrupaYAKASIdizi 3 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
As far as Turkey wanting to meet with Armenia-Why? Look at their timing? - Yes I do agree with you that both sides should meet front of UN with all documents, witnesess, historical authors, yes even Dr Justin is welcome :)
DrummerDaddy2000 3 years ago
well i wonder why though that the armenians have not taken their case to an international court ? they keep pressuring western govournments to support the genocide claims despite this! im sorry but armenia is not the country in question sufferring prejudice from the west.
tekke100 3 years ago 4
If either side prideful of their heritage, history etc. Now, if one feels that the evidence, the judge, the jury etc are subjective . . . then why would anyone agree to go to that court. Also, most eye witnesses, Armenian or not, Military or not have been deceased . . . now one can easily dispute their eye witness. Since the beginning Armenians wanted justice . . . since their case was not taken seriously . . . till now? Why?
DrummerDaddy2000 2 years ago
5*****
norvadin1234 3 years ago 3
Turkish Historical Society recently offered $20M to open the Armenian Archives in Boston, USA. Turkish Government suggested to study every historical documents available in both sides but Armenian side is not willing to do that because that way their genocide lie will come to an end.
miracc 3 years ago 6
@miracc Turkey has kept the archives closed for the last almost 100 years. Why does Turkey want to open them now? Could it be that they were busy destroying the incriminating documents and fabricating other ones? It doesn't matter, because Armenians have documents from Armenians but also Scandinavians, Germans, Americans, and Brits who were there and witnessed the genocide with their own eyes and ears.
PrepeiNaSasPw 7 months ago
@PrepeiNaSasPw archives was never closed for historians.... They were closed for common person.
MrDenocan 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sad that a PhD professor is not stating the facts, but his opinion. There are over 100 literatures and documentations that show that Turkey was an ally with Germany, in which wanted Armenians out of way and any other threats Greeks.
DrummerDaddy2000 3 years ago
this man is a scholar for gods sake , he is an expert in demography , and ottoman history he has studeid all the infrmation there is available , he has no reason to be pro turkish , he is just givimg a lecture based on the conclusions he has reached , which is what we expect from every historian , you obviously have not read deep enougnaside from the armenian propaganda , because thats all it is only engrained into their identity and mind.
tekke100 3 years ago 5
great orator, fantastic teacher, in 20 minutes i have learned more about Turkish history then i have in 18 years of american academics, 5 years of turkish education and 32 years as a turkish-american. I have been skeptical of turkish history taught by turks as well as by westerners, this was refreshingly neutral and descriptive. Fantastic work!
oscargurses 3 years ago 5