This piece isn't exactly 'atonal,' not completely at least. It actually follows an old church mode called the "Locrian" scale, in which the half-steps are located betveen the I and II tones, and the IV and V tones. Go re-learn your music theory, people.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'm not quite sold on this video. certainly it is a demonstration of exceptional violin playing, and he phrases everything wonderfully, but I find the music itself rather dull. I never cared for shostakovitch. oistrakh's awesome though!
ah, i wrote that comment almost a year ago i think; during the phase where i "didn't like" atonal music, or really anything relatively modern. I've had quite a bit more listening experiences since then. it really is a fantastic piece, and shosti 5 is one of my favorite symphonies.
thanks for uploading! hey, anyone hear the beethoven op. 131 reference?
violinchick25 7 months ago
This piece isn't exactly 'atonal,' not completely at least. It actually follows an old church mode called the "Locrian" scale, in which the half-steps are located betveen the I and II tones, and the IV and V tones. Go re-learn your music theory, people.
violinsizzle 7 months ago
Comment removed
O0oSognodorato0O 1 year ago
I didn't know there existed a violin transcription of these pieces. I really love them.
olga2809 3 years ago 2
Oh my god! I've been looking for this for at least a few years now! cant believe ive found a video of an old master playing these.
I did the three fantastic dances for my diploma, and wanted to find a decent rendition of it. At least i found it now :)
DualThunder 3 years ago 5
Outstanding!
Neishapour 3 years ago 2
Shosta forever!
VegliaBorletti 4 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm not quite sold on this video. certainly it is a demonstration of exceptional violin playing, and he phrases everything wonderfully, but I find the music itself rather dull. I never cared for shostakovitch. oistrakh's awesome though!
albachteng 4 years ago
Well, it's what they say - either you love Shostakovich or you hate him (although you're the third kind, or so it seems, hehe)=)
sephiroth999999 4 years ago 3
Just don't give up on Shostakovitch, keep on listening to his music and you may develop an ear for him. Or taste.
Lamturnik 3 years ago 5
ah, i wrote that comment almost a year ago i think; during the phase where i "didn't like" atonal music, or really anything relatively modern. I've had quite a bit more listening experiences since then. it really is a fantastic piece, and shosti 5 is one of my favorite symphonies.
albachteng 3 years ago 8
Thank you!
Jeandebolanos 4 years ago
wow... wut a bow control... like always... thx for the video!!!
udm77 4 years ago 3