they abandoned this song early on. I saw them live in around 1998 and they didn't play it. I just looked and saw it's not on their greatest hits album. Anyone know why they stopped playing it? Maybe because it does seem to be about suicide?
@atticus126 - also reading Jake's book (very good!). The band wanted FNT as their first single, but the MCA head wanted this. The band (via MCA) spent a million dollars to get it promoted (payola), and it went no where.
There is an interesting page on how payola works these days - all legal, via 'consultants'
@marcusg0th I can't say for sure but that's always been my take on the song... if you look up the lyrics it seems pretty clear to me that it's about a suicide.
This video sounds like its about sombody that committed suicide by "stifling behind surburban wheels" like suffocating in a garage, rather than living their full life and going down in flames
"Now your father's face is frozen between anger and tears, your mother's hair's amazingly gray, and I'm seeing these friends for the first time in years, it's icicle reunion day."
one of the most poetic lines I've ever heard, Semisonic is amazing
The song is simply about the stifled feeling of realizing "this is all there is, I'll never accomplish much more than this." He is being greeted by a "ghost" of his future, who reminds him that he has a long life of responsibility, and not much glamour left. Genius.
@rootandsky Haha I can easily believe it. This song was a bad choice for a lead single. The label guy was trying to fit them into hard rocking alternative music. And that's not what they were. They were adult contemporary easy listening, albeit with distorted guitar. Plus their image was terrible: 33 year old dorks in turtlenecks were never going to appeal to the early/mid nineties MTV generation.
From what I recall, I think that it's about a friend's death (possibly due to suicide) and how it affected friends and family. Listen closely to the lyrics.
... I didn't even know a video for this song existed, let alone one so gloriously 90's. One of my absolute favorite songs from one of my favorite bands. Thank you.
I woud like to have seen the origional version of this video before they cut out all of the fire. I'm reading Jakes book right now and the story behind this is awesome.
Man, this band and song alike ROCK! It's sad Semisonic didn't get farther than they did. Dunno why. Anyway, I like the video regardless, it fits the song really well. Thanks for the upload1
That drummer really needed to just shave his sad head...
turoniner 5 days ago
Comment removed
turoniner 5 days ago
they abandoned this song early on. I saw them live in around 1998 and they didn't play it. I just looked and saw it's not on their greatest hits album. Anyone know why they stopped playing it? Maybe because it does seem to be about suicide?
atticus126 2 months ago
@atticus126 - also reading Jake's book (very good!). The band wanted FNT as their first single, but the MCA head wanted this. The band (via MCA) spent a million dollars to get it promoted (payola), and it went no where.
There is an interesting page on how payola works these days - all legal, via 'consultants'
jondoe8889 2 months ago
is vamprie bill the singer?--kidding--some of the most poetic rock lyrics i have ever heard.
dansig123 5 months ago
Everytime I hear "Closing Time" on the Radio I shake my head that it wasnt this song that went big.
1800Randy 6 months ago
THIS IS A GREAT SONG. I HAVE LOVED IT FOR YEARS.
GeronimosLastStand 8 months ago in playlist Garden Party
this song is about suicide?
marcusg0th 11 months ago
@marcusg0th I can't say for sure but that's always been my take on the song... if you look up the lyrics it seems pretty clear to me that it's about a suicide.
29bpm 10 months ago
The drummer has a great book out. Very good read about being a "rock star." A must read for young musicians starting in the biz. Very well written.
biggerbigd 1 year ago 3
@biggerbigd I'm reading it now, had to come see what this song was about
drummerjmp 8 months ago
honestly, i saw them live with the Verve Pipe @ Irving Plaza NYC and they were AMAZING live.....
djvictroladadj 1 year ago
w00t #69 like >.<
djvictroladadj 1 year ago
It makes me sad that none of my friends know this band.
MBP6705 1 year ago 2
Chocolate: It's actually: "now your father's face is frozen between anger and it's years..."
But you are still 100% right. It's beautiful.
grope4luna 1 year ago
great divide is one of the best records of the 90s. i wish there was a vid for the title track up.
brandonedge 1 year ago 3
90's were the ebst, i demand a 1 way timemachine!
SaltRock0000 1 year ago
i love this song
wicketwicket1 1 year ago 2
Always loved this tune...their best tune. Period. Great band!!
misterpress 1 year ago 2
This is their best song!
634devil 1 year ago 2
Remember when this came out and it didn't catch on at all, but it's my favorite of theirs.
agriffina 1 year ago 2
covering this song is really fun. great song by a great band
DesecrationSmile52 1 year ago 2
Its sad to know that this seriously tanked when it came out
evilnarc 2 years ago
This is one of my favorite songs of all time, it brings me back to the first girls i liked..jeez scary stuff
lastbroadcast1 2 years ago
This video sounds like its about sombody that committed suicide by "stifling behind surburban wheels" like suffocating in a garage, rather than living their full life and going down in flames
dwellersire 2 years ago
"Now your father's face is frozen between anger and tears, your mother's hair's amazingly gray, and I'm seeing these friends for the first time in years, it's icicle reunion day."
one of the most poetic lines I've ever heard, Semisonic is amazing
chocolaterazr96 3 years ago 21
down with mitnick25
obamamaniac42 3 years ago
I love this song. And the video is fun. I love Semisonic ^_^
taxes15 3 years ago
this is a totally rockin song! gona have to get it tabbed by my guitar teacher as i doubt there is a lesson on youtube.love 'singing in my sleep' too
jimboc88 3 years ago 2
why is this the only place on youtube where the video is?
BacklightProductions 3 years ago 2
i freaking love this song
BacklightProductions 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wow this song sucks
Mitnick25 3 years ago
The song is simply about the stifled feeling of realizing "this is all there is, I'll never accomplish much more than this." He is being greeted by a "ghost" of his future, who reminds him that he has a long life of responsibility, and not much glamour left. Genius.
chrism823 3 years ago
Oh really? I think it is more about Dan dealing with Matt and Dan s upcoming record deal.
"I said friend you have a life to see..why do you have to scare me so?"
If you really know Trip Matt was the catalyst, Dan was the flame, John was the root and Elaine was the freight line to drive them home.
grope4luna 3 years ago
inspirational
skootrd 3 years ago 3
lol I'm reading the book too. Probably everyone who reads it checks this vid out.
vaelrix 3 years ago 3
did those directors even listen to the song before they wrote their suggestions for the video?
xdxdxdhapa 3 years ago
Yea, im actually reading that book right now. I really like Semisonic, theyre so underrated
bobbyflay 3 years ago 4
Love this song! Thanks for posting it.
mackhine 3 years ago
Perfect in one word explanation ;)
ConflictBGS 3 years ago 2
i can't believe this song went nowhere on the radio.
rootandsky 3 years ago 28
@rootandsky It did in certain areas of the country. But sadly, that doesn't mean anything.
bunnyknows1 11 months ago
@rootandsky Haha I can easily believe it. This song was a bad choice for a lead single. The label guy was trying to fit them into hard rocking alternative music. And that's not what they were. They were adult contemporary easy listening, albeit with distorted guitar. Plus their image was terrible: 33 year old dorks in turtlenecks were never going to appeal to the early/mid nineties MTV generation.
turoniner 5 days ago
the book is insanely awesome, read it
rootandsky 3 years ago 2
yup
ilivetobeimmortal 3 years ago
I had no idea that these guys were from minnesota that's were i'm from
stmaskater 4 years ago
U should read the book by the drummer of Semisonic its a good book. Titled So you WAnt to Be a Rock and Roll Star
daaspacepope 4 years ago 4
Does anyone know what this song is supposed to be about? :-)
BatmanFanGirl 4 years ago
From what I recall, I think that it's about a friend's death (possibly due to suicide) and how it affected friends and family. Listen closely to the lyrics.
poptartjen 4 years ago
Thanks. I figured it was as suicide the part that puzzles me is the last verse. I was thinking he was an air pilot or something. he heh ;-)
BatmanFanGirl 4 years ago
great~
beyond7477 4 years ago 2
a classic...i thought the great divide was a better album than feeling strangely fine...maybe not but a great album nevertheless.
jetstobrazilni 4 years ago 2
... I didn't even know a video for this song existed, let alone one so gloriously 90's. One of my absolute favorite songs from one of my favorite bands. Thank you.
Velasa 4 years ago 3
not the best video, but i absolutely LOVE this band, and this song!
carpiegrl 4 years ago
I woud like to have seen the origional version of this video before they cut out all of the fire. I'm reading Jakes book right now and the story behind this is awesome.
supernaut2112 4 years ago
Man, this band and song alike ROCK! It's sad Semisonic didn't get farther than they did. Dunno why. Anyway, I like the video regardless, it fits the song really well. Thanks for the upload1
orangejellosphere 4 years ago
Great song, great video. This band should have gone far.
flashbird9 4 years ago 2
as stated before, great tune embaressingly bad video. loooow budget.
thenamelessavenger 4 years ago
I like this song alot.
Mooshpups 4 years ago
Great under-appreciated talent
spikiter 4 years ago 2
one of my favourite semisonic songs. video seems a little rushed though.
rokbom 4 years ago 2
I love this song, thanks for sharing.
ruij2301 4 years ago
GREAT song.... bad video.
bigstarcomix 4 years ago
not their best
benhunt2222 4 years ago
Dan looks like Jim Carrey.
dumburt 5 years ago
i like it
bigm115 5 years ago 2