Added: 6 months ago
From: thekiranbedi2011
Views: 32,597
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (292)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • digvijay singh ,kapil sibbal,rahul gandhi,sonia gandhi ko fansi de do...india automatic sudhar jayega... jai hind...

  • gov start playing the same dirty game which they play with baba ramdeve. since the good and sincerity and true movement best guide anna hazary could not be targeted directly so now gov targeting his team one by one. the first is swami agnesh and kiran bedi. we people don’t know the deep truth. if swami agnesh was a gov agent than people will teach him lesson one day. but we have to wait and give time him to clarify what is the truth. if swami was an agent of gov to cheat anna he lost his image

  • Thank you Anna.

  • Shame on Indian national congress and prime minister that they need Anna to draft a Bill to put corruption at bay.

  • Comment removed

  • its very shameful moment for all Indian, I have seen this video first time and seen that there are only 27thousand views but compare to murder2 movie songs have more views than this video. So, can i say people don't love there own country or u all people don't like freedom from all of this.

  • End this government then only lokpal bill can pass. First, investigation of all -Corruption made by congress and any other parties in past all years. ANd Then only the next government should stand.please share this

  • aNNa u juz go on I am wId U ~~

  • such a poor quality video

  • VIDEO QUALITY IS NOT GOOD

  • @parthbhaskar

    Your kapil sibal sucks that's why u hate truth

  • @IndianDesii thanks for the reply loaded with facts and information. ahem...ahem...ur just what we need in this rational debate!

  • Anna Hazare is admired in Pakistan also.He is great, may he live long life ,Inshallah.

  • Anna Hazare, Arvind Kejriwal, Prashant Bhushan ,Kiran Bedi... are God sent Angels to save India from the clutches of Corrupt Dictatorial Govt.

  • Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad Anna Hazare Jindabad !

  • please join anna at ramlila ground,"ye mashal jalti rahni chahiye."

  • No Law can be perfect it will require amendments periodically based on experience . This has been the case with our Constitution which has been amended 94 times since its enactmen.there is no magic wand it will take time we need to have patience There is no one giant step that does it. It’s a lot of little steps. Some law can abolish 70 % corruption in one stroke is a big bluff itself ..

  • Comment removed

  • Janlokpal bill is for the people by the people while Govt Bill is by the Corrupt Govt for the Corrupt

  • Comment removed

  • Govt Lokpal aims to Protect corrupt while punishing the people. Govt's bill is a dangerous bill. We all support Janlokpal Bill the real deal.

  • @vineetkapoor88 Lokpal will be accountable to public, as the whole infrastructure will be built around modern IT systems. So you will be able to get updates on every case being fought.

    Along with that you will be able to see the IT Returns of all the LokPal members.

    And the budget expenditure of LokPal system as a whole.

  • @vineetkapoor88 Ofcourse thats the logical way of improving any system. But only in theory!

    If u make a bad initial system design (of anything) and want to improve it, that would take much more efforts compared to starting from scratch.

    The govt. bill is not at all okay!! Would u report someone corrupt, if u knew that if he gets free from charges u go to jail for 2yrs. Is that okay?

    And check your facts our constitution has been amended 94 times only!!!

    Why this came after Anna's movement....

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @vineetkapoor88 Your name seems long too! Would it be appropriate to give it a acronym? So kindly remove that particular post.

  • Comment removed

  • jai hind .....................now something will change in common people appeal against corruption

  • Comment removed

  • @nishaoberoi1 Question for you: Why don't you fast and show the way to Kiran Bedi & Arvind Kejriwal? Similar how Anna is trying to show the way to this Monocracy...

  • @ram5438 answer for yu i dont believe in fasting..n why should i fast..if de will do anything ilegal i will complain in de court of law...Everyone knows the law and order system of India. If one abides by it, then there is no problem

  • @nishaoberoi1 What de??

  • @nishaoberoi1 Hey nisha I think you are one or other way related to corrupt politician or kapil sibbal himself is writing as nisha whomever may be you,your are thoughts are cheap.

    my first question is have you studied what lokpal bill is?can you say what is wrong in it?

    you dont know anything about that 74 year old man, then you dont deserve call yourself indian.

    come on yaar It is not the competition of fasting, there is no need to fast any other person.

    Shame on U...

  • @meghraj1234567890 dude we must always condemned these kind of negative support.... good job...

  • even if this bill is sanctioned ,it wont provide any positive results against corruption but would encourage monocracy

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I disagree with both the sides Anna's Team's views as well as Government's views. I think now its time to create Janta's Lokpal Bill ;)

  • @nainajain82 A kind request to you, its a serious topic, lets not dilute it by making a laugh at, poor & mal-feed, peoples expense.

  • @nainajain82 Ok I get u are not joking. But the view about 40% rubbish is baseless!

    The govt. bill says if you see something wrong report it but in end it doesn't gets proven you are sent to jail for 2yrs. If the corrupt person is convicted he gets 6months imprisonment. So would you like to report a wrong doing now?? And similar.

    Yes for debate, but govt was the one to reject video recording of joint committee. Nothing fishy here?

    Supporting a theme won't help, come up with ideas like JanLokPal!

  • @nainajain82 And sorry if I sound abrasive... From your words I get that you are trying to make the subject light, which is very much needed in such tense times. But this thing is about justice, a children even knows Corruption is bad, but when it comes to ourself, we give ourself priority over our values, just to escape the trouble. The bottomline is we have loopholes in our constitution and we need to plug them which this bill proposes and before this Anna tried talking with our politicians!

  • Comment removed

  • @nainajain82 I know u present here a neutral view, so do I :)

    Ther is a link for a Google Doc below the video, open it, goto Slide 9, ur logic will be disapproved!

    About the New Bill I am happy. But I have a scenario, by putting NCRA & the 5 bills together, they are gonna dilute the power of the proposed Jan LokPal bill. + logically would majority of MPs vote for it i.e. to remove their main source of income & motivation for joining politics? Probability says NO!

    So in the end poor-citizen is :(

  • @nainajain82 Are you kidding! Quote from slide 9 'Only Fines on Complainants'. Compare this with the Democratically Elected govt. '2-5yr imprisonment AND fines'. What are our Elected Leaders trying 'A Joke'?

    In murder & rape the accused hurts feelings of a person, which is not measurable!

    For theft it forceful or coerced stealing!

    Corruption/Graft is not doing your DUTY!!

    Everyone can do anything at his will, if the system allows. That's private sector can't hold that analogy for PUBLIC SECTOR..

  • Comment removed

  • @nainajain82 Hey, that's good. But why not share it in a public forum, especially this 1, as its Kiran Bedi's own channel. Our suggestions might make through to the ppl who matter and even to the bill itself.

    Ur answer to my question didn't make sense. There was no option of Right-Doers! Thats the exact state v are stuck in, whether to vote for a politician or a social activist? But v prefer to be ideal, taking no risk, cause if any1 of them screws up we don't want to take blame so we dont vote.

  • @nainajain82 1/2 Thanks for PROVING nothing! No rational or logic given to support ur speeeech. Not even a small new idea? Oh I forgot even if u have one, u won't share with ANYONE! How do u wish to contribute back to the world?

    For your specific reply: Dr. MMS is a good economist & a spineless politician. Indira was a Nehru, nepotist, opportunistic politician (do your research 1st) & courageous.

    And u don't need to put the description of these great people in (), it will be a shame not to know.

  • @nainajain82 2/2 Divisions of cast(e) & religions are due to lack of education. And that is due to the money allocated for it being scammed by politicians+govt servants. (Read: Votebank Politics).

    You are the first to divide people by Profession! What rational made u quote that?

    All get tempted, good or bad, what stops them is a deterrent, which Jan Lokpal provides.

    People who live behind glass walls or think life as a disney tale won't know the pain of a mal-fed in the real world.(Watch:Swades)

  • @ram5438 You have deviated from the theme. The theme is CORRUPTION, not Aarakshan.

  • @nainajain82 What the heck. You seem to be getting less logical with each reply or maybe you can't debate cause you are on the wrong side of right.

    Where did you get impression of Aarakshan (is it recent effect of seeing the movie by same name)? If you go through my answer its in reply to your questions!

    And the theme surely is Corruption.

  • doston ye Anna hazare to din b din Dictator banta ja raha hai .see what he said y day "lokpak bill lao warna jao" who in de hell is he to say all dis ????after all sab parliament members democratic way se chun ke aaye hain ...anna hazare kaun hota hai kehne wala bill loa warna jao .

  • Anna ka supprt matt karo democracy katam kar ke dictatorship lane ki koshish kar raha hai... kal ko bole ga lokpal ka member bhi mujhe hi banao sab decisions mai hi loon ga phir election bhi nahi hone de ga ......sab Mp's ko jail mai de ke khud dictator bann ke raaj kare ga . plz do not support him it will be vv dangerous in de long run ....law and order khatam ho jayega pakistan afganistan jaisa haal hoga

  • Govt Lokpal bill draft is worthy of the dustbin because it seems to encourage corruption and choke the voice of whistleblower. Leaving the PM out of the ambit of Lokpal is like leaving a gap to become a floodgate of corruption subsequently.

    I personally feel, the draft Jan Lokpal should immediately be placed in the parliament to eradicate corruption.

  • This is just amazing initiative. I love you guys CHEERS!!!!! TEAM ANNA!!!

  • WOW!!!! The differences and the intent of the Govt is so clear! Ofcourse the Jan Lokpal Bill is for the GOOD! Thanks Kiran for the comparison!

    ALL THE SUPPORT AND blessings from Australia!

  • since a mention of Facebook here ... some stats ..Indian userbase on facebook 31 millions (33587640 ) as of August 2011 that would be almost 41.5% of the online population of India. That would be just 2.5% of the population of the country. Just wondering what percentage of the 27.8% population that live in towns and urban agglomerations are out on the street pan india...is it more that the facebook reach

  • We need better clauses for Whistle Blowers.. Their exposes can reveal a chain that start with a low level official and end up with a MP/MLA being involved in most cases. If they are guaranteed protection under the condition of anonymity, we can do a lot better., We can also bring the Police out of Govt Control when they deal with corruption cases and are forced to listen to MP/senior officers who are puppets of ministers.

  • thanks mam......

  • mam, janlokpal bill is the bill of "aam aadmi"and the men of the country are standing behind you respected people. the politicians are like the clever JACKAL they come to us only for the vote. they do not want the janlokpal bill the maximum are involved in the curruption. so we will fight till the end.

    this vew is sendin by my all club staff sector - 15a noida inclab -jindabaad

  • CLICK ON: disccentury. MY MUSIC, NEVER SEEN

  • this is biased against the govt!

  • how can yu guys accuse somebody like kapil sibal who is doing so many reforms

  • @keeratkirat Taking our tax paid 100 rupees and distributing 25 out of it for people's benefit and giving 25 to the govt. employees as bribe, 25% to Congress party fund and keeping 25% to himself. How can't we accuse Parliamentarian Kapil Sibal??

  • Many thanks to Anna Ji and his team to wake up India peoples,

    We all with you keep it up. Now time has come to make them aware (Govt) about our rights.

    But My dear friends Jan Lokpal is not only the issue, there are several other grave issues also like Black Money in Swiss Bank, Terrorism, Child Labor, Unemployment, and many more India facing a long back.

    Agreed parliament is supreme but MP's are not, we send them in parliament and provide the power to serve something beneficial for our nation.

  • thanks again mam...

  • after this comparision, it is hard to go with govt lokpal, even after all sympathies with mr. prime mnister. also, how much changes are you going to make in govt version, there are fundamental faults. indeed, the govt should consider JANLOKPAL as basic source to go forward if they are to make any changes, as and when maybe required. JAI HIND

  • 14 cangress ppl dislike this

  • @rubenb119 - Online Protest/Dharna in support of Anna Hazare & Jan Lokpal Bill (For those who are unable to physically go and protest), Protest by staying online:

    "chatzy.coXm/341990155923" - Please Delete? 'X' between '.com' to access the link

  • Kiran Bedi madam,

    We,all the youngsters of India,are with you till the last breath.Never waiver in your path,till your conscience is clear.A billion hearts throb with you in support!!!

    BUT PLEASE,ALSO REMEMBER THIS IS NOT THE ONLY ISSUE FACING US.PLEASE KEEP ON PROTESTING FOR OTHER GRAVE ISSUES FACING INDIA.YOU WILL FIND US STANDING BY YOUR SIDE THERE ALSO:)

  • if Anna's team lokpal bill comes then hole india will change. every indian should support Anna and his Team.

  • Comment removed

  • @gowchennai41 :SURE BUDDY...THINGS WILL CHANGE FOREVER..LOTS TO FEAR FOR CHINA AND USA:(

  • i do not support jan lokpal bill

  • @keeratkirat can you explain why?

  • @rubenb119 What Anna is proposing is a dictatorship of officials in the Lokpal department. Since its all powerful, there is big chance of it being the most corrupt. den waht yu guys are going to do ??autorize one more authority n bill over lokpal ??

  • @keeratkirat so according 2 U judiciary is corrupt b/c judiciary is also all powerful correct?? wht abt the parliament. they R also all powerful. so they cn also B corrupt. wht R U going 2 do abt it?sit & cry lk U R doing now? Lokpal activities R going 2 B transparent. U cn complain abt any person in the lokpal team & action will B taken. All case details & info is going 2 B publicly available. ths is a sign that India is moving forward & ppl R fed up of the corruption we hear evry day.

  • i support JANLOKPAL BILL ......

  • Good afterNoon Mam..

    All indians are with Anna and Team.. the Jan lokpal Bill be intoduced..we all are with team...

  • pls go thr the bill govt wants it to b a formality by just ending all case to fir rest the govt will take care why?? why the crroput will not be punished..

  • bedi mam

    We tried becoz of this corruption .we don’t want any editing in lokpalbill.lokpal bill have to pass as original. we support for jan lok bill...We are with u .

    vande matarm..

    jai hind

  • Bedi Mam ,

    You and your team is absolutly right and government bill is cheating and misguiding

    way to the people of the country .we people are with you this time we can't give chance to the politician for loot.

    devendra prasad  vande matram

  • @devprasad77 - Online Protest/Dharna in support of Anna Hazare & Jan Lokpal Bill (For those who are unable to physically go and protest), Protest by staying online:

    "chatzy.coXm/341990155923" - Please Delete? 'X' between '.com' to access the link

  • mam you all are doing what would have been done long ago, from you i would like to say people like Aruna to stay away from this, it is clear that thay have been stood up by Congress, these politicians can do anything, we who cannot joing directly are all with you,but listen to justice Hegde also, wee all are with you

  • thank to kirab bedi

    after seeing both bill

    in my view jan lok bill is best way to control corruption

    as jan lok committe is free of goverment influence

    i support for jan lok bill

  • @shakushetty . There is no dictatorship in the current democracy form. Its 3 entities parliament, PM & cabinet and Judiciary.. All independent.. What Anna is proposing is a dictatorship of officials in the Lokpal department. Since its all powerful, there is big chance of it being the most corrupt.. The solution that anna & team is proposing is more evil than the problem.. Only way to solve this problem is make everything transparent and open . Then every citizen of india becomes a Lokpal.

  • @dibapiba By seeing your comments and views, I think a bigger threat than our corrupt politicians are half-educated people, who have half-understanding of how the system actually works. Did u take the trouble to even go through this video? Its not about dictating, its about keeping a check! Where is it in the present system? The true pillars of a democracy are Change, Transparency & Accountability! Not the ones u quoted, if else the case was so, we would have seen end of corruption 64yr earlier.

  • @Amit04uall I completely agree with you. Jai Hind!

    And the congressians are trying to mark your comment as Spam, this is the cheap state they have fallen to.

  • I am so glad that this video has been put it. I think everyone should read it and understand and shut the mouth of all politicians who say that the common man does not understand the bill.

    The Government Lokpal bill just demonstrates how government wants to fool Indians by making a law that would not apply to the government itself.

  • Proud of Anna and his whole team....thanks to it...the patriot in me has woken up...

  • kiran bedi ji

    I salute you.The details you have provided is very informative,but i request you that please make it same in HINDI also.Because that will be more effective for all indians even for me.

    Thanks a lot

    i am with you

    Amrik singh

  • @rickyjbp - Online Protest/Dharna in support of Anna Hazare & Jan Lokpal Bill (For those who are unable to physically go and protest), Protest by staying online:

    "chatzy.coXm/341990155923" - Please Delete? 'X' between '.com' to access the link

  • kiran bedi ji

    I salute you.The details you have provided is informative,but i request you that please make it same in HINDI also.Because than will be more efffective for all indians even for me.

    Thanks alot

    Amrik singh

  • I think this is the right way and approach to educate and inform people about the difference between the two bills.This way,general people will have a fair idea ,as ignorance and half knowledge is also dangerous..but I wud also like to know as to how team anna is planning to bring the details of this bill to the knowledge of the rural/illetrate man,who is also there on the streets???need to have a local dialect paper for all the regional centers,istnt it?

  • So All the 3 branches of government parliament, executive and judicary  which were supposed to 3 independent pillars of democracy lose their independence and come under Lokpal. In effect you have changed india from democracy to Lokpalshahi (a kind of dictatorship) and nullified the constitution of india.

  • @dibapiba I am trying to gauge the meaning of your comments. It appears to me that you are fine with the dictatorship of politicians and corrupt officials.

  • I would recommend you to read the versions of the bill in details and not superficially. It is very clearly highlighted that in case if a false complaint is made then the complainant is liable for punishment as well. Jan Lokpal does not intend to be a dictator. I think its the other way round its the government who wants to be a dictator which is evident from the bill that they have made and their actions.

  • if MPs come under the lokpal bill their action/speech in parliament, where is the independence of parliament. Remember for every action there is someone who doesn't like it and that person/s can attach any meaning/motive to that action and file a complaint. So MPs wont basically be able to function. Judiciary also comes under it..

  • What Anna's bill proposes is a Lokpal who will dictate how all the organs of the state will work. Some of the provisions of the jan Lokpal bill are well-intentioned but impractical, like the case of covering lower bereaucracy.. Even if you consider 1 person in lokpal department for every 100 govt employess of other department, Lokpal will become the biggest department in india.

  • अन्ना जी आगे बढ़ो हम तुम्हारे साथ हैं ..... कुचल दो इन भ्रष्टाचारियों (कोंग्रेसियों) को...

  • hum apke sath hain. jai bharat

  • Sarkari LokPal is clearly a eyewash by the governament and its as good as not having it..its a clear waste of time .Jan LokPal is definately far far better. Mrs Bedi..I was in Ramlilia Ground Yesterday and it was a great movement..Wud Congratulate Your team for Starting this great indian Movement. Also Would request you to appeal to ppl of NCR to come at RAmlila Gnd at specified time as there has been staggered agitatations all over NCR..all ppl at one loc will convey right message to the gov

  • हर पीढ़ी को नए प्रतीकों, नए आदर्शो और नए नायकों की जरूरत होती है।

  • Yesterday 301 watched it but see the count increasing 9,426

  • Yesterday 301 watched it but see the count increasing 9,426

  • Namaste Madam,

    App log bus age bado hum app ke saath hai.

    JAI HIND JAI HIND JAI HIND JAI HIND VANDE MATRAM

  • @youandhumtum - Online Protest/Dharna in support of Anna Hazare & Jan Lokpal Bill (For those who are unable to physically go and protest), Protest by staying online:

    "chatzy.coXm/341990155923" - Please Delete? 'X' between '.com' to access the link

  • I second Zahalaha, it would be much nicer if you told it in your own voice, Kiran Bedi. But whatever you decide, I am with you and would happy to help in anyway - should you ever need my help please ask for it. Jai Hind

  • Anna ji I m with you! You are truly amazing ! May God be with you ........ Jai hind !!!

  • VANDE MATARAM,

    Donot get distracted by Aruna Roy's lokpal bill, She is just trying to save UPA govt face as she is the part of NAC run under Sonia Gandhi. Where was she since april when the lokpal was being pursued.

  • With Aruna Roy's lokpal bill, looks like we need to include this also in the comparison. Jan Lokpal Vs Govt Lokpal Vs Aruna Roy's Lokpal...

  • Brilliant work! This slide must be passed on to all Indians so they know how the govt cheated team Anna. During the press conference Kapil Sibal was telling the media that the govt drafted the bill in consultation with Team Anna. Mr. Kerjival had a different opinion to this. Thanks to this slide, it all evident how committed the govt is.

  • One of the major flaw in the Jan Lokpal bill that I could say is the selection committee, under no circumstances as per Indian constitution PM and higher judiciary can come under an institution committee that is NOT elected by people of republic of india. In a democratic country persons or institutions elected by people and for the people should be respected and no other country or institution or organization should be authoritative against people elected institution.

  • VANDEY MATRAM..

    Through this i request all Indians 2 support ANNA HAZARE bcz being 74 yrs he got nothing 2 do in framing new laws fighting wit govt but still he is fighting for us..

    All must be aware and make others know the D/B govt and jan lokpal bill and must come out of house in supporting Anna till govt passes jan lokpal bill in parliament..

    India is rich but corruption is making it poor..

    its time 2 get independence from corruption..

    we r proud nd lucky 2 have u Anna..

    JAI HIND..

  • you are not doing this for any power (even though i'd like for you to be the president/ prime minister, which ever is higher in india) and plus the fasting.... i cant put enough words here but you have everybodys support... jai hind....

  • alright... so my parents watch news channel all the time but i always hated indian news. but since anna hazare's strike started i've been watching it. what an amazing person he is 74 and doing everything that a young man would be afraid to do. he is truly amazing. he is today's gandhi. actually he's todays anna... i am in living in usa born in india but ill still say that i am anna. even everybody here is supporting you sir... i really appreciate you doing this.

  • Good information ! Guys stop the habit of spoon feading

  • I guess these 10 dislikes are done by none other than people supporting the Corrupted Government...which is Congress as if for now.

  • Plz explain both in your own voice......

  • have anybody asked govt............. if five ministers can make a draft for important bill........... then........ was sh. Rajiv gandhi wrong in sending 5.5 lakh letters to different GRAM PANCHYATs for inviting suggestions before making a major decision.......... I SUPPORT JAN LOKPAL>>>>>>GO AHEAD.........we are with u......

  • First of all thanks for providing the details about the bill. This bill is perfect against corruption.

  • I think we should share these slides on slide share and not only on Youtube as there is not voice in these and it is difficult to read some of the small text. Just a suggestion if it is not too much for you all.

    -Jai Hind

  • anna team ka bill hi pariwartan laa sakta hai

  • we are with you madam aapke bill mein dum hai ......... vandey matram