When i first learned this song this is exactly how I played it. Then I saw Paul doing it and switched to his original version. Either way sounds good.
Wow i finally realised this wasnt paul with like 10 seconds left in the video. This was just an absolutely amazing cover. You my friend have done justice
@marycockburn1 really? anything else? are his strings wound ok? how about his nails... are they short enough? your kidding right? tell me your kidding.
@marycockburn1 not me... but kinda harsh for something that sounds really good. Why does it have to be exact is the point i was getting at in a sarcastic way.
@mrhunters cant help it if i hear something thats coverd if its not played like the original than to me its not worth it. sorry if that pisses you off. nice ovation btw. just prefer to play songs done by others how they do them. if i wrote a song and some one changed it id be mental
@marycockburn1 fair enough.. then it's not criticism, its opinion... (and this is not the owner of the video, just a viewer) I agree that is a sweet ovation.
Well progressed chord structure, and timing...you did the song proud, and it's always a pleasure to listen to any Beatles song when they're performed with such dedication. I'm sure the boys would be proud.
@Ystorm5leader "I'm not playing this absolutely correctly, and am aware of that.. just in case anyone wants to leave a comment to that effect." There is no need to inform him if he already knew.
I play blackbird this way (by this way I mean sliding up and down for the walk up the fretboard thing and with the strumming) I don't know how to scientifically put it, but that's the best I could come up with. S'long as it sounds the same/similar, who cares. Great cover man your voice suited it. As for the haters out there, lets face it, there's a lot on youtube who like to put people down on anything. Fuck 'em. Good job!
i just love this cover and i dont care how its played, as long as its played well it does not need to be exact it sounds good, this is my favorite song of all time even tho i prefer pauls version this is the best cover ive came across cant wait to get my black bird tattoo..............
without music there is only silence and what a horrible silence that wud be
Very nice! Played a bit different than Paul`s original but accomplishes the same thing. This version is actually easier for me to play than how Paul wrote it.
@whyyeseyec With respect to all here present, though this version may pass in the pop world for a nice bit, it does not accomplish the same thing as Paul's version, nor probably would any version, no matter how accurately mimiced from Paul's. In my experience, it is always true that the most interesting and musical bits are difficult to play initially which is why most give up on them. Learning the right way is instructive though, and there are several videos of that on Youtube.
@whyyeseyec And with of course respect to all here present: though it won't guarantee that you will become a musical genius, it NEVER hurts to know some proper theory, nothing too advanced, but at least learn something about chord function, e.g. in a major key: I, ii, iii, IV, V, vi, vii (dim). This is what makes chords work: their relation to one another, and you cannot learn it just by learning chords alone. See the Wikipedia article on "Blackbird". It shows how it "works", in part.
I'm glad y'all put out the advice not to cover the Beatles, or I might have covered them and then never had any respect from anyone, just like the Foo Fighters and Sheryl Crow and Fiona Apple and Aerosmith and Bob Dylan and Pearl Jam and Nick Cave and A Perfect Circle and Tori Amos and the Beach Boys and the Black Crowes and The Who and Stevie Wonder and U2 and Thrice and Soundgarden and Frank Sinatra and Elvis and the Red Hot Chili Peppers and hundreds more. Wouldn't want to wind up like them!
number one rule of life behind dont touch the water fountain with ur mouth. no matter how good you are never cover the beatles or you will be classified as the fifith jonas sister
@PhilliePhan9908 who made you the musical authority? Anyone can cover anything they want, and theres nothing you're "supposed" to do or not do musically. Music has no rules, you play what you feel in your soul and in your heart.
@Cpetrodrum I didn't say i was the musical authority. all i said was that covering the top band ever shouldn't happen. i didn't say that no one could, i just think you shouldn't. take it easy.
good job man, ur voice is pretty awesome. the guitar is kinda week though, i think ur playing like a real simple version or sumthin. the little bit harder one sounds a lot better and its still not all that hard to play
So true, i wish they did, but now its about stupid stuff i could care less about with no real good beat and lyrics are stupid now "your a jerk i know" Wth?
And you my good sir (xylopolist), you do have an amazing voice like Newgrasskid said, simply amazing. You are very talented, if you ever make a CD tell me, this is amazing
ok all the people saying "bad guitar"....no it's not! seriously, just browse some other youtube videos. you will quickly see just how good this guitar is. no, the picking pattern is not the same as the original, but so what?!
this is a great cover. i just spent (longer than i care to admit :) listening to all kinds of covers of this one song, and yours is easily among the top. great voice, right on pitch, beautiful guitar, good feel to it. nicely done. 5*
Beginning always reminds me of " Lagrima" by Frenandor Sor
sinner810 2 weeks ago in playlist More videos from xylopolist
YOU are .AMAZING. I love your voice. Great voice
MVSoff 3 months ago
I think your voice is beautiful, as well as the song. Great job :o)
baygirl1214 4 months ago
check out Alterbridge live at amsterdam's version of Blackbird and you' lle thank me for it it's Epic!!
clarissa1976 4 months ago
Not only does this not sound nasty like most other covers of this song On Tube, it sounds real nice. Great voice.
moneyquickeasy 4 months ago
He doesn't do the brat rite
dustmeyster 4 months ago
Who is this? This is amazingly beautiful!!!!!!!!!!
Em1980ish 5 months ago
When i first learned this song this is exactly how I played it. Then I saw Paul doing it and switched to his original version. Either way sounds good.
whyyeseyec 5 months ago
your playing it wrong, much too wrong. you simplify the picking to much, and its your base strings that are off so you know
gabolab123 6 months ago
@gabolab123 He can play it anyway he wants. Hence: cover.
moneyquickeasy 4 months ago
Great voice bro.... a kind of blues in it... reminds me a lot the Jeff Healey... Congrats... and keep going...
rodrigotramandai 6 months ago
nice!
Dontchokeonfear 7 months ago
gross
Zambeethoven 7 months ago
Wow i finally realised this wasnt paul with like 10 seconds left in the video. This was just an absolutely amazing cover. You my friend have done justice
dillpickle327 8 months ago
YOUR PLAYING IT WRONG sorry to sound a shit bbut your starting it of ok but on the take these broken wings its not a slide up down
marycockburn1 8 months ago
@marycockburn1 really? anything else? are his strings wound ok? how about his nails... are they short enough? your kidding right? tell me your kidding.
mrhunters 7 months ago
@mrhunters sorry you cant take critisim
marycockburn1 7 months ago
@marycockburn1 not me... but kinda harsh for something that sounds really good. Why does it have to be exact is the point i was getting at in a sarcastic way.
mrhunters 7 months ago
@mrhunters cant help it if i hear something thats coverd if its not played like the original than to me its not worth it. sorry if that pisses you off. nice ovation btw. just prefer to play songs done by others how they do them. if i wrote a song and some one changed it id be mental
marycockburn1 7 months ago
@marycockburn1 fair enough.. then it's not criticism, its opinion... (and this is not the owner of the video, just a viewer) I agree that is a sweet ovation.
mrhunters 7 months ago
@mrhunters mate sorry
marycockburn1 7 months ago
@marycockburn1 and fair warning don't watch my version.... your head may explode :p just kiddin.
mrhunters 7 months ago
@mrhunters hahahahaha. i didnt meen to sound like a dick mate sorry
marycockburn1 7 months ago
@mrhunters im sure your good have u seen anything of mine im crap but i try lol
marycockburn1 7 months ago
all is perfect, exept for the guitar ^^'
OupsmanTheFirst 8 months ago
Awesome:)
lovosazul 9 months ago
Dude you could get some major ASS with these skills!. sing it to a girl and I bet you 20 bucks she will melt
MrSweetleaf92 9 months ago
Awesome Voice. But i must admit i like the original guitar riff better.
Awesome anyways ;)
Keep it up.
Helbelinc 10 months ago
How do you learn to sing like that?
halfstepdown88 10 months ago
Your an excellent singer and guitar player. Keep on rocking.
5649320 10 months ago
You sing very well, but I'd recommend still doing the full, correct guitar part.
I mean-- just a suggestion.
But I understand covers are supposed to be creative (Except for Jessie McCartney's cover of this song... it sucked).
Anyways, good job.
ThatOneMusicGuy789 10 months ago
I'm going to record me playing this. I can play the actual version perfectly. No offense to xylopolist.
Ystorm5leader 10 months ago
@Ystorm5leader congrats homie. youre the real musican
tophue 8 months ago
@TheMangoGuy I didn't read the description.
Ystorm5leader 10 months ago
The BEST cover of Blackbird I have heard on YouTube! Wowww
lucke689 10 months ago 27
Excellent.
Well progressed chord structure, and timing...you did the song proud, and it's always a pleasure to listen to any Beatles song when they're performed with such dedication. I'm sure the boys would be proud.
Cheers mate, and well done.
Rick
Kaenz, OZ.
Rickporgera 9 months ago
Have to agree...This is a first rate cover. You've got it down pat, and the boys would be proud.
Well done mate,
Rick
Kaenz, OZ & PNG
Rickporgera 9 months ago
@lucke689 watch cameron mitchell's cover :))
bishounennoecchi 4 months ago
liked but not your guitar playing, your voice..
CanKuman8 11 months ago
holy shit your like amazing!!!
supergirls1311 11 months ago
@harysman Thank you! I see versions of this that are wrong a lot. Soon I will post a video of me playing it the originial.
Ystorm5leader 1 year ago
@Casanova: dude, I was informing him, and why do you care so much?
Ystorm5leader 1 year ago
Wrong strum pattern, dude.
Ystorm5leader 1 year ago
@Ystorm5leader
Who gives a shit?.
I don't give a shit.
Paul won't give a shit.
The man playing this song doesn't seem to mind either
So then the question arises, why do you give a shit?
CasanovaSessions 1 year ago 18
@CasanovaSessions I don't give a shit
Johnny75416 3 months ago
Comment removed
harysman 1 year ago
@Ystorm5leader Yes of course original is different. This is easy version :D
harysman 1 year ago
@Ystorm5leader "I'm not playing this absolutely correctly, and am aware of that.. just in case anyone wants to leave a comment to that effect." There is no need to inform him if he already knew.
TheMangoGuy 10 months ago
I love this song and you did a beautiful job with it. No one can do it like Paul McCartney but you came pretty close!
evillovely7 1 year ago
I love your voice
artsingguitar 1 year ago
I play blackbird this way (by this way I mean sliding up and down for the walk up the fretboard thing and with the strumming) I don't know how to scientifically put it, but that's the best I could come up with. S'long as it sounds the same/similar, who cares. Great cover man your voice suited it. As for the haters out there, lets face it, there's a lot on youtube who like to put people down on anything. Fuck 'em. Good job!
claytonsufc 1 year ago
do you have an ovation?
vballchics128 1 year ago
@vballchics128 can't you see that? yes. that is an ovation guitar.
Jagstaldincola 11 months ago
i just love this cover and i dont care how its played, as long as its played well it does not need to be exact it sounds good, this is my favorite song of all time even tho i prefer pauls version this is the best cover ive came across cant wait to get my black bird tattoo..............
without music there is only silence and what a horrible silence that wud be
so thank you for the music
sineadw86 1 year ago
Comment removed
sineadw86 1 year ago
nice job but the beatles didn't write this song. paul mccartney did.
daredfoxchick889 1 year ago
is his guitar tuned down one half step (ie, E-flat tuning)?
baalzebubble 1 year ago
Comment removed
baalzebubble 1 year ago
gotta add this cover to favs for sure,cause your voice is amazing,you playing in some band ? if not,you should be,if you do,then good luck!
DurtyHarrys 1 year ago
check my cover tooooooooo!! and leave a comment!
THANKS :D
parasbokhari 1 year ago
Simply beautiful
TheDarDar1 1 year ago
Very nice! Played a bit different than Paul`s original but accomplishes the same thing. This version is actually easier for me to play than how Paul wrote it.
Great job on vocals too!!
whyyeseyec 1 year ago
@whyyeseyec With respect to all here present, though this version may pass in the pop world for a nice bit, it does not accomplish the same thing as Paul's version, nor probably would any version, no matter how accurately mimiced from Paul's. In my experience, it is always true that the most interesting and musical bits are difficult to play initially which is why most give up on them. Learning the right way is instructive though, and there are several videos of that on Youtube.
acbulgin2 1 year ago
@acbulgin2 And finally, my very best for you all!
acbulgin2 1 year ago
@whyyeseyec And with of course respect to all here present: though it won't guarantee that you will become a musical genius, it NEVER hurts to know some proper theory, nothing too advanced, but at least learn something about chord function, e.g. in a major key: I, ii, iii, IV, V, vi, vii (dim). This is what makes chords work: their relation to one another, and you cannot learn it just by learning chords alone. See the Wikipedia article on "Blackbird". It shows how it "works", in part.
acbulgin2 1 year ago
beautiful job. i think i like your version better that the beatles. you don't have the corny little birdies in the background. lol. soulful voice.
powerfulnun 1 year ago
I just wanted to inform you that you're not playing it absolutely correct, and I'm sure you're aware of that.
Meyepadwe 1 year ago
I'm glad y'all put out the advice not to cover the Beatles, or I might have covered them and then never had any respect from anyone, just like the Foo Fighters and Sheryl Crow and Fiona Apple and Aerosmith and Bob Dylan and Pearl Jam and Nick Cave and A Perfect Circle and Tori Amos and the Beach Boys and the Black Crowes and The Who and Stevie Wonder and U2 and Thrice and Soundgarden and Frank Sinatra and Elvis and the Red Hot Chili Peppers and hundreds more. Wouldn't want to wind up like them!
afakaz 1 year ago
Oh My Gowd, I LOVE IT!
:'D
GinaaMonster 1 year ago
number one rule of life behind dont touch the water fountain with ur mouth. no matter how good you are never cover the beatles or you will be classified as the fifith jonas sister
quarrymen3000 1 year ago
Seriously get over yourself. It's a beautiful cover.
NuckingFutter 1 year ago
you're not supposed to cover the beatles...ever.
PhilliePhan9908 1 year ago
@PhilliePhan9908 who made you the musical authority? Anyone can cover anything they want, and theres nothing you're "supposed" to do or not do musically. Music has no rules, you play what you feel in your soul and in your heart.
Cpetrodrum 1 year ago
@Cpetrodrum I didn't say i was the musical authority. all i said was that covering the top band ever shouldn't happen. i didn't say that no one could, i just think you shouldn't. take it easy.
PhilliePhan9908 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@PhilliePhan9908
"you're not supposed to cover the beatles...ever."
what's wrong with U?
IChoseTheRedPill 1 year ago
Im moved... I did some research and now im even more move by its meaning. It sounds better than the original if you ask me.
216kingDavid1 1 year ago
This is a great beatles song!
07fabfour 1 year ago
very good song
simesricardo 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You are my inspiration for my blog...you do this song so amazingly awesome!!!
Thank you.
JacquelineD420 1 year ago
You are my inspiration for my blog...you do this song so amazingly awesome!!!
Thank you.
JacquelineD420 1 year ago
Ovation guitar, i approve :)
Gromstyle 1 year ago
Your very good... but the title is misleading
Dave7oddjob 1 year ago
Nice vocal.
aidanr444 1 year ago
The acoustics in that room are amazing. Good job.
drinkingwithwalruses 1 year ago
I like Paul's version but I actually prefer your version. !!!
jasedwads 1 year ago
@jasedwads I prefer Paul"s version but I like this version
Tinc00lb3ans 1 year ago
You are really good!!!!
ShamyNas16 1 year ago
Wonderful !!!
Utah08 1 year ago
Amazing. Thought you were Paul for a second. Great job!
fairyqueenqt 1 year ago
@fairyqueenqt no you didnt
Tinc00lb3ans 1 year ago
I like Jon Lajoie's version better!!
17lookatme17 1 year ago
thats my fav song, and this is the best cover ive heard yet
freekinkessler 1 year ago
crazy... good!
durfster1 1 year ago
this is just amazing! oh god, as good as Paul's version! and your voice is perfect for this song! I want to say BRAVO ! :D
niirvanaaa 1 year ago
AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!
moonbeamstar1976 1 year ago
My Hero.
James9x3 1 year ago
guitar lessons?! yes please!
violetsareblue92 1 year ago
AMAZING VOCALS!!
Billiejoe401 1 year ago
Nice playing and singing. Lovely version
BTW, get a life 1970metalfan.
saxismyaxe 1 year ago
@saxismyaxe well its to slow for me so what also he needs to tune his guitar and get the strumming pattern right
1970metalfan 1 year ago
You Are Good
MDexs 1 year ago
awesome stuff, well done mate!
bainbridge82 1 year ago
@bainbridge82 its not right he,s not as good as you think
1970metalfan 1 year ago
im 13 and this is my favorite song (:
missannabanana18 1 year ago
Amazing voice, thank you for making this! :)
zljng 1 year ago
ahh lovely playing
your voice suits this song really well
enyfink 1 year ago
PERFECT
albertbox07 1 year ago
What kind of guitar is that? good job man.
lhschillin101 1 year ago
good voice but you got the plucking wrong
MegaSuperhardcore 1 year ago
what tune it is?
Gugaaax 1 year ago
@Gugaaax
Guitar tune down 1/2 step
I think so...
luandivad 1 year ago
good singing
xterra43 1 year ago
Love your voice!!
yoliyofi 1 year ago
greAt voice man
esej1 1 year ago
this is really Amazing!!!!!!
AGD4797 1 year ago
yeah just add that bit of picking cuz the voice is amazing, really... amazing
MJequalsPBeatles 1 year ago
nice job man. digging the voice, really unique. playing is good too. keep it up man!
Fransisco181 1 year ago
good job man, ur voice is pretty awesome. the guitar is kinda week though, i think ur playing like a real simple version or sumthin. the little bit harder one sounds a lot better and its still not all that hard to play
Tstraub90 1 year ago
your voice is the most soothing thing ive ever heard
xoredhead47 1 year ago
I love this
it's greaaat
whoaitsaflyingllama 1 year ago
but the voice is nice
xxxNOERVANAxxx 2 years ago
beautiful voice
Wickedpru 2 years ago
you have to use folkpicking
xxxNOERVANAxxx 2 years ago
you mean travis.. travis picking style,,
bigbutlittlebrother 2 years ago
he always forgets to strum.
amplifiymytaco 2 years ago
Awesome voice
Riftlol 2 years ago
Why is he flipping us off, the whole song?
SpeedBuggy92 2 years ago
very good cover, i like what you did for the rhythm
earthman202 2 years ago 2
Nice :P
Look my channel 2 i have covered Julia and blackbird to :P
All please take a look and give me advice
lollyhobbid 2 years ago
Uhm donkeyboy... ive learned this song att 2 days. no problem, how the fuck can you be trying to cover this song i Months?
darkdude760 2 years ago
you are amazing! ive been trying to cover this song for a couple months now! really really good!
donkeylove15 2 years ago 2
its good man.
and im not sayin that much haha
Jurr144n 2 years ago
i loveeeee the key you play this in. you sound incredible
dirtrider2009 2 years ago
@dirtrider2009 this is the normal key
romanliver 2 years ago
its a half step down. maybe full. at least half tho. i compared them with editing and its not
dirtrider2009 2 years ago
it's so so so nice :)
MusicalFreakies 2 years ago 5
beautiful i loveeeeeee your voice! and your guitar playing is amazing, (:
purpletycoon 2 years ago 5
@purpletycoon this is the normal key.......
romanliver 2 years ago
@romanliver no it isnt, watch paul mccartney play it, sorry man, its not the right one, but its still a good cover
Drizzydid 2 years ago
omg this is like the only good cover ever made, excellent, love it. i am huge mccartney fan so thanks for giving this song justice
bofopy 2 years ago 4
The trick is to really hammer home the screach across the guitar when you go from high to low notes.
SirPwn4lot 2 years ago
good job ! keep it up
Im surprised by the good sound of ur guitar man !!!
drvn07 2 years ago
that string was trying to talk to me with sign language
Rainman270 2 years ago 7
ahh finding a guy with a good voice is so hard
:D this is great
kiisings88 2 years ago 6
This song is excellent
to bad people don't make songs like this anymore
ziffena 2 years ago 39
@ziffena
So true, i wish they did, but now its about stupid stuff i could care less about with no real good beat and lyrics are stupid now "your a jerk i know" Wth?
And you my good sir (xylopolist), you do have an amazing voice like Newgrasskid said, simply amazing. You are very talented, if you ever make a CD tell me, this is amazing
1979HeathLedger2008 1 year ago
@ziffena they do. just gotta find em lol
dawky101 1 year ago
wow. Your voice is amazing.
Newgrasskid 2 years ago 44
You have a great voice, but you obviosly know that. I just finished learning this song recently, it's so beautiful :) Nice job.
TheJustJune 2 years ago 6
voice is unreal fair play man!
odorgasm 2 years ago 4
I play this song tonight :D
I don't speak english, but this song is great :D
teoka13 2 years ago 5
Awesome :D
domofluffy 2 years ago 4
Very nice...
Krazede 2 years ago 4
i really love your voice, you did a great job.
AmEEbz 2 years ago 4
Hmmm.....too slow.....but it still sounds very nice, and your voice sounds so beautiful! :D
oldgrannycatari 2 years ago 4
your guitar is half step down, mm, you need to improve your fingering, but you have a great voice ;D!
Regards!
Triplee8 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Beautiful! Wonderful job. :)
artsyfartsyme 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
damn if u could sing like paul it would make it a hell of alot better i can sing like paul so ha but really ur good
400austin 2 years ago
man you're so damn good : )
globuska0895 2 years ago 2
is that an ovation? Im planning to get one of those :] I love this cover. You voice is great
AnneWorld 2 years ago
I have an ovation celebrity its an elecrto acoustic very nice
mastermind172 2 years ago
Ibanez Montage? Or Ovation?
rastamaniakTHC 2 years ago
Im play guitar but your playing good en your voce is great
nederlandseman23 2 years ago
No one can do justice next to The Beatles...
But you have a beautiful voice and play beautifully... don't put down your talent for little mistakes...
Thank you for Sharing
~GYPSY~
GypsyDayDreamer 2 years ago 2
man ur voice is good ;]
rastamaniakTHC 2 years ago 3
Great job, great voice :)
evilnijn 2 years ago 3
great
TheGReaper1234 2 years ago
awesome! :) but maybe it's a too slow...
Cheere96 2 years ago
OMG your voice is great!! good cover!!!!
ferviteri 2 years ago 2
I like it... You rock!
titelune24 2 years ago 2
ya great voice
arkalauz 2 years ago
The guitar is not quite in tune, but your voice is definitly! Wauw<3
MajaHHede 2 years ago
Beautiful singing :)
You could indeed speed up the fingerpicking in some parts, but this sounds really good to me anyways, great work!
Ropepope 2 years ago
not bad speed it up a bit
degeneratex869 2 years ago
i wouldnt go that far but it is amazing
ke10pwns 2 years ago
dont listen to these fuckin faggits..i like it better than the original song wish i could do wut ur doing
footballcrazed22 2 years ago
ok all the people saying "bad guitar"....no it's not! seriously, just browse some other youtube videos. you will quickly see just how good this guitar is. no, the picking pattern is not the same as the original, but so what?!
this is a great cover. i just spent (longer than i care to admit :) listening to all kinds of covers of this one song, and yours is easily among the top. great voice, right on pitch, beautiful guitar, good feel to it. nicely done. 5*
aowrya 2 years ago 4
p.s. simplistic does NOT = bad. in fact, it's quite appropriate for this song
aowrya 2 years ago 2
That was a very good cover. And I think you did the song justice.
GG5789 2 years ago 2
so what the picking pattern is different its a cover get over it, i like it dude 5 stars
Rick5495 2 years ago 3
great voice
jigsaw9567 2 years ago 2