Interesting fact. This was the first music video in Chinese popular music history. From watching documentary. The movie was controversial in that it brought music from the streets to the silver screen. This particular type of song and lyrics were typically sang by street prostitutes in Shanghai. (Hence the erotic connotation to the lyrics.) The composer broke barriers by bring this style of music to the screen and made Zhou Xuan a pop music super star of her time.
reminds me of old granny..she sailed to malaya with late papa..and love playing this songs....i recall when i was a kid in 60s back in KL....they're gone but their stories,memories,adventures, surviving spirit and their love for china stays on...
just so touching,,,reminds me of late old grandma who sailed to malaya then with late papa...they play this song all the time..i recall when i was a kid in 60s in kl,, they're gone but their stories ,adventures, their love for china stays on....
just so touching,,,reminds me of late old grandma who sailed to malaya then with late papa...they play this song all the time..i recall when i was a kid in 60s in kl,,,
It just occurred to me the erotic implications of this song. The woman is the needle and the man the thread. Threading the needle... Ooooh.. Now that is Hom sup!
@sakoosoup Of cause Zhou Xuan was the first and original singer for this song. It was written as one of the lead song for her breakthrough movie.The person who wrote the melody only passed awaw 11 years ago in his 90s. The person who wrote the words,also wrote the words for Chinas National Atham, and he passed away in 1968. He had a bad time during the cutural revolution period....sadddd
@sakoosoup Of cause Zhou Xuan was the first and original singer for this song. It was written as one of the lead song for her breakthrough movie.The person who wrote the melody only passed awaw 11 years ago in his 90s. The person who wrote the words,also wrote the words for Chinas National Atham, and he passed away in 1968. He had a bad time during the cutural revolution period....sadddd
There are things in life that just grow on you as you get older and Zhou Xian's voice is one of them. The more I listen to her, the more I love lstening to her.
@6955ken I think 周璇 was 17 when the movie was made (according to the documentary). She was as innocent as the movie portrays her to be - this belies her life in later years which was full of tragedy. Even though she made many movies afterwards, her first film 馬路天使 for which this music video was made, remains her favorite.
for those who don't know this version is first and "naive" movie version... it is supposed to be carefree and rough around the edges. the later version is slower, more emotional and sad. the version that people should hear is the studio version that appears on most audio collections.
Agree with Bmei39. She is unbeatable. Any remake can only be different but not better than her. This was her classic hit. She is definitely in a class of her own. Listen to her sing not jus this song but all her other hits and u will know why.
It depends, Most people now write from left to right, if we write horizontally. However, if we mean to write vertically, we usually write from right to left. But traditionally, we write (and read) vertically and from right to left. So you just have to get use to it, I guess.
@lauls85 Writing style also depend on period. In the Ming dynasty, horizontal writing was left to right. In the Qing dynasty, it switched to right to left. The republic period it stayed right to left, until it was later changed to left to right.
It is sometimes funny to see ancient Chinese signs because the writing order changes from left to right or right to left depend on how old it is. People do get confused.
I first heard this song in the 1940's in China. Now, very time I hear this song, it brings tears to my eyes. Zhou Xuan was the most-loved singer-actress in China. She came from a sad backgroung, lived an unhappy life even when she was famous, and died tragically at a relatively young age.
@sakoosoup There is a huge amount of info on Zhou Xuan available on the Internet. Go to Google search and enter Zhou Xuan. There is also a Chinese search site, baidu.com. Enter Zhou Xuan or 周璇, for info in Chinses and English. You'll find photos and much, much more.
Thanks for posting this song, I grew up listening to the oldies like this, but never know how the singers look like. This is history, now I am eager to see the whole movie. Do you know Zhou Xuan's biography?
The boy is Zhao Dan a well known actor that was persecuted during the Communist Revolution in China this led to his death. He was from a theatrical family and had great ability as an actor - able to play various different roles.
All songs of Chou Shuen were released by Pathé Records Company of Shanghai. Now it is named EMI. This company remains all songs of hers. You may buy from any records shop. I bought many records of hers while I was in Hong Kong. Unfortunately I abandoned all these records in Hong Kong coz I immigrated to Brazil. These records were very heavy. Each one weighs ???. Glad I can hear songs of Chou Shuen here.
I should appreciate to those who posted the videos in youtube.
It's a little different (the tone and the rhythm) from the one I used to listen to when I was a kid; maybe the one I heard was a re-interpretation of this number?
Hey! flor here frm Singapore. Maybe the one you heard is the Cantonese version. I've heard both versions.This Mandarin version above is sung by Zhou Xuan. The Cantonese also sang this song in their own dialect. My nanny is a Cantonese and she sings this in Cantonese...I know Mandarin, Cantonese, Hokkien and Teochew *( a jumble of Chinese dialects). All the dialects hve different enunciation and intonations. Hope this helps...I can sing for you in Cantonese- heh!
Thanks for your comment. But the record that I first heard Zhou Xuan from was an original owned by my grandfather. The first line was very different. And I speak Cantonese, too, so I don't think it's the different dialects that are confusing me. In fact, if you click on "Last Appeared of Zhou Xuan 周璇最后一次露面", you will hear a different version, too.
Ok Wqkawai..I will go listen to the last appearance of Zhou Xuan. I am excited to hear a different version. Whoa! Yr grandpa has an original - that's amazing...you must preserve the record. from flor
Kawai, I listened to the last appearance of Zhou Xuan. It is exactly the same song, trust me. But what happened is, she sang abit of the first line, and the TV pple cut or JUMP FORWARD to the 2nd portion of the song. U get what I am saying? Hope it clears the confusion..and she is singing in Mandarin. I know this song line by line becos I was trained to sing it as a child. I am happy to be Chinese. We have a old rich culture. From FLor, Singapore
Ok.you are right in every aspect. Just treat me as stupid...ok? I'm tired of analyzing it. I just want to enjoy the song as it is. Perhaps in the earlier version, she sang with an accent (becos she was younger). Then when she was older, she used the proper Han Yu Pin Yin pronunciation. Anyway, yr Mandarin is better than mine and yes- you are clever. I admit I am stupid, satisfied? Ok...fine.
This is really simple, she re-recorded the song just for the movie. This happened a lot of times for movies from different countries because you needs to edit the song to fit in the flow of the movie
虽然当时录音设备没那么好,但是她的声音那么甜美,纯粹,真诚,可爱。这样的声音是现在很多歌手无法企及的。
kozlowsiki2000 2 weeks ago
thanks for uploading this . . .
lingbizkit19 3 weeks ago
死时五十七岁?可惜。
hongkongbabygirl 4 weeks ago
很天真,很原始的,近乎不知天高地厚的少女梦想爱情的声音。 好听!
hongkongbabygirl 4 weeks ago
如果從那時開始順承下來,沒有經歷共產時代的破壞,現在的中國流行音樂應該早已走向世界了吧?
Chinesearebest 4 months ago 4
@Chinesearebest
是啊,又一个印度,可以拍个肇家浜边的百万富翁让西方人同情同情
yaozeal 1 month ago
Greeting from Canada, I enjoyed this fantastic song let's see about 65 years ago. It still is a nice piece of music !!!
tt08ck02 4 months ago
Greetings from America!
very melodious song
cmhrao 5 months ago
可惜啊,39岁就被迫害致死,唏嘘不已
linbsd 5 months ago
@linbsd 周璇并不是被迫害致死的,是57年患急性脑膜炎而逝的。红颜薄命。。。
shyboy1013 5 months ago
红颜薄命,唉。
当时这么简单的曲调与歌词但是却能令人记忆犹新传唱不衰。
xiaoribenwocaonidaye 7 months ago
Unique, outstanding and very impressive.
I heard of Zhou Xuan fame many years ago. Had never heard of her singing till I found this on Youtube months ago.
bkkhatyai 7 months ago
30年代的歌,
有一種很特殊的情懷,
令人一聽難忘…
好感動!
iceknife1989 7 months ago
Interesting fact. This was the first music video in Chinese popular music history. From watching documentary. The movie was controversial in that it brought music from the streets to the silver screen. This particular type of song and lyrics were typically sang by street prostitutes in Shanghai. (Hence the erotic connotation to the lyrics.) The composer broke barriers by bring this style of music to the screen and made Zhou Xuan a pop music super star of her time.
astroboy2345 8 months ago
周璇不愧是金嗓歌后!
jgyarthur 9 months ago
reminds me of old granny..she sailed to malaya with late papa..and love playing this songs....i recall when i was a kid in 60s back in KL....they're gone but their stories,memories,adventures, surviving spirit and their love for china stays on...
123kcsee 10 months ago
just so touching,,,reminds me of late old grandma who sailed to malaya then with late papa...they play this song all the time..i recall when i was a kid in 60s in kl,, they're gone but their stories ,adventures, their love for china stays on....
123kcsee 10 months ago
just so touching,,,reminds me of late old grandma who sailed to malaya then with late papa...they play this song all the time..i recall when i was a kid in 60s in kl,,,
123kcsee 10 months ago
just so touching,,,reminds me of old grandma who sailed to malaya then with late papa...they play this song all the time..i recall
123kcsee 10 months ago
is this the original video??
Jennystarburst 10 months ago
@Jennystarburst yup
PeacherLiz 10 months ago
我的手机铃声就是这歌。很古典,很有味道。说不出来的味道。
jiejiao0104 11 months ago
It just occurred to me the erotic implications of this song. The woman is the needle and the man the thread. Threading the needle... Ooooh.. Now that is Hom sup!
lwongphoto 11 months ago
@lwongphoto - Very True Indeed - You Are Intelligent
khatpandwa 11 months ago
I lived in Vancouver. Found it in Chinses DVD stores. I can sent you my copy if you want, it's in Video CD though.
jojo2468able 1 year ago
I am wondering between Li Xiang Lan Vs. Zhou Xuan who was original singer for this song?
sakoosoup 1 year ago
@sakoosoup Of cause Zhou Xuan was the first and original singer for this song. It was written as one of the lead song for her breakthrough movie.The person who wrote the melody only passed awaw 11 years ago in his 90s. The person who wrote the words,also wrote the words for Chinas National Atham, and he passed away in 1968. He had a bad time during the cutural revolution period....sadddd
ahhingme 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@sakoosoup Of cause Zhou Xuan was the first and original singer for this song. It was written as one of the lead song for her breakthrough movie.The person who wrote the melody only passed awaw 11 years ago in his 90s. The person who wrote the words,also wrote the words for Chinas National Atham, and he passed away in 1968. He had a bad time during the cutural revolution period....sadddd
ahhingme 1 year ago
this is the best version, there is no version that can be better than hers even if the audio at that time sucked compared to today's!!!
周旋's 天涯歌女 cannot be repeated!!
这是最好的版本,没有版本能变得更好,即使当代的錄音比现在的差!
MrBigEnchilada 1 year ago
There are things in life that just grow on you as you get older and Zhou Xian's voice is one of them. The more I listen to her, the more I love lstening to her.
Contrerasrobert1 1 year ago
那时候竟然尽然就用传统的戏班来为流行歌曲伴奏,不可思议
smkyy 1 year ago
周旋那時候像個十五六歲的少女 聲音細的很自然 像是娃娃音 不像有些模仿周旋的歌星故意拉高尖細的嗓門唱出來 就很做作了
6955ken 1 year ago
@6955ken I think 周璇 was 17 when the movie was made (according to the documentary). She was as innocent as the movie portrays her to be - this belies her life in later years which was full of tragedy. Even though she made many movies afterwards, her first film 馬路天使 for which this music video was made, remains her favorite.
astroboy2345 1 year ago
很少看得到老歌有mtv哦,好听!谢谢分享。。。。
fly789789 1 year ago
谢谢分享这首经典好歌!!
conpla 1 year ago
然后国都就被破了。
mayflydn 1 year ago
She sang like a lovely 3 years old little girl , very cute . I love it .
nce04048g 1 year ago
I have this movie VCD "马路天使"
jojo2468able 1 year ago
@jojo2468able Where are you located I like to purchase a copy.
ahhingme 1 year ago
I'm surprised that there's a MTV for the song.
Thanks for posting.
bigboss97 1 year ago 2
how beautiful.
zhinan888 2 years ago 4
看了我好感動, 謝謝...
MegaMusicwhore 2 years ago 6
for those who don't know this version is first and "naive" movie version... it is supposed to be carefree and rough around the edges. the later version is slower, more emotional and sad. the version that people should hear is the studio version that appears on most audio collections.
she was incredible.
ushireborn 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
ushireborn 2 years ago
Classic. Li Xiang Lan version also very unique.
kikapo1974 2 years ago
her son is raised up by 田漢
carrollckjcm 2 years ago
Her voice is bit low and coarse. But it suits Er Hu.
Tried Li Xiang Lang, is different.
chengho2007 2 years ago
Agree with Bmei39. She is unbeatable. Any remake can only be different but not better than her. This was her classic hit. She is definitely in a class of her own. Listen to her sing not jus this song but all her other hits and u will know why.
Nanyanguo 2 years ago 3
I have listened to many versions, in my view, no one can be as good as Zhou, not even Terisa Tang.
bmei39 2 years ago 11
以前不太喜歡老歌,總覺得憋著嗓子唱出來的,後來接觸粵劇崑曲京戲,感覺3.40年代老歌星帶著一點中國古典戲曲的唱腔演繹電影角色吧!當時電影算是摩登玩意,1937周璇不到20歲,有這等音色跟表演技巧很厲害!
escada19821010 2 years ago 6
在當年來說,已十分高水準.歌手本身也演譯得很好,所以當時很受人愛戴。
lochunhung2 2 years ago
当年录音技术太差了,声音有点失真。
fullmoonmax 2 years ago
i just notice the chinese writing is read from right to left haha, is really long time ago...
zirron75 2 years ago 5
It depends, Most people now write from left to right, if we write horizontally. However, if we mean to write vertically, we usually write from right to left. But traditionally, we write (and read) vertically and from right to left. So you just have to get use to it, I guess.
lauls85 2 years ago
@lauls85 Writing style also depend on period. In the Ming dynasty, horizontal writing was left to right. In the Qing dynasty, it switched to right to left. The republic period it stayed right to left, until it was later changed to left to right.
It is sometimes funny to see ancient Chinese signs because the writing order changes from left to right or right to left depend on how old it is. People do get confused.
astroboy2345 1 year ago
I've heard many versions. Zhou Xuan's is still the best, off tune erhu and all.
It has...charm, something which all the others lack.
bidufu 2 years ago 5
看了以上的意见,觉得这些写感言的人,即没知识又没水准,还是多读点书吧,别再丢人现眼。周璇是中国至今最伟大的歌唱家,人美歌甜,希望大家对她多认识些,免得让人笑话,谢谢!!
mymogatemyhw 2 years ago 4
不至于最伟大吧! 芳艳芬, 邓丽君等也是很出色的, 你听过没有? 无论如何, 我蛮喜欢周璇她那独特的唱腔, 林黛玉的感觉.
cschan369 2 years ago 3
周旋是第一代影星
算是个时代代表
说她伟大是因为她代表了一个时代的艺术
是第一个偶像歌星
开辟了一个艺术的新时代
所谓承上而启下
是为艺术家
hanwei1984 2 years ago 8
我并没有要贬低周璇的意思,但如果用你的理论把她这个音乐家与贝多芬比,贝是英雄造时势,而周只能是时势出的英雄而已!
cschan369 2 years ago 3
民初妇女的地位还是很低,周旋的出身悲惨得近乎民国版的slumdog millionare。 可能说,于她的时代,一位女性的歌手只能被打造吧。
totosun4fam 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
還有下面那個sweetcandy539的阿陸仔,耳朵在我身上,愛聽什麼東西老子的權利,什麼叫做唱的沒人家好聽就不能批評,你講這種話本身就暴露你的程度之低下,我不會做汽車,但是我有自己的鑑賞準則,有錢買汽車我就可以批評,照你的邏輯,你也不必看棒球了,反正你也不會打嘛,儘是說些無用的廢言,人家一句話就讓你惱羞成怒,在社會上要陷害你這種人可真是容易哪!
porkhere 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
你們幾個傢伙,片子放上來不敢讓人批評就別放,有本事放就要有本事聽人說難聽,我覺得難聽你們有意見嗎?啊不然是想怎樣?你也不能怎樣嘛,充其量只能在這邊打嘴砲,飯桶!
如果你沒本事拿刀槍逼人家說好聽,就乖乖接受批評,不然就只是暴露自己的氣度!
還問候我年紀多大,你什麼東西,動不動就問候人家年紀,家教可真好啊!
porkhere 2 years ago
怎么像是在那里已经听过了呢
很好听呀
hinblack 2 years ago
词好曲好歌也好. real classic.
junjunge68 2 years ago 6
我想是因为当时的录音设备不好,所以声音质量放出来和现在的比差一些吧
人家唱得挺好,我觉得;)
iamzzl 2 years ago 9
awesome!!!!!!
jiumentidu 2 years ago
Comment removed
simomtse 2 years ago
难听你干吗还听啊???你能唱得比她好吗???不可以对吗???所以就请你乖乖的避上你的嘴,然后滚蛋!!!!
sweetcandy539 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
你什麼東西啊你,這不關你的事情,滾一邊去!
porkhere 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
這首歌真有夠難聽了
porkhere 2 years ago
porkhere 你年紀有多大了 ? 你說難聽 ? 你耳朵有病呀 ?
simomtse 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
你莫名其妙耶,我不能說難聽啊,你共產檔啊!
porkhere 2 years ago
姑娘十八一朶花
lochunhung 2 years ago
the boy's smile is quite dirty...
very yam(cantonese)
no offends to the actor k
jacquijia 2 years ago 6
嘻嘻,郎呀郎 = 狼呀狼!!! 哈哈,开玩笑啦。。。。
SEz610i 2 years ago
@jacquijia 我喜歡周璇的唱腔. 無與倫比. 也同意你的, 那個男的有點難頂,
好淫的表情, 也夠造作, 有倒胃感覺.
lcsthomas 1 year ago
She sang really great!
No one can replace her lovely voice!
Thanks for sharing! 5*
ming0508 2 years ago 4
are you sure this is the original version of Zhou Xuan?~~ confused.
jill198751 3 years ago
definetly brings back memories to the older generations and to those who know of Zhou Xuans legacy of the generation today. Such a beautiful song
theaznkid8 3 years ago 2
wow... i thought it was a sad song... but after watching this original version... seems like its a happy song...
asvoriapenxil 3 years ago
zhou xuan performed both happy version and sad version of this song in the same movie. And both of them are equally beautiful.
jhe326 3 years ago 5
Even as a little girl half a century ago, I loved this song and even though I can barely make out the words! Thanks so much for uploading.
LoveLotusHa 3 years ago 4
Beautiful! Hen hao!
aiyanglee 3 years ago
so unpretnetiously beautiful! zhou xuan is an angel from the sky!
pizmiov 3 years ago
非常好听。。小时候经常听老人唱这些歌曲。。。而且是从来没上过学的老人,很多年竟然还记得歌词,真佩服这些歌曲的魅力。。
strayelu 3 years ago 18
i like this song very much..
jeanhom1 3 years ago 2
還蠻好聽的耶
真是會唱~
yvonne7982 3 years ago
how sweet she was...
c76h 3 years ago 2
I first heard this song in the 1940's in China. Now, very time I hear this song, it brings tears to my eyes. Zhou Xuan was the most-loved singer-actress in China. She came from a sad backgroung, lived an unhappy life even when she was famous, and died tragically at a relatively young age.
wingklow 3 years ago 34
I love this song very much. Whenever I hear this song, tears welled up in my eyes with the memory of her sad background.
Patricklam1963 3 years ago 2
@wingklow
I like when someone share past of Chinese super star in English. Anymore about this movie and Zhou Xuan?
sakoosoup 1 year ago
@sakoosoup There is a huge amount of info on Zhou Xuan available on the Internet. Go to Google search and enter Zhou Xuan. There is also a Chinese search site, baidu.com. Enter Zhou Xuan or 周璇, for info in Chinses and English. You'll find photos and much, much more.
wingklow 1 year ago
@wingklow , yes i agree similar to the death of T. Teng.. but her friends were mixed up into the drug scene in Japan
Idorun100 1 year ago
She is so cute...
Now I wish I was born 60 years early
hkboy82 3 years ago 4
sweet
sospire 3 years ago
i love her
calvinma1 3 years ago
zhou xuan is so lovely...
balsid07 4 years ago 2
The first time listening to this song by Zhou Xuan. :) Very captivating smile and and her song is sweet. ^_^
Also like her acting. :)
LeeYiCong 4 years ago 2
周漩好可愛﹗
hongkongmama07 4 years ago 4
Thanks. Now I know where this beautiful song comes from.
niulang 4 years ago
Thanks for posting this song, I grew up listening to the oldies like this, but never know how the singers look like. This is history, now I am eager to see the whole movie. Do you know Zhou Xuan's biography?
orcaskat 4 years ago
Wow!That boy is cute!
summary1982 4 years ago 4
The boy is Zhao Dan a well known actor that was persecuted during the Communist Revolution in China this led to his death. He was from a theatrical family and had great ability as an actor - able to play various different roles.
richardyingren 3 years ago 2
I didn't know that she was so sweet!
ahsue8 4 years ago
thank you
marsover 4 years ago
Oh ! Your vids are really rare ,thanks for sharing them with us .
happyccdna 4 years ago 7
What is the name of the male actor in this movie? Was he famous? He's cute.
alacboy 4 years ago
zhao dan (趙丹)
he was the top billing actor in 30's and 40's
he is in heaven now...
ozgamboi 4 years ago 3
This is a great film, and if you want to see a version with well written subtitles, check out Street Angel put out by Cinema Epoch.
ty
tlyoung88 4 years ago
she was so cute... and natural.
zhinan888 4 years ago
I love her, xie xie.
richardyingren 4 years ago
what a classic. She was so much cuter than a lot of the stars today!
zhinan888 4 years ago
49年新中国成立后,除了繁体变简体,一些汉字的发音也发生了变化。但是现代京剧里还是保留一些过去的发音。
tinystar316 4 years ago 3
Zhou Xuan's 50th death anniversary is this year's September 20th. There will be a "Tribute to Zhou Xuan"
on 8th september, here in Singapore at the Esplanade. Tickets on sale at all sistic outlets. Please support!!
phyphy777 4 years ago
All songs of Chou Shuen were released by Pathé Records Company of Shanghai. Now it is named EMI. This company remains all songs of hers. You may buy from any records shop. I bought many records of hers while I was in Hong Kong. Unfortunately I abandoned all these records in Hong Kong coz I immigrated to Brazil. These records were very heavy. Each one weighs ???. Glad I can hear songs of Chou Shuen here.
I should appreciate to those who posted the videos in youtube.
ienjoyverymuch 4 years ago
chan hai m koi sai hkbbs!!! tor che tor che!
zhonghua2006 4 years ago
A silver screen legend!
What a Classic lady!
terencekuo 4 years ago
It's a little different (the tone and the rhythm) from the one I used to listen to when I was a kid; maybe the one I heard was a re-interpretation of this number?
wgkawai 4 years ago
Hey! flor here frm Singapore. Maybe the one you heard is the Cantonese version. I've heard both versions.This Mandarin version above is sung by Zhou Xuan. The Cantonese also sang this song in their own dialect. My nanny is a Cantonese and she sings this in Cantonese...I know Mandarin, Cantonese, Hokkien and Teochew *( a jumble of Chinese dialects). All the dialects hve different enunciation and intonations. Hope this helps...I can sing for you in Cantonese- heh!
florleow 4 years ago
Thanks for your comment. But the record that I first heard Zhou Xuan from was an original owned by my grandfather. The first line was very different. And I speak Cantonese, too, so I don't think it's the different dialects that are confusing me. In fact, if you click on "Last Appeared of Zhou Xuan 周璇最后一次露面", you will hear a different version, too.
wgkawai 4 years ago
Ok Wqkawai..I will go listen to the last appearance of Zhou Xuan. I am excited to hear a different version. Whoa! Yr grandpa has an original - that's amazing...you must preserve the record. from flor
florleow 4 years ago
Kawai, I listened to the last appearance of Zhou Xuan. It is exactly the same song, trust me. But what happened is, she sang abit of the first line, and the TV pple cut or JUMP FORWARD to the 2nd portion of the song. U get what I am saying? Hope it clears the confusion..and she is singing in Mandarin. I know this song line by line becos I was trained to sing it as a child. I am happy to be Chinese. We have a old rich culture. From FLor, Singapore
florleow 4 years ago
Yes, the lyrics are the same, but how she sings it is different.
天涯呀--海角(海字的音調不一樣:這裡比流行的版本長些﹔而且角字的發音也不一樣。這裡念"覺"﹐不是念"腳"。)
淚呀淚霑襟(淚子這裡念luei﹐但在另外的片子念lei)
人生呀--誰不(這裡的誰念shei﹐但在另外的片子念shui)
You still think that they are the same?!
wgkawai 4 years ago
Ok.you are right in every aspect. Just treat me as stupid...ok? I'm tired of analyzing it. I just want to enjoy the song as it is. Perhaps in the earlier version, she sang with an accent (becos she was younger). Then when she was older, she used the proper Han Yu Pin Yin pronunciation. Anyway, yr Mandarin is better than mine and yes- you are clever. I admit I am stupid, satisfied? Ok...fine.
florleow 4 years ago
This is really simple, she re-recorded the song just for the movie. This happened a lot of times for movies from different countries because you needs to edit the song to fit in the flow of the movie
2onegrams 4 years ago
我国语(当时应该还没有普通话)不好,真听不出这些分别. 问题是她是否为了音效完美,后来故意放弃清晰的吐字? Sutherland,白雪仙等都常常用这样演绎的.
cschan369 2 years ago
thanks for posting ! love it!
bamboobru 4 years ago
woww..great old black and white
mimimoremore 4 years ago
Hi hkbbs,
I found this original video and music on youtube. What are history. This bring back to Black and white and only radio era. What a good memory.
Thank for posting.
millridge 4 years ago
Thanks for posting this. A generation of suffered...
Yibai 5 years ago
WOOOOW That's awesome !!
CherryDYDY 5 years ago