Top 12 Guys Review- American Idol Season 10 3/1/11

[cowfluf7]

You got a this dude, you got a that dude, MADE ME LAUGH SO HARD

[pushcomedy]

Paul and James are definitely my two favourites. James probably already has record companies banging on his door. Paul just has this carefree attitude, and not to mention his voice. He should also to a toothpaste commercial.

[aedavila16]

STEFANO is my favorite with Stevie Wonder song!!!!

Jacob is wonderful too!!!!!!

[spongebob123456ifly]

Scotty McCreery!<3

[TravisRambo]

Dude i agreed with everything...Stefano is my favorite and i cant believe he got wild carded. I WAS LIKE WHAAAAAATTTT

Americans are so dumb sometimes

[jsizzzle311]

I thought Paul McDonald was really amazing lol his voice is awesome, and hes awkward and corky in his own way and its really fun to watch him sing lol

[prphotomail]

you called it man

[ertpala]

freak show dude:::))))))) man you made me laugh. excellent description.

[houtcalt]

You are cute. Nice bear.

[BetsyBlue10]

What's up with the standing O for Pia...lovely voice and a beautiful young woman...is she really over-top-great? The your 5-guy pick was spot on...where were the standing Os for one of them?  These guys are exceptional, unique, and each powerful in his own milieu...none of the girls has this level of dimension...that having been said...I think Stephano is the weakest of the 5 but there is something especially charming about him...Love your reviews, by the way.....

[wutup2]

I think the girls did better tonight. My husband and I voted for 4 girls. lol We just couldn't pick one.

[TristanandIsolt]

Thanks for putting this together. I forgot to watch yesterday so for now I am taking your word for it. I am very surprised that you are giving no chance to Jovany, Brett and Clint as I have thought they were just behind Jacob as having the best voices of all the contestants.

[bigEdudeReviews]

@TristanandIsolt I know that at this point, you can have the best voice in the world, but if you screw up a performance or dont make it believable, it's over...

[TristanandIsolt]

@bigEdudeReviews Yep. I was able to listen to them all on youtube today and agree that Brett and Clint deserve to go home. I disagree about your thinking on Jovany. He was solid and with his looks he will get enough votes to move forward. I am looking forward to your review of the women. I think the ones that should move ahead are Pia, Thia, Lauren T, Ashthon and Karen. I know Lauren A will make it through but I don't think she is deserving.

[TwistedSisters9194]

I like how you specified each top 5 guy you chose! haha country dude, latino dude, gospel dude, rock dude, r&b soul dude...lol!!!