Added: 2 years ago
From: carrieunderwood
Views: 4,084,700
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (5,126)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • WOw! the high notes were and still are incredible. Randy definately knew he did something right when he let her sing that song. Incredible, chills

  • @jwrape I would agree, Carrie can do incredible high notes with such ease and that is why Randy couldn't keep that wide smile from his face. His song was meant for high vocalist, which she obvious is.

  • I got goosebumps when she reaches that high note on the chorus!

    I love Carrie!!

  • iiiiiiiiii LALALALALALLOVE this song :)

  • I do believe Disney's woody was modeled off of Randy

  • wow he's smiling like an idiot but they are awesome!!!

  • love,loe,love this song!! There singing like Angels!! <3 <3 Awwsome'ly beautiiiful Job guys!! Mmmm'wah!!

  • In the statistics I saw this video is most popular with ages 45-64 , I'm only 23 but man do I love this!! So beautiful.

  • gose bumps!

    

  • WoW

  • no matter how old that man gets he will always be a very handsome man

  • A one proud Randy . Watch his face on 1:37 and 3:_ _ something ( ? forgot ) A mazing , he's so proud of her singing his song !

  • Wow she really nailed this, Randy Travis sounds like he did back then.....this version has become my favorite

  • look at 2:05

  • haey this song is one of my favorite,love it,

  • Carrie did sing this so well and this duet just made a great song even BETTER!!! It hits me everytime I hear it. I think WE ALL have a I TOLD U SO in us. I KNOW I DO!!!!

  • I wonder if simon likes that kind of music

  • 1:36 awesome! both are amazing as singers!

  • such a great song. it was great by Randy and its Great by Carrie, love both versions and this one with both is also great

  • amazing. simply amazing.

  • LOVE IT...love Randy Travis and Carrie...awesome together...

  • I <3 this video. I love Carrie Underwood, and have idolized Randy Travis for as long as I can remember.

  • I just look at Randy Travis's video... Didnt know bout him be4 this but he is good.. no wonder he is where he is now.... okay........ respect!

  • This performance was outstanding and lead me to becoming a fan of not only Carrie Underwood but it made me appreciate how good RT used to be.

  • does randy travis have parkinsons? i noticed a weird head movement at 2:03-2:07

  • @Jayjee123 He does that to stretch his voice

  • he gave her his stage and he was proud of her. Randy is iconic to the country music industry and this shows his class is top shelf.

  • poor guy out of breath =P

  • I can listen to this over and over. This song fits my situation ans I can relate.

    Carrie Underwood's voice cannot be descrived in words and I l have loved Randy Travis forever. TY American Idol for bring them together for the best duet ever!!!!!

  • best duet song ever....!~~~

  • @90tuancuong better than islands in the stream? nah

  • man this reminds me of good times

  • One word..... Beautiful.

  • I don't see what not to like about this 2 amazing singers

  • I absolutely love how Randy enjoys her singing his song.....he's very proud.... love it!!!

  • I LOVE CARRIE UNDERWOOD,,

    SHE'S MY MODEL

  • I TOLD YOU...... NOW I GOT SOMEONE BETTER THAN YOU... lol

  • This is an amazing performance!

  • @39schatz Agree amazing one

  • he has an amazing voice i love it...

  • i LOVE randy travis. hes one of my favorite artists and has always been since i was a little 6 year old singing along to pray for the fish :)

  • @glovesyoulikealot LOL

    When I was 3, I would sing along to "Forever and Ever, Amen" and say "You may think I'm wild and I'm 3" LOL

  • she's awsome,,,,but hes the greatist...i love randy travis....can't change this mind...

  • I still "heart" Carrie. It`s been a whole week,but she is so friggen hot! and talented:) .

  • carrie your a great singer your number 1

  • just how big is Randy's head ??

  • Randy looked at Carrie like he was so proud of her and loved it that she sang "his song" so well. :)

  • @BabbbyGirl123 Yups.. then Randy said UNBELIEVABLE

  • @BabbbyGirl123 he wasn't looking at her like that, he was trying to look down her dress lmao

  • @BabbbyGirl123 That becaused her high vocal range fits this song better than his low vocals

  • @BabbbyGirl123 I agree! That's exactly what I saw when I watched the video! Cute:)

  • @BabbbyGirl123 His proud of her, because she put his song in the correct vocal range, which she possess and he doesn't and she does it so easily.

  • someboy mine telling what did leyoster say that was blow out of proprotion.

  • Carrie dose a good job but Randy has the realy true country voice and I've always liked his presintation of the songs he sings!

  • Comment removed

  • rated as class singer. no doubt about it...want some more of carrie;s songs.

  • Nothing but class.

  • I (heart) Carrie.

  • Carrie Underwood, like Martina McBride, is one of the few country artists that sings better live than in the studio. That is the mark of true talent.

  • Please search "Scoot Blount" and see my version of Three Wooden Crosses. Im not lucky enough to pay to promote the video. Please comments and help me build my views. Thanks you so much!!

  • wow can that girl ever sing

  • How generous of Randy to invite Carrie to sing this duo with him...

    She's good very good...But............Randy Travis is the king on this one...

    Awesome Duo....God Bless...*Country Girl*

  • @GaCountryGirl024 The reason, Randy invite her to sing with him, because she asked if she could put this song on her record, which she did and at the Grand Ole Opry, where he invite her to be member of the Opry, e said she did a better job on this song then he did and it fits her vocals perfectly.

  • Comment removed

  • I agree. Randy Travis is a legend of country.

  • you gotta admit that 20years ago, Randy Travis was, and probably still is hot.

  • Two great talents. Randy has passed his peak but he has a body of work that any artist would be proud of. His voice is still full and rich and a joy to listen to. What can I say about the American Idol champ? Carrie deserves everything that has come her way since winning American Idol. As they sing together, you can see the admiration Randy has for Carrie's talent. Randy is a legend. Carrie will become one. Best wishes to both.

  • Two great talents. Randy has passed his peak but he has a body of work that any artist would be proud of. His voice is still full and rich and a joy to listen to. What can I say about the American Idol champ? Carrie deserves everything that has come her way since winning American Idol. As they sing together, you can see the admiration Randy has for Carrie's talent. Randy is a legend. Carrie will become one. Best wishes to both.

  • GREAT JOB...GIVE ME YOUR OPINION OF MY NEW SONG-"LADY ACROSS THE ROOM"- CLAY MYERS  THANKS SO MUCH

  • randy still nailed it even though he had bronchitis!

  • Amazing.... I am blown away at how beautifully she can sing this song.  She did him (Randy) proud....

  • She does it so naturally... effortlessly... we are blessed to have her with us!

  • I am from germany but during my two week stay in america in march 2009 i watched american idol and this song was on and this so totally reminds me of a really great time in america! they are both so talented.

  • Tengo much alma. :)

  • carrie sings way way way way better than kelly

  • Wow, I just realized that during the first half of the song he plays the guitar, but by the second half, he is so blown away by her that he doesn't even pretend to play it any longer...This is a perfect Duet!! 

  • @juniperbreezesforme Randy wasn't blown away by Carrie. He already knew how good Carrie's vocals are. That is why he gave his permission for her to record this song on her "Carnival Ride" album.

  • I hear she wears boxers. 

  • I like Randy Travis a lot, but Carrie puts him to shame!

  • @mcobraii Your comment is the meanest of all comments!!! Randy Travis chose to be Carrie's mentor because he realized that Carrie is the best vocalist of all time who can really do justice to his greatest hit songs such as "I Told You So." Please, listen to the original version of the song, solo by Randy Travis. That was released way before he had an ailment which caused him to lose some luster in his voice. Next time, be careful of your comments about other people; should not be demeaning!!!

  • @mcobraii Your comment is the meanest of all comments!!! Randy Travis chose to be Carrie's mentor because he realized that Carrie is the best vocalist of all time who can really do justice to his greatest hit songs such as "I Told You So." Please, listen to the original version of the song, solo by Randy Travis. That was released way before he had an ailment which caused him to lose some luster in his voice. Next time, be careful of your comments about other people; should not be demeaning!!!

  • @loyestor1951 I was not saying it to be mean. It's my opinion that Carrie has a much better voice than Randy Travis. Did I not say that I like Randy Travis a lot. Yes I did, I believe these to be my exact words. So next time before you get all defensive, try not to twist peoples comments into meaning somethingelse. And by the way Carrie is an extremely talented young lady, but she is not the best vocalist of all time.

  • @mcobraii

    I remember your comments, exactly. I read that you like Randy a lot but in the succeeding part of your comment you diminished him a lot, too!! Maybe, you did not mean it, but I am sure that everyone who reads your comment would discern the words the same way as I did. And, I hope you don't mean that Carrie did put Randy to shame intentionally!!! That would be a stretch!!!

  • @loyestor1951 In no way did I diminish him. The only meaning of my comment was that Carrie has a better voice than Randy. That's it. If I would have said Randy sucks, Carrie is so much better. Then that would have been mean. I grew up listening to Randy Travis and love many of his songs. Even when you're great there is always some one better.

  • @mcobraii

    You can't really compare a man of Randys age to Carrie as far as power. Randy has sang thousands of times compared to Carrie. Go back and look at the 1982 recordings of RT. They are both really, really great and years down the road we will all look back and say, man will we really ever know just how great they were? I look back at Heart, The Eagles etc.... and still get blown away.

  • @BigCookinCajun Randy has already said that Carrie does better job than he does. And as of proof watch Carrie's version at the Grand Ole Opry.

  • @BigCookinCajun I agree with you. loyestor1951 blew my comment way out of proportion.

  • Carrie may not realize herself actually how good her vocals, but Randy definitely knows how good her vocals are. I think sometimes, Carrie being so hard on herself, due to the fact that she is a perfectionist. She never thinks she does an excellent performance.

  • amazing. only word needed to describe this performance

  • I see 133 dislikes today. I don't know what to say to that. There are a few Idol moments when you can say that a superstar is born, and I think this is one of them. You can see it on Travis' face when he can't stop himself from smiling at 1:36. There are many amazing moments on Idol, but this one is up there with the best. 133 dislikes. Inexplicable.

  • @boboandjacob It's not inexplicable. It's very easily explained : 133 tone-deaf Taylor Swift fans.

  • this song is so true

  • this song is so true

  • every time this song comes on the computer on my play list i stop and sit down to listen. This song will never get old they are both great singers

  • wow ilove ths song

    

  • great music! two of my favs

  • It's titled "I lost my mind" its here on youtube. thanks again-Clay Myers

  • beautiful job!! I love both you guys. I use to hang in nashville years ago..but drug addiction stopped me in my tracks from dreams. I wrote a bunch and a have narrowed it down to one to showcase to you. I know that the guitar and me are no very good studio quality...but money is an issue nowadays. so take a listen if you can I know you are busy. thanks for your time and may God continue to bless you. -Clay Myers

  • @TheGeorgiaKay Really? You need to grow up! Nasty ass! Maybe because you don't get any you feel the need to make comments like this.

  • @TheGeorgiaKay that comment was just nasty...dude...you're twisted...

  • @TheGeorgiaKay what the fuck?

  • @TheGeorgiaKay i bet he wasn't

  • WOW.. carrie is crazy good... and i have nothing against a country legend , but randy's voice got weak from age =(.. still an amazing performance

  • #1

    

  • This Girl is just amazing, her voice is ridiculously good!!!!!!!!!!

  • 133 people have no souls.... daywalkers I assume.

  • he is so proud of her

  • Just one comment: WOW !!!!

  • She's got really mighty voice, WOW! Randy is apparently delighted

  • carrie is so damn sexy

  • outstanding, Randy was great.

  • Glad too be an OKIE BOOMER SOONER!!!!!!!!!

  • Her live performance is outstanding! Srsly gave me the bumps.

  • Randy Travis is a country legend. Hes so underrated!

  • @HeavenlyValo Carrie doesn't think he is underrated, because she respect him enough to ask him for the right to this song and Randy said that was best decision he could have done. As he put this song suits her vocals so well.

  • @HeavenlyValo Yes, Randy Travis is a country legend. But he isn't underrated, trying telling that to Carrie and other singers. He is well-respected singer, songwriter.

  • just amazing-two great talents

  • i get goose bumps shit

  • wolftones

    

  • Love this song and fair play to Carrie she totally owned this song absolutely love her voice and Randy is just a legend xxxx :-)

  • one of the rare that can manage to sound good on both the record, and during a live performance. go Carrie! and.. Randy! lol

  • she did a great ob i love this song

  • WOW WOW WOW~~Now, This Is Real Country Music~~Carrie & Randy~~Beautiful Duet :)

  • so beautiful!

  • carrie underwood is sooooooooooooooo awsome  she knows how to sing

  • Didn't she sell the most # of records for any Idol winner?

  • @carrier1231 yup she surpassed kelly clarkson!

  • @peach I knew she would pass Kelly with such ease, she is way better than Kelly without a doubt.

  • can anybody till me which episode of american idol is this ?

  • told you so but you had to go. Now I found somebody new and you will never break my heart in two again.

  • people like lil wayne over this?....

  • @blakekoz11 I like lil wayne, but if I had to choose, I would so pick this!

  • I love this song! when randy smiled at carrie when she sung "i told you so" it shows how much proud he is at her. this song truly gives me goose bumps. both of them are amazing live!!! i love both of them!! Randy is so sweet to let carrie sing this.!!!!! i love itt!!!!

  • this is a great song, they sound so good together. love it..

  • Randy aged so fast. But it is ok because i can still see him as he was, He also sang this song much better then anyone else.

  • He looks like a proud PaPa!!! What a mentor she had! And remember this is a live performance! She gives me goose pumps! I love them both!