@Clevelandgirl96 We played this at Cleveland State three years ago, my freshman year. I was on third trumpet. The woodwinds were deaf by the end of the finale.
@peteytheaardvark well, your kind (no offense there) usually gets the whole orchestra deaf... I play the cello and had the misfortune of sitting in front of the brass during Orff's Carmina Burana; they went nuts, we went deaf.
God I love the ending of this movement. I think I can hear definite influences of Shostakovich in Bernard Hermann's scores for Hitchcock -- especially those gentle strings at the end of this movement -- it sounds literally like out of the OST to North by Northwest. Has anyone else picked up on this musical similarity? I have no idea whether there was any causal link between them, but they certainly came to a similar place in that part of this wonderful symphony.
@darkprose It's fair to say that Herrmann was inspired by Shostakovitch a good deal, along with Delius, Sibelius, Vaughan Williams, Berg, Stravinsky, Debussy, Wagner, Walton, Prokofiev etc... His stunning rejected score for Torn Curtain is also very Shostakovian in its timbrel 'greyness', and polytonal harmonies.
Check out his recording of Hamlet from "Music from Great Shakespearean Films."
@RogueRotting360 Thanks for the suggestions. I knew that Hitch rejected Herrmann's score for Torn Curtain, but I haven't had a chance to hear it. Is it on an album of some kind? I will have to find it.
Never mind sound quality, the PERFORMANCE is astounding! Perhaps the best DSCH 5 I have ever heard, and have heard quite a few! No conductor so fully finds and presents the deep Russian soul of this music as does Svetlanov!
jaja se le mueven los cachetiños!
jcast18k 5 months ago
I think, it is hard to overestimate a true value of this music. I love the first movement, especially when it comes to the pulsations of the strings.
pinturner 5 months ago
7:08
nixrox13 6 months ago
@nixrox13 Yeah, gorgeous viola soli!!!! Usually it screams, and this is dark and introspective, fabulous!
Wavewolfaroha 5 months ago
this piece is SO hard to play.
StrigonLead 7 months ago
After Mravinsky's fifth, maybe this is the best performance of this symphony
alcoreiter2 7 months ago
Playing this in orchestra this upcoming school year!!! So excited!!!!
Clevelandgirl96 8 months ago
@Clevelandgirl96 We played this at Cleveland State three years ago, my freshman year. I was on third trumpet. The woodwinds were deaf by the end of the finale.
peteytheaardvark 6 months ago
@peteytheaardvark well, your kind (no offense there) usually gets the whole orchestra deaf... I play the cello and had the misfortune of sitting in front of the brass during Orff's Carmina Burana; they went nuts, we went deaf.
galicaeable 5 months ago
My teacher Mikhail Tolpygo (now teaching in México) is principal of violas section of this orchestra. Beautiful version!!!
metastasis61 8 months ago
Восхитительно!
Liubtsale 8 months ago
this is the music for katharsis
i've never understood Shosatkovich, but now i believe i do
flaminia5 8 months ago
I hear a few similarities with the Princess Mononoke soundtrack.
goobtron1 8 months ago
God I love the ending of this movement. I think I can hear definite influences of Shostakovich in Bernard Hermann's scores for Hitchcock -- especially those gentle strings at the end of this movement -- it sounds literally like out of the OST to North by Northwest. Has anyone else picked up on this musical similarity? I have no idea whether there was any causal link between them, but they certainly came to a similar place in that part of this wonderful symphony.
darkprose 9 months ago
@darkprose It's fair to say that Herrmann was inspired by Shostakovitch a good deal, along with Delius, Sibelius, Vaughan Williams, Berg, Stravinsky, Debussy, Wagner, Walton, Prokofiev etc... His stunning rejected score for Torn Curtain is also very Shostakovian in its timbrel 'greyness', and polytonal harmonies.
Check out his recording of Hamlet from "Music from Great Shakespearean Films."
RogueRotting360 9 months ago
@RogueRotting360 Thanks for the suggestions. I knew that Hitch rejected Herrmann's score for Torn Curtain, but I haven't had a chance to hear it. Is it on an album of some kind? I will have to find it.
darkprose 9 months ago
@darkprose The 1977 Elmer Bernstein LP is the highest quality (of performance and sound), though Joel McNeely's is the most complete.
RogueRotting360 8 months ago
powerful stuff
MrLindenson 10 months ago
the people who dislike this are those who...eh wait there are no dislikes XD
360Flicks 10 months ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
Yeah, down with Stalin! lol
Chymczuk1 10 months ago
Comment removed
Chymczuk1 10 months ago
Throws up his Metal Horns at 3:15 \m/
YamiRyan4509 11 months ago 2
Comment removed
hyeonj315 11 months ago
Is it just me or at the beginning he looks like a frickin' machine gunner! Pow!Pow! --Pow!Pow! -- Pow!Pow!
bigtimv 1 year ago 5
@bigtimv Same thought x]
jeromesim 11 months ago
mmm Svetlanov.
stpd1957 1 year ago
I can almost feel new neurons forming whenever I listen to this piece... so creatively stimulating
LexingtonWells 1 year ago 5
the sound quality is great!
Terpentijn 1 year ago 3
So incredibly moving.
locomotifx 1 year ago 2
Wonderful, I listened to all the arrangements, and they are fantastic.
duba3988 1 year ago
Sublime!
Vasyukov 1 year ago
I know it's hardly relevant to this wonderful art, but I had no idea Richard Nixon was such a dedicated aficionado of classical music.
woodencardboard 1 year ago 50
@woodencardboard Well that's just a wonderful observation. The seriousness of this will always induce giggles within me, now. Ta. Mwhahahaha
whahappened 1 year ago
@woodencardboard Ah que c'est drôle! Vous avez raison :)
Memale2009 7 months ago
THE GREATEST PERFORMANCE OF A TERRIFIC SYMPHONY !!!
antal202 1 year ago
Conductorrr where did you purchase the DVD which is symphony appears on?
Albertan1956 1 year ago
Anatoliy Lyubimov is playing the oboe, such a bad sound.
oboistru 1 year ago
almost definitive.
Forest1227 1 year ago
Sound quality was great to me. One of the best. Powerful, intense.
jmlancashire 2 years ago 2
Never mind sound quality, the PERFORMANCE is astounding! Perhaps the best DSCH 5 I have ever heard, and have heard quite a few! No conductor so fully finds and presents the deep Russian soul of this music as does Svetlanov!
AndreiKrakovsky 2 years ago 30
@AndreiKrakovsky Well said and I couldn't agree more.
adambomb30 1 year ago
@AndreiKrakovsky Mavrinsky is the authority of shost... music,
leontud 7 months ago
The recording quality is horrible.
Which is a shame, because this is the only complete series of videos for the 5th.
sacramushmygoat 2 years ago
@sacramushmygoat Actually, there's a series of videos done by the San Francisco Symphony.
Glarfugus 2 years ago