How can i say this...This is a REALLY bad chart. Have you seen the tab for this song? Nope...Didn't think so. Im re making this for customhero. And yes i believe they are finally going to start up again.
Ill agree with you that this is a bad chart, but its not REALLY bad. And tabs dont need to be used to make good accurate charts. Ive made quite a few charts so far and havent used tabs for a single one and probley never will.
Yes, but to make a professional chart, you need tabs. Thats the only way to make a chart just like the real guitar. I used to make my charts without tabs. I got rid of every single one because they were horrible. Mine are 100% now. But yes. You dont need a tab to make a good chart.
You understand that five plastic buttons and the order in which they are hit is the question here, right? I don't understand how anything for GH like this can be considered "accurate." There's no such thing.
Usually there are a few good ways to chart some parts. This is not right at all. I am a professional charter. I know what I'm talking about. This guy apparently didn't use a chart or he had a really bad one. I make my charts feel like your playing the real thing. And only good charters can be accurate.
Cause xXGuitarherosheroXx totally works for the company making guitar hero charts... I just find it funny that some kids who make their own custom charts consider their "work" professional. Making your own charts is a fun hobby I have to admit, but no more than that.
Sure, for most people it is just a hobby, but a lot of good charters from SH have been recruited by Neversoft/Harmonix to create the official charts. I can't speak for xXetcXx's charts because I don't know his charts, I was just pointing out that it can turn out to be a "paid occupation" if you're especially good.
My early work I have to admit is not that good, but my most recent work is 100%. I consider it as good as if it were professionally made. Possibly even better then if Neversoft/Harmonix made it. And I know for a fact that I could damn well get a job charting official songs but I have given up that. I have bigger plans now.
Good job except for at 5:52 is John and Jordan playing that awesome riff I just watched the vid and it is definitely those two playing it rather than the chords you put in but good job! we all make mistakes
ok this is a good start, but there are way more places to put notes. for example, from 1:40 to 2:00, John playes all those notes that you think r only played by Jordan. i've seen them live for the reunion tour so i know. great show.
they just have a steady kick on each beat (since its 6/4 time, it'd be on each quarter note) and then do like fills all away around the drums or single notes for each head change. not too complicated.
ok why didnt u play the guitar/keyboard unison part at 1:40.....a alot of ppl tell me that its only keyboard...but thats not true, i saw them live, JP played it
actually Tony Levin of King Crimson is the bassist and at the time this album was recorded Derek Sherinian was still in Dream Theater this is what made Jordan Rudess a member of Dream Theater
np mann If your a big fan of DT you should read Lifting Shadows the Authorized Biography of Dream Theater. Its how I know all that stuff about them. Trust me its a great read.
yeah jordan was asked to join DT after doing the LTE tours for the 2 years that they put out stuff. i really hope they do a 15th anniversary tour, cause they 10th was a beast.
the solo after the keyboard is guitar.. after the silence chords, there is a guitar solo, but the chart decided to do the rythem instead of the lead.. pitty.
Looks like the only reason he's getting hate for a bad chart is that he does it like Rock Band, where you don't play the parts that sound like a guitar, but you just play the guitar. 'Cause yeah, there's a synth in there.
All I know is I can't complain because I can't do any better.
at 00:51 that little run is done by keys, but is played by guitar on here. and at like 00:22 and 00:41ish those run downs are played by guitar and keys together and the guitar just stops.
however... 4 keys never will compare with 7 strings and 24 notes per string that make 168 options.. i mean, it is a great game, but is like u guys are realy realy pruod showing a football game pretending u are a real sport player...
Ehh...chart wasn't that great. 1:40-1:54 and 5:51-6:05 both should have been guitar parts instead of the looping tracks. I would probably download the chart and edit it to my pleasure though.
Dragonforce doesn't even come close to this kind of music. Liquid Tension Experiment is made of 4 skilled musicians instead a chink who can play the guitar faster than anyone else. Big friggen deal. It doesn't sound any good when he plays.
nice job, though a lil disapointed u didnt play the guitar part in teh ebgining and the end (at around 5:55-6:06) not sure if that was piano or guitar but i always thaought t was guitar
1:41 Is a guitar solo..
tjittosz 1 year ago
acid raaain some stay dry but others feel the pain XD
gurumaster89 2 years ago 6
Hahahahaha
norgesnus 2 years ago
The last part of the song is played by the chapman stick, not by the guitar, no final guitar solo :(
Yukabron 2 years ago
this chart doesnt do this awesome song justice at all. this song properly would be in dragonforce / jordan air of difficulty level
rissx 2 years ago 4
Search for cosmic pope acid rain, that chart does this track justice ;)
ShinerCCC 2 years ago
2:48 is epic! i love this song
reddysn33blet 2 years ago
Uhh, during the crazy drum and keyboard solo, there's also a tap solo.
SynisterSir 2 years ago
that's a guitar solo at 1:41...I was looking forward to it too. :(
drawman3354 2 years ago 3
I think its a keyboard solo, not sure if pettruci plays it live but i'm certain its a rudess solo.
tpstar 2 years ago
Pettruci doesn't play it. I've watched some live videos of acid rain and it's a keyboard solo, not guitar.
SlinkyMushrooms 2 years ago
@SlinkyMushrooms i think they are playing along keyboards and guitar...
skotous 1 year ago
l2play guitar hero.
Lambardo665 3 years ago
aw no solo? :(
kyle21843 3 years ago
I love the keyboard in this song.
Razor7343 3 years ago 2
Not a good custom song.
inthefle 3 years ago
..Isn't this Dream Theater?
RichardKohl 3 years ago
no it s a side project by Mike Portnoy and John Petrucci, I think. (drummer and guitarist of DT)
lostfacts 3 years ago
And don't forget Jordan Rudess! Plus, Tony Levin on bass/Chapman's Stick.
Scrotolotopus 3 years ago
no it is liquid tension experiment, a super band
mike portnoy - drums
petrucci - guitar
rudese - keyboard
tony levin (king crimson) - bass
weonweon1 3 years ago
Acid Rain is on Live Scenes From New York, so I can see why you'd think that it's Dream Theater :)
AudunYT 3 years ago
awsome but you should have done the solo at 1:45
DanielHoward777 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
pfh. go and play a real guitar.
PhantomSocke 3 years ago
I'm so sick of everyone replying with this same crap. When someone is good a Street Fighter, you don't tell them to go learn real martial arts.
This is just a game. If you're not interested in the game, you have no business being here.
Anyway, awesome chart and awesome band.
SKETCHi09 3 years ago 12
shame it was only a side project :(
DanielHoward777 3 years ago
How can i say this...This is a REALLY bad chart. Have you seen the tab for this song? Nope...Didn't think so. Im re making this for customhero. And yes i believe they are finally going to start up again.
xXGuitarherosheroXx 3 years ago
Ill agree with you that this is a bad chart, but its not REALLY bad. And tabs dont need to be used to make good accurate charts. Ive made quite a few charts so far and havent used tabs for a single one and probley never will.
badchaddd 3 years ago
Yes, but to make a professional chart, you need tabs. Thats the only way to make a chart just like the real guitar. I used to make my charts without tabs. I got rid of every single one because they were horrible. Mine are 100% now. But yes. You dont need a tab to make a good chart.
xXGuitarherosheroXx 3 years ago
at 1:29 Should have done the solo. Not the chords.
Jeran3442 3 years ago
Actually no. Its on a keyboard. Even i didnt chart it haha. Ill chart it for rhythm though =]
xXGuitarherosheroXx 3 years ago
/watch?v=FqcJ8ECPPK4&feature=related
nope, if you watch them doing it live, you'll clearly see Petrucci doing the solo along with they keyboard in perfect synchronization.
facetheslayer9 3 years ago
You understand that five plastic buttons and the order in which they are hit is the question here, right? I don't understand how anything for GH like this can be considered "accurate." There's no such thing.
Mujahadeen49 3 years ago
Usually there are a few good ways to chart some parts. This is not right at all. I am a professional charter. I know what I'm talking about. This guy apparently didn't use a chart or he had a really bad one. I make my charts feel like your playing the real thing. And only good charters can be accurate.
xXGuitarherosheroXx 3 years ago
Hahahahahaha I love how you just called yourself a professional charter. As if charting guitar hero songs is an paid occupation.
frisboneross 3 years ago
frisboneross: Uh, how do you think the official game charts got there? Because someone was paid to make the charts.
plu48 3 years ago
Cause xXGuitarherosheroXx totally works for the company making guitar hero charts... I just find it funny that some kids who make their own custom charts consider their "work" professional. Making your own charts is a fun hobby I have to admit, but no more than that.
frisboneross 3 years ago
Sure, for most people it is just a hobby, but a lot of good charters from SH have been recruited by Neversoft/Harmonix to create the official charts. I can't speak for xXetcXx's charts because I don't know his charts, I was just pointing out that it can turn out to be a "paid occupation" if you're especially good.
plu48 3 years ago
My early work I have to admit is not that good, but my most recent work is 100%. I consider it as good as if it were professionally made. Possibly even better then if Neversoft/Harmonix made it. And I know for a fact that I could damn well get a job charting official songs but I have given up that. I have bigger plans now.
xXGuitarherosheroXx 3 years ago
Great chart. 5/5
Bendy218 3 years ago
Good job except for at 5:52 is John and Jordan playing that awesome riff I just watched the vid and it is definitely those two playing it rather than the chords you put in but good job! we all make mistakes
Chrisakacloud 3 years ago
xD!
sharxsxd 3 years ago
Faltou notas e a guitarra está atasada
Furiabr3 3 years ago
what is this? the rhythm version. there were solos in this that i didnt get to play. wtf.
awsomeAwsomeness 3 years ago
ok this is a good start, but there are way more places to put notes. for example, from 1:40 to 2:00, John playes all those notes that you think r only played by Jordan. i've seen them live for the reunion tour so i know. great show.
PhantomDarkTheif 3 years ago 4
they just have a steady kick on each beat (since its 6/4 time, it'd be on each quarter note) and then do like fills all away around the drums or single notes for each head change. not too complicated.
PhantomDarkTheif 3 years ago
ok why didnt u play the guitar/keyboard unison part at 1:40.....a alot of ppl tell me that its only keyboard...but thats not true, i saw them live, JP played it
soocool78 3 years ago
yeah, if he added it, it would have made jordan look easy :P im not a guitarist but from what i've heard, jordan is easy cuz its all "tapping"
n e way still would've been even more kickass xD
PimpMasterT 3 years ago
wow thats awsome!!!
V3770 3 years ago
NICE!!!!!!
TheCatDarkness 3 years ago
why didn't you put the original sound of the game?
FiatObscuritas 3 years ago
de+ cargao xD
Comrax 3 years ago
tubo bien pero en la mita y en el final te ekivocaste mucho el puntaje para mi es un :8,50 (ocho 50)
habilero 3 years ago
the bassist is different too
ledzeppelin7510 3 years ago
Its sounds like dream theater...funny I thought this song was by them, it sound alot like em
Sonicboomx 3 years ago
It is the same people as dream theater. It has everyone but the singer in it.
Arekkusu5 3 years ago
actually Tony Levin of King Crimson is the bassist and at the time this album was recorded Derek Sherinian was still in Dream Theater this is what made Jordan Rudess a member of Dream Theater
metalhead1800 3 years ago 3
Nice, I didnt know that was the cause of Rudess becoming a member of DT, thank you very much n_n
HybridBox 3 years ago
np mann If your a big fan of DT you should read Lifting Shadows the Authorized Biography of Dream Theater. Its how I know all that stuff about them. Trust me its a great read.
metalhead1800 3 years ago
doesn't have the bassist (John Myung), and at the time, Jordan Ruddess wasn't in Dream Theater yet.
metallica910 3 years ago
I believe Rudeness started with dream Theater also in 1999... maybe? I am not sure
Beadbud5000 3 years ago
yeah jordan was asked to join DT after doing the LTE tours for the 2 years that they put out stuff. i really hope they do a 15th anniversary tour, cause they 10th was a beast.
PhantomDarkTheif 3 years ago
Which show were you at? I was at the Chicago one.
Connexion009 3 years ago
bad chart...
you just charted it in rythym and only charted few leads...
wish it was all lead so theres a hard part like the solo...
tsk...
R2Gsavior 3 years ago
the lead woulda been to hard to chart at that partim guessing haha, i thought it was pretty good though
JonnyBa7x 3 years ago
kinda bad chart...
triviummusician 3 years ago
the solo after the keyboard is guitar.. after the silence chords, there is a guitar solo, but the chart decided to do the rythem instead of the lead.. pitty.
DFLGW 3 years ago
Bad chart.
weraslolreeee 3 years ago
I LOVE THIS
black man super approves -thumbs up w/ standing ovation-
blackbum7 3 years ago
does anyone know if this is supposed to be in GH4? I googled GH4 setlist and saw this in the final tier but it could have been a fake setlist
Brrc509 3 years ago
It was probably fake, but that would be fucking awesome if it was in there.
Word has it there will be some DT in GH4 and Rockband 2 though.
Spazman173 3 years ago
awsome
BFMVTEARSdontFALL1 3 years ago
Looks like the only reason he's getting hate for a bad chart is that he does it like Rock Band, where you don't play the parts that sound like a guitar, but you just play the guitar. 'Cause yeah, there's a synth in there.
All I know is I can't complain because I can't do any better.
Koshugan 3 years ago
Let's just throw this in there to avoid getting hate for no reason:
What I mean is that as long as I can hear a guitar playing the notes he's got going and it sounds right to me, it's good enough.
Koshugan 3 years ago
I can honestly say this is the worst chart I've ever seen
Marxious 3 years ago
lol i know. its a fucking instrumental, but u didnt chart the solos.
ghey...
chicken6111 3 years ago
One of the solos is the keyboard.
Spazman173 3 years ago
*Clap Clap* :)
Goku313 3 years ago
Yeah, some Petrucci's solos are missing
Awesome arrangement any way
cabmill 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you know what would be more fun , to play the music for real, instead of playing in the grandma's basement in front of the tv.
destructiondragon 3 years ago
And what do you tell people who play simulationgames? Go play God instead?
What do you tell people who play FPS games? Go join the army?
What do you tell people who play RST games? Go collect your personal army and send 'em off to bash people in the head?
Seriously.. stfu.
fuckayt 3 years ago 13
the guitarist and pianist are the best in the world for liquid tension. and theyre in the same band. effing awesome group
Crimeboss2 3 years ago
just for the record the 2 solos are on the guitar not keyboard.
jimrat92 3 years ago
the guitar part at 1:41 should have reflected the solo part, not the rhythm part....woulda made it more fun...
saxev2005 3 years ago
BEST SONG EVER ! THANKS 4 THE UPLOAD !!! (I like Sidology 2 Trinity too =) )
NE0KRATOS 3 years ago
Nice Chart, Bad Player
Lolxd122 3 years ago
omj thats crazy man this should be the jordan/through the fire and flames of gh4 dude
omjurmom96 3 years ago
esto es una mentira yo lo jugue todo y nadie juega mejor que yo. es imposible .
chino04ar 3 years ago
Not charting the two solos is just lazy. Besides that, the chart is well done.
yackleberry 3 years ago
Maybe because the 2 solos were played on a keyboard?
Wedigar 3 years ago
Nice chart; I'm just upset that the two awesome solos were left out :(
TehFix0r 3 years ago
can customs songs only be written for Xbox360? if possible in Wii or PS2 please help me out!!!
SemphasNecros 3 years ago
I'm pretty sure there only playable through PC and PS2. it doesn't work on Xbox 360 or Wii
LightningTrident 3 years ago
1:43 to 1:54 is a guitar part.
t3hgir 3 years ago
Yeah... that was the only part I wanted to see... I'm almost mad now.
agentpissant42 3 years ago
Guitar part TOO. Dont insult us keyboardist xD
phronesys 3 years ago
Well its harmonized :)
t3hgir 3 years ago
AMAZING
blackfootsquirrel 3 years ago
awesome nice job, wish i could play it
patman0 4 years ago
lmao those Are some insane chords...gotta try this one out
dethlock33 4 years ago
Played it on GH3, good job on this
HeroofTime55 4 years ago
AWESOME!
but you should be able to play the the ending keyboard solos. with out em, its to tiring...
pansypwner 4 years ago
awesommmmmmmmm
persini 4 years ago
sick video,
to clear this up, at 1:40 is guitar definitely, maybe keyboard syncopation.
I have seen vids here on youtube of this song live, and it focused on the guitar only
jewgler 4 years ago
Don't they play at the same time? They do that on a lot of Dream Theater songs (Metropolis comes to mind)
4514nj35u5 4 years ago
the guitar hero part isnt even covering the real guitar.
xxbassdemonxx 4 years ago
Yes it is, the later solos are keyboard.
Wedigar 4 years ago
at 00:51 that little run is done by keys, but is played by guitar on here. and at like 00:22 and 00:41ish those run downs are played by guitar and keys together and the guitar just stops.
xxbassdemonxx 4 years ago
however... 4 keys never will compare with 7 strings and 24 notes per string that make 168 options.. i mean, it is a great game, but is like u guys are realy realy pruod showing a football game pretending u are a real sport player...
btw nice played
damianovix 4 years ago
umm... isn't it 5 keys compared to 6 strings?
Guitars have 6 strings and Guitar Hero guitars have 5 buttons... right?
pansypwner 4 years ago
yep, but the guitar hero guitar do NOT have any fret... there are just 5 keys... the real guitar have 22 (sometimes 24) frets PER string =)
.damianovix
damianovix 4 years ago
Guitar players and GH players aside, it's just a game. No need to start laying out facts that are readily available to us.
TheLiberator 3 years ago
Lol at the whammying at 3:35.
balladechina212 4 years ago
he did only what he wants to do
kakkoneone 4 years ago
LOL, dude 1:40 is a guitar and keyboard sync part. good job anyway.
LuffsMetul 4 years ago
no, at 1:40 it's not...it's a keyboard lead followed by a keyboard solo.
Ghost2867 4 years ago
Actually, let me correct myself...it's a keyboard lead followed by a guitar solo...:X
Ghost2867 4 years ago
your mistaken, watch the live movies. 1:40 is a guitar and keyboard sync solo.
LuffsMetul 4 years ago
I've seen several live videos...however, they focused on the keyboard at that part...could you perhaps provide me with a link if I'm mistaken?
Ghost2867 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is fucking gay. why would he post that... Faggot.
StrawberrySmelly 4 years ago
Blasphemy!.. go listen to your rap music you ignorant son of a bitch! John Petrucci is a God!
oopsxlandmine 4 years ago
yo...just wondering...why did you edit this for the song to play on top of the video instead of just having the audio in the original video?
XHiddenAnimeX 4 years ago
why are there still chords at 1:45? that is clearly a guitar lead.
nightmarecinema33 4 years ago 5
Becuase the chart creator had mercy
iammaxhailme 4 years ago
That waz awsome!!! That is my favorite song!!!
Anime3001 4 years ago
Great stuff!
i couldnt even keep up with my eyes..stuff trying to play it
DavidWorley235552 4 years ago
were I can download that?
erickpainkiller 4 years ago
lol they were clapping in 4/4 heh
bait9561 4 years ago
Really well done, 5/5
Your sync was really on too.
whitestripesftw 4 years ago
el wn seco XD
herala 4 years ago
wow u miss two major guitar solos, one u even have urself playing the bass rythm, that wasnt too great
petermenking 4 years ago
it was the rythm of the "main guitar" ¬¬"
(my english ins't good"
Arthur147258369 4 years ago
except for the guitar in the beginning and the end. it rocked
hrlysk8r69 4 years ago
Ehh...chart wasn't that great. 1:40-1:54 and 5:51-6:05 both should have been guitar parts instead of the looping tracks. I would probably download the chart and edit it to my pleasure though.
Enanito01478 4 years ago
that's up there with dragonforce.
dynelol 4 years ago
Dragonforce doesn't even come close to this kind of music. Liquid Tension Experiment is made of 4 skilled musicians instead a chink who can play the guitar faster than anyone else. Big friggen deal. It doesn't sound any good when he plays.
FromYourOwnBY 4 years ago
OMFG NICE =O=O=O=O=O
mixaone 4 years ago
nice job, though a lil disapointed u didnt play the guitar part in teh ebgining and the end (at around 5:55-6:06) not sure if that was piano or guitar but i always thaought t was guitar
soocool78 4 years ago
That's definently keyboard...
iammaxhailme 4 years ago
No, it's a unison between the keyboard and guitar.
There's 3 of them missing in this chart.
anubis462 4 years ago 2