Added: 4 years ago
From: BassClef707
Views: 408,392
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (303)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Do you think David Lean had some sort of thing for trains. Could there have been something Freudian in it?

  • Brilliant storyline and well ahead of its time when made! Celia rules!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • This is one of the best Love stories ever!

  • What a g8 flim !

  • !!!!THX !!!!

  • ''What ever your dream was, it wasn't a very happy one was it?''

    ''...No''

  • florianska6 you have a message. thanks for your comment.

  • can you imagine the modern version..... no perhaps not ( the mobile phones would be going off constantly)

  • @lewstone1934

    Brilliant comment - and oh so true!!

    florianska6

  • We all need some clandestine love. :) Er, how about the"relationship" of Trevor and his doctor roommate? heh.

  • Has anyone seen this on the PostSecret website a few years back...?!

  • all bye my self, don't want to be, all bye my self an------y-more

  • @kopynd1 Hehe he stole it from Rachmaninov :)

  • Brilliant acting.

  • I like to think of their trains in Clapham Junction, and their refreshment room as that awful place in the tunnel under Platform 14, the one that was a sweet shop in the 80's. Is it still? Please God, say it is.

  • An English tear-jerker of the first degree----absolutely wonderful. Thank you for posting it.

  • like if The History Boys made you look up this beautiful film

  • Love this film. The ending chokes me every time I see it - you can see their hearts breaking. Two people doing their best to do what is right regardless of personal cost. Is it social repression? How much better would society be today if there was more self discipline?

  • @steveduncan2 Dear Duncan., Nope, not repression. One/you could say inhibition. . Keeping of secrets is not repression. . There is nothing external making the folk be secretive. . I don't think that in 2011, there is any less 'self discipline' than in those days, or even one hundred years before that. . One only needs to read von Krafft-Ebing to see that there was just as much discipline in olden days as today. . . Cheers. from, del-boy.
  • Wow, been there. Standing on the edge of platform. 'cept, I only sort of came round after someone had rugby tackled me to the floor.

    I've never seen this film before, only the History Boys rendition of it but I think I might like to see it now.

  • A bleak and tragic story; such a study in repression and heartless social repression. The stiff upper lip masking as ever the horror of the banal.

  • @Wobdifurousness yah omg yah

  • @Wobdifurousness No, it's not masking the horror of the banal.

    .

    What is banal about the holding of hands at her home with her husband who asks if there is anything he can do for her.

    ?

    .

    Cheers.

    from,

    del-boy.

  • I really liked this film, the characters remain so engaging despite it's age.

  • i hate how the film splits the words 'til death do you part' in half.. those words exist in reason. this film practically exhibits the idea that it is (or was) normal for honest married women to find love in another partners. why did she marry the crossword puzzle guy in the first place if she knew there would be greener grass on the other side? there is such a thing as being single. i thought the ending was great, but what if it had been just the opposite? she would have destroyed so much.

  • It Breaks my Heart

  • NEVERMIND it's Rachmonnonoff which he copied

  • @phatato

    Rachmaninov's 2nd Piano concerto - 2nd movement.

    :)

  • IS IT JUST ME OR DOES THE MUSIC IN THE BACKGROUND SOUND LIKE "ALL BY MYSELF"???

  • @phatato It is 'all by myself'.The song was based on Rachmaninov's concerto which you hear in this clip.

  • @phatato yes he used it as he said it was the most haunting music he had heard

  • Such a nice film

  • As amazing and powerful as the rest of the film is, I could watch that last *minute* a million times.

    As a matter of fact...

  • Kills me, every time

  • OOOH. SO THIS IS WHAT MICHAEL BAY WAS TALKIN ABOUT. TRANSFORMERS 3 WILL MAKE BAD BOYS 2 LOOK LIKE BRIEF ENCOUNTER. I GUESS THATS GOOD NEWS ! I CAN'T WAIT NOW ! SORRY TO INTERUPT ! PEACE !

  • Sorry, meant to type Alec

  • Of course the whole thing about this film is captured in the last scene. She never had an affaire with Ales, she never even met him; he did not exist. the whole thing was a dream, a fantasy.

    Even now, after so many viewing, the final scene still brings a tear to me eye.

  • @jeremy1000100 No it was not a dream fantasy it happen but she was rememberign it at home way back. u need to watch the movie again.

  • @jeremy1000100 .............She did had affair a long time ago and was thinking about it love this movie love it

  • Absolute classic film but can anybody tell me what she says between 1:11 and 1:18 please? Much appreciated.

  • @Claire93D "My dear I've been shopping till I'm dropping. My throat's parched. I thought of having tea at Spindles but I was terrified of losing the train."

  • @Claire93D Dolly says " My dear I've been shopping until I've been dropping, I thought of having a tea at Spindle's* but I was terrified of losing the train"

    Very quick 1940's English speech, very hard to decipher for a non-English speaker

    *Spindle's would have been a café in the town

  • I love this movie, could watch it over and over! Some of my favorite parts are the great British trains, and of course the Refreshment Room, and Myrtle!

  • of course the right thing to do was leave everything behind and start a new life. fuck your husband!

  • I love the ending. Instead of having a massive overblown goodbye, circumstances force them to restrict it to nothing more than a polite gesture. This is one of the few films where I feel sorry for the lovers and the husband.

  • If you like this clip then you must see ... 'The Astonished Heart' - starring Noel Coward and Celia Johnson. I believe this is being released on DVD in January 2011 at long last and will make a great gift for valentines day

  • @filmbuff48 You can get it streaming now on Netflix. First in my queue - after I finish my current "Brief Encounter" obsession. :-)

  • It's a great film and I do love it so but now that I've seen the Victoria Wood parody, I just keep laughing during this film..

  • Thaynk yoe sow mach. Reayly quiyte wanderful! A delyte to wautch.

  • The last movie where people behaved in a manner I totally understand.

    Relationships have never been the same.

  • A true tearjerker, for anyone who has any sense of right and wrong. Call me old-fashioned but staying power in relationships is sadly lacking in today's society. If more people lived by this code, Jeremy Vile would be out of an overpaid job.

    However, is it right that Laura stayed? Modern convention states that she should have gone, flown free, abandoned her children, thought of herself, Not the right thing to do, of course.

  • @nickhutchinson1

    Dear nikohut.,

    You said to, so: 'Old Fashioned' !

    .

    .

    Cheers.

    from,

    del-boy.

  • Based on a Noel Coward one acter. I always thought the Rachmaninoff was a bit much; and this final scene, at least he had a wit to interpose the busybody. The other doctor, earlier in the film, was an interesting touch as well, to remind us of the sordid theme at bottom

  • It's all up to interpretation. Interpretation, interpretation, interpretation...

  • A wonderful film.

  • I have always feared meeting my "soulmate" when im with the "love of my life" already...

  • The second best british film ever, after The Third Man.

  • I bought this film on DVD yesterday! It's really great! One of the greatest British films of all time.

  • Oh England I miss you!

  • A wonderful classic film.

  • Oh Lord, but this film is just so wonderful.

  • Wonderful film. Makes me sad for a lost time when people were more thoughtful and generous in the heart. Lovely. Nostalgic.

  • My favourite of all stories. I love this film, its so painfully beautiful and makes me cry everytime. 

  • Quite simply the most exquisite love story ever filmed.

  • @jrtrmish

    Fully agree with you.

    I must have watched it a hundred times but it remains fresh and powerful.

    florianska6

  • @florianska6

    Do you have any idea why you've watched the same movie so many times, or why you've said publicly that you have done so?

    .

    Cheers.

    from,

    del-boy.

  • @jrtrmish Absolutely. So so wonderful

  • That's so sad. I should say "Been there, done that". I had a similar experience. It stays for ever and it follows one around every day. But on the more prosaic level; My, - doesn't Crewe Station look good?

  • i don't know that it's changed that much. there are still mother's and wives who have a sense of conscience and wouldn't want to hurt their families in that way.

    the difference is that divorce is so much more acceptable and accessible now. perhaps if it had been so in the 1940's the story would have had that extra temptation.

    Also it seems that there are a few men acting high and mighty. Even in the time of the film the chances of a man walking out would have been alot higher than a woman.

  • Simply perfect ending. Hollywood couldn't have resisted the happy finish. I love Dolly Messiter's short appearance. Great actress.

  • Everytime I see this film, I cry my eyes out......simply heart breaking

  • One of the most moving and stunnong movies of all time, but maybe because I am British

  • This chokes me up

  • This scene reminds me so much of my last gf, we broke up after 18 months in a very "brief encounter" way. We couldn't speak as we parted for the last time. I know I'll never see her again; this film speaks beautifully to those who know true heartbreak. A true masterpiece

  • Every time I watch this (which is often) I always want to scream NOOOO!! when Dolly walks in! It's so painful...and I don't even mean that in a negative way at all, quite the contrary: the fact that it frustrates me that much shows just how powerfully heartbreaking this movie is. Such brilliant filmmaking. Love it!

  • i HAD A BRIEF ENCOUNTER WITH CELIA, SHE TROD ON MY FOOT IN 1957.

  • god this was so ahead of its time wasn't it?

  • @pigasus6 Yes by 4 weeks.

  • @pigasus68 And why are you telling God? What's wrong with us? I'm determined to get you to reply to me? Are you going to?

  • @pigasus68 Or is this just a brief encounter?

  • I saw this at the guthrie in minneapolis, MN. They did an amazing job stayed true to the movie and vision. Fantastic

  • I did too...It was incredible!

  • if it was me, I would grab Dolly's purse and smack her in the head with it

  • so sad..................her husband knew..

  • O-M-G when he puts his hand on her shoulder like that...I sobbed. I miss the days of cinema when these kind of doomed love affairs were done so beautifully.

  • wonderful movie. ageless...

  • I saw this in Film 4 the other day. Holy frick what a blinder....the end is brilliant and there is no way a modern film would end like it...buy this film its nails!!

  • Likewise i recorded it and watched it today, its probably one of my all time favourite films now

  • Flawless. My favourite film.

  • To me it does not have any flaws. I love this film

  • it brings a tear to my eye every time

  • I am a great big guy but I cry EVERY time at this closing scene---superbly acting and so deeply moving. The subject of infidelity is dealt with in a most dignified style.

  • She ruined it, they couldn't even say goodbye properly. This is definitely one of the best british films of all time xxx

  • the first minute of so of this kind of reminds me of that scene in atonement when James and Keira are in café. I have a feeling the actors took a look at this for inspiration.

  • BRILLAINT ACTING!

  • The eighties? this was the forties

  • "God bless this ship and all who sail on her...."

  • Un chef d'oeuvre!...

    où l'on perd mult kleenex!...

    Je crois que la pièce originale dont s'est inspiré D Lean s'appelle " Still Life" ou " Still Alive".... je ne sais plus...

    Merci pour ce post!

  • Absolutely hypnotic..Just found this DVD alongside a wonderful ladys DVD player..almost thrown away by a neighbour. Celia Johnson?..her amazing eyes..I want to know all now.

  • What an actress Celia Johnsone was; just look at her eyes. Only truly great actors can act with their eyes like that, (think of Pacino, for example). Also, this film was adapated from a Noel Coward play, a dramatist usually noted for his comedy, rather than tragedy. Such a heartbreaking end, but such a realistic one.

  • i choked up

  • A masterpiece of movie making :- perfect.

  • Of course this film is heartbreaking to watch. However, the most touching aspect of the film is that a group of people can come together and create such a masterpiece of cinema.

  • This is a great film. Just goes to show, you dont have to have loads of special effects, BIG love (sex) scenes. How many films being made now, how many Hollywood block busters will still be being watched and enjoyed in 64 years time..???

  • I suspect that this film above all others strikes a deep note with many of us who in some way or another have "been there"

    both painful and deeply rewarding

  • Indeed it does.

  • @womford also the musical inspiration for all by myself by eric carmen

  • Watch "it can't last" frm thet same film on YouT. To die for, break your heart.

  • LOVE THIS MOVIE!!! I cried like a baby at the end. They really do not make good movies like this anymore. TRUE CLASSIC in every way

  • Fantastic movie, one of the few love stories I actually understand.

    With modern movies I can't keep thinking 'But I would never do that', 'Whats wrong with them!', 'think of your reputation'.

    But I guess I'm a bit old fashioned...

  • I bought the DVD, I love everything about this film!

    Thank you!

  • God , how I love this film..makes my skin tingle for the last few minutes..Noel Coward and all of the cast have created one of the most true renditions of impossible love..

  • why "impossible"?

    in "Still Life" laura and Alec have a real love affair

  • Excellent.

  • So what's so great about this??

    Well, what's great about it . . . is that if you show it to 25 year olds today . . . 95% of them will laugh in complete bewilderment.

    And why is that great?

    It shows us that . . . if these 25 year olds can lose the capacity to feel this certain kind of emotion . . . then maybe there are OTHER emotions that the REST of us have lost the capacity to feel.

    How do we find out? And what would we do about it . . . if it were true?

  • "If you died you would forget me

    and I want to be remembered"

  • Probably because a lot of modern blokes arent worth marrying.

  • makes me feel rather pleased to be British (please read in clipped 1940s movietone) ;-)

    seriously, the cords of decency and restraint which yank her back to her husband are truly admirable and sadly lacking in our society today. Seems most modern day wives would've dumped him long before just for the times crossword habit.

  • I couldn't agree more. They don't make em like that anymore. This entire movie would have lasted only a few minutes if set in todays world; Brief Encounter 2009 "Hello you're a bit of allright" "You're hot!" "Lets go to my mates place" "Sure" "Hello mate, can we use your place for some hanky panky?" "No problem pal." "that was nice hanky panky" "I'll leave my husband in the morning." "yay"
  • errrr...you missed,

    Leave your husband..?? No luv dont be 'F'ing mad bint. Ive had you now.. No man can respect a woman who gives herself away so easy. Go home to your little life, husband and kids. Im off to have a life..!! Good byeeeee.. ;-)

  • The whole point of having an affair is NOT having it.

    If they had the affair it would have totally ruined the movie.

  • "makes me feel rather pleased to be British"

    Luckily for all of us who truly love movies, there are many many reasons for you Brits to be proud of your contributions to filmmaking.

    "Seems most modern day wives would've dumped him long before just for the times crossword habit."

    As usual, I seem to be out of step. I've always loved Fred, in no small part because of his oh-so-civilized post-prandial habit of doing the Times crossword.

  • i wonder what British women thought of this film at the time? Maybe brought home to them that some were not happy in their marriages and divorce was a shameful thing in the 1980's in England.

  • This, in my opinion, is a better ending than the stage production mainly because she hugs her husband. I know its not much of a difference but I like it so much more :]

  • This is the most beautiful love story of all time and always makes me cry! The thing that makes me laugh though is when her child says in a very posh voice "but there's no pantomimes in Joooon"!

  • The orchestral music in the background sounds like Eric Carmen's All By Myself...he must have sampled it, the similarity is too great.

  • just what i thought.

  • He did sample it. The music that you hear in the background is the wonderful Sergei Rachmaninov's Second Piano Concerto #2. One of the most romantic pieces....

  • thanks for letting me know, was dying to know that...

  • Such a gentle film. Britishness at its best.

  • I've seen this play performed in the Marlowe Theater in Canterbury last week, and this REALLY made me cry.

  • A love story without a happy ending...this movie's just...oh, there are no words.

  • I'm on my mid-thirties, a bloke and have just watched this adorable film. I guess most of us had this sort of hard-to-say goodbye in our lives someday.

    On another topic, is it only me who thinks Rachmaninoff Piano Concerto #2 is way too similar to still-to-come Nilsson's "Without You" ?

  • makes me cry every time

  • The most beautiful love story ever made. Or ever will be made.

  • God Bess Noel Coward!!

  • Thanks for posting this super film scene.

    How I eagerly wait for it to come out on bluray!

  • this is a magical film, it is possibly the best heartbreak film ever made. it is all about the words not said and impossible situations. only love for another can do this to you....

  • I feel like this film is perfection--the dialogue, the subtlety of the direction, the acting--you don't see films like this anymore. <3

  • It has what most modern films don't possess - class and restraint.

  • Such a wonderfully sad scene, classic film.

  • "Thank you for coming back to me"

    God! I started crying along with her. I love Brief Encounter.

  • My favourite film - thank you for uploading.

  • Thank you for coming back to me

  • I FOUND A LINK TO WATCH THIS MOVIE ONLINE, FULL AND FREE:

    blogger-films.blogspot.*com/20­08/10/brief-encounter.html

    (ERASE THE *)

  • this was my late nans fav movie its still a classic

  • aunque pasen los años siempre me emocionare al ver esta pelicula, increible la interpretacion, lamusica ,es la sinfonia n. 2 opus 18 para piano y orquesta de rachmaninoff, .siempre lloro en la escena final. es simplemente maravillosa.

  • Having gone through such an encounter in my life, I will always watch this movie with fond rememberances of a love once had and gone.

  • I love this movie too. It was all so dearly sad. But Laura did the right thing by going back to her family, and Alec to join his brother's medical practice in S. Africa. The encounter never really would have lasted because of the sneaking around they had to do. I love the music of Rachmanioff's Piano Concerto #2. It's the perfect accompaniment to the film. I have to get that recording and a copy of the movie.

  • I love this movie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • <3 this film

  • God, this is so sad. But it's so breathtaking, just beautiful. The musical score, the acting, the accents, the whole period--was just beautiful.

  • heartbreaking. the secret.

  • heart breaking

  • It's romantic and heartbreaking. And powerful.

  • This is amazing. I really hope I can find a copy of this movie for myself.

  • you guys are all dumbfucks if you dont understand the secret.

    I felt the touch of his hand on my shoulder for a moment,

    and then he walked away,

    away out of my life forever.

    the picture says 1:10:00-1:10:08.

    what she says and this persons secret.

    apparently someone she loved had walked out of her life.

  • Probably my most favourite British film of all time.

  • indeed a great secret .

  • so she cheated....mentally, physically....

    what's all the hubbub?

  • This movie never fails to bring me to tears...

  • her voice reminds me of Keira Knightley.

  • crazy bird.

  • I'm from post secret too. This is a really touching secret =^)