Added: 4 years ago
From: JackMcConnell
Views: 92,276
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (235)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I love it when she says "forever and ever and..."

  • why was she crying again?

  • @latteluva her grandma died.

  • Melissa R. <333

  • melissa r should have won..i love her

  • That made me wanna cry.

  • Chelsea suck.

  • Melissa and Asia <3

  • i remember watching this show and being sooooo obsessed with it and here i am 6 years later still feelng the same way. i've been listening to this song nonstop ! i love melissa r <3

  • i love asia... she really did deserve to win, shes unique, and her own voice....

    but leaving sucked......but she had a kid, soo being on tour all the time would make her not be around the kid.....

    i still dunno she was awesome.

  • I remember orignally watching this yearssss ago....I come back to this video here and there because both of these girls vocals in this video are amazing. I literally get chills each and every time. Amazing!

  • I really thought Melissa R was going to win....

  • loved it!

  • Melissa R is soooo pretty! I love her

  • Asia looked like a little girl when she stood beside The Pussycat Dolls OMG.

  • Melissa R is great but its a crime to say they are better than aerosmith. Its a classic . Their version will always be the best !

  • her voice iz so awsome asia its intense n makes me wanna cry..!

  • Dont Wanna See Da Black Girl Win Dam Asia Yue Did Da Damn THing

  • Melissa is way better and a lot hotter than Nicole =]

  • She's obviously hotter than Nicole =]

  • melissa r so should have won...i hate asia and she didnt even stay with them anyway

  • Melissa sings better! I like her dress, anyone know where she got it from?

  • I love this cover :-)

  • wow! i dont like asia that much...but her voice really suits this song......i liked this cover alot! poor melissa r.....aawww.....<3

  • Asia's vibrato sounds like a goat laughing

  • Beautiful. I love it! Great singers. So sweet the emotional one.

  • I love Asias voice in this song :O omg but I loved Chelsea's voice all together, my other fav was nicole i think her name was lol

  • the hand thingie asia does wit her mic is so distracting :S melissa R should of won

  • <3 melissa

  • This was the only song I liked Asia's voice on!

  • MELISSAAAAAAAAAA <3333 love herr. she was my fave.

  • this is like the only performance i rmbr from that season :)

  • awe, why did Melissa cry?

    :O

  • @m0niccaa she said afterwards that the song reminded her of her grandma. i'm not exactly sure what happened with her grandma, but yeah.

  • becuase i think her grandma died and this song reminded of her

  • Tehy sound amazing.

  • Asia is a bitch. I hated her.

    I like more Melissa R. and Chelsea. They both sing to my heart. Hope that Melissa R. get major label sign someday :)

  • i thought asia was gonna cry cuz o her baby but i was shocked but it still was sad :(

  • i love asia but they shouldve let melissa r. win cuz i knew there was gonna be problems with the fact taht asia has a daughter, and chelsea is already in the paradiso girls

  • Comment removed

  • I loved there performance! Melissa R sounded great, but in this show asia was better! & yes Asia won but she did choose to qo solo plus other issues & to top it off im actually qlad none of these qirls won bcuzz the pcd qroup lost one member already and there not makinq any new music as much as they did bcuzz the others in the qroup aint beinq recoqnizzed as much as there lead doll Nicole! Its like as if its Niclole featerinq the dolls but yu could find out more by searchinq it! I HOPE ALL WORKS

  • I luv the look of Melissa S!but why they r too short!at least their height should be upper 160!

  • yea asia left cuz they wouldnt let her bring her baby on tour with them

  • Melissa I adore youuuuuuuu

  • TOTALLY AGREE! melissa r should have won! or chelsea!

  • @13chabelilla the pussycat dolls thought that melissa r looked to much like nicole

  • asia isn't a bad singer but definitly not the greatest

  • WOOOOOOOOOW !

  • i'm still with aerosmith version, but this sounds good

  • Wayyyyyyyyyyyyyy better than the original version

  • @MissTwilight07 are you kidding me? yes i agree that they covered the song pretty well but no one can sing this song better than steven tyler <3

  • Comment removed

  • @MissTwilight07 lol totally not. the original version by aerosmith is way better!

  • I remember watching this on tv...... Melissa R. should've won not Asia, her voice was stronger and she had a better look.......i don't mean to offend anyone she just looked like she would've have fit in more with the dolls than Asia. Wat happend to Asia anyway?

  • i think she left cause of her baby.

  • Melissa's voice was so much better than Asia's.

  • where can i download this? I really want to have this!!

  • I like this better than the original lol

  • it really is...LOL

  • LMFAO, she sung her part, ROFLMFAO, she jus kept going, lmao

  • can u please tell me what "ROFLMFAO" means?

  • Roll

    On

    Floor

    Laughing

    My

    Fucking

    Ass

    Off

  • hahahha thanks

  • who song whos part ?

  • this was great ! this looks kinda hd

  • Asia even LOOKS like a drag queen rsrsrss

  • she does not

  • wow melissa!!!!!! xoxo

  • Comment removed

  • melissa è fantastikaaa!!!veramente complimenti...

  • i hate asia's voice at 1:39 :s

    But melissa r is the best always!

  • asia went solo cuz she didnt want to be a back up dancer she had real talent i think pcd should change thier name to nicole and the pcds ugh i hate them go asia baby i love u!!!

  • no she didnt she wanted to be the lead singer and she wanted more money thats why she left and her solo isnt working out for her any more so she gave up.

  • PHILLAPEANA GO MLISSA

  • this was the best performance out of the whole season!

  • AGREE! :D

  • i hate it when asia taps her fingers on the mic..... its really annoying

  • i knoooooow !!! i hate it tooo

  • she thinks she is christina aguilera r__r

  • lol

  • Hello none of you make any sense you suppose to be listening to the music and not what she does with the mic

  • i never notice but the judges have scary looks on their faces whenever the girls are singing. O.O

  • the beautiful melissa

  • okay first of all

    In showbizz you think of yourself, maybe she got offers? she's not really using her voice being a backupsinger.. why are people trippin

  • Who r u talking to Maribuu?

    Just wondering?

  • I wanted to reply some people, and I forgot :( So I just wrote it.

  • i hated asia and i didnt want her to win. she didnt even join the group! she decided to pursue her own carrer. too bad everyone hates her.

  • too bad she wasn't in Girlicious! she would've totally won! =D

  • Girlicious is even skankier than PCD, she was right to pursue her own career.

  • As much as i love this performance it doesnt top aerosmith singing it.

  • this song makes me want to cry =)

  • Asia Made her own choices,,,nothing wronge with that...But Mellisa was awsome her crying made it pure...she should hav won or made her own band or went her own way

  • Meliisa R ROCKS MY SOCKS

  • HAHA god sometimes asia sounds like a freekin sheep especially at 1:36. :D

  • Hahahaha rapcitygirl4, i so agree with that, if only she wasnt in this video, it would of been my favourite. Asia puts too much theatrics to her voice it sounds fake.

  • i lovve asia she deserved to win and i dont blame her for not joining pcd. why work so freaking hard (harder than the actual pcd memebers did for their spots) just to become one of like ten girls who no one knows... IF I WERE TALENTED LIKTE HER ID WANNA BE LEAD TOO ;]]

  • Asia is so stupid! If she wasnt gonna accept to be in the PCD why'd she go on the show nd tak someone elses chances dat really wanted to be in it? She shouldve never even tried to win if she was gonna declined it! Duhhh.

  • Maybe she had a change of heart..?

  • i prefer Melissa R! she is pretty, has a damn good voice!

    Asia is so fake! and she wanted to do her solo thing! that's why she didn't enter to the PCD!

  • I was tiqht when Mellisa R. lost :[

    Asia was qood too . but look now she aint even in the Pussy Cat Dolls *

  • Im so glad Asia won she deserved more then any1! Melissa had a gud voice though

  • what happened to asia? i never saw her with the pussycat dolls....

  • she declined because of her daughter

  • i love ASIAAAAAA shes so pretty they did pretty good

  • I love this.

    I wish they would do a complete cover.

    This was one of my favorite preformances from it.

  • Well, actually. Melissa R singing it was just <3

  • Melissa R is my favourite... damn she didn't win :( <33

  • If she won it would be good talent gone to waste, all shes gonna do in PCD is back up dance thats it, they wouldnt let her sing cuz shes gonna outshine Nicole. She's better of solo, shes gonna be bigger than PCD. she already has an album i dunno when its coming out.

  • Melissa R i sooo beautiful! (:

  • i love this song of aerosmith

    this version is good Mélissa r have a good voice and she is beautiful it's right she kinda looks like nicole pcd and vanessa hudgens

    asia too have good voice but she has some difficulties

    ps : soory for my english i am franch ^^

    bye

  • they sing so well together

  • poor her when melissa cryies!

  • i know robin is kinda harsh

  • Melissa R is soooo daaaamn hot!

  • Love you Melissa R ! :b

  • Wow this song is soo good !

  • I think that Melissa R should won....The 2 best voices that i like in there are Malissa R and Chelsea they are my favorite voces i just love them...i hope 1 day i would be one of those girls in stage..and i really like that music but i hate Asia...who like's her?...whatever..=)

  • i luv Melissa R ♥

  • Whats with the fingers on the microphone?

  • 1.48 was a fabulous note from Asia though

  • we just told you damarwin! ,. so hardheaded.. lol sorry

  • Poor Melissa. She should have won. :-)

  • why melisssa cried?

  • she thought about a relative that passed away or something

  • The song reminded her about her grandma. And she was soo sweet :D

  • MELISSA R. Should have won.

    i got pissed off when ASIA won.

    SHE SUCKS.

  • i can't stand Asia! she's such a drama queen!!! i don't think she shoulda won! even tho she won, she didn't even record with them. she quit! i think they should put Melissa R. in to replace Carmit! that would be awesome!

  • Lmaoo @ Asia's haiir ahahaha ! (:

  • Melissa R all the way<333333

  • Melissa is Beautiful ! & Very Talented ! In my opinion , She should've won .. Not Asia . :)

  • I agree! ;)

    I <3 Melissa!

  • Is Melissa Dating An Australian Fan?

    =|

    It Said She Was In Wikipedia, But It's Gone Now..

    It Even Had A Link To His Name.

    I Was Like =O

    I Just Thought I'd Let Ya Know.

  • She's dating Jeff Viray but I don't know if he's an Australian fan.

  • i think jeff viray is the dancer who dance with her in the dance clip

  • yeah she was crying because the song was rememebering her grandma ! and she did diee .

  • Mellisa R should have won...maybe she'd still be in The Pussycat Dolls now !!!

    Anyway Girlicious are here now lol :L

  • ahh ditto! i hated asia!

  • She thought of her grandma, thats why she was crying, I don't know if her grandmas dead or not but all i know is that she thought of her grandma

  • was melissa crying or did she just feel like caughing or what happened?

  • hi melissa! you are so great :) you have a complete package.. you're so beautiful w/c is a real filipina beauty,and has a good heart, unlyk asia.

  • MELISSA ROCKS!!

  • i hate asias fake singing

  • They should make a full version of this cause the boy version sucks no offense o.o

  • i loveee melissaaaaa <3

    asia is ugly :)

  • Soo true, it's a crying shame she won!!

  • OH MY GOD melissa ROCKSSS!

  • thanks for posting this!

    better sound quality and video quality than the rest

  • Melissa R should have won :(

  • i completely agree ! =[ and they said that they were looking 4 a girl that would be a good role model and asia iz far from that.

  • i LOVE melissa r's voice in this song. you can tell she really put herself into the song.

  • BeautifuL performanCE

  • look at Melissa R....

    she's a natural singer and dancer....

  • in some ways i like this version better

  • u like this one better cuz theres no yelling in it like the aerosmith version lol

  • i just love melissa r., she was great singin this music

  • Is very goOd perfomance ! I Love Melissa R and Asia

  • I LOVEEEEE melissa R she so hot so cute so amazing she is the best

  • I totaly agree

  • Not to be rude or anything, but Asia looks funny when she sings, and her voice is all squeeky. Tbh, I really didnt know why she was still in the competition. Mellisa R was amazing, she totally should have won.

    x

  • i luv melissa r

    she is so pretty

    no offense i liked asia but i think melissa should of won

    melissa roxs

  • aww..in this vid they were hugging and stuff..good chemistry...kinda hard to believe that not long after that they were screaming at each other..dang..

  • asia looks like a bitch... also when she walk

  • poor melissa r, she was thinking about her grandma :(

  • i thought about Asia;]

  • u r so stupid be nice at least she is showing some emotion in this song its not funny

  • asia have nice volce and she can bm better

    and i like asia

  • maybe the shoulda just taken Asia, Melissa, and Chelsea and made a girl group. that mighta actually worked. beside i luv all 3 of them.

  • everyone hates asia because shes ugly..

    but her voice is good..and melissa is pretty and she has a good voice..and its so pointless how asia left the group

    arrgg melissa should of won :@

  • I think its a good remake.. i like the original version but this one is not that bad :D Like it XD