incredible amazin what can i say just awesome may i dont have words you are just a great great musician and please keep this radiohead covers you can save the world covering this music we need you man and i have to say that if thom see this he would probably be amazed us me. keep workin hard and all the good luck for you
The meter of this song is very strange, which is what makes it difficult. He did an amazing job. Stop trying to be all high and mighty and criticize him for being off by a half step here and there.
Wow, all you people who like this and think it's an awesome cover have no ears. He sounds like Thom, has a nice voice, and has the rhythm right, but he's playing the wrong chords and singing the wrong note repeatedly at the beginning of every other line!!
Sorry mate, but this is awful. You're singing entirely the wrong note on the 2nd and 4th lines of every verse. It should be A Natural in the vocal part and you're singing A#. The chord in the piano is also incorrect -- it moves from an F# Major chord, to an f# minor in order to match the vocal part, then down to the E Major chord. But it sounded like the rhythms were right -- which is the hard part for most people
@danakerman hey man, maybe you should stop to make it seem like you know it all, it's a cover, the guy will do it how he wants to do it, please, take this in note, and I am a musician by profession, never ever listen to a cover thinking of the actual song, do as it was his own song.
@ilikeredandblack I'm also a trained musician and have been a professional musician for twenty years. I complimented deshkl on what I thought he did well. I LOVE creative re-interpretations of songs, and I LOVE creative covers. However, I feel there is usually an obvious difference between a creative change and someone singing/playing a wrong note. Unfortunately, this is an example of the latter. And, to be honest, I was criticizing those who said this was a "perfect" rendition.
@MajorracoonStudios I said professional, not famous. Don't confuse the two. Are you claiming to know all the professional musicians in the world? I can assure you there are many more of us than you know about or could ever hope to. Exactly how many classically trained professional musicians can you name? I literally know several hundred just like me that you've never heard of. Just because you don't know something doesn't mean it's not true. I stand by my criticism above.
AHH! I hate to be a youtube critic. Dude, that was awesome but I think it would have been cool to take those pipes you have and put your style into it a bit. However, if Yorke were to get in a car accident and needed a replacement singer, you'd be the guy I pick man. You're him in a different body haha.
he is not out of tune, he is just singing different notes, adding his own touch. you are right that he isnt singing and playing exactly like thom yorke, and if that was his goal, he could do better. he was probably just doing it how he felt like doing it.
the vocals aren't the hard part anyway. not many people understand the rhythm of the song.
Good cover, good vocals. You should of switched to F#m instead of keeping it major when the "black eyed angels swam with me.." verse starts and all the subsequent verses that are similar to that verse. Sounds more beautiful and melancholic. Good job though
Vocals are off pitch from what Thom sings, couldn't sing along with this one, but the piano is dead-on. But when I say off pitch, I don't mean out-of tune. you just raise up a few steps in areas...
Covers aren't always about getting it perfect to the original! I love how you made it your own by experimenting with the vocal line! Great Job!! :)
MusicalGamer13 4 months ago
don't care about those 7 bieber fans. that was very intense.
ZeroFrillsMan 7 months ago
incredible amazin what can i say just awesome may i dont have words you are just a great great musician and please keep this radiohead covers you can save the world covering this music we need you man and i have to say that if thom see this he would probably be amazed us me. keep workin hard and all the good luck for you
TheAmcampa 9 months ago
Best Pryamid Song Cover EVER ... Period
Simplepeepee 1 year ago
The meter of this song is very strange, which is what makes it difficult. He did an amazing job. Stop trying to be all high and mighty and criticize him for being off by a half step here and there.
RSmassacre 1 year ago
Wow, all you people who like this and think it's an awesome cover have no ears. He sounds like Thom, has a nice voice, and has the rhythm right, but he's playing the wrong chords and singing the wrong note repeatedly at the beginning of every other line!!
danakerman 1 year ago
Sorry mate, but this is awful. You're singing entirely the wrong note on the 2nd and 4th lines of every verse. It should be A Natural in the vocal part and you're singing A#. The chord in the piano is also incorrect -- it moves from an F# Major chord, to an f# minor in order to match the vocal part, then down to the E Major chord. But it sounded like the rhythms were right -- which is the hard part for most people
danakerman 1 year ago
@danakerman hey man, maybe you should stop to make it seem like you know it all, it's a cover, the guy will do it how he wants to do it, please, take this in note, and I am a musician by profession, never ever listen to a cover thinking of the actual song, do as it was his own song.
ilikeredandblack 1 year ago
@ilikeredandblack I'm also a trained musician and have been a professional musician for twenty years. I complimented deshkl on what I thought he did well. I LOVE creative re-interpretations of songs, and I LOVE creative covers. However, I feel there is usually an obvious difference between a creative change and someone singing/playing a wrong note. Unfortunately, this is an example of the latter. And, to be honest, I was criticizing those who said this was a "perfect" rendition.
danakerman 1 year ago
@danakerman haha, well said sir, you said everything I wished you didin't say. lol
ilikeredandblack 1 year ago
@danakerman if you've been a professional musician for 20 years, then why have I only known this now.
MajorracoonStudios 8 months ago
@MajorracoonStudios I said professional, not famous. Don't confuse the two. Are you claiming to know all the professional musicians in the world? I can assure you there are many more of us than you know about or could ever hope to. Exactly how many classically trained professional musicians can you name? I literally know several hundred just like me that you've never heard of. Just because you don't know something doesn't mean it's not true. I stand by my criticism above.
danakerman 8 months ago
It's so hard to play that damn song and sing. good job!
BUNNEESLAYER 1 year ago
ufff hermano
exelente trabajo
me encanto tu video 5*****
eres grande deshkl
saludos
davidrums9 1 year ago
awesomeeee
ab6122 2 years ago
that was amazing.
HandOfMusic 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
PIANO 95%
VOICE 43%
benjaminiriarte 2 years ago
@benjaminiriarte
Have you tried? this song is impossible to cover. Kudos to deshki
pittapitta 2 years ago
imposible??? jajajajaja , for u!!
benjaminiriarte 2 years ago
If it's so easy then where's ur cover?
jirdimaster 2 years ago 2
AHH! I hate to be a youtube critic. Dude, that was awesome but I think it would have been cool to take those pipes you have and put your style into it a bit. However, if Yorke were to get in a car accident and needed a replacement singer, you'd be the guy I pick man. You're him in a different body haha.
kurtzrepublican 2 years ago
Wow. I loved what you did with this. Great job, mate. You really did this amazing song some justice.
alexvstrex 2 years ago
why have u taken the major notes on the second bits of each vocal? bit random but doesnt sound too bad on the whole... keep it up!
bigspliff01 2 years ago
very good...but don't close off vowels so early to stay in tune.
brockjarrett789 2 years ago
i'm delighted
ElenaKnyazeva 2 years ago
amazing cover. your music rocks keep up the great work.
hiimlarry 2 years ago
beautiful cover ;D!
CRperro 2 years ago
I love your piano playing,its quite good.
Now you really have to work on one part of the voice because you are 100% out of tune there!
Its the part where you say "Blacked eyes angels smile with me"
and "all the things I used to see"
You are out of tune there on the star of the sentences!(half a tune) you have to go half tune down...
Anyhow you have a very nice voice,and I like your sort of vibrato.
Good job :)
aMUSEdxxXx 2 years ago 2
amuse
its...."i jumped into a river what did I see.
black eyed angels swam with me.
A moon full of stars and astral cars
And all the figures I used to see."
just to let you know
fpowars 2 years ago
he is not out of tune, he is just singing different notes, adding his own touch. you are right that he isnt singing and playing exactly like thom yorke, and if that was his goal, he could do better. he was probably just doing it how he felt like doing it.
the vocals aren't the hard part anyway. not many people understand the rhythm of the song.
sheatheman 2 years ago
Absolute amazing
Best cover i ever heared!
Jenia6109 2 years ago
No.
He just stays major where Thom Yorke hits minor notes in parts.
It might even work as a harmony.
With this song you can do anything.
Proweys 3 years ago
flawless cover.
DaEvilAvocado 3 years ago
wtf? who the fuck are u? Thom Yorke? xD
gr8 job
dkamane666 3 years ago 10
Good cover, good vocals. You should of switched to F#m instead of keeping it major when the "black eyed angels swam with me.." verse starts and all the subsequent verses that are similar to that verse. Sounds more beautiful and melancholic. Good job though
StrungOutFlip 3 years ago
god the song is sent from outer space... I can tell you have been there too :)
dilligan 3 years ago
This is really good. Do you write any of your own stuff? Would love to hear it if you do.
madmatt3000uk 3 years ago
Vocals are off pitch from what Thom sings, couldn't sing along with this one, but the piano is dead-on. But when I say off pitch, I don't mean out-of tune. you just raise up a few steps in areas...
jlnajera 3 years ago 5
Right timing and stops...Awesome cover mate, AWESOME..
BuzzieBee77 3 years ago
Outstanding, you deserve far more views. =D
xylopolist 3 years ago
WOW!!! Even captured the mood just right. NICE!!!!
synyster11 3 years ago
good shit man. 5*
Jimster666 3 years ago
wow, this is fucking good
great cover my friend
skullface90 3 years ago
great job!
you have the right feeling in your piano-playing.
it´s nearly perfect
MISSchaosMELTS 3 years ago
fantazmagorichno=
phantasmagorical
:)
doorsandwalls 3 years ago
absolute ace mate.
fantastic cover.
i did notice a little disterbance with the piano playing, but pretty close to flawless.
keep it up.i liked your other covers as well, nude is a hard song, and you did a good job with it. cheers.
JaBenny 4 years ago
ty v much m8, i appreciate it :)
deshkl 4 years ago
Bravisimo COBY!!!
tasonni 4 years ago
for the horde!
deshkl 4 years ago
very very nice
ljkove 4 years ago
ty priest :)
deshkl 4 years ago
wow great job my friend.. one of the better covers of this on YouTube..
check out trugritt 's cover of this (which admittedly is still my favorite)
five stars and a fav! great work....
jdjustice72 4 years ago
thx m8, and yeah trugritt's cover kicks ass :)
deshkl 4 years ago