Silenced? NOT!! He answered in a calm, relaxed and measured way. Also, "scrappy"? how so? I also did not see him 'suffer' and the use of the word 'Horrendous' is not an accurate description of the exchange. Jews who challenge Israel simply present a problem for Zionists that they dont know how to handle. Telling the truth is unpopular i guess.
yeah, I think the "questioner" was coming at Judt in a accusational and vendetta like manner, that was more revealing of him, rather than revealing anything about Judt.
this is how they work. its the name and the label that matters, the book cover not the book, the headline not the paper. They know they are perpetrating a scam.
Tony Judt was a remarkable man, who died much too young. His work remains remarkable. I wish this questioner could give Judt back the 10 minutes of his life he wasted.
the guy recommended a better role model for judt to choose. that was weak. then the questioner says "that's your interpretation" and Judt responds by telling him an exact QUOTE by the israeli president. shut down. lol.
Israel does try to say that it speaks for all jews. It seeks to link anti-zionism with anti-semitism. The world is bored with Israel's deceipt and wants Israel to grow up, before Arab hordes bury them.
@volapuk49 - Care to visit Hebron? No Jewish toilets there. 400 Jews fling all waste on Arabs walking in the streets below. When Arabs leave, more shit-slingers move in. House by house, street by street. It's the Jewish way.
The point is not that Israel is somehow an embarrassment. The point is that the concept of a nation-state based on a religion, as Israel is, is an anachronism in the modern first world.
His question is rehearsed to the point where he comes off sounding self-conscious, desperate, and confused; could it be that this is the moment he realizes he has a crush on Tony, thus throwing him into a homosexual panic?
The title of this video is apropos to nothing. Did you even watch the video before you posted comment?
Compared to the questioner, he does seem silent. On another level, the questioner, as someone with obvious connection to the powerful and influential, presents a well spoken 'self-hating jew' statement. Self-hating patriot is the next vein of sympathy for pathetic foreign policy by the U.S. and it's entrenched 'values' of late. We are already building the wall on the border. Next will be the Canadian demarcation zone. Quite a road map Israel.
It's a great sadness that one is unable to properly hear Tony Judt speaking in the video. I have only recently encountred his writings which I have found illuminating and deeply thought provoking. I think his views on Isreal are entirely on the mark. They maybe contentious for those with firm and inflexible views but they are neither vindictive nor cruel. Rather they are the expressed views of a man with a thoroughly modern mind. What a sadness that he has died.
When a word appears in quotes, such as the word "silenced" in this instance, it is to indicate irony, that the exact opposite concept of the word is meant to be conveyed. You must study what irony and its cousin sarcasm mean, note instances of it in your daily life including how you yourself use it, before making such uninformed comments in a public forum.
I've given this video a "Poor" rating for no other reason than that it's false advertising. ("Tony Judt is 'Silenced'"). If everyone on YT would do the same, hopefully we'll get less of this silly nonsense.
@SexyBack887 SexyBack, your name says it all; but where's the brain?
That Jews are often in the forefront of the critics of Zionism and the unjust policies of Israel (Chomsky, Judt, et al.) does the Jewish culture some credit, no? So, we see: There are many Jewish critics of Israel.
Sadly, one of the results of Israel's iniquity is the recrudescence of ignorant anti-Semitism. And, a "jew (sic) that doesn't support Israel" is like Bob Herbert criticizing Obama, an enlightened human being!
What has the lesser-spotted global conspiracy of fanatical secular humanist extremist Nazi Maoists got to do with anything? Do you need us to call a doctor or can you manage?
How is he "silenced"? The questioner attempted to browbeat Judt with boorish speculation as to his motives in criticizing Israel and Mr. Judt responded with eloquent aplomb, notwithstanding the fact that one couldn't hear him very well. Perhaps that was the "silencing"!
@princeandrey --Maybe the title is a play on words, referring to the difference between the microphone settings (chosen by Boston College?), that practically "silenced" Mr. Judt, while providing the questioner a setting that BLASTS our ears.
@princeandrey: Neither does it follow that all speculation is false as well as it doesn't follow that all speculation is false. By the way: can you prove who burned down the Reichstag yet? Since it's speculation that it was done by the Nazis as well as it's speculation that it was done by the German Resistance.
@princeandrey "The questioner attempted to browbeat Judt with boorish speculation as to his motives in criticizing Israel..." Isn't this browbeating with boorish speculation? Not the Israelis but the Israeli "government" like any other "government" not only has to be questioned - but the existence of a government (everywhere on this world) at all has to be questioned. "Even" ants are more forwarded - since they're organized in p2p networks, in clouds - and are the dominant biomass on earth.
@m0ses1 Yes, you're both quite right. I stand corrected, though it is a bit subtle for a forum such as Youtube, but "silenced" is certainly used in irony. By the way, I love the way someone used the word discutant here. And I'm not being ironic.
The Debate between Dinesh D'Sousa and professor Wolfe was also censored. Even the report about this censorship which appeared on Fox news and was posted on you tube was censored from YouTube. Boston College appears to be overtaken by fanatic secular humanist extremists who use the tool of censorship just as their heros of the past did- Stalin, Mao, Hilter, and communist governments of the world.
LOL how is he "silenced"? The point he made in his article was that one of the flaws in Zionism has been one its establishment of a government which claims to represent the entire Jewish diaspora and yet is incapable of doing so. That's a perfect benign and uncontroversial point.
Can you imagine me a jamican girl who attended a primary school called Hillel Academy founded by the jewish community in Jamaica -one of the oldest communities in the "New World", I find Tony Judt an archangel in the world of free thinkers he is human , a man , a jewish man , not just saying "yeah yeah" (meeh meeh)like the rest of the worlds 'sheep !! Not to mention the sound quality sucks ..but still doesn't play in the obnoxious interviewers favour!!!
erm... perhaps the "silenced" in the title is referred to the adjusted volume of prof. judt's audio that, to me, appears lowered... and certainly that would be the only way in which the questioner could silence the prof.
The embarassment are jews like the one "asking the question" and the millions who support Israel's criminal policies toward the Palestinians. Tony Judt and decent people like him, will always fight to end Israel injustices.
Albert Einstein did not want a state of Israel and wanted to live side by side with the arabs. He criticized the mistreatment of the arabs before 1948. He was not well liked in the zionist community.-- I learned about the newest biography of Albert Einstein.
Israel had it's nakbah too. It was in 1977 when the revisionist branch of zionism came to power for the first time with the likud party: Begin, Shamir etc. That was the beginning of the end for Israel. This is so sad! Today there is no way back! There is no way the 250000 people living on the other side of the green line will move peacefully. There is no way the humiliation and anger of the Palestinian population can be repaired. Israeli fascism has killed the zionist project! What a shame!!!!
mshireyankee what a complete twat you are. Learn your history before you sprout such silly bullshit. Palestine is their home. Educate your mind, the jews treat the people of palestine like caged dogs and you are ok with that, are you. I take it you wouldnt fight back if your town was walled in and your neighbours killed with 2,000 pound bombs dropped from the sky. I suppose you wouldnt fight back with any shitty means possible. Come on grow up its Israel that has to answer for its war crimes
If American Jews do nothing to stop Israel´s criminal actions, how can they critizise or judge the German People for not having stopped Hitler?????? They allow and support Israel´s policies because the majority as racist fanatics who believe. There are only a handfull of brave and decent men such as Tony Judt, Norman Finkelstein and ilan Pappe (all of them Jewish) who dare to stand against Israel´s crimes.
Why should they stop israel's attrocity, they suffered didn't they... ? :-)
Too bad i guess they didn't suffer at the hands of the Palestinians or the muslims... at least then they're arguement would have probably been relevant.
What Israel is doing will eventually come to haunt it. There is a thing called "Karma", if you harm someone destiny inevitably has a way of doing the same to you. So I guess that inevitably in the future there will be more jewish persecutions and maybe another holocaust (remember: history repeats itself)and people instead of standing against it, will remember what jewish people have done to the palestinians.
The Jews in Israel are doing nothing wrong. They are protecting their own land. They have every right to do whatever they want to do to the the Palestinians. So many inocent Jews are being kiled by Palestinian suicide bombers. Palestinians should stop complaining because they have their own country. It is called Jordan!
My friend, you are a case in point. Your ignorance on the subject is obvious. Instead of reading books your opinions are based on what you have been told and the one sided news you receive. The Israeli government counts on that ignorance and that fanaticism. Since you do not read, look for ilán pappe on you tube or see: Palestine 05: part 1/2 and Palestine 05: part 2/2
or read "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine" by Mr. Pappe, it is a good start.
you are completely and utterly brainwashed !!! people like you disgust me !!! how could the jewish community support this madness when not many years ago they themselves were being persecuted the same way by Hitler!?!? and now you hide behind the false ideals that people are being antisemetic with this "either your with or against us" mentality, you should be ASHAMED!!! FUCKIN FASCIST AND ZIONIST PIGS !!!!
How the hell do europeans, who lived in europe for millenias claim Palestine to be there land, aside from god's promise what justification is there.
The Caananites and the phoenecians were there before the jews (both semetic people btw)... and the "arabs" came after. Now the thing is arabs are now the descedants of the Caananites, phoenecians, philistinians babylonians AND the arabs of arabia etc...
99% of non jewish Semetic people are what u today call ARABS... PALESTINIANS (arabs of palestine)
That said the arab cultural and geographic identity has inherited what these other peoples (such as those mentionned above) once were. Meaning that if u actually examine the different arabs from morrocco to Iraq ull find the traces of many different groups of peoples...
No asshole Jordan is not their country. Fucker u don't tell a person born in Jaffa or Jerusalem and who was kicked out forcibly, a person who's family has lived there for centuries and centuries that he belongs in Jordan.
I wish normal everyday Jews would realize that the actions of Israel, AIPAC, ADL et al. are hurting them so bad. They're creating antisemitism by calling everyone an antisemite. And there encouraging conspiracy theories by lying and suppressing debate.
for far too many these days, to be a jew, particularly in the US, is to be moved by the holocaust..this leads to people acting like nazis to prevent Nazism.dangerous and ludicrous. Hitler used the media to brainwash everyone, as soon as everyone accepts that the media is better than anyone else's view, or more revealing than any other source, then that will only lead to tyranny.AND HAS
this jewish idiot believes that israel is a democracy that you must vote for who we tell you to vote for factually stopping aid via amnesty interpal redcross because they did not vote for abass.and in created israel proper cristian and muslims dont have a vote.
The interviewer smugly remarked that Tony and his friends take no risk by speaking out their opinions of Israel, outrageously implying cowardice. Obviously he risks a great deal by virtue of the fact that fanatics attempt to slander his reputation or possibly even threaten them with violence if they continue to speak out.
Youre aggressive antagonism is only going to isolate you further from the rest of the world including allies such as evangelical Christians too. You should take up a more Ghandi-like policy instead!
Israel gave back 100% of Gaza. It is free of Jews. so they launched rockets at and shot people in Israel. why wuld leaving Judea and Samaria be any damned different?
The difference would be that if the Israelis and even some of the Palestinians were to emmigrate to the US and Canada, there wouldnt be any excuse by Jihaders to attack them. Im proposing that the region within 75 miles of Jerusalem be converted into a shrine.
When Jordan controlled the Old City of Jerusalem, they woudln't let Jews in to visit holy places despite treaties saying that they would. since Israe ahs contorlled it, virtually anoyone who wants can visit.
You, along with your hawkish compatriots obviously lack faith in God. When He is ready he will bestow the real Jerusalem and its component regions to all believers. Until then all (including Christians & Moslems) should simply convert the region into a shrine that reflects our belief in God. Atheists should stay out and quit the antagonism. Innocent blood has spilled in this conflict and atrocities committed by all!
Silenced? NOT!! He answered in a calm, relaxed and measured way. Also, "scrappy"? how so? I also did not see him 'suffer' and the use of the word 'Horrendous' is not an accurate description of the exchange. Jews who challenge Israel simply present a problem for Zionists that they dont know how to handle. Telling the truth is unpopular i guess.
perussell66 2 months ago
yeah, I think the "questioner" was coming at Judt in a accusational and vendetta like manner, that was more revealing of him, rather than revealing anything about Judt.
bnlang898 3 months ago
this is how they work. its the name and the label that matters, the book cover not the book, the headline not the paper. They know they are perpetrating a scam.
quarkmuffin37 4 months ago
Tony Judt was a remarkable man, who died much too young. His work remains remarkable. I wish this questioner could give Judt back the 10 minutes of his life he wasted.
kemperboydresearch 8 months ago
the guy recommended a better role model for judt to choose. that was weak. then the questioner says "that's your interpretation" and Judt responds by telling him an exact QUOTE by the israeli president. shut down. lol.
talibalhidaya 8 months ago
the poster and the questioner are both fools... no rationale behind it. and Judt shut them both down. He's very smart.
talibalhidaya 8 months ago
I guess the only silence comes from tha shitty microphone. The only thing the questioner did was question his motives and thats it.
MrAlecaf 9 months ago
well the guy who posted this was a fucking moron
1337Lucca 10 months ago
Israel does try to say that it speaks for all jews. It seeks to link anti-zionism with anti-semitism. The world is bored with Israel's deceipt and wants Israel to grow up, before Arab hordes bury them.
JohnnyRock2000 11 months ago
The traitor is now dead.
One less offensive piece of dirt to deal with.
Next will come Chomsky, Amy Goodman and Finkelstein; more self-hating Jews.
volapuk49 1 year ago
@volapuk49 Well when it comes to hatred, you seem happy to spread it.
shemp2 11 months ago
@volapuk49 - Care to visit Hebron? No Jewish toilets there. 400 Jews fling all waste on Arabs walking in the streets below. When Arabs leave, more shit-slingers move in. House by house, street by street. It's the Jewish way.
JohnnyRock2000 11 months ago
@volapuk49 ....the same way early Israel attacked innocent villages
and killed everyone....even all the children.....?...and as a California
rabbi recently said, that's the real way to get your " enemies "
sounds pretty SICK to me.....get therapy or become a Christian,
remember, from a Jewish guy ?!
ohioguy7 10 months ago
"Tony Judt is "Silenced" at Boston College"
Others call it listening and responding to personal attacks without rambling and name calling the person asking the question.
Funny how someone would post this as if the person asking the questions put him in his place.
To bad they did not provided his whole response.
popiedo 1 year ago 2
Judt 1... other guy 0
Moun10eer14 1 year ago 2
lmfao 0:08 he gives the finger to the judge.
Jalenxx 1 year ago
The point is not that Israel is somehow an embarrassment. The point is that the concept of a nation-state based on a religion, as Israel is, is an anachronism in the modern first world.
FAHayek89 1 year ago
The questioner obviously has a hard-on for Tony.
His question is rehearsed to the point where he comes off sounding self-conscious, desperate, and confused; could it be that this is the moment he realizes he has a crush on Tony, thus throwing him into a homosexual panic?
The title of this video is apropos to nothing. Did you even watch the video before you posted comment?
cliklab 1 year ago
@cliklab Not to mention pretentious.
weddleston 1 year ago
Prof Judt is not silenced at all. Who on earth penned the title for this video?
RepublicanStones 1 year ago
Compared to the questioner, he does seem silent. On another level, the questioner, as someone with obvious connection to the powerful and influential, presents a well spoken 'self-hating jew' statement. Self-hating patriot is the next vein of sympathy for pathetic foreign policy by the U.S. and it's entrenched 'values' of late. We are already building the wall on the border. Next will be the Canadian demarcation zone. Quite a road map Israel.
happyhalberstam 1 year ago
It's a great sadness that one is unable to properly hear Tony Judt speaking in the video. I have only recently encountred his writings which I have found illuminating and deeply thought provoking. I think his views on Isreal are entirely on the mark. They maybe contentious for those with firm and inflexible views but they are neither vindictive nor cruel. Rather they are the expressed views of a man with a thoroughly modern mind. What a sadness that he has died.
artmanack 1 year ago
R.I.P Tony Judt. You will be missed.
Good response to a silly question... "It almost seems like that's what resonates in your soul" (laughable)
Navidnak 1 year ago
Zionist pros as usual active in the public speech domain (such as fora). "The ennemie is everywhere"
Prof Judt, R I P.
CaptainBluebear08 1 year ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Pseudo-Intellectuals come and go, Israel is forever!!!!
rachelgolem 1 year ago
@rachelgolem Hey Golem! Why don't you go schmegel away and go write racist shit against Black people like you did about Cynthia Mckinney?
Coward!
shipmaker14 1 year ago
Tony Judt is not silenced, he is a fair discutant and listens to his counter part.
Stupid propaganda video. typicall for the israel lobby
devrimhan1971 1 year ago 2
Zionists are just pigs that use the holocaust to justifiy their vile actions against the Palestinians. I have nothing against Jews.
kromed01 1 year ago
When a word appears in quotes, such as the word "silenced" in this instance, it is to indicate irony, that the exact opposite concept of the word is meant to be conveyed. You must study what irony and its cousin sarcasm mean, note instances of it in your daily life including how you yourself use it, before making such uninformed comments in a public forum.
Btw, Judt rules.
bc9021010001 1 year ago
Wow, thanks. Actually Judt is vindicated through this video. It's great watching it.
sternumagnum 1 year ago 2
I've given this video a "Poor" rating for no other reason than that it's false advertising. ("Tony Judt is 'Silenced'"). If everyone on YT would do the same, hopefully we'll get less of this silly nonsense.
TroyOi 1 year ago
A jew trying to control another jew. Nothinh special. A jew that doesent support Israel is an enlightened jew.
SexyBack887 2 years ago
Comment removed
u61d 1 year ago
@SexyBack887 SexyBack, your name says it all; but where's the brain?
That Jews are often in the forefront of the critics of Zionism and the unjust policies of Israel (Chomsky, Judt, et al.) does the Jewish culture some credit, no? So, we see: There are many Jewish critics of Israel.
Sadly, one of the results of Israel's iniquity is the recrudescence of ignorant anti-Semitism. And, a "jew (sic) that doesn't support Israel" is like Bob Herbert criticizing Obama, an enlightened human being!
princeandrey 1 year ago
I don't think the questioner is quite arrogant enough.
Scott89119 2 years ago
What has the lesser-spotted global conspiracy of fanatical secular humanist extremist Nazi Maoists got to do with anything? Do you need us to call a doctor or can you manage?
sartoresartus 2 years ago
hay que ser tonto para titular el video asi.
numaios2 2 years ago
How is he "silenced"? The questioner attempted to browbeat Judt with boorish speculation as to his motives in criticizing Israel and Mr. Judt responded with eloquent aplomb, notwithstanding the fact that one couldn't hear him very well. Perhaps that was the "silencing"!
princeandrey 2 years ago 73
@princeandrey That's why "silenced" is probably in quotes.
brrk3001 1 year ago
@princeandrey --Maybe the title is a play on words, referring to the difference between the microphone settings (chosen by Boston College?), that practically "silenced" Mr. Judt, while providing the questioner a setting that BLASTS our ears.
cpeebler 1 year ago
@princeandrey: Neither does it follow that all speculation is false as well as it doesn't follow that all speculation is false. By the way: can you prove who burned down the Reichstag yet? Since it's speculation that it was done by the Nazis as well as it's speculation that it was done by the German Resistance.
vertexgo 7 months ago
@princeandrey "The questioner attempted to browbeat Judt with boorish speculation as to his motives in criticizing Israel..." Isn't this browbeating with boorish speculation? Not the Israelis but the Israeli "government" like any other "government" not only has to be questioned - but the existence of a government (everywhere on this world) at all has to be questioned. "Even" ants are more forwarded - since they're organized in p2p networks, in clouds - and are the dominant biomass on earth.
vertexgo 7 months ago
If this is supposed to make Tony Judt look bad then it fails spectacularly.
m0ses1 2 years ago 3
@m0ses1 Yes, you're both quite right. I stand corrected, though it is a bit subtle for a forum such as Youtube, but "silenced" is certainly used in irony. By the way, I love the way someone used the word discutant here. And I'm not being ironic.
princeandrey 1 year ago
you cant hear Judt-he's not miked properly for this video.
ronzoni1001 2 years ago
Silenced? How? When? Quite the opposite in fact.
ArthurGoodlad 2 years ago
The title of this video is a joke!!!!
Silenced me bollox !
RepublicanStones 2 years ago
I don't really see how Prof. Judt was silenced.
I think the title is misleading.
dakhilaf 2 years ago
does anyone know the name of the guy who asked the question to tony
ned262626 2 years ago
The Debate between Dinesh D'Sousa and professor Wolfe was also censored. Even the report about this censorship which appeared on Fox news and was posted on you tube was censored from YouTube. Boston College appears to be overtaken by fanatic secular humanist extremists who use the tool of censorship just as their heros of the past did- Stalin, Mao, Hilter, and communist governments of the world.
prffsrx 2 years ago
LOL how is he "silenced"? The point he made in his article was that one of the flaws in Zionism has been one its establishment of a government which claims to represent the entire Jewish diaspora and yet is incapable of doing so. That's a perfect benign and uncontroversial point.
freethinker17 2 years ago 2
We are sure Isreali's Gov, One of the most Evil in the world.
jennydov123 2 years ago 6
Can you imagine me a jamican girl who attended a primary school called Hillel Academy founded by the jewish community in Jamaica -one of the oldest communities in the "New World", I find Tony Judt an archangel in the world of free thinkers he is human , a man , a jewish man , not just saying "yeah yeah" (meeh meeh)like the rest of the worlds 'sheep !! Not to mention the sound quality sucks ..but still doesn't play in the obnoxious interviewers favour!!!
dubtress 2 years ago
he is totally right,
titsh 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Judt is just a human , he's rude and not even proff .
You suck man... really
MoonsBeloved 3 years ago
Can't hear.
gldsmthj 3 years ago
erm... perhaps the "silenced" in the title is referred to the adjusted volume of prof. judt's audio that, to me, appears lowered... and certainly that would be the only way in which the questioner could silence the prof.
randoz1 3 years ago 7
The embarassment are jews like the one "asking the question" and the millions who support Israel's criminal policies toward the Palestinians. Tony Judt and decent people like him, will always fight to end Israel injustices.
arturohd 3 years ago
Albert Einstein did not want a state of Israel and wanted to live side by side with the arabs. He criticized the mistreatment of the arabs before 1948. He was not well liked in the zionist community.-- I learned about the newest biography of Albert Einstein.
nystagmus 3 years ago 3
beacuse he was a man with great inteligence, not like zionist, agressive nazi idiots
titsh 3 years ago
where the hell is the av club when you need them?
6458522 3 years ago
At what point exactly was Judt "silenced"? Seems to me the guy asking the question was a complete rambling ass and Judt put him in his place.
gabouchka 3 years ago 60
@gabouchka I second you're comment, it seems it common theme with Israeli supporters.
popiedo 1 year ago
The guy just rambles on incoherently without acturally asking a question thinking hes so smat! Go Tony!
xbowhntrzx 3 years ago 3
what the fuck I can't hear anything
trance2307 3 years ago
The guy should have had a separate directional micro for Judt or aimed the one he was using for himself at him.
hawkmoon1948 3 years ago
I suspect whoever made the video doesn't want you to hear Judt.
queanbeyan 3 years ago
Judt wins!
andy7666 3 years ago 5
Israel had it's nakbah too. It was in 1977 when the revisionist branch of zionism came to power for the first time with the likud party: Begin, Shamir etc. That was the beginning of the end for Israel. This is so sad! Today there is no way back! There is no way the 250000 people living on the other side of the green line will move peacefully. There is no way the humiliation and anger of the Palestinian population can be repaired. Israeli fascism has killed the zionist project! What a shame!!!!
warmperson2007 3 years ago
End the Pakistani occupation of Indian land.
roht5 3 years ago
mshireyankee what a complete twat you are. Learn your history before you sprout such silly bullshit. Palestine is their home. Educate your mind, the jews treat the people of palestine like caged dogs and you are ok with that, are you. I take it you wouldnt fight back if your town was walled in and your neighbours killed with 2,000 pound bombs dropped from the sky. I suppose you wouldnt fight back with any shitty means possible. Come on grow up its Israel that has to answer for its war crimes
japy1875 3 years ago 5
I need a bit more contextual info. Can't figure out what this video is about.
AnthonyBlunt 3 years ago
Tony Judt completely owned whoever was asking the questions.
FilipeBrasAlmeida 4 years ago 3
If American Jews do nothing to stop Israel´s criminal actions, how can they critizise or judge the German People for not having stopped Hitler?????? They allow and support Israel´s policies because the majority as racist fanatics who believe. There are only a handfull of brave and decent men such as Tony Judt, Norman Finkelstein and ilan Pappe (all of them Jewish) who dare to stand against Israel´s crimes.
arturohd 4 years ago
Why should they stop israel's attrocity, they suffered didn't they... ? :-)
Too bad i guess they didn't suffer at the hands of the Palestinians or the muslims... at least then they're arguement would have probably been relevant.
zionismisfilth 4 years ago
What Israel is doing will eventually come to haunt it. There is a thing called "Karma", if you harm someone destiny inevitably has a way of doing the same to you. So I guess that inevitably in the future there will be more jewish persecutions and maybe another holocaust (remember: history repeats itself)and people instead of standing against it, will remember what jewish people have done to the palestinians.
arturohd 4 years ago
The Jews in Israel are doing nothing wrong. They are protecting their own land. They have every right to do whatever they want to do to the the Palestinians. So many inocent Jews are being kiled by Palestinian suicide bombers. Palestinians should stop complaining because they have their own country. It is called Jordan!
mshireyankees 4 years ago
My friend, you are a case in point. Your ignorance on the subject is obvious. Instead of reading books your opinions are based on what you have been told and the one sided news you receive. The Israeli government counts on that ignorance and that fanaticism. Since you do not read, look for ilán pappe on you tube or see: Palestine 05: part 1/2 and Palestine 05: part 2/2
or read "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine" by Mr. Pappe, it is a good start.
arturohd 4 years ago
you are completely and utterly brainwashed !!! people like you disgust me !!! how could the jewish community support this madness when not many years ago they themselves were being persecuted the same way by Hitler!?!? and now you hide behind the false ideals that people are being antisemetic with this "either your with or against us" mentality, you should be ASHAMED!!! FUCKIN FASCIST AND ZIONIST PIGS !!!!
SilverNrGy985 4 years ago 3
How the hell do europeans, who lived in europe for millenias claim Palestine to be there land, aside from god's promise what justification is there.
The Caananites and the phoenecians were there before the jews (both semetic people btw)... and the "arabs" came after. Now the thing is arabs are now the descedants of the Caananites, phoenecians, philistinians babylonians AND the arabs of arabia etc...
99% of non jewish Semetic people are what u today call ARABS... PALESTINIANS (arabs of palestine)
zionismisfilth 4 years ago
Caananites...babylonians etc...
That said the arab cultural and geographic identity has inherited what these other peoples (such as those mentionned above) once were. Meaning that if u actually examine the different arabs from morrocco to Iraq ull find the traces of many different groups of peoples...
zionismisfilth 4 years ago
No asshole Jordan is not their country. Fucker u don't tell a person born in Jaffa or Jerusalem and who was kicked out forcibly, a person who's family has lived there for centuries and centuries that he belongs in Jordan.
U belong in Germany ashkenazi
zionismisfilth 4 years ago
Judt's a wonderful fellow.
1legerdemain1 4 years ago 2
Smart guy: nuts on the idea of a one state solution!
Itzik Basman
vergeharget 4 years ago
I wish normal everyday Jews would realize that the actions of Israel, AIPAC, ADL et al. are hurting them so bad. They're creating antisemitism by calling everyone an antisemite. And there encouraging conspiracy theories by lying and suppressing debate.
pobasted 4 years ago 3
for far too many these days, to be a jew, particularly in the US, is to be moved by the holocaust..this leads to people acting like nazis to prevent Nazism.dangerous and ludicrous. Hitler used the media to brainwash everyone, as soon as everyone accepts that the media is better than anyone else's view, or more revealing than any other source, then that will only lead to tyranny.AND HAS
OZMYMAN 4 years ago
this jewish idiot believes that israel is a democracy that you must vote for who we tell you to vote for factually stopping aid via amnesty interpal redcross because they did not vote for abass.and in created israel proper cristian and muslims dont have a vote.
OZMYMAN 4 years ago
Israel is a democracy? What happened to the dude who let it slip that Israel has nukes
hipsxnxheartx 4 years ago 2
The interviewer smugly remarked that Tony and his friends take no risk by speaking out their opinions of Israel, outrageously implying cowardice. Obviously he risks a great deal by virtue of the fact that fanatics attempt to slander his reputation or possibly even threaten them with violence if they continue to speak out.
ChristWillReturn 4 years ago
Youre aggressive antagonism is only going to isolate you further from the rest of the world including allies such as evangelical Christians too. You should take up a more Ghandi-like policy instead!
ChristWillReturn 4 years ago
Tony Judt, like many intellectuals and college professors shows that high IQ does not equate top smart
mb300sl 4 years ago
Is calumny all youve got? Tony's the most rational voice to challenge your violent campaign to control Judea.
ChristWillReturn 4 years ago
Israel gave back 100% of Gaza. It is free of Jews. so they launched rockets at and shot people in Israel. why wuld leaving Judea and Samaria be any damned different?
mb300sl 4 years ago
The difference would be that if the Israelis and even some of the Palestinians were to emmigrate to the US and Canada, there wouldnt be any excuse by Jihaders to attack them. Im proposing that the region within 75 miles of Jerusalem be converted into a shrine.
ChristWillReturn 4 years ago
That includes Tel Aviv.
When Jordan controlled the Old City of Jerusalem, they woudln't let Jews in to visit holy places despite treaties saying that they would. since Israe ahs contorlled it, virtually anoyone who wants can visit.
Who is going to listen to your proposal?
mb300sl 4 years ago
You, along with your hawkish compatriots obviously lack faith in God. When He is ready he will bestow the real Jerusalem and its component regions to all believers. Until then all (including Christians & Moslems) should simply convert the region into a shrine that reflects our belief in God. Atheists should stay out and quit the antagonism. Innocent blood has spilled in this conflict and atrocities committed by all!
ChristWillReturn 4 years ago
this talker with back to camera is really tiresome.
when o when will we cleanse the world of this scum?
daviddll33 4 years ago
How come the questioner has a better microphone than the guest speaker?
matt605 5 years ago