Added: 3 years ago
From: IGNentertainment
Views: 100,330
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,895)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • how did brawl lose to world of goo?

  • brawl is my winna

  • Oh and the thing that it's ridiculous to put dislikes, just because World of Goo won this battle... If people haven't played it yet, play it, it's a worth to buy.

  • World of Goo i think it's the best puzzle game of all time.

  • mario kart????

  • World of Goo? seriously, even I have and it`s a great game in all, but it was too short. I`d vote for SSBB

  • Mario Galaxy wasn't even a nominee...

  • @shpladau it was goty in 07. this is 08 so it cant be a nomanee

  • World of GOO<3

  • WTF Braw didn't win?

  • I fully agree with their decision. Go play the game, you will be moved.

  • Not goo its had to be brawl it had to

  • Fuck you Ign Brawl should have won

  • Why so many dislikes? World of Goo IS better than brawl.

  • @omarcortes88 You can play stuff like World Of Goo on gaming websites, its an insanely overrated game, Brawl is complex, original, makes sense and is just allround a better game.

  • ok so soccer and guitar hero got on here but not okami or super mario galaxy?

  • @DumDum5551 Super mario galaxy was 2007, this is 2008.

  • mario kart?

  • as if some crappy soccer game or guitar hero would be better than world of goo or ssbb

  • @Jnmicter lool. i know right

  • IGN just made a "Top 100 modern games". Goo was ranked 32 and Brawl was ranked 10 ...not very consistent

  • @potsiiscool umm, if I remember right number 10 on that list was CoD4. Mario Galaxy 2 was number 4.

  • @elenpop2 nope CoD4 was 19 and brawl was 10... :/

  • ssbb's best feature is the huge amount of content to unlock in the game

  • No okami?

  • Comment removed

  • this people are crazy super smash bros for the win

  • well at least it was not GH world tour what a pile of crap.

  • BRAWL RULES!

    

  • Where the hell is Okami.

  • @GeMaMaPe I can't believe Guitar Hero got on but not Okami.

  • Brink adverts - fuck off, I'm not buying your shitty game.

  • FUCK WORLD OF GOO, LONG LIVE OKAMI!!!!!

  • i, peronally thought SSBB should have won, but, i respect IGN's decision. World of goo is a good game. thumbs up IGN!

  • Okami~!!! That game freekin rocks! Game developers should hang their heads in shame because it's not only about the graphical power of a game console that they make games for, its also about the power of imagination. And with a game like Okami, the team that put it together are highly imaginative. Game developers just don't get it. Im kinda tired of playing games that says "shoot first and ask questions later." I need substance in my games... a good story. Okami brings it. Other games just dont.

  • Where da fuck is da Conduit and world of goo is a fkn gay game! -:(

  • I absolutely LOVE Super Smash Bros. Brawl... but World Of Goo is a masterpiece of a game.

  • 666 dislikes its SATAN!

  • @ArtixRocks21 not anymore

  • @ArtixRocks21 EL DIABLO!!! *holds up cross*

  • Pfft....should have been Bros.

  • are you serious ign, world f goo, thumbs up if you think ssbb should have won

  • NEEDS MOAR OKAMI

  • world of goo won because it was original. who the fuck cares about better graphics, it doesn't change the fact that SSBB (even though it is a good game) was nothing special. this is one of those rare occasions that i actually agree with ign's decision.

  • @tgbandroid17 it's not just graphics.. Goo did deserve to be nominated BUT super smash bros is a celebration of all things Nintendo. I'm just going to copy/paste what i said earlier: "characters (33 + Sonic and Snake), great story/cut-scenes, many different fighting styles, stage editor, awesome new and classic music themes, multiplayer/online mode, trophies which provide a huge amount of info on Nintendo history etc. IGN just didn’t want to go with the obvious choice so they can seem original"

  • @potsiiscool While Brawl is certainly a great game, it isn't great for the reasons you say. Great story? Really? There weren't many different fighting styles, besides the occasional breath of fresh air like Olimar or Ice Climbers. The 'information' the trophy's provide can be found on Wikipedia (probably more in depth). Online was horrible. The games balance was way off, not helped at all by so many characters. Don't get me wrong, the game was very, very fun. Continued in next post...

  • @ParadoxJuice Continued...But WoG went the extra mile with all of this. Brawl can get repetitive very fast, but World of Goo always throws more new ideas at you. I can't really explain it much more, but Brawl goes through phases for me, sometimes I enjoy it, sometimes I don't. I also feel like the game has SO much more potential than this (recovery especially. I love the fights to grab the ledge, but a lot of the time, all you can do is jump and use up+B). WoG is ALWAYS fun for me.

  • @ParadoxJuice when i said story, I was referring to the cut-scenes not the entire subspace mode. I just think that it's too intentional of a snub just so they can create controversy. How much "fun" one had shouldn't be the only factor (or else some Newgrounds games would win game of of the year ). As for the characters not being balanced (with the exception of Meta Knight) I don't think they are that uneven (my mains belong to the middle and low tier). Goo just had the element of surprise...

  • @tgbandroid17 But Super Smash Bros is BY FAR more fun... I have both, and no doubt have I spent more time, and had more fun with SSBB... sure, it's mostly a copy of SSBM, but it is FUN and that is what matters!

  • @tgbandroid17 it is a opinion other peoples opinion could be diffrent like mine is brawl but the game is more funner when you play with friends and cousins we made this thing called the Super smash bros X tourny we made our own there was like 8 people there 1 on 1 and who ever win's goes to the next round.

  • I'm glad World of Goo won, half the people that vote against it probably haven't even played this masterpiece.

  • world of goo beats SSBB?! are you fucking kidding me IGN?!

  • Dont listen to IGN they dont know what the f*** there talkin about

  • ssbb is the best, not world of goo. brawl had better graphics better everything. i think.

  • World of Goo? Bad graphics? Are you fucking kidding me?  The game was much more gorgeous that Super Smash Brothers Brawl.

  • come on reely .... it shood be brawl or mario kart

  • Let me ask, did any of you actually PLAY world of goo? Brawl was a huge downgrade for the series but it was still good.

  • WTF..... and the winner is (Assuming brawl ofc) WORLD OF GOO!! 0.0

    ign is retarded for even saying world of goo u just pissed nintendo fans and people who creted the other nomineed games off nice going FAGS

  • worst choice ever.. 

  • The reason why WoG has bad graphics is because it's an indie game.

  • Wake up people! IGN has been undermining Nintendo for YEARS. Almost all major gaming publications have become corporate mouthpieces for Sony and Microsoft. Only 1 nintendo game in the last ten years has won an IGN GOTY award. Beautiful games like Galaxy 2 and Zelda TP have been passed over in favor of TRASHY fps games. It's a joke. Nintendo could release a masterpiece and the bozos at IGN would say "you now have a reason to dust off your wii's" This is what I've come to expect from IGN.

  • SSBB IS THE BEST!IF YOU DENY THAT THEN YOU THINK THAT THEN YOU THINK A FRIGGIN' BLACK BALL GAME IS BETTER THAN A GAME SERIES THAT HAS BETTER GRAPHICS.WAY BETTER.SO THIS IS A RETARED LIST THAT JUSTIN BEIBER MADE.

  • did you people actually take a look at world of goo? :C

    It makes me sad when people complain about such a perfect game.

    Please, just try it out and then judge.

  • What the hell is world of goo?

  • World of Goo was actually a good game guys. It's almost as good as Limbo was on XBL Arcade.

  • WHY was guitar hero in this list, #1, why is a fucking soccer game in this list #2, and why arent Okami, TWILIGHT PRINCESS, and mario galaxy in this list?!

  • @atult333 sorry to ofend you in any way my friend posted a comment to you when I was getting a soda I was not meaning any harm to you say wanna be friends?

  • world of goo=world of shit

  • I got bored early on with this game.....

  • WTF super smash bros is so much better then the shit that won.

  • gay result...

  • liesliesliesliesliesliesliesli­eslieslieslieslieslieslieslies­liesliesliesliesliesliesliesli­eslieslieslieslies

  • You're all fucking ignorant idiots and I'm talking about the WoG haters.

  • world of goo... seriously...

  • World Tour, Pes, World Tour shouldn't even be on there, wheres mario kart and metriod.

  • Brawl is better, but world of goo is still awsome. Brawl should have obviously been the winner, though.

  • World of goo is better than brawl?Cool beans...

  • Brawl!!!

  • Wow. I'm shocked that I'm actually starting to think Gametrailers is a lot more credible than IGN

  • Hi guys remember me? i'm the guy that posted that comment up there.... ive taken all your guys edvice and bought it..... turns out its crap but i understand why it won.... i shall now tell you: ok brawl has some set backs like the fucked up repair shit i had to go throgh before i could really play it.... but there are fun things like online multiplayer........ok next game, guitar hero 4, 1 problem, bad graphics, thats all ok well now that ive said that cann ppls plz stop RANTING god.....

  • @Idtelos just shut up already. You don't even deserve a thumbs up.

  • No More Heroes is way better than all this crap (especially crappy ass brawl). Thumbs up if you agree!

  • Why the FUCK wasnt okami here!?!!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!

  • World of Goo - Great

    Brawl - Good

  • World of Goo was really great, but Brawl had a TON more content and fan favorites!

  • Ive noticed whatever they show first is always the winner.

  • These comments dissing the world of goo are entirely off.... World of Goo knew exactly what it wanted to be. It seamlessly meshed unique design, challenging gameplay, and creative aesthetics. That's why it's better than any of the other games on this list.

  • hum SSBB is much better but goo is good too

  • ssbb will pwn all those games

  • SSBB skull fucks the competition, and im an xbox fanboy

  • Let me set this straight:

    World of goo is awesome.

    Brawl is awesome too.

    When I played world of goo the first time, I was just amazed at how great this game really is. It was a surprise. How such an unknown game could turn out to be one of my favourite games ever.

    But with brawl, I think the whole hype killed that. I already knew everything about the game before its release, and had high expectations. But of course, no game could have met them. Not even world of goo. But wog didnt have that.

  • @TheLBPguy100 I completely agreed, I never thought that a 15 doller game was going to change my life so much

  • No Twilight Princess?

  • @MrFatChocobo twilight princess wasn't out in 2008

  • @potsiiscool It was released in Europe December 2006....

  • @MrFatChocobo exactly...not 2008...this is for titles that were released on 2008....not that were available then..

  • World of Goo is amazing, have you guys even played it?!? Why are you guys calling IGN ignorant when all you do is judge

  • @rulerofyourface still it's a wii-ware game and that limits it a lot. It did deserve to be nominated BUT super smash bros is the ultimate Nintendo game: many characters (33 + Sonic and Snake), great story/cut-scenes, many different fighting styles, stage editor, awesome new and classic music themes, multiplayer/online mode, trophies which provide a huge amount of info on Nintendo history etc..The two just don't compare. IGN just didn’t want to go with the obvious choice so they can seem original

  • @potsiiscool Although everything you say is 100% true, there is one thing that Brawl doesn't have, and that my friend, is goo.

  • @rulerofyourface well, Snake's tight butt more than covers that loss

  • @potsiiscool That thing is probably full of Goo anyway

  • @rulerofyourface SHUT THE FUCK UP!!!! ITS A WIIWARE GAME NOT A FUCKING KICKASS GAME LIKE BRAWL ONCE AGAIN STFU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @02Duderock I admire the fact that you didn't accidentilly type a 1 instead of an ! like most people do. By the way, just cause I side with World of Goo, doesn't mean I don't think Brawl is amazing, infact, I've logged in over 395 hours in it, have beaten the Subspace Emissary 5 times each with a different difficulty level, never hacked it once, and have completed every Challenge using four hammers and once I pwned a level 9 ganondorf teamed up with a level 9 bowser with jiggly Puff, just sayin

  • Still, a lot of people don't understand that SMG is an 07 game...and it doesn't make sense to criticize World of Goo when you haven't actually played it yet.

  • WHERE IS SUPER MARIO GALAXY!? WHY DIDN'T BRAWL WIN EITHER THOUGH? ARE YOU FUCKING SERIOUS, WORLD OF GOO!? AND WHY PES 2008 IF WE WANTED THAT GAME WE WOULD BUY A SHITTY PS3 OR 360! PLUS, OH I GIVE UP!

  • World of goo was a cool game but it doesn't deserve best game of the year over BRAWL!!! D8

  • And are eleven years old and not smart enough to understand great indie games

  • @GTtheEpic Hey man watch out, these people are for sure mad, cant you tell by there epic full caps -.-

    Indie FTW

  • @xXKiTheifXx keep it real

  • World of goo-brawl. Good pick ign. I'm guessing most of you faggots commenting haven't played world of goo.

  • WHAT THE FUCK! WHY ign you zuck mtfckr

  • ITS ON STEAM FOR 3$ RIGHT NOW!!!!!

  • WTF THIS IS BULLSHIT I AM GOING TO CALL IGN UP TO TeLL THEM WHAT A CRAPPY JOB THEY DID ON THIS I DEMANED A RECOUNT!!!! >.< now all I need is phone serivce

  • bullshit

  • To be fair, Brawl is basically a graphical upgrade from Melee and there arent any big differences in the gameplay in Brawl. But yeah, a wiiware shouldnt be GOTY simply because it is a Wii game, and content-wise Brawl pwns most Wii games. Wheres Metroid Prime 3 Corruption? Why wasnt it nominated, that was like the best wii game I ever played, and my 1st.

  • world of goo looks more like a iphone app then a wii game (brawl should have won in '08)

  • This is an outdated thing, but World of Goo is a fucking WII WARE GAME.How could it be better than a full on game with amazing graphics, a great story, AND a stage editor

    Remember kids, you can't spell ''Ignorance'' without IGN!

  • @AwesomeHaxor99 Brawl? Great story?

    That is not even opinion, that is purely biased!

  • @AwesomeHaxor99 someone has a biast

  • @AwesomeHaxor99 i'm also mad and i agree completly agree

  • @thersgonebad no they dont they suck balls world of goo sucks a ton

  • @AwesomeHaxor99 Way to be a close minded idiot. If you had played the game, you would not be saying that. Don't get me wrong, I love Brawl as well, but I don't see World of Goo being any inferior to it. Just different, and brilliant in it's own ways.

    Your argument of WoG being a wiiware game is also pretty irrational.

    Also, google it up, it's not just IGN praising world of goo, it's basically every single reviewer out there. And for a very good reason. Do yourself a favor, play it.

  • @AwesomeHaxor99:

    dude that comment is pure win.

  • @AwesomeHaxor99 hahaha great

  • @AwesomeHaxor99

    You sire are a ignorant bitch! World of goo is one of the greatest games on any platform, and as you said, It's really old now. AwesomeHaxor? More like IdontKnowGoodGamesIfItWouldSla­pMeInTheFace..

  • @AwesomeHaxor99 You probably didn't hear about Limbo, did you? One of the best of 2010 and it's for the "xbox's wiiware". World of Goo is not better then Smash Brawl. AT ALL. But being wiiware is not a problem.

  • @AwesomeHaxor99 World of Goo is an awesome game. Learn to respect other peoples opinion. You yourself are ignorant for blocking out other peoples opinion.

  • @RI3G Who ever said I'm blocking out opinions? I'm stating my opinion. Learn the difference.

  • @AwesomeHaxor99 Well you did call them ignorant. Also why can't a wii ware game be awesome?

  • @AwesomeHaxor99 because of the gameplay, just look at the old Goldeneye 007. Is that game bad just because of the graphics? And what about Mario 64 and Ocarina of Time? STOP DISSING THE WII. I'm sick of 360/PS3 fanboys that diss the wii, sure, the games on the 360 and PS3 are awesome, but so are the ones on the wii

  • @AwesomeHaxor99 also wtf in uk world of goo only came out 4 months ago wtf ign

  • according to ign, they said brawl isn't much different from its prequels... if their idea of barely any difference is online play, boss battle mode, an adventure mode that actually makes sense, then half the worlds games doesn't have much difference with each other

  • 2006 Twilight Princess

    2007 Super Mario Galaxy

    2008 world of goo

    2009 New Super Mario Bros. Wii

    2010 Super Mario Galaxy 2

    ♫ One of these things does not belong here. ♫

  • As good as Brawl was, it wasn't quite as good as world of goo.

  • WII WARE SHALL BURN IN HELL!!!

  • and brawl... sorry for the kids but what a piece of shit

  • WTF!!!!! World off goo can suck my nuts BRAWL KICKS ASS !!!!!!!!! FUCK IGN BRAWL SHOULD WIN IF U AGREE THUMBS UP

  • if you hate brawl you must probaly wish mario had died cause sonic saved all the nintendo characters :o

  • ok... let me just say one thing..... WHAT THE FUCK! WHY THE HELL DIDNT BRAWL WIN! WORLD OF GOO IS BASICLLY LIKE SOME PORN GAME YOUD SEE ON PS 3 OR 360! WTF???? WHY DO PEOPLE LIKE SHITTY GAMES?????? IDK!!! THUMBS UP IF YOU AGREE

  • @thersgonebad World of goo isn't bad! you are just bashing at it because you are trying to make a point.

  • @thersgonebad brawl did win

  • @thersgonebad you mad bro

  • @thersgonebad It didn't win because Its because indie games are kick ass.

  • @thersgonebad Have you even played World of goo, good sir?

  • @thersgonebad now maybe your just not into the stragegy game genre but the music and the gameplay is just amazingly created and put together in a whole

    that is why ^^

  • @thersgonebad

    SHUT UP SHUT UP SHUT UP SHUT UP!!!!!!!!!!! BRAWL IS THE BEST WE GET IT!!!!!!!! THEY JUST THOUGHT WORLD OF GOO WAS BETTER!!!!!!!!!! QUIT YOUR GAY FANBOY RAGE AND GO FUCKING TRY THE GAME!!!!

  • @Evilguy951 your the one whose raging more

  • @aggron28

    hmm. you have a point.

  • @thersgonebad LOL dont judge games. world of goo is so fun and addictive.

  • @thersgonebad

    Stupid Idiot.

  • @HerbJon look at my last comment retard..... i said i just played the game and ppl stop fcking around with my shit....ok? i no what you ppl were gonna say " fuck you rs world of goo is good!" fuck you! i know that now smart ass

  • 3 reasons why brawl should have won:

    1) Its awesome

    2) World of Goo is lame

    and 3) People who wanted World of Goo to win were umm... NINTENDO HATERS!!

  • @harpiefunfun90 I love nintendo, and i wanted world of goo to win!

    Also, stop calling WOG lame just to prove a point!

  • no animal crossing no mario kart? ? and fukin de blob makes no cence

  • .....WHAT

  • Not brawl

    huh

  • Is this a joke? How did brawl lose?

  • What?! World of Goo should'nt have won, it should've been Brawl

  • @chaosmonkey79 you haven't watched the video obviously, Brawl was one of the nominees

  • i think all wii games are for little kids.it was made for motion but most of the games are just button pushing.i hate the wii!

  • @thenunez96

    uhh, resident evil 4? no more heroes? red steel 2? how are those games for little kids? and great games like brawl, which can be enjoyed by all ages, do not use motion controls... and dont forget games which don't abuse motion control, such as galaxy and other m...

    god, such a freaking troll...

  • wow pes 08 made it to the nominees.... i thought i was the only person who played it...

  • brawl is defianatly the best choice

  • Super Smash Bros Brawl is way way way way way way way way way way way way way way way way better that World Of Goo

  • @superlurf clearly you've never played world of goo

    i'd say it's just as good as smash bros.

  • @LaPicturesque  well done world of goo is class

  • is this a joke? World of goo?

    I've played that game. It is indeed fun. but i could mention 100 08' titles that i think is better

  • @mrninja1995 Lol I know I could too.And besides,it's not even a real GAME,it's just a WiiWare title.Oh well,like they say,you can spell ignorant without ign.

  • @mrsnipe597 Are u kidding me!!!!

    First of all that was 2008 so ther was no good games for Wii

    Still World of Goo is a real game (even if is WiiWare)

    And the only two better games for Wii are Super Smash Bros Brawl and Resident Evil Darkside Chronicles

  • AHHHHH SO MANY BRAWL FANBOYS!!!!!

  • @XDArK2442X how many world of goo fanboys are there?

  • @animeizmylife zero.... i loved brawl and i never played world of goo and im not complaining... however, i bet most of these people havent played it either... cept mrninja there

  • cmon you have to admit world of goo is addicting

  • @thebfbc2master ye but seriously what r u still playing with friends now: world of goo with its cool coop or the simply awsome Brawl vs mode. ye you dont have to answer i know it

  • world of goo?!

    it must be amazing to beat brawl....

  • @01PoNd It sucks ive played it!

  • They didn't have Okami. This list is a fail.

  • @Jazzkamiden Okamis a port.