Added: 3 years ago
From: sticktodrums
Views: 32,958
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (128)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • im amazed by your fountain of journey info...a big fan open to changes journey went through

  • @ Misterdrum78, Du bist ein Arschloch :)

    Let's here you sing like the new lead singer of Journey (Arnel Pineda)

    Behind every successful man there lies a pack of haters. For those who hate Arnel Pineda (lead Singer Journey) you people are just envious of him. NEW JOURNEY is awesome! (*^ o ^*)/

  • NO STEVE= NO JOURNEY

  • Hi Ryan! Will there be a review on Eclipse?

  • Journey is the best !!! All the way>>>>>

  • ALL YOU FUCKING CYBER BULLIES....TAKE YOUR STUPID COMMENTS

    ELSEWHERE........YOU ALL BRING NOTHING TO THE TABLE!

  • Arnel SUCKS

  • Why would they go and re-record "Faith In The Heartland" that was originally done by Steve Augeri? What a slap in the face to Augeri. The remake was terrible.

  • @misterdrum78 The producer Kevin Shirley liked FITH from Generations and HE wanted the band to re-record it cause he though he could do better in production.

  • "after all these years" kinda reminds me of "faithfully", but with a notably more sophisticated melodic character.

  • sticktodrums-you should not have made this video-it is rubbish. You have a strangulated voice which is not for broadcasting with the ums and ahs. Arnel Pinada is fantastic and this is a case of opportunity occurring when the preparation has been done. Arnel has earned his place in the world as the frontman for Journey.

    I wish Arnel and Journey many years of success.

  • are a professional singer to review that ...

  • Treaty4 well said.

  • Who cares about what you think? I dont give a shit. Arnel rocks! you dont!

  • You do realize that I am saying Arnel rocks?

  • gregg rolie was the best singer....

  • Correction: By far.

  • Yowzer! You are darlin'. The CD is great! At first I was not happy about Jeff Soto being fired, but Arnel has proven he has what it takes to deliver the Journey sound. True, at times Arnel sounds like Steve, but he definitely has his own flavor. "Turn Down The World Tonite" is the by far the best song on the album. I certainly want to go see Journey again. And No Steve is a troll that should not be given the time of day.

  • You are a HYPOCRITE.

    Here, you talk sweet words. Elsewhere, you are racist. You equate Filipinos to Mongoloids

  • OH my... you are fine!

  • it doesnt matter if there are some who dont like arnel... arnel cant please everybody..

    its not arnel's fault if neal schon and the rest of the band believe on him..

    arnel talent is not the only thing we admire, his inspiring story too..

    go arnel the issues from ur critics are nothing compared to what u have done and achieved at this moment.....- u made JOURNEY believe on you and other big names in the industry.. Godbless.. and for your crictics, we will just pray for them

  • sticktodrums, your music is louder than your talking..i can not understand the words what you're saying..:(

  • If you ignore the Umms, this was a very good review video. Whether it was critqueing Journey or Balls-In-Flame (?). You showed good production knowledge and unbias views.

    Nice Job my friend,

    MTS

  • Nothing was really scripted so I was thinking off the top of my head what I wanted to say... Thanks though!

  • I like Arnel, he's got his own style, a fantastic voice and he fits the journey sound perfectley! There so many Perry wannabes on youtube, I'm just glad Neal didn't choose any of them! Cause there is only one Steve Perry and he could never be replace by a replica!!

  • royalmile, appreciated. that's what friends are for!

  • No Steve has a point that Arnel doesn't sing nearly as well as Steve. Rollie ALWAYS best! The original!! I need my meds. You like guys??

  • Rolies is/was always the original sound of Journey. However, you need to listen to the Stickodrums Journey Revelation album review alwaysshere. LISTEN AND LEARN! This is an excellent review.

  • I love you bro. I am proud to be one of your closest friend. Go for it!!!

  • Same here my bro

  • you can't take nostevejourney's point of view seriously. He has no mental capacity to absorb real facts. He has only have eyes on Perry.

  • hi sticktodrums, you probably don't come across with my ID's. Just to say that his deluded/deluted ID's is the same creator of alwaysshere/haggardfan123 and NoSteveNoJ0urney. Don't listen to this scumbag and nasty troll. I cleared them up slowly. I agree with your reviews. I think, it is based on facts and reality. I agree, Arnel's voice sounds Journey. He will be remembered as one of the best tenor in Journey.

  • Watch out for IMPOSTERS

  • No Rollie No Journey

  • you look like Steve Perry... Are you imitating him?

  • where you from? your cute.....

  • I think the best offense for you Ryan is to retreat. This alwayss guy is out to get your goat. He/she just won't accept any reasoning beside his/her own. Journey is journey with or without SP. The legacy is there for whoever they hire to continue it and it so happened that Arnel is the new guy who is more than capable to make new things happen for this beloved band.

  • Unfortunately, I deal with a lot of haters and Perry loyalists who bring up race, age and other things that have no bearing on whether or not Arnel is a great singer with Journey. People are entitled to their opinion, but if they are ignorant, I wont deal with them

  • Deluted say YOU are ignorant. ROLLIE is best front man for Journey. Sure, Steve was the STAR, and Arnel is only a GLIDING PARROT of Steve. Deluted say you too young to know anything about the REAL Journey

  • Ah, Yoda is here now so we can all rest easy... You are another that judges a book by its cover. I know more than you probably ever will about Journey.

  • Not according to your reviews!

  • Don't you mean "Deluted say 'According not to your reviews'"? since you're speaking like someone who's trying to sound intelligent?

  • That made no sense, but then again neither do your reviews. Rollie was ORIGINAL BEST Journey, Perry a STAR, Pineda, a Gliding Parrot copy of Steve. NO ROLLIE NO JOURNEY

  • Read your original post... You sound like a fool starting out with "Deluted say..." like your trying to be Yoda who is much smarter than you obviously are.

  • Deluted refers to himself in third person. Does that mean a FOOL? Deluted not American. Don't be a racist with the way some talk. All you talk about is Gliding Parrot Arnel and Gay Steve, ROLLIE was best!! Give him some Props!

  • Im not being racist. You spoke normally in your response when you said "That made no sense". You talking about about yourself in the 3rd person just makes me laugh.

  • Rollie only HALL OF FAME member. Let Deluded know when puppet Arnel get there.

  • Not Hall of Fame from Journey, from SANTANA.

  • I agree, alwaysshere/haggarfan123/Noste­veNoJourney/fake delutedperryfan198O is trying to sound intelligent and obviously not. don't let this nastry troll controll your videos mate. 5 stars review!

  • you are too old BITCH! get LOST DUMBASS!!

  • Journey is a band, not Steve Perry. Sticktodrums, Thanks for presenting such a balanced review.  I met the guys at a Meet and Greet during their concert in Manila, and they were all nice guys.

  • age and experience doesn't mean no steve no journey is better than us younger fans. i am a modern journey fan. I live in the present. all i could do is to remember perry and nothing else. Grandpa at 44? is over pushing SP lol. His SP doesn't care!

  • lol, grandpa no steve no journey is so desperate. he's been bashing journey-pineda for week like a 3 years old child. Shame of this old man! Actually, i lost respect and faith about SP because of this childlike fan. Grow up grandpa!

  • Jon Waite is not the same kind of singer as Perry at all. And writing partners don't always click like the guys in Journey did. My point isnt that Perry wasnt a great singer because he is one of teh best of all time. My point is is this: Journey was more than Perry. They moved on and they still sound like Journey. You either take it or leave it. This isn't 1981 and Perry ain't coming back. So since we both agree that Escape is the best Journey album of all time, why are we arguing?

  • Thank you for at least being open minded. I saw Arnel at one of the very first shows and one of the last shows in the US. He seemed really worn down by the last show and he was sick. Neal is a workaholic, we all know this. Arnel was sick at Superbowl. Im sure like Perry, over time Arnel got worn down, especially since he NEVER did a tour this big before. Its like being an athlete, he gave it all at the beginning and then he had his off nights just as Perry did. Shit happens.

  • alwasshere can "EAT" APs' dust !!

    Arnel is doing MEGABUCKS...while

    your still chasing your "unemployment

    paycheck" ...fucking MONGREL!!

  • HEY ALWAYSSHERE where in bay area do you live coz i am sooo gonna kick your ass and fuck ur mom while u watch....faggot...

  • thank you sticktodrum for supporting Asian talent in journey. you look like Keanu Reeves :)))))))))) honestly, you look like him!

  • I'm a big fan of Steve Perry, I think he's the classic voice of Journey, but Arnel Pineda sounds great and brings something of his own to Journey!

  • alwayssshere is maybe a relative of perry...or maybe a son of perry out of wedlock....he is a perrymaniac who can't move on....i pity you alwaysshere

  • Whats funnier, is he has like 5 accounts that he would spread his hate with. I ended up blocking all of them cause all he wanted to do was cause trouble.

  • hahahaha....nice review sticktodrums...by the way i was at kona concert...and man, arnel really rock the house....he's totally amazing...he's getting better and better.....separate ways....oh god...what a pipes he got....the noooooooo....(goosebumps) he has the pipes...i stopped believin after perry left the band....but after hearing the band's concert...i'm now a believer

  • alwaysshere..for your information the hits song of journey now which is AP sing it have already begun coming out and heard here in some radio station in the Phillipines...beside SP.

  • and what did arnel get paid for the tour .scale............ and what songs did he help write?????None but Journeys first choice jeremey did.

  • Neal wasn't sold on Hunsinger. Arnel is a much better singer choice for the material which was already written before he joined. Kinda like how Fleishman cowrote a bunch of stuff before Perry joined.

  • lmao yes he was jeremey didn't want the job due to the singer drama that was going on and the point that he just had a baby and wanted to saty home!and the way neal handled tapegate well arnel just better watch

  • his back and his voice because neal will stab him when he least expects it!and will run his voice in the ground and will replace him just like augeri!

  • alwaysshere: Fuck YOU IDIOT COWARD! you QUIT and "Feel the Change" DUMBASS!!

  • do you think they actually have the talent to have a new sound???If they did or even wanted one they wouldn't have fired soto!

  • Thanks for this review, though I was really hoping to hear a little bit more about the lyrics and themes they chose for the new album. It seems that this had something to do with reaching their target market/audience worldwide. Overall though, you did a great job. Thanks again... I shall now be hoppin' on to the music store to get my own copy...

  • damn puppet show!

  • tnxs for viewing puppet show wahahahahah......

    arnel had a bunch of dollars and the album revelation made a platinum what a puppet show.You shut up bitch... FUCK your mother in your house... then say I love puppet show wahahah.Your perry cant make a platinum again He cant be back in journey and his voice thats the truth and besides YOU HAVE A JELOUS TO ARNELyou know why YOU ARE NO BRAIN.. try to learn in school not always criticise to arnel this is for you ,l,^_^,l,, who cares about you!!

  • your such a dumbass why dont you get out of your closet and wipe your chin you porchomnkey piece of shit!

  • again and again this is for alwaysshere

    ,l,,^_^,l,, thxs for viewing puppet show the puppet show made platinum and sold out concerts.......

    puppet show puppet show made journey

    back wahaahahahah!!!!!

    !!!

  • hahahahahahah hell he's making aliving singing perry era songs if they didn't sing perry songs no one would go see them!

  • Perry era songs are a part of Journeys history and what also made them big. Every band that has new members plays teh old hits as that what people know. And keep your comments here clean please.

  • well when people keep saying arnel is better than perry ...prove it lets see them tour as the new journey like the cars did...hell you know they couldn't sell out crap playing the new stuff...neal wanted a perry puppet not a new sound!

  • Perry could not go on Tour now with Journey no matter what. Look at his live videos from 86-87, 91 and 94-95. I love Perry, but thats reality. The Trial By Fire tour never happened for reasons other than his hip. Journeys moved on and found a frontman that does justice. Deal with it.

  • hahahaha yeah right and if perry wanted back in neal would fire arnel faster than he hired him!!!He knows who the fans would really want to see!

  • You are obviously delusional and not aware of all the facts. Perry will never tour again due to his age and voice.

  • No kidding really???lmao I'm just saying if he called neal he'd have the lead spot and yes he probably could tour again and whens the last time you've actually heard his voice I'm mean he has been in the studios!

  • No doubt Perry can still do well in the studio. But Arnel suffered what Perry did back in the day, tour fatigue and burnout. Perry would not last a week on the road. Journey is a touring AND recording band and for that reason Perry was fired and will most likely never play with them again.

  • no he won't he's said so many times but if he did they take him back in a second ... and arnel will have the same fate as augeri did and neal wont give a shit he'll just replace him.

  • He's also said many other things about Perry so the reality is, it wont happen.  Journey has lived on with new singers longer than with Perry in the band so either deal with it or live in the past.

  • live in the past ...hahaha thats exactly what journeys doing!They haven't had a real hit since he left!

  • Um thats why the album already is Platinum?

  • hmmm yeah and it's because arnels so called hometown's bought the albumn 10 and 20 at a pop but you sure don't hear it on the radio being played ...hell they remade the classics and when you hear journey on the radio it's always perry you hear!

  • Success isn't just measured by being on the radio. They still have a HUGE following along with new fans. You're just a hater so Im done here.

  • good it's about time...the truth usually hurts

  • The truth is that you are a hater. Arnel kicks ass so get lost.

  • lmao yeha he's a great cover singer...he obviously can't do it solo ...so go the cover band route!

  • Obviously you're a dumbass because 1: he did have a solo career as well as 2: an album with his own band. And yes, there's a lot of money in doing covers, he does the best cover of almost every band out there showing just how good he is before he played with Journey. You're digging your own grave here.

  • yet here you are still responding to me hahahaha and your the dumbass if his solo career was any where he wouldn't have needed journey or the zoo...but he did... and go look at some videos of the zoo and the half empty seating...remeber there is a difference between a cover singer and an actual artisit with his own hits!

  • Journey is doing better with their new singers than Perry did on his own solo... There's a reason for that.

  • really I bet perrys solo career went better than arnels did!!!and theres a reason for that to..

  • Because he had fans like you! So at the height of Journeys career, Perry does a solo album and it takes off cause people like you only care for Perry. But his 94 album didnt do so well. Again, Journey with their new singers have done better than Perry did on his own after everything was said and done. As much as I love Perry, him on his own AINT Journey. And Ill take Journey with any of their new singers playing Journey songs than Perry and his backing bands playing Journey songs.

  • hey where's the video show casing the new artist at?????

  • Go Go Go! AP.. The Thrilla from Manila.. ARNEL PINEDA!

  • i totally agree Escape is the best but I will give credit to revelation. I think, revelation is the best produced ever come back since Perry. I felt young again! The journey (revelation) superb tract sounds that journey breath new life in the Amazon river with Arnel sounds haunted effect. It's just mind blowin!

  • neal hired a new puppetsimple as that !

  • second part of review. The concert disk is outstanding and has AP jumping around, kidding with Neal and all having a good time Dean does a great Mother, Father with him singing. This line up has a chance. SA was very good as the first replacment of SP. Arrvial was great, they are not there yet with the songwriting. The only reason Arrival did not have hits is because of lack of air time. The band will continue to face that problem it seems to be less with AP do not cout them out yet!!!!!

  • I have reviews of the other discs up.

  • I'll review the rest. The 2nd disk is a recording of greatest hits. It is not simply Arnel Pineda singing to recorded tracks but him and the band singing their best songs. SP fans may be upset and feel disrespected. The sound is respectful and fresh. Sometimes you will think it is SP. Ther was Journey before SP and there is one now. SP is hugh and the best rock singer hands down. AP brings energy and life to the band that even if it contunined with SP would be a shell with all the conflict.

  • good review Ryan, this s not about one person but the whole band. i've never seen the whole journey members connected like this now since perry's gone. Revelation is the best journey's album ever produced bext to Escape, in my opinion. I love the whole package.

  • Escape is the greatest album of all time.

  • I totally agree. I played it over and over again. Thery need that spark again. They keep on having problems in getting there but they will be that good again.

  • Nice REVIEW...its not all about who's WHO now..its not about Perry OR Arnel..but its all about journey's HITS...

  • Yup! Its about Journey and the music. I'll be doing more review of Journey stuff next month after I post some more of my tunes on the web.

  • yeah your right this is not about one guy or individual this is all about the whole part of the BAND. without the band How will SP be discovered? i think we give the whole credit not to just one person, but to the band "JOURNEY"

  • Ryan,please lower the background music next time..fair and honest..great review

  • Its been noted. I have more reviews on their way due next month.

  • I'd be looking forward for that..thanks Ryan

  • Can't hear your review for the back round music.

  • wish its available here in the philippines...CD's good

  • who are u? you look delicioussssss,,,yummmmmy

  • Thanks for this review bro. It was really detailed and good.

  • ...better with a lower background sound though

  • ryan, it's great...thanks for the review...couldn't agree more with you...

  • Whats is wrong with you tubers ! I mean there is a multi millionare in his beach house mansion crying right now because he was thrown out of Journey for having a bad hip? Life is not fair. While the rest of us get to keep having the joy of our average joe jobs. WEll not me you see. Im a millionare too . lOL!

  • Another fine review...dude...i can't concentrate..your lips your lipsssss lookssss yummy?....is that the right word?

  • Sound good to me!

  • like your reviews! somewhat similar to Andrew of MR...

  • Who is that?

  • I think he's the MelodicRockDOTcom CEO

  • Maybe I could do freelance work...

  • l think you alrealdy did. :)

  • And get paid for it... Hahah.

  • Haggardfan123

    exactly idiot... neal found him off a LIVE PERFORMANCE, and his judgement was based on what he saw him doing LIVE..and if you check out their shows on the revelation tour youll see that he sings the songs waaay better LIVE than he did recording it...man you really are like a ten year old who wants ppl's attention, I unfortunately am giving you that attention that you love..and i am not proud of that.

  • and btw, to everyone who is reading this.. Haggardfan123 sent me a message claiming that he sings better than arnel.. plz check his videos out and make you're own judgement.. lol

  • you look like a good kid,i kinda regret saying bad things about arnel and his fans.good presentation kid i'd hire you for my company..

  • 67cabman:FUCK YOU IDIOT! what he HELL company are you atalkin' about?! Hahahahahahahahaah! are you kiddin' me BITCH! COWARD mr.toilet has company of prostitute! Wahwahwahwahwah FUCK YOU BITCH! Sucks' Jimmmytt and enjoy it BASTARD! your Mom & Sister for 6bucks each prosty IDIOT! INSANE MORON ! RACIST! DUMBASS!!

  • 67cabman:FUCK YOU IDIOT! what company?! company of Welfare?foodstamp holder? line of prostitue? BITCH COWARD! mr.toilet DUMBASS! RACIST!!Wahwahwahwah!!!!

  • hey your hot!!! ever think about singing? thanks, lora

  • Funny you should mention that... I'm working on my solo album right now and the music video is going to be shot hopefully at the end of the month for the first single off it. Subscribe to my videos to find out when!

  • Hi thanks for the info. I sure will.

  • Thanks for the compliment too! The video will be interesting...

  • perrysonny, now that you mentioned it, i took a look of him instead of listening to his great review. You are absolutely right, he's kind of good looking guy! lols...to the rest of the guys, sorry to put this in...lols

  • thanks man..

  • Hi, thanks for the review. I just listened a part of it because the background is loud, but it's a nice video.

  • thanks dude.

  • awesome review thanks for appreciating arnel,he doing his best....

  • good review but you look and sounds like lipsynching on my system.

  • For whatever reason, when I uploaded the file, it was fine, but then later on the audio and video got out of sync after a couple hundred plays... Thats a Youtube issue...

  • Hey Kevin, thanks for your review on this one...the background is a bit loud, nevertheless, I've rated your video. EXCELLENT!

  • It's Ryan... My recent reviews, Ive lowered the music in the BG. Look for lots of videos this weekend. Both more Journey reviews and more live videos on my band!

  • I know Ryan, I've realized that as soon as I've added your 'CHIME video' to my faves. Honest, I don't know where Kevin came from LOL I don't even know someone with that name ...Sorry!Smile!!!

  • "What I Needed" sounded like one of Michael Jacksons songs esp. the 1st part of the 1st. verse.

  • this guy's voice is hilarious. normally, it would annoy me if a replacement singer was so exact...but, for journey, it works. (and before everybody flips out, i mean it as a compliment)

  • Good review brother. I agree with what you said but I did think that the songs where more of a time thing than a particular song. Like that song that sounds like lights I thought it could just be in the Infinity album and so on but really good review. Good job!

  • Wow! An excellent, objective review!

    Again, I must say, with all the expertise afforded this review and to come out as fair and totally unbiased as it has, is just incredible.

    A piece of advice... it would help to easily find your reviews if you tag it with the names of the bands that you are reviewing. I for one did not want to miss this and I'm sure many others feels the same way. Thanks to the forum I was frequenting that I found out about your channel.

    Great job and please keep em coming.

  • sticktodrums,

    you are musically trained to come up with a well-balanced review like that but need to tone down the song background a little bit so people can hear what you are saying other than that, you did great with it.

  • Thanks! My recent reviews either have lowered music in the BG or none at all when I am speaking. Since I had 10 minutes to review 11 songs, I wanted the listener to hear both what I was saying as well as the music... Now, my reviews focus on a handful of songs going more in depth.

  • good job...journey is back!!

  • You're absolutely right about Revelation's all new songs - That they all sound Journey! Arnel has such an unbelieavable powerful dynamic voice that suits well with Journey. I hope they release more CDs with re-records of top sellers improved with powerful instrumentals and vibrations.

  • ya, what makes Journey be Journey is their "sound" and not the singer. Sure Perry influenced their sound, but with every new member they have evolved while retaining their sound. Im making another review right now focusing on their writing and "sound".

  • Revelation CD 1 is an excellent CD. All the songs are awesome. I couldn't think of any other CD as good as this one that I have bought. Other CD's i've bought usually only have 1-2 good songs and the rest are sleepers.So far the best song in this track is "What I Needed."

  • Yes, all in all its a fantastic buy. I bought it for the new tracks and live DVD and the new tracks are almost all winners. The addition of the 2nd CD was a smart move to show that Arnel has the pipes to sing the older material as well. I still says "Learn to Lose" is the monster song.

  • clap clap clap...like your intro. nice reviews. where's the 3rd part ? :)

  • Im working on Part 3 as I type. Im going to be doing an in depth comparison before I revie wteh DVD...

    These videos take a lot of time to edit and put together so Im doing them in pieces.

  • "Faith in the heartland" at 3:02 "where eagles fly"; arnels voice just flies along with it. compare it with the older version.

  • I like both versions. I actually like Kevin Elsons production on Generations better personally just cause it sounds more like the Escape era as he produced Escape and Frontiers. Arnel does a great job on ALL the songs and Revelation has a more "modern sound".

  • true, both are good.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more