@rytallica898 Humor, another abstraction, and clearly a creative act, depends on both right and left hemispheres for certain subtypes of humor—prosodical manipulation more to the right, 3rd person dramatic irony to the right, but odd relational humor more left.
Bear in mind, none of these information types lateralize exclusively left or right. Please be careful when you posit something as general as abstract conceptualization to be a right hemisphere activity.
This is a very good, informative video explaing a little about tDCS. I would really read a lot more before any of this is attempted. You can cause the reverse effects of what you are trying to do if you are uninformed.
@QwAdr0x256 RIght brain is not a creativity center. This is just a myth perpetuated by sensationalist news and pop psychology. Truly most abilities are distributed between both left and right lobes (although sometimes they are differentially distributed, e.g, a form of processing is sometimes 60% right and 40% left).
@keithhallamg1 But I do not just want to correct you. I would prefer to set you right. The right cortex: neuropsychological lesion studies (see Elizabeth Warrington) shows *more* visual information about multiple angles of an object is lateralized right, whereas in the left, more CANNONICAL views lateralize there. And yet, in another domain, musical notation, mathematical symbols and manipulation, these abstract concepts localize more to the left.
@keithhallamg1 I can also explain hypotheses about the mechanisms of the information processing that occurs between the various cortical areas to synthesize these experiences....if you're not convinced.
@rytallica898 i think the main idea is that this technique can be used to enhance your certain capabilities in each particular case. People should really think of this. Surely activating the right lobe (and inhibiting the left one) won't develop you much but it can give you access to some extra skills in certain tasks. This should be used carefully and smart way.
@Sergiuss555 Obviously. I never denied tDCS's efficacy. My comment to keithhallmg1 was aimed squarely at incorrect notions about the brain.
As for activating right and inhibiting left—we've been doing it for years without tDCS! Sodium amaytal tests allow us to selectively turn off a single hemisphere of a human's brain, safely. Certainly, some concrete forms of processing are laterlized, e.g., language. That's not being denied.
@rytallica898 Additionally, I denied that abstract conceptualization was unilateral in the same way that vision and motor planning are not unilateral.
I can go more in-depth into this, but right now I have a deadline coming up. And someone from NIMH is calling.
@Sergiuss555 What I did deny, as well as anyone who's had an actual class in cognitive neuroscience (and was awake for it), was that any processing type uses exclusively one hemisphere. Even language isn't TRULY 100% unihemisphereic. Go read UC-san diego hospital's paper on children with perinatal right hemisphere lesions and tell me right hemisphere isn't used in language.
@rytallica898 ok, i think we have nothing to disagree about here :) as I completely agree to everything you said. I don't agree about most of processes being "completely unilateral", but I would notice that inhibiting does not mean switching off/freezing.
It is too bad that our brain is too deep and inaccessible and our influence can be too vague and rude so far.
@keithhallamg1 p.s. Response 2 and 3 are out of order for some reason. Just flip the order when you read them.
Oh lastly, the enterprise of modular localization has several flaws. Read "The New Phrenology" by Uttal. Neuroscience is busy moving to a more computational, systems, and connectome methodology to overcome this.
@QwAdr0x256 p.s. creativity is thought to be related to the breadth of connections cortical modules all over the brain (among a slew of other causes). Saying "right brain = the source of creative thinking" is extremely naïve.
the electrodes position is random or is there an specific position? and why? Also wondering about the amperage and voltage. How do they reached those values?
Thanks for the informative video. Changing brain function is always a little bit unnerving, but also very interesting and cool research!! Do you know how to become part of the trials for tDCS and math comprehension? I would most definately be a test subject for that!
TDCS uses small electrodes placed in DIRECT contact with the head and a weak current is used to inhibit or excite action potentials in the cerbral cortex, biasing towards or againsy specific neuronal set firings (activity). TMST uses a strong electromagnet positioned near to, but not touching the scalp, to actually cause specific firing patterns to occur.
Comment removed
rytallica898 2 weeks ago
@rytallica898 Humor, another abstraction, and clearly a creative act, depends on both right and left hemispheres for certain subtypes of humor—prosodical manipulation more to the right, 3rd person dramatic irony to the right, but odd relational humor more left.
Bear in mind, none of these information types lateralize exclusively left or right. Please be careful when you posit something as general as abstract conceptualization to be a right hemisphere activity.
rytallica898 2 weeks ago
This is a very good, informative video explaing a little about tDCS. I would really read a lot more before any of this is attempted. You can cause the reverse effects of what you are trying to do if you are uninformed.
intilli4 2 weeks ago
I want to stimulate the right side of my brain (creativity) can I use this device to accomplish this?
QwAdr0x256 9 months ago
@QwAdr0x256 RIght brain is not a creativity center. This is just a myth perpetuated by sensationalist news and pop psychology. Truly most abilities are distributed between both left and right lobes (although sometimes they are differentially distributed, e.g, a form of processing is sometimes 60% right and 40% left).
Signed,
Neuroscientist (grad student)
rytallica898 1 month ago
@rytallica898 No it isnt but it is associated with abstract conceptualization which is a fundamental part of creativity.
keithhallamg1 2 weeks ago
@keithhallamg1 But I do not just want to correct you. I would prefer to set you right. The right cortex: neuropsychological lesion studies (see Elizabeth Warrington) shows *more* visual information about multiple angles of an object is lateralized right, whereas in the left, more CANNONICAL views lateralize there. And yet, in another domain, musical notation, mathematical symbols and manipulation, these abstract concepts localize more to the left.
rytallica898 2 weeks ago
@keithhallamg1 I can also explain hypotheses about the mechanisms of the information processing that occurs between the various cortical areas to synthesize these experiences....if you're not convinced.
rytallica898 2 weeks ago
@rytallica898 i think the main idea is that this technique can be used to enhance your certain capabilities in each particular case. People should really think of this. Surely activating the right lobe (and inhibiting the left one) won't develop you much but it can give you access to some extra skills in certain tasks. This should be used carefully and smart way.
Sergiuss555 2 weeks ago
@Sergiuss555 Obviously. I never denied tDCS's efficacy. My comment to keithhallmg1 was aimed squarely at incorrect notions about the brain.
As for activating right and inhibiting left—we've been doing it for years without tDCS! Sodium amaytal tests allow us to selectively turn off a single hemisphere of a human's brain, safely. Certainly, some concrete forms of processing are laterlized, e.g., language. That's not being denied.
rytallica898 2 weeks ago
@rytallica898 Additionally, I denied that abstract conceptualization was unilateral in the same way that vision and motor planning are not unilateral.
I can go more in-depth into this, but right now I have a deadline coming up. And someone from NIMH is calling.
rytallica898 2 weeks ago
@Sergiuss555 What I did deny, as well as anyone who's had an actual class in cognitive neuroscience (and was awake for it), was that any processing type uses exclusively one hemisphere. Even language isn't TRULY 100% unihemisphereic. Go read UC-san diego hospital's paper on children with perinatal right hemisphere lesions and tell me right hemisphere isn't used in language.
rytallica898 2 weeks ago
@rytallica898 ok, i think we have nothing to disagree about here :) as I completely agree to everything you said. I don't agree about most of processes being "completely unilateral", but I would notice that inhibiting does not mean switching off/freezing.
It is too bad that our brain is too deep and inaccessible and our influence can be too vague and rude so far.
Sergiuss555 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
rytallica898 2 weeks ago
@rytallica898 i mean, you don't eat with your feet, and you don't dig with your teeth.
so, why using the left/right/whatever lobe/nucleus while solving a task which is better done with another lobe/part etc.?
Sergiuss555 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
rytallica898 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@keithhallamg1 p.s. Response 2 and 3 are out of order for some reason. Just flip the order when you read them.
Oh lastly, the enterprise of modular localization has several flaws. Read "The New Phrenology" by Uttal. Neuroscience is busy moving to a more computational, systems, and connectome methodology to overcome this.
rytallica898 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@QwAdr0x256 p.s. creativity is thought to be related to the breadth of connections cortical modules all over the brain (among a slew of other causes). Saying "right brain = the source of creative thinking" is extremely naïve.
rytallica898 1 month ago
the electrodes position is random or is there an specific position? and why? Also wondering about the amperage and voltage. How do they reached those values?
Wondering if I can try it by my self.
gerbosan 10 months ago
Comment removed
rytallica898 1 month ago
what's the concentration of the slat water, and what was the material of the electrodes.
MrQuetiapine 1 year ago
Thanks for the informative video. Changing brain function is always a little bit unnerving, but also very interesting and cool research!! Do you know how to become part of the trials for tDCS and math comprehension? I would most definately be a test subject for that!
bitbythehorsebug 1 year ago
It would be useful to use a proper speaker.
amnettube 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
whats the difference between TDCS and TMS"Transcranial magnetic stimulation"
cryonyits07done 1 year ago
Comment removed
pokerdice1 11 months ago
TDCS uses small electrodes placed in DIRECT contact with the head and a weak current is used to inhibit or excite action potentials in the cerbral cortex, biasing towards or againsy specific neuronal set firings (activity). TMST uses a strong electromagnet positioned near to, but not touching the scalp, to actually cause specific firing patterns to occur.
pokerdice1 11 months ago
Comment removed
cryonyits07done 1 year ago