Added: 3 years ago
From: snake1411
Views: 65,831
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (71)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I will be going to my first sugarland concert in sept, and love this song does anyone know how often they actually perform this song at their concert??? thanks

  • I LOVE SUGARLAND!!!!

  • I was there and it was GREAT! How could you knock it she ROCKS!!

  • no offense to anybody. but this is no where near as good as matts version...(the original). it is so much better.

  • Comment removed

  • I love both versions. But Sugarland is my favorite band ever so i'm a bit biased, I love it!! They're amazing singers

  • how in the world could this be better than the original when the original is going to have so much more soul and feeling behind it. you guys really need to think of what a cover song is. they here a song and like it and play it. thats it. a singer songwriter spends months maybe years writing a perfect song and then bands like this think they just bec they are successful in their genre they can just take it and make it better. you can never do better than an original period

  • @treflipper hey since its a cover of a song you like, stop dissing it. some people like the new twists their favorite bands put on a song they already like. you cant say this band doesnt do it well. of course itll be different but you dont have to diss other people you asshole.

  • hey funnybunches320 you idiot, it was in response to someone who said that the cover was better. You are a moron. What I said was clearly response to someone else. Someone said that the cover was better. And its not because when Matt wrote it. HE FELT IT. Its his song. he and only he can do it best. Thats what i was saying so stop calling me an asshole and stop telling me what to fucking think.

  • @treflipper One, they aren't even in the same genre, and two, they did it with just as much, if not MORE soul than Matt.

  • Not a bad version, better than the original if you ask me. A little twangy though. For a great "livingroom recorded" version, search under Jessy H and take a listen. With some microphone assistance, the version would be the best.

  • a little twangy? sugarland is a pure country band....it should be twangy.

  • seriously, don't do a fuckin cover song if you aren't going to live up to it.

  • You're so mean. Did it ever occur to you that there are many people that like their version. Just because you have an opinion about it does not mean that it is the absolute truth. Get over yourself.

  • those many people need to have their hearing checked

  • You are a fool!

  • seriously. this version is better than the original. so don't leave dumbass comments ;D

  • this version is ridiculously horrible

  • they sound better than the original person that sings it

  • i am so with you on that one.

  • Comment removed

  • this is the only thing country i like. i like nothing country i just think the chorus sounds cool

  • Matt's is so much better.. But of course no body has anything on him.

  • i luv u Jen!!!!

    4 all u ppl tht r wondering sugerland did this song first!!!!!

  • no they didn't

  • What relationship, if any, does Sugarland have with Matt Nathanson?

    I liked the cover, but I was a bit surprised to see a country group cover a Matt Nathanson.

  • hes been opening for them at some of their concerts but basically they just like him so they sang one of his songs lol

  • Matt Nathanson, opening for Sugarland? Wow, that's quite a mix in genres!

  • yah i know but i like it lol since i think they are both really awesome

  • i may be wrong, but i was told that sugarland did this song first..?

  • nope matt did it first..I really like this cover though

  • matt brought out the album Some Mad Hope in 2007 which has this song on it :o) :o)

  • i thought they did a very good job. I like this version. its different.

  • Obviously you've not seen them sing that song live and up close. They did an awesome job.

  • if they would have got the words right it would have been alright but "thrill of the silence"? uh... no.

  • they did pretty good but their voices (at least hers) are too country-sounding for this song. i like matt's version much better

  • they totally ruined this

  • Agreed

  • wow that was so bad!!!

  • lame. they ruined it.

  • I LOVE THIS VERSION! this should of been thier song, not matt nathanson's. Hes such a nobody in the mainstream world and Sugarland are definetly somebodys.

    WELL DONE JENNIFER!

  • to have kristian sing the chorus on his own is pretty cool

  • Absolutely to agree with you lolomgjae, nobody does it like Matt.

  • this is a good cover, but nobody does it like matt. matt`s version is simply awesome.

  • ok ill agree they did the song good......but if youve ever been to one of Matt's concerts, you'd have to agree no one can sing this the ways he does.......good cover though nice to see Matt's gettin national recignition like this.......GREAT!!

  • I actually like Sugarland's version better...It seems like it comes more from the heart and the harmony is awesome!

  • I do love both versions. As a country fan who loves sugarland its hard to pick one. But it's not fair to really compare the two with out a better quality recording but the harmony towards the end of this version is quite unique. I must see sugarland in concert one day!!

  • I love Sugarland but this song .....eh....... I like Matt Nathanson's vocals better on it......to each his/her own ...... I think (however) if someone wants to sing a song that you wrote that would be an incredible compliment to the songwriter so congrats to Matt for having his talent recognized by a larger audience.

  • It seems more poignant to have a woman sing it.

    Both versions are great though!

  • exactly, sounds a bit wimpy by a dude but simply an opinion. like when Trace Adkins covered "Break Down Here" by julia roberts

  • I'm going to go against the flow... I love Sugarland's version more than Matt Nathanson's.

    Also, love Jennifer Nettles on guitar :D

  • Matt Nathanson Rocks!!

  • Matt Nathanson Rocks!!

  • I love this song!  It really hasn't got much airplay, so I was pleasently suprised when one of my favorite country bands covered it. I had to buy their c.d. when I heard this was on there.

  • being a huge Matt fan, its a compliment to his musical talents that a bad of Sugarland caliber would do a cover of his song. Its great. I love it

  • umm...yeah, no matt nathanson that's for sure..

  • i love evry single one of sugarland's song be4cause they r the best band in the world

  • Love this!!

  • Wow I love this :)

  • I love this song

  • Yeah... this isn't bad, but Matt's is about a zillion times better. But if it gets him more coverage, I won't complain. :o)

  • I'm not a country fan, but this is pretty good. I still prefer Matt though.

  • not too bad for a country act. the yodeling during the "hold ons" are unbearable

  • im with schrabob... matty all the way :)

    but not a bad attempt... it was good until the harmonica/sing along came in... from there it went downhill...

  • down hill ain't very far with SL though... its just another version of the song... i love it :))

  • Sorry, but I'll stick with the ORIGINAL by Matt Nathanson.

  • yeah, u do that!!!

  • Best concert ever! Can't wait for their new CD : )

  • Ahhhh, I was so there like standing up against the fence like right under them :D They do this song so well :D

  • Thank you for getting a video of this! I love it.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more