*Rare* Hadith lesson by Sheikh Hussain Ahmed Madani

[oigeezer]

@AlQuranWalSunnah

What did he accomplish in the field of hadith except by oppressing them, which the Arab Ulema refuted him immediately on?

[mohammedislam12]

@AlQuranWalSunnah ur forgiven, but dnt misunderstand me i aint showing hatred towards albani, nor insinuating slander or backbiting. this is not hate spreading just an exchange of opinions. i thnk wht u shud do is do more research on all scholars, n then possibly understand why the ideologies of albani's show more of an attack upon those who follow madhabs then uniting muslims together.

[mohammedislam12]

@AlQuranWalSunnah No condemnation is taking place, if i simply dnt find a person reliable due to facts, then i dnt need to accept his works - N this sentence i hav in fact written probably applies2 albani when it came2 doing taqleed..if u really take all the facts N understand it/u take sum facts N understand it -this really Is Not The Same Thing. u cnt ignor certain muslims handlin hadith N cre8n own tafsirs without knowledge, 1 shud stand up against the injustice being done 2the pious scholars

[mohammedislam12]

@AlQuranWalSunnah Think before you speak..do not compare a great Prophet to another person. If knew the history of the Prophet, Albani is incomparable to the Prophet. Nabi Muhammad (SAW) was known as the Truthful One and the Trustworthy One among the non-believers [before Islam was established openly], it was Abu Bakr [RA] who did not hesistate in revealing 2 the ppl that if the Prophet (SAW) went on Mi'raj then he did so. This is whr sum ppl believed and others disbelieved.

[mohammedislam12]

@AlQuranWalSunnah The fuqaha R qualified doctors N the muhaddiths R the qualified pharmarcists. the pharmacist provides medicine2 patients but may nt understand y doctor has prescribed such a medicine for the patient. the qualified doctor has both medical and pharmaceutical knowledge, the Dr. doesnt need2 provide daleel 4 his reason on prescribing such medicine-bcoz he is a qualified student of medicine

[mohammedislam12]

@AlQuranWalSunnah Bukhari Vol 1 Book 3, Number 100:

I dont fink u shud put hadith up if u urslf dnt understand it.

[mohammedislam12]

@AlQuranWalSunnah Slander can only be something that is not true and damaging to that specific person's reputation. in fact i am only inciting the truth. please answer the what you will do if ur operation was to take place by an unqualified surgeon, wud u take the risk?

[mohammedislam12]

@AlQuranWalSunnah and my opinion on albani is that he is of unreliable source. firstly unknown qualifications, no teacher of hadith, re-compiled sahih al-bukhari & adab-ul mufrad with only authentic hadith - which is confusing for many lay muslims today, and have created people to go a step further in criticising specific scholars among the As Salifus Saliheen.

[mohammedislam12]

@AlQuranWalSunnah There is no backbiting being involved here, just merely our opinion on albani. we r all entitled to our own opinions. I know many shuyookh of the present but i do not seem them an equal to or above the pious scholars of the past - this is what i directing my answer to you. for our own understanding, if you urslf find a person/scholar unreliable then you wud usually go find another scholar that is of reliable source - nd i know here both we can agree that this is what we all do

[mohammedislam12]

@AlQuranWalSunnah Can you imagine one day that someone is about to undergo surgery and he/she finds out that the surgeon has not been to medical school, and in fact is 'unqualified' [has no certificates nor ne records of being taught by a professor]. Do you think the patient will risk their own life for this operation?

If Albani had a teacher or some qualification then he might be a reliable source depending on what point of avenue he is coming from.

[mohammedislam12]

@AlQuranWalSunnah Then what gives u the right to say that Albani was a respected scholar 'like all the rest in the past'. if a student of ilm has no teacher, how do you expect to find that student that may begin 2 teach and even give fatawas. Will it be a reliable source or an unreliable source?

Every new-appearing scholar has a teacher and thus becoms qualified to teach only if they have a teacher. This shows a great difference between contemporary scholars and the great scholars of the past

[mohammedislam12]

@AlQuranWalSunnah What has he accomplished in the fields of Hadith? Hasn't he accomplished by teaching others to learn arabic, then interpret their own understanding of hadith, follow 'his' authentication of hadith by disregarding the scholars of the past.

if you are stating Shaykh Ahmad Madani (R.Alaih) was on the rong path or ne other scholars who praise the works of great scholars of the past then it is u who are putting a veil on ur heart and mind.

[BaytHerz1007]

this is in urdu

[usiddiqui7]

Amazing. Of all the Elders of Deoband, I have always admired Maulana Husain Ahamad Madani the most. His sacrifices for the Deen and for the Muslims of India were utterly profound. He is the unsung hero of the Indian Independence movement.

[FarisiTheTruthSeeker]

Brothers,

I am really surprised at the pattern in which the videos are uploaded on this channel.

u wanted to upload a video of a person belonging to ur group, then before that u upload a video slandering and personally attacking another scholar.

If u want to introduce the Khalifah of Rashid Ahmed Gangohi, u can do it right away. for that u don't need to slander Al Albani.

I don't know what u are trying to achieve by all this.

May Allah protect the ummah from the bad intentions of all. Aameen

[mohammedislam12]

@FarisiTheTruthSeeker No slander, just the truth, and the truth mus b told even if it hurts. it is our duty2 REMIND and WARN u frm corruptin ur deen by merely follown the fatawas n advice of a person who has nO QUALIFICATION or PERMISSION of deriving correct understanding and laws frm hadith combined with Qur'an, He has initiated FANS that NOW criticise n ridicule the scholars of the past un/knowingly. The Common ppl [non-mujtaids] R told2 follow ONLY 'sahih' hadith - this is Albani's NEW Madhab

[hanzakhan]

shaikh ul arab wal ajam syed Hussain Ahmad madni r,a

zinda baad

[shaju0]

Subhan'Allah..