Ok, after Ive seen this whole match, wich was great btw! But I cant hold myself, I must add that having the 2x Lion chariots, was aboout 240pts to almost a 100% waste since they just swirreld around in the movement and never really got to charge.
Also, Swordmasters are great I cant argue with that, but I would rather have 1 unit of them, and bigger (about 20-21) along with shield of saphery.
Sure, no forest sure hurts an HE player in enemy shooting phase due low T and nothing to hide behind.
Oh ow! That was a turn around towards the end. I really enjoyed this batrep. Honestly thought Josh was going to win.. ah the fickle winds of fate. Y'know guys, I think when the new Warhammer comes out and you've both had time to digest it..
Another GREAT Battle Report! These are the best on the internet. Contrary to some comments, you guys are very good with the rules, especially getting the rules right without slowing the game down badly and looking everything up.
Just a few thoughts w/ the battle:
1) Drain Magic is absolutely needed... HE magic should be focused on casting it
2) Always persue
3) Assassins are crazy good (HE have no counter in this edition)
4) Consider using phoenix guard against Black Guard??? (I 6)
Don't take seaguard -_- Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard, Just take the fat units of spearman if you want the combat, archers if you want the shooting
Well, new army book ;), old faction... It's a pretty nice army book too 0 I've had a glance through. Not really liking some of the new models - a little bulky for my tastes... Powerful combinations available - but nothing Daemon level... captures the character of the army well IMHO.
@JohnChAsur I think they said at the beginning that they just chose models that they thought would be "mirror-images" of each other - I'm not sure that they each developed their own army list.
I know, but in the mirror match, the Dark Elves had the advantage, with a better flying character, fast cavalry, assassin.... Black Guard with Banner of Hag Graef.
I definitely agree. - although pursuing that broken unit would have taken care of the assassin. Not offering his mage on dragon up on a silver platter to the manticore might have spared that loss and prevented the DE magic from snowballing. Focusing the bolt throwers on suppressing enemy fire might have limited the damange to the swordmasters, Spreading those chariots out to cover both flanks might have helped against the fast cav, etc....
Also remember that Josh was limited in what he could bring because of the Mirror game that we agreed to play. We are considering a game of no-holds-barred. I don't think High Elves are a weak list by any means. They just need to be able to use their strengths better.
HE just are entry-for-entry inferior to DE. Black Guard with the ASF banner are better than everything in the HE book and cheaper to boot. HE have no good answer to Assassins and Shawn wasn't even using the Hydra OR the Invincible Dreadlord or any of the other dirty tricks DE have that HE can't do anything about.
I think Gav Thorpe made the DE book with the intention of never wanting to lose to High Elves ever again. He succeeded.
Very nice report like always! Btw regarding the Tzeentch lore, flickering fire of tzeentch is a flaming attack and it clearly says so in the Warriors of Chaos army book :)
i guess the best bet to beat these banner of hag whatever would be to charge this unit with both chariots simultanously and a unit of spearmen.
tomtom34b 5 months ago
Ok, after Ive seen this whole match, wich was great btw! But I cant hold myself, I must add that having the 2x Lion chariots, was aboout 240pts to almost a 100% waste since they just swirreld around in the movement and never really got to charge.
Also, Swordmasters are great I cant argue with that, but I would rather have 1 unit of them, and bigger (about 20-21) along with shield of saphery.
Sure, no forest sure hurts an HE player in enemy shooting phase due low T and nothing to hide behind.
Itachis4n 1 year ago
u have to buy dark riders indavidullay ggggrrrrr
TheMrLegenddave 1 year ago
@TheMrLegenddave or do what shawn has done and buy glade riders and corsairs and mix them up to make them look more DE-ish
RedDemon73 1 year ago
I absolutely love the Dark Elves
You should consider fielding a unit of 10 Cold One Knights with A master with Hydra Banner
CurseoftheGarrett 1 year ago
Oh ow! That was a turn around towards the end. I really enjoyed this batrep. Honestly thought Josh was going to win.. ah the fickle winds of fate. Y'know guys, I think when the new Warhammer comes out and you've both had time to digest it..
Time for a Grudge Rematch!
Lostsoul1889 1 year ago
GREAT BATTLE REPORT!!! THX!!!!
Anusbenini 2 years ago
snapple fact #845
a lemon contains more sugar then a strawberry.
jantinator 2 years ago
Congrats! :D
I love to see HE die. :P
Andersp90 2 years ago 3
Another GREAT Battle Report! These are the best on the internet. Contrary to some comments, you guys are very good with the rules, especially getting the rules right without slowing the game down badly and looking everything up.
Just a few thoughts w/ the battle:
1) Drain Magic is absolutely needed... HE magic should be focused on casting it
2) Always persue
3) Assassins are crazy good (HE have no counter in this edition)
4) Consider using phoenix guard against Black Guard??? (I 6)
jthuffma 2 years ago 2
Don't he learn from his mistakes? Taking seaguards? 15p/ model getting rammed by bolt throwers....
JAMEISA000 2 years ago
Don't take seaguard -_- Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard Don't take seaguard, Just take the fat units of spearman if you want the combat, archers if you want the shooting
wargamerLoki 2 years ago
did you here about the new fantisy faction beast men
brady1998 2 years ago
no offence but who hasn't
ultramarine1234 2 years ago
Well, new army book ;), old faction... It's a pretty nice army book too 0 I've had a glance through. Not really liking some of the new models - a little bulky for my tastes... Powerful combinations available - but nothing Daemon level... captures the character of the army well IMHO.
JohnChAsur 2 years ago
I love the manticore wings. And oh, I enjoyed. More fantasy reports.
granduelist 2 years ago
HE were just hindered by army selction, bottom line. Nice batrep, but very inevitable result :).
JohnChAsur 2 years ago
@JohnChAsur I think they said at the beginning that they just chose models that they thought would be "mirror-images" of each other - I'm not sure that they each developed their own army list.
mtbell68 2 years ago
I know, but in the mirror match, the Dark Elves had the advantage, with a better flying character, fast cavalry, assassin.... Black Guard with Banner of Hag Graef.
JohnChAsur 2 years ago
I definitely agree. - although pursuing that broken unit would have taken care of the assassin. Not offering his mage on dragon up on a silver platter to the manticore might have spared that loss and prevented the DE magic from snowballing. Focusing the bolt throwers on suppressing enemy fire might have limited the damange to the swordmasters, Spreading those chariots out to cover both flanks might have helped against the fast cav, etc....
mtbell68 2 years ago
Why wasn't the Manticore rider hit on 2s? He's a Large Target IIRC...
JohnChAsur 2 years ago
Over half range.
blackattack100 2 years ago
Cheers - didn't notice him measuring the first time round ;).
JohnChAsur 2 years ago
wood elves can get a noble on great eagle
atrchtnn 2 years ago
do a warmachine rep!
aam44Nose 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
nice, thanks for sharing!
JimboJitsu 2 years ago
Also remember that Josh was limited in what he could bring because of the Mirror game that we agreed to play. We are considering a game of no-holds-barred. I don't think High Elves are a weak list by any means. They just need to be able to use their strengths better.
bluetablepainting 2 years ago
@bluetablepainting I think you should play a game of a few units high elf swordmasters against some goblins or skaven. Horde vs elite
blackattack100 2 years ago
@bluetablepainting Shawn, have you considered swapping each others (same) armies and playing again?
Fireflash9999 2 years ago
I always do that!
ultramarine1234 2 years ago
HE just are entry-for-entry inferior to DE. Black Guard with the ASF banner are better than everything in the HE book and cheaper to boot. HE have no good answer to Assassins and Shawn wasn't even using the Hydra OR the Invincible Dreadlord or any of the other dirty tricks DE have that HE can't do anything about.
I think Gav Thorpe made the DE book with the intention of never wanting to lose to High Elves ever again. He succeeded.
NaelokQ 2 years ago
Very nice report like always! Btw regarding the Tzeentch lore, flickering fire of tzeentch is a flaming attack and it clearly says so in the Warriors of Chaos army book :)
Jesyce86 2 years ago
2nd victory ive ever seen him have
1cathar 2 years ago 2
This was a great battle. You guys are made of awesome!
sasjhwa 2 years ago
@chazzer1357 your an idiot, If you had listened at the start, they were playing a mirror game, therefore he could not have taken any of those things.
Aetos325 2 years ago 2
@chazzer1357 He didn't fail, he just lost, there is a big difference in playing warhammer.
lukeclews 2 years ago 6
i loved this bat rep i think it was real special keep them coming !!!!!
Number1GamerAsh 2 years ago
Orcs have flying hero choices too... The wyverns...
Maalve1 2 years ago
@ Maalve1
The wyvern is a only for lords
Dixu0000 2 years ago
can you do a chaos deamon army battle for 40k perferably khorne or nugle?
TheNitroBeast 2 years ago
Always take the "standard of balance" against DE if you are a HE player. infinite hatred is just awful.
akoni63 2 years ago
lizardmen have a terrradon... if that counts for anything
thedarklordellesar 2 years ago
Awesome grudge match, Shaun, Luv the manticore convert lol lookin sweet.
TwilightAZ 2 years ago
i wonder... does the paint chip off since its only a plastic tabel?
the dice rolling sound funny on plastc
RetributionAngel 2 years ago
that guy started like me! LOTR strategy, but then i went into fantasy then 40k
thedarklordellesar 2 years ago
Awsome game! Keep up the good work!
Safstrom1 2 years ago
yay dark elves!
Irontoad88 2 years ago
BLACK GUARD!
clubace090 2 years ago
you guys should think about getting a tripod for the camera when you do battles and stuff
xxHavoKx 2 years ago
Renn; in the errata on the GW web site says Tezch magic from the DoC book that says "fire" in the name is indeed a flaming magical attack.
gstruction 2 years ago
Good game. Dark Elf victory was deserved.
kartoffelnpommesgut 2 years ago
2 units of dark riders would cost the world man.
EddyB0yz 2 years ago
awesome and inspireing
thedarklordellesar 2 years ago
man of the match was the bolt thrower crew.
Onyxtitan123 2 years ago
Comment removed
Fireflash9999 2 years ago