The Only Mysterious Theater YouTube Poop Anyone has Ever Made

[Ghoopty]

A little too normal and long.

[FilmmakeroftheFuture]

Which Nostalgia Critic episode(s) are you referencing?

[doughnutser256]

LOL at 3:08-09 "SILENCE!"

[Humbledingify]

What is is the monster with the letter B at the end called?

[wileyk209zback]

@Humbledingify The Beautiful Day Monster (I'm not kidding!)

[Humbledingify]

@wileyk209zback No, I meant what skit is he from?

[wileyk209zback]

@Humbledingify It's from a segment where Kermit explains the sound of the letter "B." The monster was in other sketches too, but this was the only time he actually acted like a scary monster.

[mcht50202]

should do the poop treatment for case of missing cat and circle search...

[mcht50202]

hahahaha!! sooo funny!! but oh my shit! i accidentally saw the intro and now i felt like puking...

[Humbledingify]

More like Vincent Eighteen!

[Ian16545]

And thus ended Vincent Twice Vincent Twice's run on Mysterious Theater. He was replaced the next week by a new host, Diana Pigg.

BRAVO, WileyK!

[tscastro114]

Even after all these years (and even in Youtube Poop form) the Mysterious Theater intro still looks extremely creepy.

[doughnutser256]

@tscastro114 Those eyes in the dark at 0:17 are from a Golden Book Video story called What Was That! That scene was when all three of the brother bears are hearing sounds like "a bump, and a thump, and a clump." What Was That! was actually a Golden Press Book that was first released in the 1970s. The video version is more dramatic and creepier than the book version for younger kids because the book version did not have the eyes in the dark, or creepy cheesy animation.

[doughnutser256]

@doughnutser256 The Golden Book Video that is playing is actually mine.