Me: Well you see its all over a question if sound is a technical detail or merely a matter of perception. Now if your counting it as a matter of perception, then yes somebody has to be there to hear it. But if your counting sound as a manipulation of airwaves and molecules bouncing off each other then no, nobody has to be there for a sound to exist.
You: Wtf u reading that off wikipedia or something LOL?
@bloood9 just a little curious but from what your saying it seems that anyone that doesn't have a strong intrest in science and how the world works is an idiot? You don't need to know how to live to be alive.
I think Deaf culture is perfectly defensible given how limiting oralist education is. It's easy for us to learn sign language. It's near impossible for a born-deaf person to learn to lip read - some can, but mostly only deafened people lip-read or lip-speak with any facility.
I'm not Deaf, but I've learned two sign languages, and have a solid appreciation for Deaf poetry (based on hand-shape, meaning & rhythm) and Deaf culture.
Plastic surgery tends to fix your expression - you can smile, but you may lose the ability to frown, scowl, look surprised (or unsurprised...) - and basically end up like her barbies. Seemingly cheerful, but not very communicative.
Its a question of existance. It doesn't have to be if you heard it or not. If you weren't around to even see it would it happen? LIke this statement "If we were to have a nuclear holocaust and no one is there to be aware of the universe, the univese doesn't exist. Same goes with the tree, no one was there to hear or listen to it. Therefore it failed to exist to fall or make a sound.
The universe would exist regardless of us. To think that it would cease to exist without us is to grossly overestimate the importance of humans. The universe is grander than us.
That is the kind of thinking that got humans to be plagued by the delusion that god exists and that it created the universe just for us.
Ok.... There was a lady who was walking in the forest with her dog and was killed. If u r reading this, then u will find a dead bloody body hanging in ur closet. U will be haunted and killed by her. to stop it posti this to 6 other videos in 30 GOOD LUCK
dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 vids u will die withn 2 days nw uv startd readn this dnt stp this is so scary snd ths ovr 2 5 vids in 143 mins when ur done press f6 nd ur crush's name wll appear on the screen n big letters ths is so scary cuz it actully wrks ths really wrks
Being a film collector I can honestly say that this is an awarding short film. I hope you can get it on the film festival circuit. Are you currently working on a feature film?
anyone (above 21, at least) remember the movie 'Mr. Holland's Opus'? That was touching, and this short reminded me of that. Well done. Steve, if you haven't already, you'll be Hollywood in no time!!!
its really good but ill tell u what, u can be a great musician being deaf, if u at least ONCE u listened to music. But if ure born deaf, im sorry, ull never be a good musician, u may be able to feel the rythm but unluckily, thats a very little part.
Correction: Beethoven had always been deaf. He used to 'feel' the different intensities of each note to decipher sound harmonies. That was taught in school. Check your resources, sweetheart.
ShroudedFury is correct, there were Musicians out there that were deaf. Very talented Musician's at that. I watched this video, and realized after the first 60 seconds that this video was to prove a point to the audience that even though one may have lost their hearing ability, it does not mean they are useless.
Let me see now.. I believe Mozzart was deaf and he was a bloody genius! So like Spaceboy said, stop trying to be a smart ass. I play keyboard and i can play ity with my eyes closed so if i was blind i could still play. Take Stevie Wonder for example. If a person is deaf does that mean that they also lose the ability to read sheet music? I don't think so some how. Sight and sound are NOT the only form of human senses you know. Before you make stupid comments use some initiative and think!
y the heck are people rating so badly ure comment, ure actually saying something positive!!!! id date her too, shes not VERY hot, but shes still fairly good...
too good for words your amazing dont listen to those brats they re jeulous that they cant make a vid or they ll drown in terrible comments if they have something mean to say they should keep it to themselfs!!!i used to be like them hurting ppls feelings im not anymore all cuz of this vid your an inspiration plus there are WAY more amazingly good comments then bad ones so ignore them and odnt feel bad :):):)<3<3<3
take critics positively, because some people may think the video is bullshit, and still be ok. So shut up and think before u speak. The idea is very good, but if u know anything about cinema, ull realise its not as good as it looks.
oh my godness i almost cried this is very sad and happy was this real is tina really deaf plz make more videos about tina plz plz she should get a puppy or somethin like that!plz!oh and tinas really pretty im going to wear my hair like yours now more often cuz thats the exact same haircut as me this is beautiful you should write a poem and send it to me oh that would be great thanx for making this vid its so awesome <3
Hey SpaceboyProductions can you please I don't know monitor the comments, people don't need to see that bull crap. This is your video, delete wack job comments please.
You're a worthless bastard, and you deserve to be hung for saying that, or at least locked away from society. Where do these people come from? Wow the internet is great, but damn you get wack jobs on the comment boards, just imagine a young kid seeing that kind of comment Pierceher posted. It's sad enough you have to get used to it, as you grow, but gosh Pierceher get a life, you hateful bastard.
for those who have given this a "-3": it's true though, who does give a busker $10?!
although, the $10 in the short film is an exaggeration. It is there to emphasise to the audience that her music is appreciated.. through this the director can convey to the audience his view of "If a tree falls in a forest and no one's around...does it make a sound? Does it matter if you know it's fallen?"
it's basically all apart of how a movie is composed to portray certain views.
are you fkin retarded i have deaf friends that can speak fine wth you dont even know what you are talking about. Btw did you know that most of my deaf friends can lip read lol. I am not deaf. Nice vid.
Very heart warming film, gives me, a whole new perspective on death people etc. Either way instead of feeling sorry for someone, you should try to help them as much as you can, and hope they can make it in life, just as well, if not better then your self. This really makes me want to get in touch with my other senses. I often use my eyes, ears, smell, but never really thought to use the others that often. Sweet a learning experience ! Thanks for the upload!
This is a staged fantasy. The actor is not deaf, or playing guitar (no one is; it's sequenced). The clip is a success in that everyone accepts it as real. Are you more gullible than you thought? There were no subtitles until people complained. Feeling kind is cheap, being kind is harder. Perceiving reality is more than a knee-jerk response to what you THINK you saw or heard.
Wow, this has a powerful message in the story. Pretty damn good for a fellow Australian, Im australian too, and dude you should like put this into like the Film Festival or a competition cause this would like probably hit Rank 1-5.
omg its just a video you dont need to criticize everything. this may not even be a real deaf girl - its a video! i think it has a strong message and thats all that matters.
hmm, this was the message of the film, that it does make a sound, but outside of the metaphor it doesn't make a sound. You'd have to think the world revolves around you to think it does. It's like saying it makes an image if you can't see it. Read other comments. The waves we turn into sound aren't designed to function like that.
What a stupid video. Some chick trying to guilt trip people into likeing her crap. Funny how a 'deaf' girl can speak perfectly and manage audio editing.
Next time, when I girl tells me I'm not listening to them I'll tell them."You don't need to listen to hear"...:)
winfire82 1 month ago in playlist My Top Videos
Great job
dragonvader 2 months ago
this is a truly wonderful film. im inspired
derrekjt 2 months ago
This is truly beautiful I am pouring in happy tears, thanks to everyone participating in the making of this brilliant documentary! Love and light!
Ichliebemusikundybd 4 months ago
i remember watching this video back in 08.. still great
Horseluver003 5 months ago
each of us have gifts we can share. we need one another to make us complete.
hearing is a challenge yes your eyes can see. yet you are valuable in what you do. wanted send a poem too long so i can not God bless good vidio
gmcf7 6 months ago
This is adorable!
kjetulfern 8 months ago
"If a tree falls in a forest, and doesn't land on an American, then did that tree really fall?"
Janjacobsen89 10 months ago
ive watched this video like 20 times for no apparent reason.
elephantkidd 1 year ago
naja echt aber ich bin irgendwie traurig weil ich ziemlich einsam bin
fayroeske58 1 year ago
Me: Yes, it makes a sound
You: Why?
Me: Well you see its all over a question if sound is a technical detail or merely a matter of perception. Now if your counting it as a matter of perception, then yes somebody has to be there to hear it. But if your counting sound as a manipulation of airwaves and molecules bouncing off each other then no, nobody has to be there for a sound to exist.
You: Wtf u reading that off wikipedia or something LOL?
Me: No im just not an idiot
bloood9 1 year ago
@bloood9 just a little curious but from what your saying it seems that anyone that doesn't have a strong intrest in science and how the world works is an idiot? You don't need to know how to live to be alive.
MsQwert666 5 months ago
@MsQwert666 easy, it was a joke.
bloood9 5 months ago
cutest girl i've ever seen.
donreplies 1 year ago
@donreplies u need to go outside lil more then.....
iTrollThis 11 months ago
steve anthopoulos is Greek??
MrAristhegreek 1 year ago
This is very good. I enjoyed it very much :)
simpletoadstool 1 year ago
THIS IS GOOD
sylaryout 1 year ago
this i pretty cool , check out my media short film its pretty funny
craig931509 1 year ago
585 people dislike this which means 585 people are idiots!
Rkool1234568 1 year ago
Wow... this film was brilliant! I really enjoyed it, I think you did a great job!
12bEcKaBoObOo12 1 year ago
If a tree falls on a woman in the forest... what the hell was a forest doing in a kitchen?
WhaleBlueTwentyTwo 1 year ago 2
nice
snoopdogplaya36 1 year ago
are u seriously deaf
misslol241 1 year ago
i would have titled this
Listen With My Eyes
but congrats on winning all those film competitions!
Thenbz6 2 years ago
@Thenbz6 The thing is, it was named Tree in the Forest because the idea was probably captured because of the question.
xPoptartt 1 year ago
this made me cry,a lot
Erika236 2 years ago
sound only becomes sound when someone hears it, if no one is there then no one hears it. therefore its only vibrations
panteraCFH94 2 years ago
great video
jackassunit22 2 years ago
this is a great movie 5 star rating
harrydibbs 2 years ago
I think Deaf culture is perfectly defensible given how limiting oralist education is. It's easy for us to learn sign language. It's near impossible for a born-deaf person to learn to lip read - some can, but mostly only deafened people lip-read or lip-speak with any facility.
I'm not Deaf, but I've learned two sign languages, and have a solid appreciation for Deaf poetry (based on hand-shape, meaning & rhythm) and Deaf culture.
'So-called' separates you from me.
God bless you, too.
h.
cinnamonbrandylite 2 years ago
ThompsonSeedless,
Plastic surgery tends to fix your expression - you can smile, but you may lose the ability to frown, scowl, look surprised (or unsurprised...) - and basically end up like her barbies. Seemingly cheerful, but not very communicative.
cinnamonbrandylite 2 years ago
Its a question of existance. It doesn't have to be if you heard it or not. If you weren't around to even see it would it happen? LIke this statement "If we were to have a nuclear holocaust and no one is there to be aware of the universe, the univese doesn't exist. Same goes with the tree, no one was there to hear or listen to it. Therefore it failed to exist to fall or make a sound.
batnooker 2 years ago
The universe would exist regardless of us. To think that it would cease to exist without us is to grossly overestimate the importance of humans. The universe is grander than us.
That is the kind of thinking that got humans to be plagued by the delusion that god exists and that it created the universe just for us.
pokermaster54 2 years ago
that was touching....:) !
hsi77 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ok.... There was a lady who was walking in the forest with her dog and was killed. If u r reading this, then u will find a dead bloody body hanging in ur closet. U will be haunted and killed by her. to stop it posti this to 6 other videos in 30 GOOD LUCK
coolcrayon95 2 years ago
yeah me 2 love this video :)
Emomoz 2 years ago
I love this video!
supcarolin 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 vids u will die withn 2 days nw uv startd readn this dnt stp this is so scary snd ths ovr 2 5 vids in 143 mins when ur done press f6 nd ur crush's name wll appear on the screen n big letters ths is so scary cuz it actully wrks ths really wrks
pankakecrack 2 years ago
Awesome smack in the face of blind people. Tina FTW :)
Sairex666 2 years ago
She isn't meant to be talking.
She is thinking.
ShelbyAnne23 2 years ago 5
ShelbyAnne23, that is correct.
SpaceboyProductions 2 years ago 4
she's from Australia
thats why she has an accent
GhostPremier 2 years ago
omg i lvoe this vid so touching
beautyful556 2 years ago
I love your writting, every video made by spaceboy is so great. Keep doing it.
LRluisro 2 years ago
really good! :)
golala4 2 years ago
this is a great video :]
0LeThiMyHanh0 2 years ago
also, don't most people have a wierd voice impeddiment, ?
rachaelandfriends 2 years ago
well,
its the same as asking how they can speak english
rachaelandfriends 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
how the hell does a deaf person have an accent?
sox4d 2 years ago
It's movie! And she doesnt have to be born deaf..
SpitfireSweden 2 years ago
someone else is talking for here or she became death later in her life so she stills know how to talk
beautyful556 2 years ago
that was heartwarming
mssamnt 3 years ago
you have a beautiful voice.. you should sing,love ya ,john
cybermoviestar 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what a bitch
PakPhillip 3 years ago
i subscribed and ur my fav video <3
kevinmyhomes 3 years ago
i liked it.
MaStErNeZ14 3 years ago
good ,but for my taste a bit too sweet
zillyberlin 3 years ago
That was really awesome.
Subcribed.
MamaLlama876 3 years ago
The video has lot of inert mean in it.............i liked it
sammartin321 3 years ago
Your so pretty
If you can hear ur beatyness makes up for it
stupidpeoplecar3 3 years ago
hey that was really beautiful! thanks! XD
monickio 3 years ago
"if the only thing you have to point to in regards to god is a book, your a tool bag"
adamisthereinventer 3 years ago
shes hot lol
jk
moviekingg 3 years ago 2
Sorry, I am lazy, and a elitist snob,
I've tracking New York,Chicago,Sundance,Toronto
Santa Barbara and San Francisco festivals and only for features. I am sorry I missed your film until now
bryandawkins 3 years ago
Oh no, no, it was only in smaller festivals.
SpaceboyProductions 3 years ago
Being a film collector I can honestly say that this is an awarding short film. I hope you can get it on the film festival circuit. Are you currently working on a feature film?
bryandawkins 3 years ago
Thanks, it already has been through festivals, you can see a list of them on the right. And yes I am working on a feature.
SpaceboyProductions 3 years ago
dumb
yodawgwaddup66 3 years ago
anyone (above 21, at least) remember the movie 'Mr. Holland's Opus'? That was touching, and this short reminded me of that. Well done. Steve, if you haven't already, you'll be Hollywood in no time!!!
SheiRaga 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this was crap y would you throw out an mp3 player? plus a tree does make a sound. this chick just cant hear it
pattso92 3 years ago
That's exactly the conclusion she comes to during her narration while you were too distracted by the CD player.
SpaceboyProductions 3 years ago
Maybe you should get out of the street before you're hit by the truck you can't hear.
Kidding. Good video.
F33bs 3 years ago
its really good but ill tell u what, u can be a great musician being deaf, if u at least ONCE u listened to music. But if ure born deaf, im sorry, ull never be a good musician, u may be able to feel the rythm but unluckily, thats a very little part.
canomarquina 3 years ago
Correction: Beethoven had always been deaf. He used to 'feel' the different intensities of each note to decipher sound harmonies. That was taught in school. Check your resources, sweetheart.
SheiRaga 3 years ago
i am interpreting this video for my sign language class, is there anyway that i can get a copy of the script? please and thank you!
kristenicole18 3 years ago
Me and my friend love this vid, very funny and insperational, thank you :D
SadieNCosiRBitchin 3 years ago
"maybe why my barbie dolls seem so happy is because plastic surgery does that to your face." hahaha
this is such a beautiful short, i had tears in my eyes by the end of it.
i see by the credits you got many family members to help u out on this one, lol, families are great aren't they.
Lakshack 3 years ago
It was actually Beethoven that was deaf... Love this video!!
lukehoenigman 3 years ago
ShroudedFury is correct, there were Musicians out there that were deaf. Very talented Musician's at that. I watched this video, and realized after the first 60 seconds that this video was to prove a point to the audience that even though one may have lost their hearing ability, it does not mean they are useless.
Keep up the good work Spacebody Productions.
Xile005 3 years ago
Let me see now.. I believe Mozzart was deaf and he was a bloody genius! So like Spaceboy said, stop trying to be a smart ass. I play keyboard and i can play ity with my eyes closed so if i was blind i could still play. Take Stevie Wonder for example. If a person is deaf does that mean that they also lose the ability to read sheet music? I don't think so some how. Sight and sound are NOT the only form of human senses you know. Before you make stupid comments use some initiative and think!
ShroudedFury 3 years ago 2
I think you're thinking of Beethoven who became deaf but still continued to compose & perform based on his inner perceptions of music.
I'm fairly sure Mozart's hearing was relatively good until his relatively early death...
Helen
cinnamonbrandylite 2 years ago
Nice work, I appreciate it.
It makes you warm and cuddly inside, but it's utter nonsense. I doubt that someone whose deaf can play in a band. You need to hear the others.
M4darasz 3 years ago
maybe your video should have subtitles. not everyone can hear the narration.
OrichtoKato 3 years ago
1. People who can't hear well don't usually visit YouTube.
2. Just in case someone does, there already is a subtitled version, see "more info" smartass.
SpaceboyProductions 3 years ago
amazing!!
gatxx 3 years ago
alrite
ralphknightsno2 3 years ago
omg
that was amazing
im on the verge of tears
RokimiEck 3 years ago
why would you tell peaople that you are theaf when you don't need to?... why would you tell lies when you don't need to?...
superdios 3 years ago
that was really good i made me almost cry
jamiebowman71 3 years ago
Wow. Way to make a former Marine cry like a little girl.
TheRealReno 3 years ago
This was very sentimental mushy
it wasent bad but a bit cliche
but it wasent bad.
alotofcheese76 3 years ago
beautifeul film ! ^^ loved it
molanguinhu124 3 years ago
This is wonderful. Thanks for opening our eyes to your ears.
MarkDanteTroiano 3 years ago
okay this vid is sweet
onewiseperson 3 years ago
that was enjoyable
SmokingBomber465 3 years ago
that was so lame what yooh said it was awesome and im deaf
jamiebowman71 3 years ago
awsome vid kinda sad
keboy22 3 years ago
This was Excellent, please do make more
burninearth 3 years ago
thhat is blooody beutiful
itwasntmyshout 3 years ago
VEry nice
Doomedlight 3 years ago
omj that was amazing.
tiiswhoibe 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ur hot! id date you if ur deff thats nothing to feel different about ur still a person is that not what we all are
redtiga 3 years ago
I actually like your comment but a bunch of people negatived it!
that is stupid.
alotofcheese76 3 years ago
y the heck are people rating so badly ure comment, ure actually saying something positive!!!! id date her too, shes not VERY hot, but shes still fairly good...
canomarquina 3 years ago
whoever said anything about dating her?
martydosh 3 years ago
curran18: Watch the credits.
martydosh 3 years ago
Absolutely beautiful film it makes me feel uplifted!
Ichliebemusikundybd 3 years ago
LOVELY VIDEO
mouimen 3 years ago
Simplemente fabuloso. saludos desde Chile
zajakiel 3 years ago
That is an amazing work of art. Good job.
JesusDisciple777 3 years ago
Great job, love the story and all the effects and production. I enjoyed that!!!! it was moving.
Kiyaz 3 years ago
tina is very attractive
sopackid 3 years ago 2
wow that was so moving!
i found this expecting a comedy sketch that would keep me entertained
instead i found something much better
inspiring stuff!
eastywest92 3 years ago
too good for words your amazing dont listen to those brats they re jeulous that they cant make a vid or they ll drown in terrible comments if they have something mean to say they should keep it to themselfs!!!i used to be like them hurting ppls feelings im not anymore all cuz of this vid your an inspiration plus there are WAY more amazingly good comments then bad ones so ignore them and odnt feel bad :):):)<3<3<3
clubpenguinrocx123 3 years ago
take critics positively, because some people may think the video is bullshit, and still be ok. So shut up and think before u speak. The idea is very good, but if u know anything about cinema, ull realise its not as good as it looks.
canomarquina 3 years ago
oh my godness i almost cried this is very sad and happy was this real is tina really deaf plz make more videos about tina plz plz she should get a puppy or somethin like that!plz!oh and tinas really pretty im going to wear my hair like yours now more often cuz thats the exact same haircut as me this is beautiful you should write a poem and send it to me oh that would be great thanx for making this vid its so awesome <3
clubpenguinrocx123 3 years ago
Great job, really has meaning behind it
WinnieThePooh54321 3 years ago 2
this made me cry... very well done, inspiration for all ppl
Davison2005 3 years ago
Awwee beautiful story, I cried out of joy!
LOAKGGFULIEBE 3 years ago 2
Ireally enjoyed this ,it was beautiful. I'm crying happy tears.
sogirlgems 3 years ago 2
that was really cute, i loved it.
Broockle 3 years ago 2
most intellectual youtube video i've seen in a while.
thatssensational 3 years ago
Great job. Keep up the excellent work. It was very successful on every level. Adorable girls, good production values, polished and touching.
mugawit68 3 years ago
genial! conmovedor!!
cuboluminoso 3 years ago
btw, the below comment is in relation to "musikTECH (1 week ago)" comment.
Smiles143xD 3 years ago
Hey SpaceboyProductions can you please I don't know monitor the comments, people don't need to see that bull crap. This is your video, delete wack job comments please.
universallove90 3 years ago
I do monitor them and generally the very crude ones don't get seen. The stupid comments suck, but that's the price for the exposure.
SpaceboyProductions 3 years ago
Great video! : )
universallove90 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It is so cool! you could also insult her! yell things like omfg you fucking bitch I wanan cut you up! and she wouldnt notice! loll
Pierceher 3 years ago
You're a worthless bastard, and you deserve to be hung for saying that, or at least locked away from society. Where do these people come from? Wow the internet is great, but damn you get wack jobs on the comment boards, just imagine a young kid seeing that kind of comment Pierceher posted. It's sad enough you have to get used to it, as you grow, but gosh Pierceher get a life, you hateful bastard.
universallove90 3 years ago 6
In the ocean, there are times which we must live for. In the ocean, there are lands which must be found.
GilbertsonDerick 3 years ago
Gorgeous program!!
universallove90 3 years ago 2
simply awesome
lineriderskillz 3 years ago 2
who gives 10 bucks to a busker?!, most ive givvin was 2 bucks
musikTECH 3 years ago
for those who have given this a "-3": it's true though, who does give a busker $10?!
although, the $10 in the short film is an exaggeration. It is there to emphasise to the audience that her music is appreciated.. through this the director can convey to the audience his view of "If a tree falls in a forest and no one's around...does it make a sound? Does it matter if you know it's fallen?"
it's basically all apart of how a movie is composed to portray certain views.
Smiles143xD 3 years ago
Nice vid! really well put together! Thanks!
parellichick 3 years ago
what an inspirational vid
artem1002 3 years ago
i like your funny shit better, this
blows
smurphalotte 3 years ago
lol that heaps funny i know what you mean i got this video sent ot me and i was like what the hell.
crickit000 3 years ago
this is awsome!great vid!
Loonyroxmyoddsox 3 years ago
nice work
WJ2593 3 years ago
they are greek
TheHowToTrio 3 years ago
she probably has a friend speaking for her because no deaf person can speak that clearly.
and she's totally cute.
oh hey "ezscottitall", it's DEAF not DEATH.
curran18 3 years ago
are you fkin retarded i have deaf friends that can speak fine wth you dont even know what you are talking about. Btw did you know that most of my deaf friends can lip read lol. I am not deaf. Nice vid.
QQitzLlama 3 years ago
Nice video.
Fatherfilms 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
u r so cruel
teasing death people
how is this vidoe sapose to help people
ezscottitall 3 years ago
It was a interesting story, a little sad but teaches you something
Fordesman 3 years ago
yerrr.... load of crap.
L2play guitar, and ahh, yes there would be sound if a tree fell regardless if someone was there to hear it~
luc0002 3 years ago
it must be a fake vid i mean she talks pretty clear for a deaf person.
robchaosi 3 years ago
Even if fake, talking clear and being deaf isnt strange theres people that become deaf at a late part in their life.
LaddiSmiles13 3 years ago
:|
ahh.. To the people discussing the voice of this girl- obviously it was narrated..
read the credits.. geez..
colt777rulz 3 years ago 2
shes hot!
horsewithbadfeet 3 years ago 3
I have tourettes sound sets my tics off and people hear me from 3 blocks way away. I have actually used ear plugs to help me with my tics.
JonahTorn 3 years ago 2
Should start a band too!
ImmortalDestructor 3 years ago
Very heart warming film, gives me, a whole new perspective on death people etc. Either way instead of feeling sorry for someone, you should try to help them as much as you can, and hope they can make it in life, just as well, if not better then your self. This really makes me want to get in touch with my other senses. I often use my eyes, ears, smell, but never really thought to use the others that often. Sweet a learning experience ! Thanks for the upload!
Ichliebemusikundybd 3 years ago
MMmmk and for your future's sake mate it's "Deaf" ;)
Fordesman 3 years ago
good story =)
animallover5626 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
If a nun gets raped in the forest by the Pope, and there's no little choirboys around, does that mean the Pope's not a paedophile?
Stumblefuck 3 years ago
man soo touchy ,,,hmm sweet
ma123music 3 years ago
Nice story.
I just wish she could actually play guitar.
Or at least fake it a little better.
maryisblue 3 years ago
it looked alright to me
asw34wefdsf 3 years ago
hahah i know this girl, shes breana and she goes to my school :S lol
tbbozo08 3 years ago
So once we're gone...and there are only people around who never saw or heard us...did we exist?
[er, pass the Prozac, please]
DrHMFIC 3 years ago
Very moving, good on ya!
AccordionManiac 3 years ago
Loneliness is graceful, No one can see you fall.
JunAllan 3 years ago
This is a really moving story. Well done!!
MysticalGuides 3 years ago
Why don't you idiots shut up, and enjoy the program. Fucking ignorant dip shits
SEXBEACH2 3 years ago 2
is this a true story?
mileyfan605 3 years ago
This is a staged fantasy. The actor is not deaf, or playing guitar (no one is; it's sequenced). The clip is a success in that everyone accepts it as real. Are you more gullible than you thought? There were no subtitles until people complained. Feeling kind is cheap, being kind is harder. Perceiving reality is more than a knee-jerk response to what you THINK you saw or heard.
benboyang 3 years ago
Nice video.
Phrozius 3 years ago
Wow, this has a powerful message in the story. Pretty damn good for a fellow Australian, Im australian too, and dude you should like put this into like the Film Festival or a competition cause this would like probably hit Rank 1-5.
sakurashizune 3 years ago
I wonder if this video would still give the same message if you turned sound off...
vectorsss 3 years ago
omg its just a video you dont need to criticize everything. this may not even be a real deaf girl - its a video! i think it has a strong message and thats all that matters.
cinnamon5566 3 years ago 2
i cried when i watched this video its so sad
mrpoepoe2 3 years ago
Well this didn't make any sense.
If a tree falls down it sure makes a sound even if you are not there - just because the world isn't revolving around you.
Perhaps that was the message of the whole thing?!
RedDragon6988 3 years ago
hmm, this was the message of the film, that it does make a sound, but outside of the metaphor it doesn't make a sound. You'd have to think the world revolves around you to think it does. It's like saying it makes an image if you can't see it. Read other comments. The waves we turn into sound aren't designed to function like that.
SpaceboyProductions 3 years ago
You can define sound as HEARD or as CAPABLE OF BEING HEARD. That's entirely why there is no single answer.
benboyang 3 years ago
Interesting thought. I'd say an image only exists when seen, not when capable of being seen, so in this pattern sound is only sound when it's heard.
SpaceboyProductions 3 years ago
In one way it is just facinating..
jingfromjang 3 years ago
What a stupid video. Some chick trying to guilt trip people into likeing her crap. Funny how a 'deaf' girl can speak perfectly and manage audio editing.
mattopian 3 years ago