y didnt this song become popular it was the best song in the world i cryed the first time hearing it and i dont cry easily just the emotion and anger and love its SO FREAKIN BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol :) <333333333
@milton216 Yeah, I am pretty sure this is the only time she performed it. I am sorry I don't have the whole thing and the quality sucks. My battery died right at the beginning of the song and I had the wrong setting on. OF COURSE it would happen for my favorite song.
i think shes really good and when ppl go on bout her forgetting the words well id lyk them to try and be sixteen sing in front of a HUGE audience to lyk 20 different songs even more and not mess it up at least onece or twice
miley is amazing and has a wonderful voice but shes a teenager and EVERYBODY makes mistake s so just leave her alone xxx
i really dont think she was gonna cry coz she has to sing that all the time and she has to get use to is im dorry i dnt see how she was gonna cry but i loooove her she my idol
I love Christina aguilera, she is my absolute IDOL, but come on! Comparing 28 year old Christina to 16 year old Miley?! Not really fair, obviously Christina is better, she has had wayyy more experience. Miley's pretty good for her age i'd say! :)
she sounds kinda bad here, but I odnt think that this is an easy song for her to sing, it is really emotional, she sounds lkee she is holding back tears.. great sound!!
I thought it was pretty good, it was the last song of the night and she sang all the songs from the "Breakout" album and like 4 or 5 from the "Meet Miley Cyrus" album, so her voice was probably going out after that.
It's not a cell phone. It is actually a 300 dollar camera zoomed in all the way from far away. It is supposed to take amazing videos but when there are a lot of lights it gets confused and ends up being blurry...
...but the sound is amazing. It is hard to get sound that good on a digital camera.
First of all she didnt even go to foxwoods as hannah montana buddy .... and i should no that she didnt sing it bcuz im tribal plus i was there fornt row seats babii ...!!
lol im just kidding but god video .......but She didnt go as hannah jus if u messed up a lil ........ lol bye bye JPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJ
omg she's amazing!! ive been waiting for her to perform this!!!! nick should figure out what a looser he was for leaving her... but she's doin better without him!! :)
i know i wanted to go more then ANYTHING! and i went to register because my mom finally said yes and guess what!?- the registration ended the night before! i started like crying!
i miss mileys old style
AMani919 9 months ago 2
y didnt this song become popular it was the best song in the world i cryed the first time hearing it and i dont cry easily just the emotion and anger and love its SO FREAKIN BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lol :) <333333333
mrassassinscreedable 1 year ago 6
perfeeeeeeeeeita ♥
stephanieJFSS 1 year ago
where was this at?
ashleyrox57 1 year ago
does she not like this song or something?
she never sings it live except for this performance.
it's one of my favourite song from her.
theajdivas10 1 year ago
@theajdivas10 It's too personal :)
xcrazylittleme 1 year ago
Comment removed
theajdivas10 1 year ago
wish she'd sung this on the wonderworld tour, it was my favorite song from breakout (:
MCrocks2 1 year ago 4
islam is the only true religion.
Saramausi1996 1 year ago
@Saramausi1996 hahaha yeah right xD what a joke
cyrusandjonasrocks 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the memory i wwanna forgeet IS GOODBYEE, i love that music, i love miley... ♥
crazypeppersshow 1 year ago
Niley <3
stinepuzz 1 year ago
woah, how can she be so emotionless singing this one? pretty sure she didn't actually take part in its composition.
deutschesmaedchen 1 year ago
man she is really feel the pain poor miley
i love yoou miley amwaa
stedeo1 1 year ago
It kinda sounds like the CD. is she lipsyncing?
J0N4SBR0TH3RS 1 year ago
It' s her best song ♥
RainbowGirl456 1 year ago 2
This is my Fav song by breakout album!!!
jennsyagirl 2 years ago 10
ooo.. i don't like how she doesn't sing it with any emotion or heart. even this song, she sings it for show.
nikki27673 2 years ago
i dont like "till cry" parts.these parts are not the same as record
CeLLBuR 2 years ago
Do you think she cried after singing this song?
lisibrauneis 2 years ago
is this the only live performance of goodbye?
i cant find any other ):
milton216 2 years ago 26
@milton216 Yeah, I am pretty sure this is the only time she performed it. I am sorry I don't have the whole thing and the quality sucks. My battery died right at the beginning of the song and I had the wrong setting on. OF COURSE it would happen for my favorite song.
lyndsey21090 2 years ago 5
really thank you for uploading this video
(:
milton216 2 years ago
yes but she should sing that song more often
1996JONASfan 2 years ago
Amo esta cancionn!!! I love this song!!!
DannyandXiika75 2 years ago
NILEY FOREEEEEVER *-* ♥
BestDedah 2 years ago 5
I love this song!!!
Go Miley!!!
MsSelenaMileyFan 2 years ago 6
miley is fantastic!!!!
atramlie 2 years ago 6
i honestly love this song.. it is my fav song by her!!!
00jonezy 2 years ago 2
my favourite song! i love it so much! ! !
milseldem 2 years ago
i love this song!!!!
NatalyMarta 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she sounds terrible there!!!
sosoandcille 2 years ago
i really love this song .. it makes me cry sometimes, and i guess that miley cries too. i love her; go on, miley.
aida07 2 years ago 4
she must be holding back those tears during that time
niley520 2 years ago 3
anybody knows where else to find live of this song? i love this song and i cant find other videos of her singing this live :(
sharontan26 2 years ago 2
i think it's the first time she sing that song live
1996JONASfan 2 years ago 5
Rock on Miley :D !
xCHRISTYYY 2 years ago
the first time i heard this song it made me cry <3
it's such a sweet song. miley is an inspiration.
shesmichelle 2 years ago 2
i think shes really good and when ppl go on bout her forgetting the words well id lyk them to try and be sixteen sing in front of a HUGE audience to lyk 20 different songs even more and not mess it up at least onece or twice
miley is amazing and has a wonderful voice but shes a teenager and EVERYBODY makes mistake s so just leave her alone xxx
thank u
MILEY U ROCK xxx
sandee1996 2 years ago 5
do you guys think that this song reminds her by nick jonas?
nut i don`t think that she had tears in her eyes....but....
crysysy 2 years ago
huhuh shs no good live lol!
achilies12346 2 years ago
i know she isnt good.... SHE IS AMAZING!
miryface 2 years ago 4
*sorry
alvinfor3v3r 2 years ago
i really dont think she was gonna cry coz she has to sing that all the time and she has to get use to is im dorry i dnt see how she was gonna cry but i loooove her she my idol
alvinfor3v3r 2 years ago 3
Aww, poor Miley!
ashlynjuliet 2 years ago 2
You can really tell she was gonna cry ,
]:
NicoleRocksAvasSocks 2 years ago
I love Christina aguilera, she is my absolute IDOL, but come on! Comparing 28 year old Christina to 16 year old Miley?! Not really fair, obviously Christina is better, she has had wayyy more experience. Miley's pretty good for her age i'd say! :)
aly142 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
mkaayy,
well how about this, when christina aguilera was EIGHT, she sand better than that.
im not trying to hate on miley and her success
personallly i dont give a fuck about what she does. dont care at all.
i was stating my opinion.
shes not a live performer,
Miley isnt that great in my eyes, shes not really good at all. HM is just much overrated.
thats just my opinion. sorry if that offends you.
livetodancexox 2 years ago
I AGREE WITH YOUU!
THUMBS UP.
christina aguilera is a natural singerrr
i love herrrr.
shes my idol!
livetodancexox 2 years ago
thats the day after my birthday lol
JessMarie101 2 years ago 2
YOu can tell she was holding in her tears
chickengoodt 2 years ago 6
love this song!!!
000siu000 2 years ago 4
i love this song so much!!
PrincessFazdlyn92 2 years ago 4
Y0U WERE THERE?
OneLittleAsianBaby 3 years ago 2
she sounds kinda bad here, but I odnt think that this is an easy song for her to sing, it is really emotional, she sounds lkee she is holding back tears.. great sound!!
xochase 3 years ago 11
I thought it was pretty good, it was the last song of the night and she sang all the songs from the "Breakout" album and like 4 or 5 from the "Meet Miley Cyrus" album, so her voice was probably going out after that.
babydove101 3 years ago 4
this is my absolute favorite miley cyrus song!! i love it soooo much! i love miley!!
naleyOTH4ever 3 years ago 27
my tooo
marlijn91 3 years ago 2
finally no one singing in the background!
lilgyal28 3 years ago 6
this song is amazing
catchingdreamsxx 3 years ago 10
i love this song an she is amazin singing live u can tell this from this video
she is a great performer to!!!
metromiley04 3 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
i loove her songs....but i hate her....i dnt know y i hate her but i just do....whatever!!
Razanalkatkotah 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I agree!!
GracieStoner 3 years ago
I love this song! Miley's voice is awesome! But, I don't like the quality of this video... eew
dudeihatekatyperry 3 years ago 4
What do you except from what I suspect is a cell phone?
RikeyOMFG 3 years ago 2
It's not a cell phone. It is actually a 300 dollar camera zoomed in all the way from far away. It is supposed to take amazing videos but when there are a lot of lights it gets confused and ends up being blurry...
...but the sound is amazing. It is hard to get sound that good on a digital camera.
lyndsey21090 3 years ago
My apologies. :) Yes, I can understand that the lights gets it confused and blurred.
But I agree on the sound, the sound is extraordinarily good. (:
RikeyOMFG 3 years ago
Why thank you. :)
lyndsey21090 3 years ago
i love mc
dulglamurosa 3 years ago 3
her voice is amazing
ashleyjoemiley 3 years ago 2
she doesnt sound too fabulous live
but i still love this song
and shes pretty sweet as well =]
SimplyFabulus 3 years ago
Comment removed
liv289 3 years ago
The UK needs a Miley Cyrus tour <3
LittleDevil01 3 years ago 6
awesome :)
loveyubabe 3 years ago
I love this song, but I have to say that when Miley sings this live, its not as good as when she sings it on the album.
Don't get me wrong, I love Miley's songs! But I just don't think she sings good live.
popmusiclover97 3 years ago 2
duh. they fix their voices when they record.
illshutup 3 years ago
i agree but studio makes it sound better
dudeihatesneha 3 years ago
First of all she didnt even go to foxwoods as hannah montana buddy .... and i should no that she didnt sing it bcuz im tribal plus i was there fornt row seats babii ...!!
lol im just kidding but god video .......but She didnt go as hannah jus if u messed up a lil ........ lol bye bye JPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJPJ
lasiababy101 3 years ago
i love this song so much.
mad4miley78 3 years ago
she wrote this song 2 years ago and yess she was dating nick then!!!!!!!!!!!
Niley4ever212 3 years ago
Trust me, I know, I was a fan back then. I would go to concerts LOOKING for Miley.
lyndsey21090 3 years ago
wait u were a fan BACK THEN? Does that mean ur not a fan now! lol...just wondering!!!
MNKJfan 3 years ago
actually she just wrote it arond last year with Antonina Armato
hannah17cyrus 3 years ago
i was there....i snuck down to the tenth row it was awesome!
kaypar2409 3 years ago
she wrote dat song about nick a couple of years ago
WrightReyes0507 3 years ago
Well, more like she was inspired by Nick to write the song because she saw he wrote his own songs and wanted to do the same thing.
Although I think it is directed toward Nick, now. (Obviously)
lyndsey21090 3 years ago
she is amazing.
im so glad that she finally sang this live!
:D
itsmmkay 3 years ago 2
fave**
lovelifeshop 3 years ago
thi is my fae song on mileys album and miley sounds amazing!
lovelifeshop 3 years ago
MY FAVOURITE IN THE ALBUM !!! :D
oldbluujeans 3 years ago 2
omg she's amazing!! ive been waiting for her to perform this!!!! nick should figure out what a looser he was for leaving her... but she's doin better without him!! :)
live2dance5895 3 years ago 10
absolutley better Nick is so wrong for her, perfect for Slutena Hoemez, they are both big cheaters
huggercrazy 3 years ago 23
lol
EmmaAndRach94 3 years ago
omg! finaly a miley supporter and the only person (i know in youtube) who suports her for the nick thing!
oldbluujeans 3 years ago 9
I kno i love it lol
EmmaAndRach94 3 years ago
Yes.
I totally agree with you guys. :)
DesignerSkylineSarah 3 years ago
:) agreed!! lol
EmmaAndRach94 3 years ago 3
Wow she sounds incredible.
JonasIsPimp 3 years ago 4
this is so awesome! one of my fave songs off her album. i love the ending, she held out that note pretty long!!
i love her!
ticklemepink190 3 years ago 4
OMG!!! I've been waiting FOREVER for her to perform this song!!!!! And she finally did!!!!
THNX SO MUCH FOR UPLOADING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
THIS IS THE BEST PEFORMANCE EVER!!!!!!!!
MNKJfan 3 years ago 4
wow the audiance are really good to her here, lots of screaming people.
gymnastmiley95 3 years ago
how much did you pay for those tickets?!
i wanted to go sooo bad, but the tckets were so expensive!
mandwcheerleader 3 years ago
i know i wanted to go more then ANYTHING! and i went to register because my mom finally said yes and guess what!?- the registration ended the night before! i started like crying!
gymnastmiley95 3 years ago
150.
lyndsey21090 3 years ago
you paid that much?!
how old are you anyway?
mandwcheerleader 3 years ago
18.
lyndsey21090 3 years ago
love this song
mariead06 3 years ago
words can't explain how amazing she is.
love her to death
lifewithsanna 3 years ago 3
i SO agree.
hey is this sanna off of oceanup?
TeamNiley 3 years ago 2
yeaah it's me:)
lifewithsanna 3 years ago
wow she was amazing. Thanks for uploading.
aprilrainer15 3 years ago 3