Added: 5 years ago
From: uevilwoman
Views: 342,178
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (535)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • amazing. still one of my faves

  • wagner sings a cappelle, take a look

  • fuck he makes it looks so easy

  • i hate his voice

  • @143622010 No one cares.

  • @143622010 No one cares. 

  • I love Simon's smile in the beginning. It's all like "I'm so proud of this kid" :)

  • what ever happen to clay after american idol...he was the best ever....

  • @n4sir804 nothing much unfortunatley

  • he lost cuz big fat black bastard rueben studdard was more lovable that a skinny little white gay boy. He might have lost but he didn't get beat. Clay shit on rueben every time they sang

  • How did he lose? Simply not enough voters motivated to text in...but, that said, he didn't lose once the records came out. He slaughtered Ruben Studdard.

  • Nothing about him says "fun". I think an idol has to be entertaining, to say the least.

  • @isabeels2 You've obviously never seen a Clay Aiken concert then. He could be a comedian, he is HILARIOUS! and is so much fun to watch on stage.

  • @MJJMatrix I don't mean fun as in 'comedy', I mean it as in 'interesting'. I wouldn't say something like "oh, I couldn't take my eyes off of him, he's so catchy" about him, that's what I meant by the previous post. And by being fun to watch, well, I disagree. I respect your opinion, you clearly like him, but can't feel this way about his performance. :)

  • @isabeels2 Thats a good point and I completely agree. This performance was quite boring, then again.. this is one of his first ever performances on the show. But he really is very 'interesting' to watch during other performances. I'm sure that you would love some others that he has done. I highly recommend exploring some of his performances, and I hope you like them. (:

  • @isabeels2 no. an idol is suppose to have a great voice and sing like this.. im sure u like justin bieber and dont care about the voice...

  • @wenom12345 He's also supposed to be catchy and I don't feel that Clay is. And no, I don't like Justin Bieber. I like good quality pop (wich excludes rihanna and stuff like that), blues, glam rock from the 80's, classic rock from the 60/70's, jazz from the 40's and classical music. You shouldn't use an information as an argument if you don't have it, it makes you look stupid. As for the voice, I'm a singer, so that is what I pay the closest attention to and never said Clay wasn't a great one.

  • I love Clay Aiken!!!!

  • He looked over confident with himself. He was too busy acrobating his voice, and overdone the song. He has a beautiful voice, but in this song I don't feel that he put his heart in this song. He was just singing the song, it had no soul in it. His face expression didn't match the song, he was smiling almost like sneering.

  • He looks so chill when he sings.

  • pretty good.. best version i've heard on idol has to belong to Jorge Nunez tho..

  • Good singer but I prefer David Archuleta's version of the song more!

  • Thumbs up if you wish you had singing voice like Clay's.

  • He is just amazing.

  • This was the only good performance he had.

  • @bowler3008605 Seriously? I suggest you put Clay's name in the search box and prepare to eat your words.

  • Fanfreakingtastic!! I'd forgotten how good he sounded on this!!!

  • I love Clay singing this song. Wow, he looks so young here...ten years ago. He's done well for himself. Terrific singer, he's even gotten better.

  • @my1chilod - That big black dude won...I can't remember his name...he had nothing on Clay.

  • @crystalvegan his name is ruben studard or something

  • @crystalvegan reuben studdard

  • I do wish Clay would record this song, anyone know how to persuade him??

  • @medrecs Clay did record the full version on his demo cd. Posted here by kaakca. Clay performed at a benefit for Bringing Broadway Home in Raleigh last June. Those amazing performances are posted here also. Search Bringing Broadway Home for Those Magic Changes, Home, This Is The Moment, duets Last Night of the World, Leaving Is Not The Only Way To Go, In Whatever Time We Have. He also performed a few from his latest CD. Most of the benefit videos are posted by toni7babe.

  • @baker358 Wow thanks for that, so glad I managed to find it

  • because Ruben sounded better. No question about it though Clay has an excellent voice.

  • because Ruben sounded better.

  • And why is he smiling throughout the whole sad song?

  • Comment removed

  • He'd lost before this. How in the God's name could that happen?

  • Fabulous, and no one has sung it better than he can. He has been the most mistreated Idol ever, and he's clearly the best.

  • Best contestant in the history of the show

  • The judges had no idea about music...bunch of druggies

  • it's good. but i like david's version better though

  • clay was robbed because he's gay. Its quite obvious now who the  clear WINNER should have been!

  • Why didn't he record this, I love his version of this song.

  • Wow! He nailed it!

  • Yes, he should have one but he didn't. But that is ok, he has made a heck of lot more money than Ruben ever has or ever will make.

  • Holy shit his voice made me go NUTS ! love that guy

  • i think that he should have won american idol jefferycrab

  • In my opinion he has the best sounding voice in AI history

  • .......great talent

  • AMAZING 0.0 <3

  • I have to say, Clay and Ruben had the two biggest voices and two of the best voices period from idol. Clay lost not because he was gay, white or small. It was simply that Ruben seemed much more likable. Clay seemed like a kiss-ass and was too goody-goody. Ruben made me smile every time I saw him singing or otherwise. I was completely ok had either won, and think both deserved it- and they have both done well from the show. Also, saw them do a show together in Reno, it was very, very good.

  • @JByrd714 My exact thoughts... pretty much :) <3

  • people go so against gay ppl and thats why he didnt win. really sad,

  • omg that was beautiful gosh he made my day really x'd

  • definatley the best idol there ever was

  • @742512345689 YES! the sound and style of his voice is amazing 

  • The USA doesn't deserve a talent like this if they didn't let this guy win

  • Love his Voice

  • Clay did NOT lose because he was gay -- at the time, he was closeted, or at least not publicly open about his sexuality. I mean, some people "knew," but it wasn't public or confirmed by him till later. It's sad to say, but it's true, he lost because he's white.

  • Amazing song - amazing CLAY - how did he lose? It was a MAJOR f*ck up .....MAJOR! I still can't believe it today - and my daughter was in tears!

  • American Idol does not have the last word on talent. I have not watched it since Daughtry was on there, that was a good year for "Talent" which is rare. Clay would have been succesful either way. The Judges left out alot of good talent this year. So sometimes it's not Americas fault. All I know is that man can Sing! And no one can take that from him.!

  • Clay is the best singer that was ever on the American Idol, I think people let his sexuality get in the way of there judging. and that is sad to know that America thinks that way. But it was proved on live TV, because remember who was voting "America" He should of one. The top 10 music charts proved that . Clay was number one according to the sells of his CD. O" I t's ok for america to buy and listen to his music cause they think nobody knows, but they can't support him by voting. it's sad.

  • he is f**in fantastic, I forgot how good he is and was on American Idol, I am so glad he did good!

  • the best AI ever!!! he's SPIRIT....ya digg

  • Hahahahah

  • He is sooo natural at it. He's relaxed and he's actually having fun. He is the ideal American idol to date.

  • They gave the prize to both #1 and runner up that year.

  • He should be the American idol

  • He has a great voice, but his little dance moves are ridiculously hilarious!

  • how did he lose?

  • I know... how could he possibly have lost after seeing what kind of talent he is. I mean I like Ruben but seriously? He has a better voice?

  • He was the most successful of that years finals, how could you say that he lost?

  • @soccerlover1598 it was SOOO close too!!!!

  • @soccerlover1598 Wasn't a teddy bear.

  • @soccerlover1598 he lost because although america is becoming more and more open to homosexuals, they are not ready for a gay american idol lol. That's why adam lambert lost too. But since they have ellen on the show now, there will probably be a gay idol winner soon....

  • @soccerlover1598

    Maybe YOU aren't open to homosexuals......I think you're dead wrong...

    Amazing song - amazing CLAY - how did he lose? It was a MAJOR f*ck up .....MAJOR! I still can't believe it today - and my daughter was in tears!

  • @soccerlover1598 'cause he's gay.... homophobia is very popular in usa ;)

  • @soccerlover1598 Who was the winner???? ;)

  • @soccerlover1598

    He didn't! He won (in all of our hearts)!!

  • @soccerlover1598 Stupid voters!! He most definately had the best & strongest voice. Also, the best voice control. He just opens his mouth and it falls out of him effortlessly!!

  • @soccerlover1598

    True fact: He actually won, but the results were mentioned wrong and it was to late to "fix it".

  • wow. he's got a really great voice! :D

  • His spikey short hair was better than his long hair. He sounds super amazing in this though.

  • clay aiken with celin dion...nice duo

  • thats your opinion which your entitled to but i personlally think his vioice is amazing. everyone has different tastes

  • I LOVEEEEEE HIS VOICE! It's amazing!

  • I wished i was the one doing this fantastic version

  • You didn't buy any of his SONGS, because he doesn't appear pleasing to your EYES?

    Your loss.

  • @holkn don't hate because you are a effin retard without a sliver of talent in your body.

  • i dont remember AI being this old school!haha its crazyy!

  • My Favorite: Dont let the sun go down on me:

    1. Clay Aiken

    2. Jasmine Trias

    3. David Archuletta

  • This is one of my most favorite Clay songs. Love it and wish he had recorded it. Better the Blublae

  • gaa this performance reminds me of my hs love :( miss them much!

  • clay aiken

  • clay aiken

  • omg ur the new elton john ur so sexy and a great singer

  • i wish i could have this version. it's awesome! does anyone can give me a link to download it?

  • So, does this dude have a music video? I don't remember him as a top artist. Cause hes a good singer. I didn't follow it, he got second right?

  • I like Clay's version rather then EJ, He has a good voice and blends well with it all. I just love clay.

  • The BEST!! EFFORTLESS!!

  • His voice is awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @SwedishBlonde79 did he lose i thought he won who won on this episode against him

  • No need to campare with Adam.Both have their own styles but personally I prefer Clay. He sings great as a song should be sung and not screeched...Clay is still the best male vocalist on AI.

    And as for manner and humbleness,I would suggest Adam take a leave from Clay - set up his own charity and go on rounds as UNICEF ambasador to wartorn countries and disaster areas.I would really like to see Adam with his black nail varnish there!

  • effortlessly..........

  • Why? Clay is super talented! Completely different styles! What is the saying? Different strokes for different folks!!!!

  • ummmm well, clay had better be glad he didnt have adam to deal with!!!

  • yes, great voice, great talent, BUT NOT A GENTLEMAN AT ALL!!!!! don't say stupid, negative things about fellow ai contenders. take some manners on humbleness from adam.

  • Wow - awesome voice! :D

  • He has a good voice but I hate the way he over enunciates every word. And watching his face is like watching Reba. Yuck!

  • hilarious

  • wow. the way he looks and the voice are sooooooo different. if i heard this id expect to see like a burly guy

  • 00 awesome

  • What a voice!!! Better than George Michael!

  • wouldn't go that far, since GM is probably the greatest vocalist of all time, but Clay is definitely in my top 10

  • george michael? greatest vocalist of all time? no

  • who else then? give me an alternative

  • Luther Vandross, all three leads from Boyz II Men are better than George Michael. There's plenty more.

  • Isnt that just a matter of opinion? I could say Martha Stewart is better than all of those you mentioned....

  • Completely agree with you. It is a matter of opinion. The question about who is the greatest singer is a pointless one as the possibilities are endless, or near as damn it.

  • Steven Tyler > All..

    "Nuff Said.

  • Brian mcknight, Steve Perry to name a couple.

  • Did he make a record at all?

  • I have to admit... he does have a pretty good voice

  • So share me on your opinions..

    bo bice version of this song or his is better..!

  • Well, I will now check out hat Lambert guy but, seriously I want to hear more of this guy....he is incredibly good.

  • such a great voice .. 5*****

  • Still the best. Been a fan since this performance.

  • Comment removed

  • no way there is no way Adam Lambert would win against Clay i mean Adam is really really good but he has nothing on Clay :P

  • That's like comparing milk to vodka. Both are great.

  • I TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Clay has a good voice but Adam is different, he's original and unique!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He gets you talking about him. I really looked forward to seeing him every week than Clay.

  • SPECTACULAR!!!

  • I love Clay and also voted for him alot, but I still think Bo's version is better. Not that he's a better singer, but just more soulful and better preformer. He really puts feeling into it.

  • I forgot how freakin talented this guy is.

  • man what an awesome voice! =]

  • one of the best idol performances!

  • That's the cream of the crop. The best of the best. I get chills still Clay.

  • WHAT does "he being gay" got to do with anything??? Great singer.

  • nzserbian: freaking idiot...elton john, who wrote the damn song, is gay. Maybe, just maybe, being gay is just a part of what makes people who they are, and special.

  • i'm not sure elton wrote the song, he sure sang it.

  • Elton John definitely wrote the darned song. Elton John is a masterful songwriter.

  • hwoods01: are you playing out your fantasies again? pig...

  • good one!

  • Pure Talent! Incredible! When you listen to all the crappy singers thay have on TV and then listen to Clay; it's night and day difference.

  • Sing it Clay, man he nailed this song

  • This was the first performance on American Idol that gave me goosebumps all over. Still makes me smile and want to cry today!

  • first and LAST for me..

  • Agree completely.

  • this is the first performance that made me pick up the phone and vote.

  • wow!!!