whats all this Elton/ Gaga comparisson crap & bitching? Elton is his own and completely different legitimate artist and Gaga simpy hasnt put in the time to be compared, just so dumb and typically Youtube shiz. As for the song itself, it is one of the most beautiful ballads ever recorded and one of Madonna's last truly great songs. The lyrics are pure poetry and the music and arrangement totally delivers. This song saved the Erotica album for me.
people seriously stop bashing Elton John and Lady gaga both are amazing artists(Yes Lady gaga is more of an artist than Madonna) but Madonna is amazing too there is NO need to compare and talk shit all the time
@955pokerface How is gaga "more" of an artist? Her music sounds like everybody else. Is it because she wears weird clothes? Is that what you think an artist it? LOL
@MyFightingSpirit P.s. try one of those surveys yourself, and check to see how many musicians cite elton john as their primary influence...i repeat "musicians"...
@MyFightingSpirit face to face would probably mean, id have to take a flight to idiotville and put up with more of your my diva is greater than your diva moans...to that, no can do....be the genius all you want. Except, try listening to some elton john before you argue the next time.
@MyFightingSpirit elton's yesterday's news...but of course madonna is fresh and hot off 2011 hmmm...and again, arguments for musical credibility based on strong points such as "yesterday's news"...well done.
@MyFightingSpirit umm yea...madonna has sold 300 million plus...elton's at about the same or around 280 mill...again, you're an idiot to even remotely argue that elton john hasn't had an impact on pop culture or the music world. Funnily though, not a single madonna album has sold as much as goodbye yellow brick road in the U.S. (her hometown) itself...but anyways...that's not something a true music fan such as yourself would care about...
@MyFightingSpirit And why am i arguing musical credibility with a 21 year old who's subscribed to the Rihanna channel!???...jeez...gnite, crank up some rihanna and get back to your frat party ass-wipe...
@MyFightingSpirit ROFL...hahaha...elton john doesn't have a legacy? The greatest rock pianist of the 20th century doesn't have a legacy? The man who composed the song (your song) that john lennon publicly admitted to being a "near perfect song" doesn't have a legacy? Goodbye yellow brick road, Honky Chateau, Tumble weed connection, Madman across the water, Captain fantastic, Caribou, Rock of the westies...those are albums to be remembered forever, so seriously STFU, you're embarrassing yourself.
I love Elthon John, just sayin. I think he is a kick ass artist. Madonna is more of a good songwriter, singer, dancer and creative mind. Not a 100% musician, but she is still good
@MyFightingSpirit Apart from many other things, one of THE MOST commercially successful artists ever. 300 million + albums, seven consecutive # 1 albums, the biggest selling single of all time and countless other achievements could classify as "flop" only in your books...so id love to hear more from your sack of stupid.
@MyFightingSpirit ROFL...the fact that you call Elton John a "flop" shows how little credibility you have with almost anything you say. Secondly, she doesn't play the guitar "very well"...she's only recently started playing. Thirdly, she is a great artist and no one can ever deny that. Fourthly, so is Gaga in her own right. Except moron fan-boys like you could never accept that. And lastly, id burn your ass to the ground if we go head to head in a Madonna quiz., so STFU and stop whining.
Lady Gaga is another product of what the Music industry picked and decided they would make famous..nothing to do with talent..don't believe everything you hear in the 'media' or even what you see lol unless you actually are in the business and are beside these artists when t
@Magnorion here we go...another sepia toned picket fence...dude!...you like madge, its cool...what with the need to bash gaga...as a matter of fact, at the stage she is in her career she's displayed far more professionalism and talent than madonna...she writes, composes, produces and plays the piano and more on all her records...madonna wasn't doing any of that shit back in 1984!...so, chill before you run your hate gob...
@ernest671 ha ha...i love imbeciles like you, i bet my ball you couldn't state like 5 career stats of madonna or even her full name for that matter, and yet here you are running off your garbage gob like a pop historian...
ignoring that though, its interesting to see how you refer to gaga as a "mainstream" product, but of course madge in '84 dressing like a slutty bride was indie brilliance right?...
@ernest671 now, lets shut you up with a fact or two...playing a few chords is one thing, but holding your own and playing side by side with elton john is another...no one here's denying that madonna is great...but you being the cunt sac you are seem to be comparing a career that's 3 decades old to one that's 2.5 years old....
all i said was if you look at madonna of '85 vs gaga of '10 it's a map that shows gaga is actually ahead in many respects of her career - artistic and otherwise
@ernest671 and ernest, maybe you'd get yourself an education on what it means to "produce" your own records, and "play your own instruments"...then, we can have an actual argument here...else, i feel like debating astro physics with a mentally challenged kid
@dhillan85 But Madge had no musical education as gaga does...Accept the facts, mate: Gaga's a hypocrit. She 'doesn't even know who she is. What makes you think M has never written a song or played an instrument?
@Sergeparadiesvogel who said madge has never written a song or played an instrument...besides, im tired on twats like you and your my diva is greater than your diva type comparisons...so hate all you want, couldn't care less...goodnight!
I know,AT LEAST it was on the video collection.But it had to be on the cd.,'cause it's more important on cd.Not just this wasn't on Celebration:True Blue,You'll See,I'll Remember!! And hits that (to me) dont deserve to be there are Burning Up(it was not a big hit) Crazy for you(who cares 'bout it?)and Die Another Day 'cause i dont like it.
Thank God there were Erotica,Hollywood,Who's That Girl,Dress You Up and Miles Away!!!
@Charliebangel lmao i was thinking the same thing. wtf was Burning Up doing on the video collection. it wasn't a hit anywhere except for charting in Australia in the top 20 lol I don't think Madonna had much to do with what goes on the cd, I think we all know the companies dictate almost everything. that's one reason she signed with live nation instead :)
Yeah,I mean what u say. But it's not fair. Where's True Blue??!?!?! C'mon on Immaculate C. it wasnt' there,I agree she had just divorced and that song was dedicated to Sean,but now?!?! Fuck!!
@Charliebangel I think "Hollywood" should not be included in her all time best collection - lyrics are way too simple. She could really picked "Rain" instead. But she always did things like that in past - like realeased "Erotic" with better lyrics with her "Sex" book, and more simple version "Erotica" was chosen as official song. "Miles Away", "Devil Wouldn't Recognize You" and "She's not Me" would so much better in video than "4 minutes" and 'Give It to Me". But, well, she's the Diva here.
I agree,dude! "Give It 2 Me" sucks,she would have realeased "Devil..." which is such a great song in HC,with Miles Away. She ruined a bit her image with that ugly video. (Man,she's 50 and she's rubbing hers.on a wall??)
But she must see the commercial point of view now:once she were better in that! She did what she wanted to do!
@ernest671 hard candy dont sucks , i understand that cd is better than hard candy, but it is super cool to its my third favourite cd of her ., and erotica its my 5th favourite cd of her >.<
MADONNA (QUEEN OF POP)
iamjayveehernandez 2 weeks ago
I love this song. <3
DonnaVirgin 1 month ago
whats all this Elton/ Gaga comparisson crap & bitching? Elton is his own and completely different legitimate artist and Gaga simpy hasnt put in the time to be compared, just so dumb and typically Youtube shiz. As for the song itself, it is one of the most beautiful ballads ever recorded and one of Madonna's last truly great songs. The lyrics are pure poetry and the music and arrangement totally delivers. This song saved the Erotica album for me.
mattvoyager 1 month ago
check out pbp189 last night i was dreaming project
pbp189 1 month ago
QUEEN OF POP
iamjayveehernandez 2 months ago
Lady Gaga is considered an artist at all?! She nothing more than a mere mimicked gimmick!
CheeseFester23 2 months ago 2
I totally agree with ntalasb ... um ... who totally agrees with whiteglenn69 ... ah ... who seems to have the agreeance of ~90 other people ...
Well when I say it like that ... it doesn't seem that special ...
vbplayar 3 months ago 3
people seriously stop bashing Elton John and Lady gaga both are amazing artists(Yes Lady gaga is more of an artist than Madonna) but Madonna is amazing too there is NO need to compare and talk shit all the time
955pokerface 3 months ago
@955pokerface lady gaga is more of an artist? Really?
plamenlesev 2 months ago
@955pokerface How is gaga "more" of an artist? Her music sounds like everybody else. Is it because she wears weird clothes? Is that what you think an artist it? LOL
leftyla 1 month ago 2
@leftyla Gaga learned her style from Madonna ;D
lizzylovebug128 4 days ago
I have to say,this IS one of her top 5 best songs of her career for sure,so Beautifal and yet sooo underrated
955pokerface 3 months ago
@MyFightingSpirit P.s. try one of those surveys yourself, and check to see how many musicians cite elton john as their primary influence...i repeat "musicians"...
dhillan85 4 months ago
@MyFightingSpirit face to face would probably mean, id have to take a flight to idiotville and put up with more of your my diva is greater than your diva moans...to that, no can do....be the genius all you want. Except, try listening to some elton john before you argue the next time.
dhillan85 4 months ago
@MyFightingSpirit elton's yesterday's news...but of course madonna is fresh and hot off 2011 hmmm...and again, arguments for musical credibility based on strong points such as "yesterday's news"...well done.
dhillan85 4 months ago
@MyFightingSpirit umm yea...madonna has sold 300 million plus...elton's at about the same or around 280 mill...again, you're an idiot to even remotely argue that elton john hasn't had an impact on pop culture or the music world. Funnily though, not a single madonna album has sold as much as goodbye yellow brick road in the U.S. (her hometown) itself...but anyways...that's not something a true music fan such as yourself would care about...
dhillan85 4 months ago
@MyFightingSpirit And why am i arguing musical credibility with a 21 year old who's subscribed to the Rihanna channel!???...jeez...gnite, crank up some rihanna and get back to your frat party ass-wipe...
dhillan85 4 months ago
@MyFightingSpirit ROFL...hahaha...elton john doesn't have a legacy? The greatest rock pianist of the 20th century doesn't have a legacy? The man who composed the song (your song) that john lennon publicly admitted to being a "near perfect song" doesn't have a legacy? Goodbye yellow brick road, Honky Chateau, Tumble weed connection, Madman across the water, Captain fantastic, Caribou, Rock of the westies...those are albums to be remembered forever, so seriously STFU, you're embarrassing yourself.
dhillan85 4 months ago
I love Elthon John, just sayin. I think he is a kick ass artist. Madonna is more of a good songwriter, singer, dancer and creative mind. Not a 100% musician, but she is still good
hidalgo699 4 months ago
@MyFightingSpirit Apart from many other things, one of THE MOST commercially successful artists ever. 300 million + albums, seven consecutive # 1 albums, the biggest selling single of all time and countless other achievements could classify as "flop" only in your books...so id love to hear more from your sack of stupid.
dhillan85 4 months ago
@MyFightingSpirit ROFL...the fact that you call Elton John a "flop" shows how little credibility you have with almost anything you say. Secondly, she doesn't play the guitar "very well"...she's only recently started playing. Thirdly, she is a great artist and no one can ever deny that. Fourthly, so is Gaga in her own right. Except moron fan-boys like you could never accept that. And lastly, id burn your ass to the ground if we go head to head in a Madonna quiz., so STFU and stop whining.
dhillan85 4 months ago
@3xWink LOL...brilliant. Sigh...fortunately, I've seen both. Herrlich!
GodConsciousness 4 months ago
Erotica is my 7th favorite album from her.
heavensentxoxox 5 months ago
Lady Gaga is another product of what the Music industry picked and decided they would make famous..nothing to do with talent..don't believe everything you hear in the 'media' or even what you see lol unless you actually are in the business and are beside these artists when t
heir doing what they actually do!
SoulCrusader 6 months ago 2
This sounds like a porn music lol
Hottux 7 months ago
Comment removed
unr1 6 months ago
I miss this MADONNA ! :) ahhh Still istenin to this song at 2011!
iamnana94 8 months ago 3
One of the most beautiful songs I have ever heard :) Love Madonna.
fefefan4lyfe 10 months ago
This video was just added to a music playlist at JustPlay.fm
justplayfm 1 year ago
wow wow wow
ramaschkaful 1 year ago
Beautiful song ever..
Eniomachado 1 year ago
I am REALLY obsessed with this song ; p
daniel87980 1 year ago 3
this is very beautiful
abcd12345 1 year ago
@Magnorion fair enough buddy...but i just thought those some slightly unqualified remarks, thats all...
dhillan85 1 year ago
@Magnorion here we go...another sepia toned picket fence...dude!...you like madge, its cool...what with the need to bash gaga...as a matter of fact, at the stage she is in her career she's displayed far more professionalism and talent than madonna...she writes, composes, produces and plays the piano and more on all her records...madonna wasn't doing any of that shit back in 1984!...so, chill before you run your hate gob...
dhillan85 1 year ago
Comment removed
ernest671 11 months ago
@ernest671 ha ha...i love imbeciles like you, i bet my ball you couldn't state like 5 career stats of madonna or even her full name for that matter, and yet here you are running off your garbage gob like a pop historian...
ignoring that though, its interesting to see how you refer to gaga as a "mainstream" product, but of course madge in '84 dressing like a slutty bride was indie brilliance right?...
dhillan85 11 months ago
Comment removed
ernest671 10 months ago
@ernest671 now, lets shut you up with a fact or two...playing a few chords is one thing, but holding your own and playing side by side with elton john is another...no one here's denying that madonna is great...but you being the cunt sac you are seem to be comparing a career that's 3 decades old to one that's 2.5 years old....
all i said was if you look at madonna of '85 vs gaga of '10 it's a map that shows gaga is actually ahead in many respects of her career - artistic and otherwise
dhillan85 11 months ago
@ernest671 and ernest, maybe you'd get yourself an education on what it means to "produce" your own records, and "play your own instruments"...then, we can have an actual argument here...else, i feel like debating astro physics with a mentally challenged kid
dhillan85 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wow, you know the truth
ernest671 11 months ago
@dhillan85 But Madge had no musical education as gaga does...Accept the facts, mate: Gaga's a hypocrit. She 'doesn't even know who she is. What makes you think M has never written a song or played an instrument?
Sergeparadiesvogel 5 months ago 2
@Sergeparadiesvogel who said madge has never written a song or played an instrument...besides, im tired on twats like you and your my diva is greater than your diva type comparisons...so hate all you want, couldn't care less...goodnight!
dhillan85 5 months ago
so sweet...
Nirvana1923 1 year ago
good =)
GuiRocket 1 year ago
LA UNICA CANCION QUE ME GUSTA...ES MAS, SI ENCUENTRO OTRO INTERPRETE, MEJOR......
irene55712 1 year ago
En serio?? Creo q tanto la cancion como la interprete son bastante respetables
pablorubiolugo 1 year ago
My favorite Madonna song.
TheMechanic11 1 year ago
@TheMechanic11 Mine too :) 8)
g7e7e7 1 year ago
This song goes out to my soon to be husband Joshua!
jussihamby 1 year ago 2
Gorgeous song and video. Stunning, and Im only 17. Madonna has great music
pablorubiolugo 1 year ago 2
Richtiges Kuschel Lied
RAVEBURNER77 2 years ago
Comment removed
RAVEBURNER77 2 years ago
mille volte meglio rain di mika...
AmyMessi2008 2 years ago
i'd still fuck the old bastard
MrSy82 2 years ago
i totally agree with you whiteglenn69
ntalasb 2 years ago 44
Possibly the most beautiful ballad Madonna ever sung... absolutely amazing -and STILL NOT on the new greatest hits compilation... FUCK, MAN!!
whiteglenn69 2 years ago 104
It's a beautiful song. The video is amazing too.
ifuseekamy 2 years ago 4
@whiteglenn69
YOU'RE RIGHT!!! WHY IS IT NOT ON CELEBRATION????
This is the real Madonna.
Charliebangel 1 year ago 2
@Charliebangel the video was in the dvd of Celebration but not on the cd i guess...
TheIlluminatour 1 year ago
@TheIlluminatour
I know,AT LEAST it was on the video collection.But it had to be on the cd.,'cause it's more important on cd.Not just this wasn't on Celebration:True Blue,You'll See,I'll Remember!! And hits that (to me) dont deserve to be there are Burning Up(it was not a big hit) Crazy for you(who cares 'bout it?)and Die Another Day 'cause i dont like it.
Thank God there were Erotica,Hollywood,Who's That Girl,Dress You Up and Miles Away!!!
Sometimes I just don't understand Madonna!
Charliebangel 1 year ago
@Charliebangel lmao i was thinking the same thing. wtf was Burning Up doing on the video collection. it wasn't a hit anywhere except for charting in Australia in the top 20 lol I don't think Madonna had much to do with what goes on the cd, I think we all know the companies dictate almost everything. that's one reason she signed with live nation instead :)
TheIlluminatour 1 year ago 3
@TheIlluminatour
Yeah,I mean what u say. But it's not fair. Where's True Blue??!?!?! C'mon on Immaculate C. it wasnt' there,I agree she had just divorced and that song was dedicated to Sean,but now?!?! Fuck!!
Charliebangel 1 year ago
@Charliebangel wow yah maybe madonna is just the type of person who doesn't forgive and forget LOL
TheIlluminatour 1 year ago
@TheIlluminatour i think the same. She wrote it specifically for him, out of her love. Since it's over, she doesn't want to go back.....
CondeFombrilac 1 year ago
@Charliebangel I think "Hollywood" should not be included in her all time best collection - lyrics are way too simple. She could really picked "Rain" instead. But she always did things like that in past - like realeased "Erotic" with better lyrics with her "Sex" book, and more simple version "Erotica" was chosen as official song. "Miles Away", "Devil Wouldn't Recognize You" and "She's not Me" would so much better in video than "4 minutes" and 'Give It to Me". But, well, she's the Diva here.
g7e7e7 1 year ago
@g7e7e7
I agree,dude! "Give It 2 Me" sucks,she would have realeased "Devil..." which is such a great song in HC,with Miles Away. She ruined a bit her image with that ugly video. (Man,she's 50 and she's rubbing hers.on a wall??)
But she must see the commercial point of view now:once she were better in that! She did what she wanted to do!
Charliebangel 1 year ago
Hard Candy sucks. The only good things were the beats and maybe the rythm
ernest671 10 months ago
@ernest671 hard candy dont sucks , i understand that cd is better than hard candy, but it is super cool to its my third favourite cd of her ., and erotica its my 5th favourite cd of her >.<
arielixx 7 months ago
@whiteglenn69 yeah, so as the power of good-bye. amazing songs, and never in compilaions... that's sad D:
Nickevolution3000 11 months ago 2
@whiteglenn69 I personally think Take A Bow is Madonna's best ballad, but Rain is good too.
selmalover 10 months ago 6