Ron Paul is the true Conservative Fox. All you have is retards like the "No Factor" and whining Sean Hannity a moronic ex construction worker that didn't want to work anymore. Then you have the constitutional Lawyer Mark Levin that knows nothing about the Constitution because he thinks the NDAA is no problem.
PEOPLE NEED TO SWITCH PARTIES 12 WEEKS IN ADVANCE OF THE PRIMARIES IN MOST STATES.
IF YOU DO NOT SWITCH IN TIME YOU CANNOT VOTE IN PRIMARY.
IF YOU ARE NOT REGISTERED REPUBLICAN YOU CANNOT VOTE IN PRIMARY.
IF RON PAUL DOES NOT WIN PRIMARY, NO GENERAL ELECTION ! REGISTER AS A REPUBLICAN. FIND OUT WHEN YOUR STATE HAS PRIMARIES. FIND OUT WHERE & VOTE VOTE VOTE ! PLEASE !
WE NEED EVERY LAST VOTE ! Copy and paste this everywhere! Thumbs up!
Ron Paul is right, how long, how many lives lost to save face?? "Honor" is only a euphism for saving face to these these die hard war mongers. It has divided our country more than ever.
RON PAUL IS GOING TO BE PROSECUTED BY UNITED STATES OF AMERICA! ITS UNCONSTITUTIONAL TO CALL AMERICAN PEOPLE INVADERS AND INITIATORS OF WARS.
RON PAUL SAID THE USA INVADES COUNTRIES AND STARTS WARS, WHICH GIVES USA A BAD REPUTATION AROUND THE WORLD , THEREFORE IT IS CONSIDERED A CRIME . A US CITIZEN WHO
WAS BORN IN USA CANT GO AGAINST GOVERNMENT POLICIES WHICH MIGHT TREATEN THE FUTURE
Hopefully we are going to have a leader as Ron Paul in Poland soon. Great man with a realistic vision, hopefully sons of America will choose Him next time - not that red idiot Obama.
Americans are too dumb to understand how big institutions such as the defense industry, The Israel lobby, and The Federal Reserve, profit from our unconstitutional wars. We spend more money overseas (Defense), then we do on our own health care and education. But what's the point in caring? America Idol is ON!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ron Paul: Probably the only true Republican left, not these money and power hungry bigots. What a great country this could be if we had more leaders like Ron Paul in office.
any of you guys remember the "family guy" episode where lois was trying to be the mayor of cohog? remember how she was trying to bring up logical points, but no one listened, while adam west just said a bunch of illogical crap that sounded good? then lois won by saying 9/11 and stuff over and over? that's this debate. the only difference is that in this one lois (ron paul) didn't have brian explaining to her how to play the game. thus, adam west (huckabee) won because he understood the citizens
I'm glad that your awake. Inform the soldiers you served with and others you know so we can take this country back and restore liberty to America. It's been long overdue.
Fucking Fox News , Piece of Shit Neo Cons ...for you lemmings out there that don't know what a Neo Con is .. Basically you can pretty much assume any person on Fox that calls themselves a "Conservative" is a piece of shit Neo Con ... they say they are for small government yet passionately support the patriot act , war and every government expansion Bush /McCain and other "Conservatives" pushed for and got implemented . They HATE Ron paul they would rather Obama win
These men are all talk-point cheap shot phonies and the audience is pathetic. Ron Paul needs to feed people gerber. He's too advance in the truth and everyone else was brainwashed.
BTW, Huckabee is a flaming collectivist. Listen to him. I wanted to throw up.
don't me mad Because your country is run by an old lady who needs a diaper change, o wait she doesn't run the country, WAS THAT GOOD SPELLING? OR DO I NEED MORE CORRECTION, OH BLOODY HELL WHAT THE DEUCE?
WW1 was started because Germany was getting too big rich and powerful.WW2 was started because Hitler told the Zionists to take there demands and shove them. The first Iraq war was started because Kuwait was stealing Iraqi oil. None of this will ever make it to the evening news.If you want to continue to believe that wars are about good guys (USA) beating evil guys( Hitler Saddam,Ahmadinejad) than the nightly news is the place to get your news. If you want the truth, You need to look elsewhere.
Ok so Hitler and Saddam weren't evil?? Which knowledge source did u get that from I wonder.
Also Germany wasn't particularly rich or powerful - if you knew anything about the first or second world war you'd know that they both happened as a result of broken treaties based on the alliance between Britain and small European countries. Your simplification of world history shows how little you know what your talking about - go back to fucking school.
This coming from a someone who doesn't know the difference between the words your and you're. lol ! You're cute! The "official" reason for World War 1 was the assassination of the Archduke Ferdinand, you complete dullard. There is no agreed upon reason for WW2, you blabbering nincompoop!
Don't embarrass yourself any further and more importantly, don't bother me again. Your ignorance and stupidity disgusts me.
I know who the fuck Franz Ferdinand you childish cunt. The declaration of war that followed between the small European countries led Germany and Britain in because of previous treaties made - so yeah I was right. I always love it when people try and pick up "your" and "you're" arguments - it's the last resort when you know you've fucked up your argument.
If you want to be a pretentious cunt about grammer then "nincompoop" isn't a word - nice one.
It took you 3 weeks to come up with that? Oh dear...
Ron Paul wasn't allowed to be president because he didn't get enough votes in the primary (people can vote these days, i know it's crazy isn't it!), and then would have obviously lost against Obama (I know you think Paul is like a cute cuddly grandfather but be realistic in terms of how an anti-war Republican would do against an anti-war Democrat).
Give it say 3 months instead of 3 weeks then your next argument might be slightly better
Of course he didn't get enough votes in the primary. Because the polls were rigged for John McCain. They didn't want an America-firster candidate to be our President.
The last thing the Israeli Lobby wants is a President who doesn't support Israel's genocidal policies towards the Palestinians. I assume you didn't read the 9/11 commission report.
They acknowledged that our support for Israel was one of the motives for the 9/11 attackers.
Oh and you did read the 9/11 commission report? All 585 pages? Yeah? Really? You shouldn't be so condescending when you it's obvious you haven't read it yourself.
And the polls were rigged... where's the evidence for this? Or is this something else you've read in a report, maybe a 10,000 page one this time, or maybe you got into some secret CIA files that no-one else knows about, or maybe your an actual CIA agent *gasp*.
That's was also named one of the reasons we got attacked on 9/11 - because we sided with Israel. We need a more humble foreign policy, worry about our own country.
Mike Huckabee has his own show on Fox News now, they need to give Ron Paul his on show on CNN or Fox NEWS or CNBC, that would be great and i think make a real difference on peoples views of the world.
@fedayeen47 i was just thinking the same thing! funny how he is allowed to be off camera and still be heard.. like a laughing audience in a cheezy sit-com
No RP isnt a 911 truther AS a matter of fact because FOX blabs about 911 so much mentioning it on one of our NATIONS DEBATES!! YOU screw balls NOW have JAPAN looking into the matter of why they're at war.
BE MORE CAREFUL IDIOTS U HAVE all NATIONS NOW WANTING TO COME TO AMERICA & INVESTIGATE.
FOX STOP BLABBING ABOUT 911 TRUTHERS STOP BEFORE U CAUSE CRIMINAL CHARGES TO BE ON AMERICA.. U NATZI's!! IF I WAS MURDOCH I'd FIRE YOU ALL!! SHUT UP FOX!!
HAHAHAHAH ALAUGH SOME MORE NOW BITCHES... ron paul is the only one in there that can logically think on such a level... i feel bad for all the little methods they have to use to downgrade him... just looks stupid.
Please take a moment to vote for Ron Paul on AOL's most recent Presidential poll. It is broken down by state and currently has Ron Paul in 5th place with 38,000 votes. McCain is in the lead with 78,000
OK Ron paul has some good points and I'll admit that he is pretty good at debating. I don't think he should try to go so in depth about plans of bringging the troops home. He clearly has no knowledge of real Military strategy(not that Bush does or anything). Another thing is when he weas debating Huckabee, they cut out half of what Huckabee said which was a good point. He talked about taking out the CIA FBI and Homeland security. My God am i the only one who thinks he is halfway insane?
We are living under a natzi regime because of these groups...why do you support tyrrany against yourself? don't you want to be free? have some self-respect! these neocons don't sacrifice themselves--they sacrifice the people and enrich themselves in the process--such is the history of tyrants in our world...but who wants to hear a history lesson? nobody--just business as usually until they lose it all...good grief!
(Writing this as a Brit from London, England.) ROn Paul is the only worth voting for. He is clear, decisive and absolutely right. Read "The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers" Paul Kennedy. Imperial Overstretch and subsequent economic collapse is a fact of history. Fox - stop treating your audience like idiots. This canned laughter is more sinister that the methods the 3rd Reich used in the 1930s.
Ron Paul is on his own obviously..therefore we the people as a democracy for whom it works for, needs to help him and stand next to him, and not wait for these "tired" cabinet members to delegate over the future of humanity! Ron Paul is TOUGH! Dr. Paul '08!!!
I feel so sorry for Ron Paul. He is the only sane man talking on the stage trying to drive in the facts into these brainless clowns and they show no sign of improvement... (sigh) and the FOX network is really not helping eighter. Obviously Mr. Newscorp doesn't like ppl who say the right things.
I hate how those other idiot candidates are always giggling at Dr. Paul.. The Federal Reserve probably payed them to do that, just like they payed Alan Greenspan to sell out.
I don't understand how anyone can fall for Huckabee's shennanigans... The polls and the Primary votes absolutely astound me. Are Americans really that scared and uninformed??? Fascism is gonna reeeeeeally suck. I'm moving to Sweden.
FOX is trying soooo hard to attack Dr. Paul here with that stupid laugh track and everything but I think we all have to agree that Dr. Paul pretty much gave them the smack down, and that's why they are so scared to have him back.
I hate the way Gulianni smerks whenever Paul speaks as if he's infinately more intelligent. He simply isnt and having him as a president would be a catastrophe larger than GWB.
Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundral~!! Listen to Huck and McCain..."Leave Iraq with honor" BULLSHIT! Nixon parroted that exact same line in 1972 with Vietnam. That war was disaster. Therre was no honor...We just had to end the slaughter of young American lives...Let's do the same for our servicemen and women in the middle east.
PEOPLE aren't stupid...They see a concerted effort on behalf of all the other clone candidates to try to marginilize Dr.Paul...Then when the democratic candidates come on stage, they shun Dr.Paul....WHY???They are trying to stop him, because his poll numbers have continued in an uward direction,This race is till wide open and they are afraid that Ron will steal their votes! Guess what, they were never their votes to begin with...MONEY BOMB 1-21-08!!!
u r correct. No one even mentioned Dr. Paul until they saw all his support. No one attacked him until his supporters started bombing the institution with monetary support for Dr. Paul.
Ron Paul kicks ass! Huckashit is full of it! It is amazing that there are still people not aware of what is really going on in this country and believe mainstream media reports like blind cows! Let's hope Dr. Paul wins the presidency so that he can restore our Nation!
The honorable Mike Huckabee is so honorable that doing anything remotely dishonorable and comprising the honor of this honorable US is absolutely dishonorable in the eyes of the honorable Mike Huckabee.
Yeah but, really who cares? The moonbats that religiously watch the Fox "news" network are so brainwashed that they will only vote for a war-loving neocon anyway. Not to say that some would might some free will left to decipher that they are being lied to and that this Ron Paul sounds reasonable. However, it is Fox's right to air whatever lies they want. It is time for citizens to wake up and find the truth!
Ron Paul's campaign will be hosting its own forum on New Hampshire television, following Dr. Paul's exclusion from a Fox News Republican "forum" tonight.
Check out Manchester television station MCAM TV-23 from 5-6 PM ET, or the simulcast online at RonPaul2008(.)com.
Let MCAM know we're are happy Ron is being given a truly American forum... email Ray Buckley (community and political party activist) at director@mcam(.)org!
Your a dunce ahsfan07.Your like the rest of the sheeple in this country.Its idoits like you whos constitutional right Dr.Paul trys to protect.Yea,lets depend on the government to save us and deprive us of more freedoms.Then again your probably on welfare anyway.P.S. ahs sucks!
Actually I'm in college and both of my parents make over 100K a year. So you think that you're better off fighting terrorist by yourself? How are were they depriving our freedoms by not allowing guns on planes? Do you know how dangerous it would be if a bullet going off and penetrating the plane? Ron Paul is an idiot and has no chance in hell, thank God. How do you feel we would be better off without the F.B.I. and all the intelligence we get? By the way learn how to spell.
He has no chance because the neocommie media will censor all who oppose their socialist agenda.Isn't censorship a form of deprived freedom?So whats FOX excuse not to allow Mr.Paul to debate a bunch of neocon zombies?The truth is ,if someone hasn't got a chance in hell, why be afraid.If Mr.Paul loses,it's always good to know the Neocons will have plenty of fresh meat( like you)for their war machne.
right. because an emergency landing as a possible result is far worse than crashing or better yet, plunging into a highrise...right... as for fbi "intelligence"...get a history lesson quick pal, before you find yourself a prisoner in a fema camp along with your parents, brothers and sisters--all housed in different compartments... the America you've been introduced to, I'm afraid, is an alien--and it's out to destroy you--believe it or not!
he actually said to minimize their spying on americans...ur subliminally brain washed by neo cons......u should ask ur self why theyres no law ever written to pay income tax...theyres a 50 000 dollar reward if u find it....good luck
This man is crazy. Blaming 9/11 on us are you kidding me! If the terrorist thought people could bring guns on the planes they would have brought guns and possibly more people. And backing down to terrorist than allowing dictators to do what they want.
ahffan07---your living in the dark. College spits out many fools, and your parents income is irrelevant fool. I'm sure a bullet hole in a plane is preferable to a hijacked one with the intent of crashing into a building, no? Wake up, you brainwashed fool.
Fox is the lowest this Country has ever sunk as far as tactically
conspiring to rig our elections. Boycott Fox. Sell or short Newscorp shares. Bombard Fox with Email and show your opinion to these low life non-patriotic, non american evil phucks!
Fox News needs to sued for libel. They are now "reporting" that Ron Paul is a 9/11 conspiracy theorist. That Ron Paul said that 9/11 was an inside job. Not even Glenn Beck had the right to ask him stupid questions related to this. We now have a misinformation campaign by Fox. We need lawyers to look into this!!!
correct. Its just funny to me how they keep on trying to get him down by using their asshole-techniques. You know what I mean, or do you think the cuts and sounds in the video are random? PROPAGANDA
Please chill people. We can't look like a bunch of loons right now. Don't send negative emails or calls to anyone. Unconfirmed reports and personal insults against RP are meat to get us fired up. Stay focused. MSM has been replaced with "Old Media". Let RP make the calls and follow his lead!!
What's this "we" stuff? And what's this "honor" stuff? The Republicans and Bush have "honorably" gutted the country of millions of living-wage jobs. Jobs a veteran could use when he gets out of the service. They "honorably" squander taxpayer's money by the billions. They "honorably" take advantage of the American people. The government and the people are 2 separate entities. No to Huckabee!
The middle east has been at war since recorded history started.Nobody can stabilize it,especially middle easteners.We have no commission to police other countries.YOU,just don't get it,Moron.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Ron Paul just don't get it ... without a USA presence in the middle east there is no hope of any stability in that region... might sound cruel and un-liberal-like, but we've got to protect our long-term interests .. get this trojan horse Paul off the fucking stage
This is not meant to be a "bash", but if anyone who is for Paul for real (not just being funny...which I assume most are) has a degree above a Baccalaureate, please respond to this. I just want to see. Thanks.
I don't remember the part of the constitution that says people with an education are less intelligent, or have less of a right to vote, or less of a right to get involved in politics. That's blatant snobbery, anyone with a degree SHOULD be offended by your tone.
to everyone who are always anti-fox, i still find the best debates come from FOX. also they give paul more air time than CNN, i wish i was able to see this one live instead of the CNN/youtube debate sigh*
I'm an idividual but I can at least relate to why people support Ron Paul. But Huckabee?!! What are you some reactionary stooge? Huckabee is nothing special. He's a true conformist.
hey you pussified code pink libdink, the Surge is Working and your AIDS medication isn't LMFAO! thank you George Bush .. as each day goes by you anti-war/pro-islamofascist/terror-appeasing cowards look more and more rediculous
I'm no liberal. You're no traditionalist, unless you mean traditions of stupidity, gullibility, and bigotry.
And for your information dipshit, I support this war. You clearly think only under a "left vs. right" model of politics, just like the owners of this country want you to.
that fact most of these goons in washington and most of the candidates for prez (excluding Paul) WOULD have been hung from a tree, and the most likely person to do it would have been Washington himself... blindness...a true sign of the age...
Today's the day to express our thanks to Ron Paul! He has asked us for our help NOW and his campaign has said that the Dec 16 Tea Party will be too late to impact the crucial early primaries. Money is needed NOW! I just donated my $100 and I know that we can "stuff" Dr. Paul's campaign with cash today if we all give what we can! Let's show the "turkeys" who don't believe that Dr. Paul can win that we are not taking a day off! The fight for liberty continues! Donate Today & help post this!
Oh, the good old days! That was a great year of debates watching Paul manhandle these jerks!
DCUPtoejuice 2 weeks ago
RP just fucking owned those other guys.
TeamKinetricks 2 weeks ago
Ron Paul is the true Conservative Fox. All you have is retards like the "No Factor" and whining Sean Hannity a moronic ex construction worker that didn't want to work anymore. Then you have the constitutional Lawyer Mark Levin that knows nothing about the Constitution because he thinks the NDAA is no problem.
exfed9 2 weeks ago
What in the hell is that retard laughing for. It's retards like that that cause our problems!
exfed9 2 weeks ago
At 5:12 Huckabee called Iraq a mistake.
kendigjl 3 weeks ago
Fox news hates America.
kendigjl 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It's not enough to say "Vote Ron Paul"
PEOPLE NEED TO SWITCH PARTIES 12 WEEKS IN ADVANCE OF THE PRIMARIES IN MOST STATES.
IF YOU DO NOT SWITCH IN TIME YOU CANNOT VOTE IN PRIMARY.
IF YOU ARE NOT REGISTERED REPUBLICAN YOU CANNOT VOTE IN PRIMARY.
IF RON PAUL DOES NOT WIN PRIMARY, NO GENERAL ELECTION ! REGISTER AS A REPUBLICAN. FIND OUT WHEN YOUR STATE HAS PRIMARIES. FIND OUT WHERE & VOTE VOTE VOTE ! PLEASE !
WE NEED EVERY LAST VOTE ! Copy and paste this everywhere! Thumbs up!
TravisVadon 1 month ago
3:45 Ron Paul bitch slapped him!!!
MrIndestructible43 2 months ago
9:55 owned.
InYourMomsBox 4 months ago
These Fox News guys have zero personality. They all act like closet homosexual Catholics.
GameJourney 4 months ago
The crowd was a bunch of rich old people
GameJourney 4 months ago
Ron Paul just OWNED Fox and that retard Chris Wallace.... Take marching orders from Al-Quada? give me a break! Ron Paul 2012
Bestmoviealive 6 months ago
Ron Paul is right, how long, how many lives lost to save face?? "Honor" is only a euphism for saving face to these these die hard war mongers. It has divided our country more than ever.
tangledinblue2000 6 months ago
RON PAUL SUCKED DICK AT THE DEBATES...HIS WORST WAS ABOUT RELIGION AND THE AMENDMENTS! HE SUCKED. WE HAVE FREEDOM FROM RELIGION IN THIS COUNTRY.
feldman30012 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
RON PAUL IS GOING TO BE PROSECUTED BY UNITED STATES OF AMERICA! ITS UNCONSTITUTIONAL TO CALL AMERICAN PEOPLE INVADERS AND INITIATORS OF WARS.
RON PAUL SAID THE USA INVADES COUNTRIES AND STARTS WARS, WHICH GIVES USA A BAD REPUTATION AROUND THE WORLD , THEREFORE IT IS CONSIDERED A CRIME . A US CITIZEN WHO
WAS BORN IN USA CANT GO AGAINST GOVERNMENT POLICIES WHICH MIGHT TREATEN THE FUTURE
OF THE COUNTRYS SECURITY .
RON PAUL WILL BE PROSECUTED BY US GOVERNMENT!
democratsaresmart 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ron Paul 2012
The only American speaking for Americans
isolatedfire 7 months ago
DOUCHE BAG ALERT AT 00:33!
RON PAUL 2012
MontagesnMore 7 months ago 3
Hopefully we are going to have a leader as Ron Paul in Poland soon. Great man with a realistic vision, hopefully sons of America will choose Him next time - not that red idiot Obama.
Tomalo111 1 year ago
"First they ignore you, then they mock you, then they fight you, then you win"
Gandhi
TheLiberty1006 1 year ago
Americans are too dumb to understand how big institutions such as the defense industry, The Israel lobby, and The Federal Reserve, profit from our unconstitutional wars. We spend more money overseas (Defense), then we do on our own health care and education. But what's the point in caring? America Idol is ON!!!!!!!!!!!!!
kuza01 1 year ago
Ron Paul: Probably the only true Republican left, not these money and power hungry bigots. What a great country this could be if we had more leaders like Ron Paul in office.
vids721 1 year ago
paraphrasing: "Your saying we should take our marching orders from Al Queda and get off the Arabian peninsula if they say leave?"
Way to be a BLATANT partisan hack, there, Fox News shitbag.
MutantBamHammer 1 year ago
any of you guys remember the "family guy" episode where lois was trying to be the mayor of cohog? remember how she was trying to bring up logical points, but no one listened, while adam west just said a bunch of illogical crap that sounded good? then lois won by saying 9/11 and stuff over and over? that's this debate. the only difference is that in this one lois (ron paul) didn't have brian explaining to her how to play the game. thus, adam west (huckabee) won because he understood the citizens
DavidsVirtualSelf 2 years ago
were morons.
DavidsVirtualSelf 2 years ago
good for the folks who courageously cheered for ron paul not knowing how the foaming at the mouth neocons sitting next to them would react.
wunderbeast 2 years ago 2
fuck you huckabee. i WAS in iraq. there is no honor in "staying the course" in this war! you do not honor me!
DavidsVirtualSelf 2 years ago 31
Glad you're back here. I always say I support the troops but I don't support the politicians for fighting a pointless war.
funnyclaw 2 years ago
Comment removed
DavidsVirtualSelf 2 years ago
agreed! and thanks!
DavidsVirtualSelf 2 years ago
@DavidsVirtualSelf
I'm glad that your awake. Inform the soldiers you served with and others you know so we can take this country back and restore liberty to America. It's been long overdue.
shiffty1032231 1 year ago
@shiffty1032231 I don't think it works that way, but thanks.
DavidsVirtualSelf 1 year ago
Fucking Fox News , Piece of Shit Neo Cons ...for you lemmings out there that don't know what a Neo Con is .. Basically you can pretty much assume any person on Fox that calls themselves a "Conservative" is a piece of shit Neo Con ... they say they are for small government yet passionately support the patriot act , war and every government expansion Bush /McCain and other "Conservatives" pushed for and got implemented . They HATE Ron paul they would rather Obama win
Wonglow 3 weeks ago
i love ron paul's foregn policy.
DavidsVirtualSelf 2 years ago 2
who's the douche bag in the background with the redneck cackle? btw, ron paul is the only republican i can respect.
captaincody665 2 years ago
These men are all talk-point cheap shot phonies and the audience is pathetic. Ron Paul needs to feed people gerber. He's too advance in the truth and everyone else was brainwashed.
BTW, Huckabee is a flaming collectivist. Listen to him. I wanted to throw up.
MrDeppness 2 years ago 2
You know Ron Paul won that state, New Hampshire.
NYJared04 2 years ago 2
Ron Paul i love u
ur a real man
go ahead
styleicon69 2 years ago
whats doe war mean? to Plant democracy? save a country? over trow comunist countrys? fuck no war= money spend, we spend it, they get it
simple as 1 2 3
PoetaVSR 2 years ago
learn to fucking type properly
getupjumpy 2 years ago
don't me mad Because your country is run by an old lady who needs a diaper change, o wait she doesn't run the country, WAS THAT GOOD SPELLING? OR DO I NEED MORE CORRECTION, OH BLOODY HELL WHAT THE DEUCE?
PoetaVSR 2 years ago
"Don't me bad"
still haven't learnt
getupjumpy 2 years ago
Obama doesn't deserve the white house like this man does. The American people certainly got screwed once again.
GaryVonGary 2 years ago
Yer right. Obama had been bought out and sold to the elites.
Put aside Ron Paul for now and get the message out that we need to inform the public as quickly as possible.
NYJared04 2 years ago
at 2.15 basacally what ron paul is saying is "hey fuck off guy im pulling out and thats it " i fucking love this guy
PoetaVSR 2 years ago
WW1 was started because Germany was getting too big rich and powerful.WW2 was started because Hitler told the Zionists to take there demands and shove them. The first Iraq war was started because Kuwait was stealing Iraqi oil. None of this will ever make it to the evening news.If you want to continue to believe that wars are about good guys (USA) beating evil guys( Hitler Saddam,Ahmadinejad) than the nightly news is the place to get your news. If you want the truth, You need to look elsewhere.
Watthiman 3 years ago
Ok so Hitler and Saddam weren't evil?? Which knowledge source did u get that from I wonder.
Also Germany wasn't particularly rich or powerful - if you knew anything about the first or second world war you'd know that they both happened as a result of broken treaties based on the alliance between Britain and small European countries. Your simplification of world history shows how little you know what your talking about - go back to fucking school.
getupjumpy 2 years ago
This coming from a someone who doesn't know the difference between the words your and you're. lol ! You're cute! The "official" reason for World War 1 was the assassination of the Archduke Ferdinand, you complete dullard. There is no agreed upon reason for WW2, you blabbering nincompoop!
Don't embarrass yourself any further and more importantly, don't bother me again. Your ignorance and stupidity disgusts me.
Watthiman 2 years ago
I know who the fuck Franz Ferdinand you childish cunt. The declaration of war that followed between the small European countries led Germany and Britain in because of previous treaties made - so yeah I was right. I always love it when people try and pick up "your" and "you're" arguments - it's the last resort when you know you've fucked up your argument.
If you want to be a pretentious cunt about grammer then "nincompoop" isn't a word - nice one.
Again I say - go back to fucking school.
getupjumpy 2 years ago
Ahh, hate to tell ya this but nincompoop is an honest to goodness, actual real word. "like it's even in the dictionary dewd"
Oh and it's grammar, with an A, not grammer...LOL!!!! Sorry you make it so easy.
onetondrumbum 2 years ago
not as easy as your filthy mother
getupjumpy 2 years ago
To getupjumpy, start boycotting corporations because they're part of the Israel apartheid..
NYJared04 2 years ago
get a life, loser
getupjumpy 2 years ago
Well we're giving the Israelis 15 million to support their oppressive policies towards the Palestinians.
NYJared04 2 years ago
That's why Ron Paul wasn't allowed to be President. Because he doesn't support Israel you numnut.
Our government is working with Israel to put these Arabs in their place.
Think man, think!
NYJared04 2 years ago
It took you 3 weeks to come up with that? Oh dear...
Ron Paul wasn't allowed to be president because he didn't get enough votes in the primary (people can vote these days, i know it's crazy isn't it!), and then would have obviously lost against Obama (I know you think Paul is like a cute cuddly grandfather but be realistic in terms of how an anti-war Republican would do against an anti-war Democrat).
Give it say 3 months instead of 3 weeks then your next argument might be slightly better
getupjumpy 2 years ago
Of course he didn't get enough votes in the primary. Because the polls were rigged for John McCain. They didn't want an America-firster candidate to be our President.
The last thing the Israeli Lobby wants is a President who doesn't support Israel's genocidal policies towards the Palestinians. I assume you didn't read the 9/11 commission report.
They acknowledged that our support for Israel was one of the motives for the 9/11 attackers.
NYJared04 2 years ago
Oh and you did read the 9/11 commission report? All 585 pages? Yeah? Really? You shouldn't be so condescending when you it's obvious you haven't read it yourself.
And the polls were rigged... where's the evidence for this? Or is this something else you've read in a report, maybe a 10,000 page one this time, or maybe you got into some secret CIA files that no-one else knows about, or maybe your an actual CIA agent *gasp*.
Charlatan.
getupjumpy 2 years ago
Read the 2nd chapter of the foundation fo the new terrorism.
NYJared04 2 years ago
How were the polls rigged for McCain?
GaryVonGary 2 years ago
That's was also named one of the reasons we got attacked on 9/11 - because we sided with Israel. We need a more humble foreign policy, worry about our own country.
MrDeppness 2 years ago
Jesus Christ, get a fucking life seriously. Paul will probably be dead before the next election.
getupjumpy 2 years ago
Going into Afghanistan is a bad idea? Paul says so at 3 minutes in this video. Good job guy.
arnabdas56 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
MSG ME ON MSN MESSENGR !!! ID IS jane24belle. im bored and need someone 2 talk 2
bertrand98 3 years ago
smack my ass plz!!!
amirbajrami 3 years ago
Mike Huckabee has his own show on Fox News now, they need to give Ron Paul his on show on CNN or Fox NEWS or CNBC, that would be great and i think make a real difference on peoples views of the world.
Epimpin101 3 years ago
That won't happen to give Ron Paul his own show.
Ron Paul's way too honest. Some don't like someone who's too honest. What are they afraid of?
PVJared 2 years ago
hahahahaha
"insert ludicrous, long-winded, doomsday scenario trying to justify an attack on iran"
:D
mangofrukten 3 years ago
yep hilarious lo
tiove 3 years ago
watch?v=c-OpIXfXKO8 - Fox news busted
watch?v=M4eAN_qGW3U - Fox news busted 2
watch?v=oGqPxn7njqM - Fox news busted 3
Twopecshaker 3 years ago
who the hell is laughing in the background? That is bullshit
fedayeen47 4 years ago 24
One of the Fox News reporters is laughing into the microphone.
Acrinimiril 3 years ago
@fedayeen47 I think it's Rudy.
Willredd94 1 year ago
@fedayeen47 cross dressin giuliani
David12King 10 months ago
@fedayeen47 All that laughing would be none other than Rudy .... yeah look how far that got him :)
baparson 8 months ago
@fedayeen47 Sounds like McCain or Romney! Whoever it is, they proved they are retarded!
Bestmoviealive 6 months ago
@fedayeen47 i was just thinking the same thing! funny how he is allowed to be off camera and still be heard.. like a laughing audience in a cheezy sit-com
coleS17 4 months ago
fuck mccain!
hotpinkmartinii 4 years ago 6
that's mccain laughing... he's such a fuckhead
JakesOnline 4 years ago 4
It's the Fox News reporters laughing into the microphone.
The Fox reporters asking the questions are tyring to make fun of Ron Paul.
Acrinimiril 3 years ago
Ron was on point and shining in this debate and made his neocon inquisitors look stupid.
Money Bomb for Ron on Jan. 21!
Down with Globalism!
Long live the REpublic!
Go ron go!!!
poopster111 4 years ago
No RP isnt a 911 truther AS a matter of fact because FOX blabs about 911 so much mentioning it on one of our NATIONS DEBATES!! YOU screw balls NOW have JAPAN looking into the matter of why they're at war.
BE MORE CAREFUL IDIOTS U HAVE all NATIONS NOW WANTING TO COME TO AMERICA & INVESTIGATE.
FOX STOP BLABBING ABOUT 911 TRUTHERS STOP BEFORE U CAUSE CRIMINAL CHARGES TO BE ON AMERICA.. U NATZI's!! IF I WAS MURDOCH I'd FIRE YOU ALL!! SHUT UP FOX!!
chere7up 4 years ago
HAHAHAHAH ALAUGH SOME MORE NOW BITCHES... ron paul is the only one in there that can logically think on such a level... i feel bad for all the little methods they have to use to downgrade him... just looks stupid.
geetsenwatzen 4 years ago 3
atlhoe123 you are a true IDIOT@! Quit Y don't you just go to jail and die! Quit living free!
Sociallive 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please take a moment to vote for Ron Paul on AOL's most recent Presidential poll. It is broken down by state and currently has Ron Paul in 5th place with 38,000 votes. McCain is in the lead with 78,000
news.aol(Dot)com/elect...
principlesfirst 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think he should just quit. he has no chance at all.just stop embarrassing yourself.
atlhoe123 4 years ago
No you don't think, that's the problem.
Nocturnous 4 years ago
OK Ron paul has some good points and I'll admit that he is pretty good at debating. I don't think he should try to go so in depth about plans of bringging the troops home. He clearly has no knowledge of real Military strategy(not that Bush does or anything). Another thing is when he weas debating Huckabee, they cut out half of what Huckabee said which was a good point. He talked about taking out the CIA FBI and Homeland security. My God am i the only one who thinks he is halfway insane?
Biznatch157 4 years ago
We are living under a natzi regime because of these groups...why do you support tyrrany against yourself? don't you want to be free? have some self-respect! these neocons don't sacrifice themselves--they sacrifice the people and enrich themselves in the process--such is the history of tyrants in our world...but who wants to hear a history lesson? nobody--just business as usually until they lose it all...good grief!
bloodycortez 4 years ago
Ron Paul is eloquent! To have him remained calm under fire, and put his points across in such a way was fantastic to me! Bravo!
Our prayers our with him. go to ronpaul2008 to donate learn more about his campaign.
principlesfirst 4 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
To support Ron Paul go to ronpaul2008 .
principlesfirst 4 years ago
Those laughs are disturbing and completely discredit any credibilitly.
Also, when the deabate leaders asked follow up questions, it almost seemed like they were argueing with Paul, am I right?
larma7 4 years ago
(Writing this as a Brit from London, England.) ROn Paul is the only worth voting for. He is clear, decisive and absolutely right. Read "The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers" Paul Kennedy. Imperial Overstretch and subsequent economic collapse is a fact of history. Fox - stop treating your audience like idiots. This canned laughter is more sinister that the methods the 3rd Reich used in the 1930s.
cedriccuthbert 4 years ago
The same people running the meida and the U.S. are the same Neo-Cons (Nazi) from the 3rd Reich
tenhustles 4 years ago 3
Ron Paul is verrry persuasive. He certainly stands out from the rest of the androids up there.
laughinb0y 4 years ago
truth has a way of convincing you, don't it?
bloodycortez 4 years ago
Listen to these assholes laugh trying to divert the message and focus only when Dr. Paul speaks! Fearing demons..
lilsompin 4 years ago
Ron Paul is on his own obviously..therefore we the people as a democracy for whom it works for, needs to help him and stand next to him, and not wait for these "tired" cabinet members to delegate over the future of humanity! Ron Paul is TOUGH! Dr. Paul '08!!!
lilsompin 4 years ago 2
interesting to hear the crowd response
imagine him debate hillary or obama. good grief he'd drill them a new asshole.
mckibbins 4 years ago
that was funny...lol
bloodycortez 4 years ago
god I love this guy
huckabee is a moron. "save honor" over american troops getting killed or having legs and arms amputated. "in god we trust" pandering fool.
mckibbins 4 years ago
"In God we trust" pandering fool.
Sweet expression to no end. Mind if I steal it?
HAHAHAHAHAHAAH!!! Awesome
napornik 4 years ago
Ron Paul kicks ass!!
iNDIGOarts 4 years ago
Wow! I hadn't seen this debate.
No wonder fox news doesn't want to include him in any more.
He tore 'em a new one.
He should study this debate and repeat that style of discourse at every opportunity.
Cogent, clear, specific and right.
boogle362 4 years ago 2
glad he gave up the dipstick "twofers" in the SC debate, what a bunch of maroons
housebound shutins eekin out living with click through revenue
desecrating the heroes of that day
FUCK you hairlip loose change losers
ripley450 4 years ago
I feel so sorry for Ron Paul. He is the only sane man talking on the stage trying to drive in the facts into these brainless clowns and they show no sign of improvement... (sigh) and the FOX network is really not helping eighter. Obviously Mr. Newscorp doesn't like ppl who say the right things.
amsd1231 4 years ago 5
Doesn't like people who THINK, for that matter...
bloodycortez 4 years ago
Poor united statians stop crying. Y'all a buch of retards with ugly bitches and a shitload of gayporn under the bed.
Eurobro's Unite!
Go EUrope!
Go EUFOR!
united s(t)at(i)ans of ass are done for!
JefGlapski 4 years ago
thats strong words, im european, and sorry im not your bro at all
TehManoSteele 4 years ago
ha ha ha! let him have it!
bloodycortez 4 years ago
I hate how those other idiot candidates are always giggling at Dr. Paul.. The Federal Reserve probably payed them to do that, just like they payed Alan Greenspan to sell out.
Fuchsia 4 years ago
If Pilots were allowed to carry guns 3,000 lives would have been saved.
TijoKJose 4 years ago
hahaha, huckabee with his "patriotism." Ron Paul smoked them all!
nhm414 4 years ago
I don't understand how anyone can fall for Huckabee's shennanigans... The polls and the Primary votes absolutely astound me. Are Americans really that scared and uninformed??? Fascism is gonna reeeeeeally suck. I'm moving to Sweden.
Fuchsia 4 years ago 2
FOX is trying soooo hard to attack Dr. Paul here with that stupid laugh track and everything but I think we all have to agree that Dr. Paul pretty much gave them the smack down, and that's why they are so scared to have him back.
codyo2 4 years ago
I hate the way Gulianni smerks whenever Paul speaks as if he's infinately more intelligent. He simply isnt and having him as a president would be a catastrophe larger than GWB.
adamfruitcake 4 years ago
the man is a total ape (Gul)
bloodycortez 4 years ago
Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundral~!! Listen to Huck and McCain..."Leave Iraq with honor" BULLSHIT! Nixon parroted that exact same line in 1972 with Vietnam. That war was disaster. Therre was no honor...We just had to end the slaughter of young American lives...Let's do the same for our servicemen and women in the middle east.
chas233 4 years ago
PEOPLE aren't stupid...They see a concerted effort on behalf of all the other clone candidates to try to marginilize Dr.Paul...Then when the democratic candidates come on stage, they shun Dr.Paul....WHY???They are trying to stop him, because his poll numbers have continued in an uward direction,This race is till wide open and they are afraid that Ron will steal their votes! Guess what, they were never their votes to begin with...MONEY BOMB 1-21-08!!!
chas233 4 years ago
u r correct. No one even mentioned Dr. Paul until they saw all his support. No one attacked him until his supporters started bombing the institution with monetary support for Dr. Paul.
Fuchsia 4 years ago
I don't think those laughs were planted. I think all of the doinks on stage with Dr. Paul were laughing.
soulshaker123 4 years ago
Ron Paul kicks ass! Huckashit is full of it! It is amazing that there are still people not aware of what is really going on in this country and believe mainstream media reports like blind cows! Let's hope Dr. Paul wins the presidency so that he can restore our Nation!
notz72 4 years ago
Thats it, I'm voting for Ron Paul. He actually isn't a puppet of the American Goverment and has the nerve to face reality.
BrockSamson01 4 years ago 7
The honorable Mike Huckabee is so honorable that doing anything remotely dishonorable and comprising the honor of this honorable US is absolutely dishonorable in the eyes of the honorable Mike Huckabee.
berkguyyy 4 years ago 3
Ron Paul! Ron Paul! Ron Paul! Check out GomerRevenge's music video...really catchy Ron Paul song!
jmielkeway 4 years ago
Yeah but, really who cares? The moonbats that religiously watch the Fox "news" network are so brainwashed that they will only vote for a war-loving neocon anyway. Not to say that some would might some free will left to decipher that they are being lied to and that this Ron Paul sounds reasonable. However, it is Fox's right to air whatever lies they want. It is time for citizens to wake up and find the truth!
PGAJAMIE411 4 years ago
He sounds like thomas paine to me
K2Tanner 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ron Paul's campaign will be hosting its own forum on New Hampshire television, following Dr. Paul's exclusion from a Fox News Republican "forum" tonight.
Check out Manchester television station MCAM TV-23 from 5-6 PM ET, or the simulcast online at RonPaul2008(.)com.
Let MCAM know we're are happy Ron is being given a truly American forum... email Ray Buckley (community and political party activist) at director@mcam(.)org!
jacquelinej12 4 years ago
Stop the F.B.I. hahaha this man is crazy
ahsfan07 4 years ago
Your a dunce ahsfan07.Your like the rest of the sheeple in this country.Its idoits like you whos constitutional right Dr.Paul trys to protect.Yea,lets depend on the government to save us and deprive us of more freedoms.Then again your probably on welfare anyway.P.S. ahs sucks!
hester32 4 years ago
Actually I'm in college and both of my parents make over 100K a year. So you think that you're better off fighting terrorist by yourself? How are were they depriving our freedoms by not allowing guns on planes? Do you know how dangerous it would be if a bullet going off and penetrating the plane? Ron Paul is an idiot and has no chance in hell, thank God. How do you feel we would be better off without the F.B.I. and all the intelligence we get? By the way learn how to spell.
ahsfan07 4 years ago
FBI, CIA... where's the WMD?
chr0nik666 4 years ago
He has no chance because the neocommie media will censor all who oppose their socialist agenda.Isn't censorship a form of deprived freedom?So whats FOX excuse not to allow Mr.Paul to debate a bunch of neocon zombies?The truth is ,if someone hasn't got a chance in hell, why be afraid.If Mr.Paul loses,it's always good to know the Neocons will have plenty of fresh meat( like you)for their war machne.
hester32 4 years ago
right. because an emergency landing as a possible result is far worse than crashing or better yet, plunging into a highrise...right... as for fbi "intelligence"...get a history lesson quick pal, before you find yourself a prisoner in a fema camp along with your parents, brothers and sisters--all housed in different compartments... the America you've been introduced to, I'm afraid, is an alien--and it's out to destroy you--believe it or not!
bloodycortez 4 years ago
he actually said to minimize their spying on americans...ur subliminally brain washed by neo cons......u should ask ur self why theyres no law ever written to pay income tax...theyres a 50 000 dollar reward if u find it....good luck
boricuamobsta 4 years ago
This man is crazy. Blaming 9/11 on us are you kidding me! If the terrorist thought people could bring guns on the planes they would have brought guns and possibly more people. And backing down to terrorist than allowing dictators to do what they want.
ahsfan07 4 years ago
ahffan07---your living in the dark. College spits out many fools, and your parents income is irrelevant fool. I'm sure a bullet hole in a plane is preferable to a hijacked one with the intent of crashing into a building, no? Wake up, you brainwashed fool.
chuckajg 4 years ago
I don't think Giuliani is laughing anymore after Ron Paul got 10% of the Iowa caucas and Rudy only got 4%.
kdeAND3 4 years ago
A revolution of the minds.
PreservingLiberty 4 years ago
Listen to Rudy Rigitoni laughing like a a school yard Bully in the background. What a Putz. 4% in Iowa. Who loves ya Rudy?
No one. My brother died in the trade towers. Puck you Rudy!
bgpiano 4 years ago
Fox is the lowest this Country has ever sunk as far as tactically
conspiring to rig our elections. Boycott Fox. Sell or short Newscorp shares. Bombard Fox with Email and show your opinion to these low life non-patriotic, non american evil phucks!
bgpiano 4 years ago
Fox News needs to sued for libel. They are now "reporting" that Ron Paul is a 9/11 conspiracy theorist. That Ron Paul said that 9/11 was an inside job. Not even Glenn Beck had the right to ask him stupid questions related to this. We now have a misinformation campaign by Fox. We need lawyers to look into this!!!
Any lawyers available???
RP'08 !!!
tito2b2 4 years ago
Ron Paul is so on point it makes me cry
pri2006 4 years ago 2
I love it. Let me answer your question with a better question. A polite way of saying I'm little bit smarter than you.
redline450r 4 years ago 2
correct. Its just funny to me how they keep on trying to get him down by using their asshole-techniques. You know what I mean, or do you think the cuts and sounds in the video are random? PROPAGANDA
Stevemasta3000 4 years ago
Please chill people. We can't look like a bunch of loons right now. Don't send negative emails or calls to anyone. Unconfirmed reports and personal insults against RP are meat to get us fired up. Stay focused. MSM has been replaced with "Old Media". Let RP make the calls and follow his lead!!
tito2b2 4 years ago 3
Good comment. He will lead us. America needs him desperately.
redline450r 4 years ago 2
"A bloodbath that would certainly occur."
LMAO
illuminutty 4 years ago
What's this "we" stuff? And what's this "honor" stuff? The Republicans and Bush have "honorably" gutted the country of millions of living-wage jobs. Jobs a veteran could use when he gets out of the service. They "honorably" squander taxpayer's money by the billions. They "honorably" take advantage of the American people. The government and the people are 2 separate entities. No to Huckabee!
Obobbakonda 4 years ago 3
I got to say this...
when I listen to the other cannidates all I hear is them attacking each other.
when I listen to Ron Paul I hear:
1. solutions to problems.
2. a man who's listened to the people
3. the type of words that are written on wall of American Monuments.
How can you not love this man?
I hear
bugsycline 4 years ago 6
I agree with you 100%.
Freedom nowadays is named RON PAUL
LibertarianEurope 4 years ago 2
The middle east has been at war since recorded history started.Nobody can stabilize it,especially middle easteners.We have no commission to police other countries.YOU,just don't get it,Moron.
move2montana 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ron Paul just don't get it ... without a USA presence in the middle east there is no hope of any stability in that region... might sound cruel and un-liberal-like, but we've got to protect our long-term interests .. get this trojan horse Paul off the fucking stage
roscoe85cj 4 years ago
When has the middle east been stable when u've been there?
kentso888 4 years ago 2
Those laughs were from a man in the seats behind Fox. They were not planted by Fox. You're reaching.
libassbug 4 years ago
Looks like everybody want to take a shot at the REAL frontrunner. (Ron Paul)
11111RaVeN11111 4 years ago
This is not meant to be a "bash", but if anyone who is for Paul for real (not just being funny...which I assume most are) has a degree above a Baccalaureate, please respond to this. I just want to see. Thanks.
jusmart 4 years ago
I don't remember the part of the constitution that says people with an education are less intelligent, or have less of a right to vote, or less of a right to get involved in politics. That's blatant snobbery, anyone with a degree SHOULD be offended by your tone.
Aberusugi 4 years ago
Wallace really throws a cheap shot here.....I used to like FOX news till I've seen how they have been railroading Dr. Paul.
BlackOmega9 4 years ago
Is this a debate between the candidates or between Ron Paul and the modirators. My God I hate FOX.
lollygager3664 4 years ago
Fuck Rudy!!!
zvertex1 4 years ago
This is why ron paul will win big time.
jammasterjayfan 4 years ago
to everyone who are always anti-fox, i still find the best debates come from FOX. also they give paul more air time than CNN, i wish i was able to see this one live instead of the CNN/youtube debate sigh*
gatsu6969 4 years ago
God damn that guys face at the end was like "aw damn, he just owned us"
Kfg929 4 years ago
lol .. the Paulzoids are nuts .. vote Huckabee and get it right
roscoe85cj 4 years ago
I'm an idividual but I can at least relate to why people support Ron Paul. But Huckabee?!! What are you some reactionary stooge? Huckabee is nothing special. He's a true conformist.
lollygager3664 4 years ago
traditionalist would be a more accurate description semengagger... and there is nothing finer than true American tradition .. God Bless the GOP
roscoe85cj 4 years ago
Yes I gag on semen. Got a problem with that?!
As for the traditionalism of Huckabee, you kidding yourself. The guy screams mediocrity.
lollygager3664 4 years ago
hey you pussified code pink libdink, the Surge is Working and your AIDS medication isn't LMFAO! thank you George Bush .. as each day goes by you anti-war/pro-islamofascist/terror-appeasing cowards look more and more rediculous
roscoe85cj 4 years ago
I'm no liberal. You're no traditionalist, unless you mean traditions of stupidity, gullibility, and bigotry.
And for your information dipshit, I support this war. You clearly think only under a "left vs. right" model of politics, just like the owners of this country want you to.
lollygager3664 4 years ago 2
"nothing finer than true American tradition?" like what, Apple Pie? My your dumm...
bloodycortez 4 years ago
Huckabee is my choice, too
jusmart 4 years ago
ron paul is the only candidate who actually understands the constitution.
zepfan989 4 years ago
Ron Paul is the ONLY candidate to even consider. Rudy should be hung from a tree.
nothwind 4 years ago
that fact most of these goons in washington and most of the candidates for prez (excluding Paul) WOULD have been hung from a tree, and the most likely person to do it would have been Washington himself... blindness...a true sign of the age...
bloodycortez 4 years ago
Today's the day to express our thanks to Ron Paul! He has asked us for our help NOW and his campaign has said that the Dec 16 Tea Party will be too late to impact the crucial early primaries. Money is needed NOW! I just donated my $100 and I know that we can "stuff" Dr. Paul's campaign with cash today if we all give what we can! Let's show the "turkeys" who don't believe that Dr. Paul can win that we are not taking a day off! The fight for liberty continues! Donate Today & help post this!
ShowTheTurkeys 4 years ago
As the poster of this video says NOTICE THE OPEN MICS MOCKING RON PAUL.
shadowfaxx1 4 years ago