An amazing effort here, Ed has done well and it's hard for them to just stop playing certain songs because of Steven leaving but it doesn't sound right without his voice.
Ed did a great job in this but BNL isn't whole w/o Steven Page. I've been a fan since the beginning and I really feel some songs were designed to have Ed sing while others only can be sung by Steve. The change doesn't evoke the same emotions. I hope they can find a way to get Steven Page back in the band.
it pains me to say anything negative about ed, i love his voice above any other i've heard... but this song should be sung only by steven. i can't handle it this way :'( it breaks my bnl loving heart.
ED ROBERTSON is one of the most creative people in the history of music...,,cuz he's got soul..ya baby ya!!!......he ranks with the greatest..
urariotalice 2 weeks ago
as i've said before. Steve has a powerful and wonderful instrument. Ed has a more endearing one. YOU try to sing better.
6kgraves 4 weeks ago
something is missing big time here and i don't know what it is.Maybe Steven knows????
cemeteryjoe 1 month ago
BNL is dead. Can't fill stadiums without Steven Page, & Ed asked Steven last min. when he needed help and that's what started the band.
mikeydook 1 month ago
Steve is family , where the hell is he? Go get him and bring him home.
michaelckerr 2 months ago
@michaelckerr you can't drag someone back to a place where they don't want to be anymore Steve made his choice.
Edchick28 1 month ago
Even though this song is painfully missing Steven's vocals, at least be glad it isn't Kevin Hearn singing. God, that guy is atrocious vocally.
arky25 2 months ago
bullshit!!!!! not good without steve. period.
VoughtF4uCorsa1r 3 months ago
bullshit!!!!! not good without steve. period.
VoughtF4uCorsa1r 3 months ago
It's almost like they are mourning the loss of S. Page.. and perhaps, one day, he will return.. Fan from day 1 of BNL.. Peace.
SuperSpencercat 3 months ago
You know what? I was thinking I was missing Steven on this, but he nailed it. It's a bitch of a song to sing (I've done it).
Mateobard 3 months ago 2
Honestly I much rather Ed singing this song. I love his voice and I think it suits the song quite well.
koolkat104 7 months ago 3
Ed is awesome
YouShouldBeThere 7 months ago 3
Ed is Barenaked Ladies not Steve get over it people
YouShouldBeThere 7 months ago 4
Lovely song, great vocals from Ed but...it makes me want to cry not hearing Steven sing this. It makes his departure feel real.
MrByronDunbar 8 months ago 6
An amazing effort here, Ed has done well and it's hard for them to just stop playing certain songs because of Steven leaving but it doesn't sound right without his voice.
jackdelamare 10 months ago 5
Ed did a great job in this but BNL isn't whole w/o Steven Page. I've been a fan since the beginning and I really feel some songs were designed to have Ed sing while others only can be sung by Steve. The change doesn't evoke the same emotions. I hope they can find a way to get Steven Page back in the band.
Juliann1026 11 months ago
it pains me to say anything negative about ed, i love his voice above any other i've heard... but this song should be sung only by steven. i can't handle it this way :'( it breaks my bnl loving heart.
Dawnjah 11 months ago
Just not the same without Steven singing it...
Just another reason to hate drugs
Beepbeepoutoftheway 1 year ago 2
What a good song. Ed is such an amazing singer. I'm so glad he kept up the band without Page. Honestly, I've always rathered his voice.
koolkat104 1 year ago
Ed's come along way in two years. Awesome job.
fitty650sx 1 year ago
Incredible performance!
Kevin, you always capture BNL so perfectly.
gigitosome 1 year ago