Brilliant .... but I don't think you should have put in the bit where he said "I love you". That's the whole point of it and what gave the episode meaning. Thank you anyway though. I cried like a baby when it was aired and watching it now nearly got me going again .... I was at the National TV Awards in Nov 07 where Dr Who got everything they were nominated for .. well deserved ... David and Billie are amazing actors!
It's really cool how she pronounces "Dårlig Ulv Stranden", though we don't say that in Norway. The Correct translation of "Bad Wolf Bay" would be "Slem Ulv Stranden"
@Arhtass Only that this doesnt sound painfuly like "Dalek". The german version of it (from the missile) was also off - It said "schlechter Wolf" whats more like "Wolf of inferior quality" XD It should have been "böser Wolf". I wonder if the welsh version was correct. That's more likely, tough, considering that the show is mostly filmed in Cardiff...
It would have ben better for him to tell her KNOW :( I know some people are complaining: "It would ruin season 4" but I think most Dr who fans, including me, would have prefered it if the Doctor NOT the clone would have at least TOLD her
Oh how I wish he had said it out loud at least once.... oh I think we knew that he loved her because every act he took for her screamed it in so many ways but even that isn't the same as hearing him say I LOVE YOU aloud!
Sighs.... fanastic job on the edit....this is as close as we'll ever get!
That's a lot of crap, I'm from Norway and I still live here, and what she said it was called is NOT Norwegian for Bad Wolf Bay, what she said wasn't Norwegian at all!
this has always, always, always made me cry. i'm kinda glad he didn't actually say i love you in the episode, cause that would've ruined the end of season 4. much more dramatic that way :)
Yours is the best Beach scene I've seen yet on Youtube. And you manage to get those 3 words in: "I love you." Naughty naughty. (But I'm proud of you.)
Always wanted to kick the Doc for not saying it way earlier.
May I ask ... why is there no video on YouTube of the actual finale to the episode where some halfwit hasn't screwed it up by doing their own fan made edit?
Just spotted a continuity flaw .. or rather a detail overlook ...
When Rose raises her hand as she says 'can i touch' ... you can see the shadow from her arm on his jacket!..
If he was just a projection that would'nt happen .. but of course i'm being nit-picky over a tiny production detail ... they would have had to have 'CGI'ed the shadow out...
Look, it quite clearly says where they got the "I Love You" clip from and if you like Doctor Who then you'll know he doesn't say it so stop banging on about it.
No he didn't get to say "I love you". You've added some sound clip in of Tennant's Casa Nova saying "I love you" I suspect. Rose gets to hear what the Doctor was going to say at the end of series 4.
I always cry when I see this. Im cring now...I've seen this about 100,00 times and I still cry when I see this part. Why is that?! Ah well... Better start mopping up the key board.
This was a very very sad episode most probably the sadest episode of Dr Who i have ever seen, rose was a really good assistant, i have never cried so much at a TV programme but this had me good and proper.
Arrr this is so cute i have wanted this to happen!!! and now you've made it happen!!!! I LOVE THIS !!! thanks sooo much for posting it. It made me cry its just so beautiful!!
Sign the petition for a Doctor Who movie with Rose and the Doctor (they'll be sending it to the BBC when they get enough signatures):
w-w-w dot petitiononline dot com / rosie111
Sorry if you think this is spam, but i don't think it is --i have signed it myself - I just want Rose back, and I know lots of people agree. thnx x x x
please check it out they will be very grateful thankyou x x
Its a kinda curse, BBF; its not like if he says 'I love you' then he'll die, but he just can't let himself love anyone, especially not humans. Imagine; he falls in love, has children, and has to endure the sight of his family grow old and die, while he doesn't age at all. Its really sad, but it was for the best, in his terms. He didn't have to admit what he can't have.
I could have killed him when he didn't say it, but now is shuch a relief, why did they stop him from saying i love you? and he dosn't feel that way about martha so she should stop trying, it's getting on my nerves. Anyone else think so? anyway thanx for putting this up its wonderfull. xxx
i cried and i have never seen doctor who... well i dont want to now that i know its going to end this way. :'( WHHHHHHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY !!!! D:
97geeorge 1 week ago
I'm not gonna cry. I'm not gonna- God I'm crying. This is the fifth time I've seen this, and I cry. EVERY. TIME.
colorXitXred 3 weeks ago
Don't cry, don't cry, don't cry.. DON'T. FUCKING. CRY.
*Sobs*
vintagehoes 2 months ago
I cried....seriously.
MsAliceCullen992 3 months ago
I didn't think I'd cry.
ImaginarySanity 8 months ago
I CRIED
izzyepp 1 year ago
Awww <3 I never got to see this epi, only the one right after with Donna....I almost cried watchin this
KayleeMay13 1 year ago
I cry everytime
ScrambleChannel 1 year ago
Brilliant .... but I don't think you should have put in the bit where he said "I love you". That's the whole point of it and what gave the episode meaning. Thank you anyway though. I cried like a baby when it was aired and watching it now nearly got me going again .... I was at the National TV Awards in Nov 07 where Dr Who got everything they were nominated for .. well deserved ... David and Billie are amazing actors!
Vegasbabex 1 year ago
Oh God. This makes me wanna cry so badly. But i hate Rose so much i dont.
MooMMD 1 year ago
WTF?!?!?!?!!?! wen he said "i love you" that wasnt his voice!!!! it was an over sound!!!
MistDemon666 1 year ago
@MistDemon666 Yay, the maker of this vid edited it. I belive it's the round-ish guy from 'the lodger.
The Doctor could never bring himself to spit out those three words...
KendrixTermina 11 months ago
@MistDemon666 It was James Corden on The Lodger.
slitheenplanet 11 months ago
It's really cool how she pronounces "Dårlig Ulv Stranden", though we don't say that in Norway. The Correct translation of "Bad Wolf Bay" would be "Slem Ulv Stranden"
Arhtass 1 year ago
@Arhtass Only that this doesnt sound painfuly like "Dalek". The german version of it (from the missile) was also off - It said "schlechter Wolf" whats more like "Wolf of inferior quality" XD It should have been "böser Wolf". I wonder if the welsh version was correct. That's more likely, tough, considering that the show is mostly filmed in Cardiff...
KendrixTermina 11 months ago
@KendrixTermina Yeah, I noticed that too. I'm half german myself
Arhtass 11 months ago
super lame
NicozyTimeLord 1 year ago
Cybermen100,
We KNOW he was gonna say the EXACT same thing, because that's what the Director said in the confedential
kopa225 1 year ago
what was the doctor about to say to her before he disaperd
CybermeN100 1 year ago
@CybermeN100 He was going to do the victory dance because Rose Tyler just said she loved him. Or at least that's what I would've done XD
motownazn 1 year ago
@CybermeN100 'I love you.'
Ladymimz1 1 year ago
It would have ben better for him to tell her KNOW :( I know some people are complaining: "It would ruin season 4" but I think most Dr who fans, including me, would have prefered it if the Doctor NOT the clone would have at least TOLD her
kopa225 1 year ago
Comment removed
lomeinie 1 year ago
Oh how I wish he had said it out loud at least once.... oh I think we knew that he loved her because every act he took for her screamed it in so many ways but even that isn't the same as hearing him say I LOVE YOU aloud!
Sighs.... fanastic job on the edit....this is as close as we'll ever get!
lomeinie 1 year ago
That's a lot of crap, I'm from Norway and I still live here, and what she said it was called is NOT Norwegian for Bad Wolf Bay, what she said wasn't Norwegian at all!
Arhtass 1 year ago
@Arhtass dude, chill. I'm from Norway as well. She was trying to say "Dårlig", it's just that she has really bad pronounciation.
lienschmien95 1 year ago
That scene makes me cry, I just love watchin it over and over again!!! :( It's so sad... I'm glad she came back though!! xxxxxxx
EleanorPascoe 1 year ago
This is so sad!!!!!!!! OMG
veetz98usC 1 year ago
Is it bad I didn't realise it was edited? I just thought my computer had screwed up at that point o.o
afrokidxx 1 year ago
lmfao @ the edit
StrawberryCoke 1 year ago
im bawling right now, this is so sadd D:
daniii37 1 year ago
this has always, always, always made me cry. i'm kinda glad he didn't actually say i love you in the episode, cause that would've ruined the end of season 4. much more dramatic that way :)
CrazyFireflyGirl 1 year ago
:( The saddest clip eva! How come HE didn't get to say it? Sure, she did.
Miss David! :(
kopa225 1 year ago
Yours is the best Beach scene I've seen yet on Youtube. And you manage to get those 3 words in: "I love you." Naughty naughty. (But I'm proud of you.)
Always wanted to kick the Doc for not saying it way earlier.
rr7firefly 1 year ago
We'll miss you David!!
Persephonenoele 1 year ago 2
Scene just gets me all choked up.
dbassplayer 2 years ago 5
WOW.
THAT WAS AMAZING
YES. THIS HOW IT SHOULD HAVE ENDED.
I give you credit my friend :D
SunsetRainbow27 2 years ago
May I ask ... why is there no video on YouTube of the actual finale to the episode where some halfwit hasn't screwed it up by doing their own fan made edit?
MurrayTheMac 2 years ago 3
What a great clip. I really enjoyed seeing him as the Dr.
chiefnut48 2 years ago 2
so sad !! it makes me cry....
zivabby 2 years ago 2
One thing i find amazing is - david tennant has a huge scottish accent but he puts on the british accent and it sounds like he is british.
Odribah 2 years ago 3
@Odribah i totally agree i mean he is such a good actor
i wish he wouldnt leave
:(
Xx
blondechick95xxx 2 years ago
@Odribah well he is british... just not english :P
xPrincessKx 1 year ago
This.
Is how it should have ended.
StellaShuriken 2 years ago
This clip makes me cry everytime I see it
So sad!!!
I love the Doctor!!!!!! <3
VLoverF 2 years ago
great clip would be even better it clip didn,t keep stopping to buffer or freezing
woodman117 2 years ago
This made me cry so much, <3 Im with the guy who said screw the two universes!
Lilanimalcrazy 2 years ago
oh. my. gosh. I lvoe you for making this!!!
josieruby1 2 years ago
God it'd be so hard not to throw your arms around him in a hug. I want to do that now! screw the two universes!
jhorst24 2 years ago 2
Just spotted a continuity flaw .. or rather a detail overlook ...
When Rose raises her hand as she says 'can i touch' ... you can see the shadow from her arm on his jacket!..
If he was just a projection that would'nt happen .. but of course i'm being nit-picky over a tiny production detail ... they would have had to have 'CGI'ed the shadow out...
Just thought i'd make you all go .... "oh yeah"
;-)
xoio 2 years ago
Look, it quite clearly says where they got the "I Love You" clip from and if you like Doctor Who then you'll know he doesn't say it so stop banging on about it.
turkeyrolls 2 years ago 2
dont be nasty .. well done x
RoseAndDoctor94 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
this is shit!
joestub 2 years ago
OMG! so sad BUT HE DOESNT ACTUALLY SAY I LOVE YOU !!!!! ~crys~
w33fabaidy 2 years ago 4
No he didn't get to say "I love you". You've added some sound clip in of Tennant's Casa Nova saying "I love you" I suspect. Rose gets to hear what the Doctor was going to say at the end of series 4.
pidlive 2 years ago
i love this episode....~cries~
BUUUUUTTTT!!!!
he does not say that!!!!! the whole point that this is sad is because he doesn't get to "I love you"!!!!!!!
Kakashirocksthesocks 2 years ago
Exactly. This should not have been tampered with.
pidlive 2 years ago 21
I cried earlier and i cried now...love this video
lordofnothing101 2 years ago 2
Moving moment. 5 Stars.
GeminiDazzy86 2 years ago
i love this video it so cool and so sad. i alswys cired doing this part
kt27rule 2 years ago
love it but he never said i love you sorry
doctorwhoizcool 2 years ago
That was a crap edit. he never said i love you. It all concludes in journeys end. Sorry to ruin it poeple!
stroppyloppy 2 years ago
C.R.Y.I.N.G <:*{
11killergirl11 3 years ago
^ CRYING ^
pitabreadpita 3 years ago
* CRYING *
kagome07love 3 years ago
Yes even though I am a hardcore DUDE this is very very sad to me
Docthewrench 3 years ago 2
I love that episode but I can't watch it without crying!
soccerstar821 3 years ago 2
i dont think ill ever be able 2 watch doomsday without crying =( T___T
cr717 3 years ago 3
this is really sad
123hoythere 3 years ago
Slip in the grammar =:3°
CherryEffect 3 years ago
I have so bitterly cry...
CherryEffect 3 years ago 2
My god, I'm crying
kissfromaroseox 3 years ago 3
and after seeing this past finale, too... the doctor is always left alone in the end.
this one was really really sad, but the most recent one, it also made me cry, for the doctor.
grimmeeper 3 years ago
uh..where the hell was the casanova clip o.O
i didn't seem to hear it all the way through the video..
videonoob117 3 years ago
It's the "I love you" that was inserted into the video since the Doctor never gets a chance to say it
Hydebehindthemask 3 years ago
does ne1 no the name of rose's music?
himrawkz 3 years ago
It's called Rose's Theme, and it's on the first Doctor Who album, composed by Murray Gold
insufferableknowital 3 years ago
his face when rose mentions the baby!
I read the statement too,
and doctor was going to say i love you too.
but it would have been too predictable!
cannot wait for this weekend's one :D
LDN92 3 years ago
He didn't get to say 'i love you'.
Sneaky editing there, lol.
frankii77 3 years ago
I love this, every time Kim! Incase you're wondering it's Becky. No I'm not stalking. I saw you were a friend on Gina's page. Lol
lovertojackharkness 3 years ago
Ah I did have a feeling it might be you! haha!
insufferableknowital 3 years ago
i've read a statement by julie garder(cant spell) but he was really going to say he loved her too
So sad
icewormie123 3 years ago
I always cry when I see this. Im cring now...I've seen this about 100,00 times and I still cry when I see this part. Why is that?! Ah well... Better start mopping up the key board.
Chatgirlone 3 years ago 2
This was a very very sad episode most probably the sadest episode of Dr Who i have ever seen, rose was a really good assistant, i have never cried so much at a TV programme but this had me good and proper.
Great Video
ShadzeB 3 years ago 35
@ShadzeB i know i was so pissed when he just disappeared!
fr3ewritergurl 1 year ago
@ShadzeB Rose wasn't his assistant, he was the love of his 10th life!! That's why he could never love anyone else until Matt Smith came :(
slitheenplanet 11 months ago
i was in such a wreck when i watched it on tv lol
orangygoodness 3 years ago
i want the music to it, any ideas what itz called or where i cud perhaps get it?
hobbo16 3 years ago
It's Rose's Theme from the Doctor Who Series 1 and 2 soundtrack :)
insufferableknowital 3 years ago
Thank you much appreciated :)
hobbo16 3 years ago
Such a sad episode I cried.
AvatarHero 3 years ago
oh dear god.. lol i hadnt seen this in agges and i was crying wen that came up then i started laughing..and now...i have the hiccups lol
xPrincessKx 3 years ago
this made me laugh. lol
drantb 3 years ago
he didnt get to say i love you though
stianna22 3 years ago
"burning up a sun just to say goodbye" - one of the best tv quotes of all time.
misseryman177 3 years ago 4
I cried so much the first time I saw this on TV. Saddest Doctor Who assistant to leave ever. :(
rumblebunneh 3 years ago 5
This was a real heartbreaker...
megs1031 3 years ago
i wish he rly got to say dat to her, it would've made the seen a little less sad then it already is..
darknessqueen3242 3 years ago
that has got to be the saddest moment in tv history... im bawling like a kid....
meso786 3 years ago
i cried when i saw this when it was on tv.
such a good episode
fudge90 4 years ago 2
Ohhh that worked sooo well.
The audio clip from Casanova wasn't the best quality, but it still sounded fantastic.
HogwartsHonorRoll 4 years ago
I'm so glad I caught this! One of the most touching scenes on film anywhere! A great vid! Thanks.
JEP177777 4 years ago 3
just watching that gave me an immense sense of satisfaction.
I've been wanting to hear him say that to her for years.
Thank-you for this vid.
And btw, katiemay14, it says if you click on more that it was added from casanova. So on that account, no freaking duh!
MusicalMadElzEfron 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He never said it you have just added that on!!!!!
katiemay14 4 years ago
i didnt here it the 1st time i got to the end n i was like wah! buh then i rewownd it n heard it! omg cry!
doctorwho1994 4 years ago 2
Arrr this is so cute i have wanted this to happen!!! and now you've made it happen!!!! I LOVE THIS !!! thanks sooo much for posting it. It made me cry its just so beautiful!!
tangytj27 4 years ago 2
I THINK THIS IS JUST AMAZING WELL DONE !!
We want Rose back!
Sign the petition for a Doctor Who movie with Rose and the Doctor (they'll be sending it to the BBC when they get enough signatures):
w-w-w dot petitiononline dot com / rosie111
Sorry if you think this is spam, but i don't think it is --i have signed it myself - I just want Rose back, and I know lots of people agree. thnx x x x
please check it out they will be very grateful thankyou x x
xXxXxcozzaxXxXx 4 years ago 3
D'you think she would've heard him clearly through the static? ;)
Just teasing! :D It was cute. :)
TheThirteenthDoctor 4 years ago 2
omgg i cried so much... evertym i see this clip i jus cryy!! x Fankoo so so much ur amazin! x i miss rose so much.. =[
ShaynexLover90xx 4 years ago 4
i think it's more emotional without the 'i love you.' but very sweet well done :) x
lottiestar 4 years ago 2
Its a kinda curse, BBF; its not like if he says 'I love you' then he'll die, but he just can't let himself love anyone, especially not humans. Imagine; he falls in love, has children, and has to endure the sight of his family grow old and die, while he doesn't age at all. Its really sad, but it was for the best, in his terms. He didn't have to admit what he can't have.
*cries*
CallMePsyco 4 years ago
Kim,that was AWESOME!
I completly agree,you should be the new RTD!
blueblood1415 4 years ago
This really made me cry! WHY!!!! Why did rose gave to go? Its not fair!! thnx so much for makin this you are excellent! BTW i'm still crying!
tangytj27 4 years ago 2
FINALLY!
I've been dreaming of this to happen!
And you've done it!
Kim - you should become the next Russel T Davies :-)
And then get another Hot Scot to play Doctor Who :-D
Or rehire David!
Lol
xxxxxx
angelofmusic7894 4 years ago
YAAAAAYYY!!!
HermioneWeasley02 4 years ago 2
oh i've been waiting for this. thanks for the closure! XD
therealstar 4 years ago
Yayyyy he said it!!
ediemcdude 4 years ago
KIM, I LOVE YOU!!!
TTYYYYY TYYY TYYYYYYYYYY
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
davidtennantmad 4 years ago
I agree with Dragonhear951. You are a complete legend. This needed to be done. Thank-you sooooo much!!!!
chriswoolleyvut 4 years ago 2
I LOVE THIS SO MUCH!!!!
THANK YOU FOR MAKING IT
you're a legend you are!!!!! and I sooo wanted this to really happen
AND
it made me cry!!! well this clip always does lol...well done for making it!!
dragonheart951 4 years ago
I could have killed him when he didn't say it, but now is shuch a relief, why did they stop him from saying i love you? and he dosn't feel that way about martha so she should stop trying, it's getting on my nerves. Anyone else think so? anyway thanx for putting this up its wonderfull. xxx
billiesbiggesfan 4 years ago 3
They didn't do David Tennant saying 'I love you' so that if Billie wanted to come back they would have somewhere to go with it.
chloegeorgeson 4 years ago 3