A straight edger complaining about cigarette smoke! I like the old AFI albums, but they sound like such nancies when they whine about Nyquil, aspirin, and second hand smoke. Straight edge blows.
what i thought loads of people loved DU it's a great album so is "shut your mouth" and this is a really good one also crash love is good most of them are great albums
CU, I wasn't too crazy about, but I have to admit I gained a greater respect for AFI when I realized they were attempting to incorperate literary themes into the music itself--almost as an experiment to change it up or do something new with their music. Frankly, it's probably one of the reasons I've been listening to them for so long.
Frankly, I'm not a huge fan of cultural or marketing spin when it comes to any artist. And as for any artist, I don't believe their work should remain exclusive to one genre. It seems in almost any other craft, from literature, painting, sculture, acting, or film, an artist is praised for their ability to have greater range outside a singluar, narrow, genre. All except for music, where the artist is insulted for "selling out." It's babish, in my opinion.
DU isn't a bad album. All of the songs are good (except for Miss Murder, it just doesn't fit, and Affliction's outro, sounds like something from Grey's Anatomy), and the sounds are interesting enough. It just doesn't compare to Sing the Sorrows sincerity, that awesome earthy tone of the instruments, and just the mood and flow of the album's tracks. I honestly think because DU was so "poppy", it lost prestige just because of that. CL is a good album, better than DU in my opinion - It was sincere.
@FamiPunk I like DU better than CL but I give you a thumb up (I don't really mind when people talk about puns in parentheses). Sing the Sorrow is honest like you say.
Man, that last bit kinda makes me wish Dexter did backing vocals either for more of the song or on more songs than just the 2. Dexter and older AFI oddly enough seem to compliment each other. But...that could just be me being an Offspring fan for the past 13 years, lol.
I love Decemberunderground. It's a magical album, I really love it. But I also love ATASF, VPOY, SYMAOYE, BSITS, TAOD, STS and CL. I have to admit, CL is by far my least favorite, it's an amazing album, but I don't know. It's like I know you can't define AFI, but it seems a little out of place, like it's not the sort of music the band should be making. But that's just my opinion, and if the band's happy I'm happy.
@Norris3MCR Because they've gotten lazy, they didn't even write the songs together on CL they put together a bunch of pre-written shit, Having said that though, I enjoy the shit they out together, not as much as this though
@AtomicRichie right, Jade and Davey wrote the songs together like they always do, and what do you mean "pre-written shit" they never go into the studio before writing
@Norris3MCR i think you should give crash love another shot i love all there albums since 92 as well but crash love and decemberunderground are really underated i love those albums so much all though sing the sorrow and black sails are my faves out of the older ones i think shut your mouth and open ur eyes is the worst to be honest besides a single second the rest of the album just doesnt do it for me but i love all there work including the rare demos and unreleased songs from both projects
@willbirkin666 Yeah, I really love Decemberunderground and agree that it's underrated, I think people looked at how Davey's appearance had changed and made a snap judgement about the album, which is unfortunate because that album is an amazing piece of work, and I love it to bits. I do love Crash Love, it's just not something I would have seen AFI making, other than songs from it's B-Sides. I do love the songs from the record, they just seem like they aren't as AFI ey as the B-Sides :}
@Norris3MCr Well davey said in the crash love interview before the album came out that the album is gonna be way different sounding then any album theve done but they think its one of the best works theyve done and I agree the album is beautiful.
Do your research guys. Davey had nothing to do with the fact that AFI isn't a great band anymore. And by "had nothing to do with" I mean it wasn't his fault. He either had to give up the screaming and wailing that we all know and love.. Or lose his voice, permanently. So, yeah. They do suck now. But quit being 15 year old girls about it. Stick to The Art of Drowning and before and you'll be just fine.
I don't know about that...I think they're about the same as far as quality goes. I love StS because it's so atmospheric but DU is so crisp and has such an interesting soundscape. You can listen to DU and find new stuff in it each time. Now Crash love is pure shi**. JK, I was surprised to see how many people enjoy it. So I just gave up on ranking the albums as far as musicianship goes.
@wecosvinosec HOW can you ppl even say shit like Crash Love or Sing the Sorrow are their best albums?? Black Sails puts both of those to shame. But I guess you were still crawling around in your emo diapers when this album was out
i saw afi at club 513 in atlanta on euclid ave. when this album first came out and it is one of my best memories any one who is also from atl and remembers this show i would love to hear about it
@helloieatchicken i didnt mean that they aren't deep i just meant that they could be interpreted any number of different ways, some of which are "profound", i personally think they are and love all afi's lyrics(even the crash love ones :P)
if only time and money never changed people or bands....we'd still have the badass version of AFI....not this 80's lookin J-pop style dudes that have kinda forgot what road they were supposed to be on....can only hope one day they go back to being badass(im a fan and all..but i honestly cant bring myself to listen to december underground...infront of people)
@haiguizeify great reply....must have taken a lot of brain power on that one....just next time...atleast TRY to be witty or hurt my feelings haha, have a great and glorious day my friend
ok for life of me i cant hear dexter holland's vocals on this. i think I can maybe hear him in prayer position, but i cant pick him out here. anybody knows what he sings?
@jugwinedrunk AFI is one of the few bands that has changed their sound dramatically without selling out. I dont know about you but I dont see teenage girls walking around screaming "i love davey havok!" that dubious honor is usually reserved for the likes of justin bieber
The progression in their sound is obvious when you listen to their albums in order. The changes just got a little bigger with each album. But the change in sound from whatever came before this, to this, to art of drowning, to sing the sorrow, is pretty logical. They slowly progressed away from punk and into rock.
@bearblaster420 i for one have always loved afi, new and old. theyre new stuff id good. so dont knock it, a real fan of any band will accept the changes a band goes through, not just be a closed-minded jerk.
goddammit ppl you guys keep on going on and on about new AFI! if you wanna bash them at least dont do it here. this video has nothing to do with the new AFI. Even then, you shouldnt, because that music is just as good as the old. All bands change, and remember, they made the same kinda stuff for 4 albums. If you count the total number of bsides, that equals to 1 album so how can you expect AFI NOT to change after 5 albums? AFI doesnt only do music for the fans, they do it more so for themselves.
i hate when people say "AFI has matured because their lyrics are more meaningful now" yeah i can say they matured their lyrics from their first album till now but when people say that they mean that sts du and cl have the most meaningful lyrics. r u kidding me? These lyrics mean sooooooooooo much more then broken radios playing suicide (not bashing on end transmission, awesome song) but really? just cuz u cant understand this stuff until u look it up doesnt mean it doesnt hav a meaning
@GreyShadowUchiha: I agree with you, Art of Drowning, Black Sails, and Shut your Mouth and Open Your Eyes have awesome, awesome lyrics. Even some of Very Proud of Ya, too. There is def evidence of some intense concepts in VPoY.
"I'm detached from you completely." - He Who Laughs Last YEAH, totally amazing concepts.
I think when people say they've matured, they're talking more bout the music style. I mean, AFI didn't even KNOW how to play instruments when they started, ha.
@GreyShadowUchiha well i meant ppl here who actually searched for a very specific song from black sails in the sunset. but yea im sure there are tons of ignorant ppl out there who dont understand the depth of AFI, be it their old stuff or their new stuff
@GreyShadowUchiha actually i can understand that stuff, i can relate to it, and i think its deep/meaningful. thats not to say that the older albums, like black sails and art of drowning, didn't have decent lyrics. you do know its entirely possible to appreciate AFI's newer work without taking anything away from the older stuff? i can honestly say the only AFI album I had really no interest in is the latest one, crash love
@GreyShadowUchiha i could say the same about you, personally i understand all the lyrics to most of their songs...you can't say any of their lyrics have less meaning and in the same sentence tell others they can't say the same about the old afi's lyrics without making yourself sound like a hypocrite
this is by far their most complete album top to bottom, but my fav songs our on open your eyes and shut ur mouth. That album has arguably their best songs.
6.sing the sorrows (i love sing the sorrows but i love the other albums more there isn't an album i hate)
and it's kinda of a tie for crash love and DU i like them but they aren't that good and for all the ones i didn't put (dork, all hollows ep, A fire inside ep, and the others im not sure where to put them but i love them all)
It means whatever it means to you :) Davey has said he intentionally writes in a way that isn't very specific, so you can interpret it the way you like. =]
This song is beautiful. One of my favourite albums.
All of AFI's cds have been great. They are an amazing band and everyone who is hating on decemberunderground just needs to understand that they have changed their sound due to the music era we're in now and because of their own life situations. Still no matter what, AFI is uncomparable to any other band.
I completely understand why AFI fans dont like their newer stuff, i.e; Decemberunderground But their newer music is in every aspect better structured, better composed music. Plus Davey has a terrific singing voice and a great scream This punk yelling or whatever it is doesn't sound good at all to me. Whatevs, im just bored atm. Please don't bitch at me. It's just an opinion, ok? Im not dissing old AFI Just saying I prefer their newer stuff And Blaqk Audio. Give it a chance, people! Thanks :)
You basically gave us the definition of punk- simple, repeating guitar riffs with simple drum patterns. The vocals are often of not much skill. And that's why I like it. Punk bands make music for the love of it, like the way I do with my punk band. It also proves that you can be simple but still sound good. I wrote a really good song using total 5 chords, all E=A+2. It's a type of music that will never die. Don't offend it.
yeah dude this is their best composed album, maybe not the most versatile, that would be AOD, everything from smile to morningstar in AOD, they are very experimental in that album but this one is best, hence the name
Miss Murder? Really? That's the only one people ever like. It pisses me off. They have so much better stuff.... Like this. I personally prefer Sing the Sorrow, but this one is closely following. All Hallow's or TAOD is next.
nah. it goes answer. very proud of ya. shut your mouth. all hallows e.p. black sails. taod. and after that the whole band died in a horrible sex change operation.
A straight edger complaining about cigarette smoke! I like the old AFI albums, but they sound like such nancies when they whine about Nyquil, aspirin, and second hand smoke. Straight edge blows.
ColtonMcBonesHeil 1 week ago
what i thought loads of people loved DU it's a great album so is "shut your mouth" and this is a really good one also crash love is good most of them are great albums
thebaconflapsable 1 week ago
CU, I wasn't too crazy about, but I have to admit I gained a greater respect for AFI when I realized they were attempting to incorperate literary themes into the music itself--almost as an experiment to change it up or do something new with their music. Frankly, it's probably one of the reasons I've been listening to them for so long.
utubesux222 3 weeks ago
Frankly, I'm not a huge fan of cultural or marketing spin when it comes to any artist. And as for any artist, I don't believe their work should remain exclusive to one genre. It seems in almost any other craft, from literature, painting, sculture, acting, or film, an artist is praised for their ability to have greater range outside a singluar, narrow, genre. All except for music, where the artist is insulted for "selling out." It's babish, in my opinion.
utubesux222 3 weeks ago
This song is so sad..yet so beautiful..and so fucking true. God I love classic AFI.
ac1dchr15t 3 weeks ago
DU isn't a bad album. All of the songs are good (except for Miss Murder, it just doesn't fit, and Affliction's outro, sounds like something from Grey's Anatomy), and the sounds are interesting enough. It just doesn't compare to Sing the Sorrows sincerity, that awesome earthy tone of the instruments, and just the mood and flow of the album's tracks. I honestly think because DU was so "poppy", it lost prestige just because of that. CL is a good album, better than DU in my opinion - It was sincere.
FamiPunk 2 months ago 4
@FamiPunk I like DU better than CL but I give you a thumb up (I don't really mind when people talk about puns in parentheses). Sing the Sorrow is honest like you say.
513986916 1 month ago
yo if you like "AFI" and there older hardcore shit
you"ll digg these dudes
Kids Carry Germs
i found there shit on facebook, it reminds me of afi during this era
hllwnevil 5 months ago
'if only pure sweetness was offered, what's this bitter taste in my mouth?"
sickmicbiscuit 5 months ago
@sickmicbiscuit Why's this bitter taste left in my mouth*
xXEnkilXx 5 months ago
@xXEnkilXx lol at this pwnage i still say then whys this bitter taste left in my mouth.
willbirkin666 1 month ago
What an amazing song!
CALLOFDUTYFREAK2001 5 months ago
Everyone shut the fuck up. AFI is afi, and that is it.
5678FUCKTHEUSA 5 months ago in playlist AFI mix by youtube
i wish there were a video for this song
alexinsc2008 5 months ago
this is a great song to bounce my tits to
impuri7y 6 months ago 2
@impuri7y I really hope you're a chick so this comment isn't gay: I fucking love you.
Rush165 6 months ago
Man, that last bit kinda makes me wish Dexter did backing vocals either for more of the song or on more songs than just the 2. Dexter and older AFI oddly enough seem to compliment each other. But...that could just be me being an Offspring fan for the past 13 years, lol.
SpanishFly120 6 months ago 3
Amazing song
stevetomesco88 6 months ago
i knew that the backing vocals sounded like dexter holland. it is him.
Madadict 7 months ago
Dexter Holland from Offspring in backing vocals :D
sobrexposicion 7 months ago
~Just going to join the debate~
I love Decemberunderground. It's a magical album, I really love it. But I also love ATASF, VPOY, SYMAOYE, BSITS, TAOD, STS and CL. I have to admit, CL is by far my least favorite, it's an amazing album, but I don't know. It's like I know you can't define AFI, but it seems a little out of place, like it's not the sort of music the band should be making. But that's just my opinion, and if the band's happy I'm happy.
Norris3MCR 8 months ago
@Norris3MCR Because they've gotten lazy, they didn't even write the songs together on CL they put together a bunch of pre-written shit, Having said that though, I enjoy the shit they out together, not as much as this though
AtomicRichie 7 months ago
@AtomicRichie right, Jade and Davey wrote the songs together like they always do, and what do you mean "pre-written shit" they never go into the studio before writing
canesrule96 7 months ago
@canesrule96 I don't know man I was drunk
AtomicRichie 7 months ago
@AtomicRichie No drinking and posting
canesrule96 7 months ago
@canesrule96 lol my bad
AtomicRichie 7 months ago
@AtomicRichie lol I was just being a smart ass
canesrule96 7 months ago
@Norris3MCR i think you should give crash love another shot i love all there albums since 92 as well but crash love and decemberunderground are really underated i love those albums so much all though sing the sorrow and black sails are my faves out of the older ones i think shut your mouth and open ur eyes is the worst to be honest besides a single second the rest of the album just doesnt do it for me but i love all there work including the rare demos and unreleased songs from both projects
willbirkin666 4 months ago
@willbirkin666 Yeah, I really love Decemberunderground and agree that it's underrated, I think people looked at how Davey's appearance had changed and made a snap judgement about the album, which is unfortunate because that album is an amazing piece of work, and I love it to bits. I do love Crash Love, it's just not something I would have seen AFI making, other than songs from it's B-Sides. I do love the songs from the record, they just seem like they aren't as AFI ey as the B-Sides :}
Norris3MCR 4 months ago
@willbirkin666 I agree...it's not recorded as well as "Answer That..." Neither is "Very Proud..!"
513986916 1 month ago
@Norris3MCr Well davey said in the crash love interview before the album came out that the album is gonna be way different sounding then any album theve done but they think its one of the best works theyve done and I agree the album is beautiful.
willbirkin666 4 months ago
afi didnt mature they went and got gay.
APlike2skate 8 months ago
@APlike2skate lmao, no
iYaoiPanda 1 month ago
what´s the meaning of this song?
onceuponatime55 8 months ago
I still have a shirt i bought at a party where AFI was playing. Its was a Friday night so they didnt have school the next day.
hillkid101 9 months ago
Do your research guys. Davey had nothing to do with the fact that AFI isn't a great band anymore. And by "had nothing to do with" I mean it wasn't his fault. He either had to give up the screaming and wailing that we all know and love.. Or lose his voice, permanently. So, yeah. They do suck now. But quit being 15 year old girls about it. Stick to The Art of Drowning and before and you'll be just fine.
ch4dz0r 11 months ago
Old AFI is better. Havoc is looking more and more queer with every new album...
chris2004cdm 1 year ago
@chris2004cdm he actually looks like a guy now though
ArmyofTodd 9 months ago
Decemberunderground is their only decent album featuring their 'new' sound. I'd rather listen to everything from The Art of Drowning and before.
Phoenixsinger93 1 year ago 3
@Phoenixsinger93 Sing the Sorrow is 100x better then decemberunderground.
squarepumplenumber2 1 year ago 18
@squarepumplenumber2
I don't know about that...I think they're about the same as far as quality goes. I love StS because it's so atmospheric but DU is so crisp and has such an interesting soundscape. You can listen to DU and find new stuff in it each time. Now Crash love is pure shi**. JK, I was surprised to see how many people enjoy it. So I just gave up on ranking the albums as far as musicianship goes.
FeelingFreshSon 4 months ago
I appreciate how they change because it gives me more motivation to express myself as I evolve.
513986916 1 month ago
@squarepumplenumber2 Sing the Sorrow is probably the best album out there to date imo if you wanna even go that far :D
wecosvinosec 3 weeks ago
@wecosvinosec HOW can you ppl even say shit like Crash Love or Sing the Sorrow are their best albums?? Black Sails puts both of those to shame. But I guess you were still crawling around in your emo diapers when this album was out
JesterEve 3 weeks ago
Dexter Holland and Davey Havok make this song 10x more awesome.
shadupp 1 year ago
this is music with heart
OuikariSoulfiah 1 year ago
i saw afi at club 513 in atlanta on euclid ave. when this album first came out and it is one of my best memories any one who is also from atl and remembers this show i would love to hear about it
uxorialkopaka 1 year ago
hahaha i love the way that despite the potentially deep lyrics the song is really about nothing more than smoking a clove cigarette
blackbubblegum47 1 year ago
@blackbubblegum47 who the hell are you? sorry but these lyrics aren't potentially deep they are
helloieatchicken 1 year ago
@helloieatchicken i didnt mean that they aren't deep i just meant that they could be interpreted any number of different ways, some of which are "profound", i personally think they are and love all afi's lyrics(even the crash love ones :P)
blackbubblegum47 1 year ago
@blackbubblegum47 i see know
helloieatchicken 1 year ago
i like afis old stuff alot better now they arent as hardcore
ZEEBOTDOT 1 year ago
if only time and money never changed people or bands....we'd still have the badass version of AFI....not this 80's lookin J-pop style dudes that have kinda forgot what road they were supposed to be on....can only hope one day they go back to being badass(im a fan and all..but i honestly cant bring myself to listen to december underground...infront of people)
BlakeTahoe 1 year ago
@BlakeTahoe If you'd stop watching and listening to gay porn you might enjoy everything AFI.
haiguizeify 1 year ago
@haiguizeify great reply....must have taken a lot of brain power on that one....just next time...atleast TRY to be witty or hurt my feelings haha, have a great and glorious day my friend
BlakeTahoe 1 year ago
ok for life of me i cant hear dexter holland's vocals on this. i think I can maybe hear him in prayer position, but i cant pick him out here. anybody knows what he sings?
MBIIdollaBill 1 year ago
@MBIIdollaBill end chorus they switch off. listen for it!
michaelstraley 1 year ago
@michaelstraley thanks! davey did some backing vocals on a few offspring songs, i hear. you have any idea which ones?
MBIIdollaBill 1 year ago
@MBIIdollaBill offspring covered on of their songs its on me myself and irene. its pretty cool I played it twice while watching the credits
outlaw45cal 1 year ago
@outlaw45cal haha thats so sweet... i gotta check it out
MBIIdollaBill 1 year ago
@MBIIdollaBill no idea, sorry!
michaelstraley 1 year ago
@MBIIdollaBill no idea, sorry!
michaelstraley 1 year ago
@michaelstraley haha yup i finally found dexter in this song :P
MBIIdollaBill 1 year ago
1) Listen to the song 2) Determine if you liked it 3) Tell yourself "i can go on without leaving a comment"
subterranean75 1 year ago 3
ahh, the pre-sellout days, how I miss thee
jugwinedrunk 1 year ago
@jugwinedrunk AFI is one of the few bands that has changed their sound dramatically without selling out. I dont know about you but I dont see teenage girls walking around screaming "i love davey havok!" that dubious honor is usually reserved for the likes of justin bieber
MBIIdollaBill 1 year ago
@MBIIdollaBill wrong. new afi is bullshit
bearblaster420 1 year ago
@bearblaster420 oh wow you have me convinced.
MBIIdollaBill 1 year ago
The progression in their sound is obvious when you listen to their albums in order. The changes just got a little bigger with each album. But the change in sound from whatever came before this, to this, to art of drowning, to sing the sorrow, is pretty logical. They slowly progressed away from punk and into rock.
EpsilonX 1 year ago
LOL at the "horse semen" comment.
Max8Jizzy 1 year ago
dexter!! offspring!
bongtoker420 1 year ago
@bearblaster420 i for one have always loved afi, new and old. theyre new stuff id good. so dont knock it, a real fan of any band will accept the changes a band goes through, not just be a closed-minded jerk.
wackogoalie30 1 year ago 2
beautiful song....afi always.<3
lynda245 1 year ago
goddammit ppl you guys keep on going on and on about new AFI! if you wanna bash them at least dont do it here. this video has nothing to do with the new AFI. Even then, you shouldnt, because that music is just as good as the old. All bands change, and remember, they made the same kinda stuff for 4 albums. If you count the total number of bsides, that equals to 1 album so how can you expect AFI NOT to change after 5 albums? AFI doesnt only do music for the fans, they do it more so for themselves.
a7xfan208 1 year ago 4
@a7xfan208 fuck yeah man
shibilski 1 year ago
this is when AFI started to get awesome musically and lyrically
EmptyOblivion32 1 year ago
One the best bands ever
DaviHavoc09 1 year ago
i listened to this album nonstop for a goood portion of my life. nothing will have the emotional connection i have with this album
theroacheater 1 year ago
Best afi song actually. Never been better...
Reneguez04 2 years ago 2
Fkn incredible voice this guy.
microsoftbighard 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is when AFI was actually good. Theyre a buncha pussies now.
RCondon828 2 years ago
@RCondon828 and wot would u no a bot that there just as good now as they wre then
3drowninglessons 1 year ago
i hate when people say "AFI has matured because their lyrics are more meaningful now" yeah i can say they matured their lyrics from their first album till now but when people say that they mean that sts du and cl have the most meaningful lyrics. r u kidding me? These lyrics mean sooooooooooo much more then broken radios playing suicide (not bashing on end transmission, awesome song) but really? just cuz u cant understand this stuff until u look it up doesnt mean it doesnt hav a meaning
GreyShadowUchiha 2 years ago 42
Thank you for saying this. That's the truth right there.
Valecita483 2 years ago 4
The lyrics on But home is nowhere... is awesome!!
Louis390 1 year ago
@Louis390 to true
3drowninglessons 1 year ago
@GreyShadowUchiha: I agree with you, Art of Drowning, Black Sails, and Shut your Mouth and Open Your Eyes have awesome, awesome lyrics. Even some of Very Proud of Ya, too. There is def evidence of some intense concepts in VPoY.
"I'm detached from you completely." - He Who Laughs Last YEAH, totally amazing concepts.
I think when people say they've matured, they're talking more bout the music style. I mean, AFI didn't even KNOW how to play instruments when they started, ha.
Love this song.
iloveroxasaxeldemyx 1 year ago 5
@GreyShadowUchiha nobody said their old shit doesnt havent meaning, at least not this album and art of drowning.
MBIIdollaBill 1 year ago
@MBIIdollaBill believe me many people i know do.
GreyShadowUchiha 1 year ago
@GreyShadowUchiha well i meant ppl here who actually searched for a very specific song from black sails in the sunset. but yea im sure there are tons of ignorant ppl out there who dont understand the depth of AFI, be it their old stuff or their new stuff
MBIIdollaBill 1 year ago
@GreyShadowUchiha you could say the samething thing for broken radios playing suuicide, any idea what davey is reffering too?
fresh098 1 year ago
@GreyShadowUchiha actually i can understand that stuff, i can relate to it, and i think its deep/meaningful. thats not to say that the older albums, like black sails and art of drowning, didn't have decent lyrics. you do know its entirely possible to appreciate AFI's newer work without taking anything away from the older stuff? i can honestly say the only AFI album I had really no interest in is the latest one, crash love
MBIIdollaBill 1 year ago
@GreyShadowUchiha i could say the same about you, personally i understand all the lyrics to most of their songs...you can't say any of their lyrics have less meaning and in the same sentence tell others they can't say the same about the old afi's lyrics without making yourself sound like a hypocrite
DarkJoker7 1 year ago 2
The backing vocals at 3:45 are done by dexter holland of the offspring
schumisenna 2 years ago 7
@schumisenna thank you i was wondering when he sings!
MBIIdollaBill 1 year ago
@schumisenna About the only good thing the Offspring did.....
xXEnkilXx 5 months ago
@xXEnkilXx no way the offspring are a great band
goneaway1989 5 months ago
@goneaway1989 I'm going to have to strongly disagree.
xXEnkilXx 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@goneaway1989 I'm going to have to strongly disagree.
xXEnkilXx 5 months ago
this is by far their most complete album top to bottom, but my fav songs our on open your eyes and shut ur mouth. That album has arguably their best songs.
Joker8815 2 years ago 3
ive finally decided this is my favorite album by afi, it was such a hard choice between this at of drowning and sing the sorrow
GreyShadowUchiha 2 years ago 3
@GreyShadowUchiha yea those are my top 3 but i think i put sing the sorrow on top, and now i gotta decide between AoD and BSiS for 2nd place
MBIIdollaBill 1 year ago
this is my favorite album by these guys.
TheMattSpaulding 2 years ago
have you ever heard more emotion!? this is fantastic guys
freedominsomalia 2 years ago 4
true...
Reneguez04 2 years ago
i miss cloves.
xphoenixdownx 2 years ago 4
Listening to Decemberunderground is like having 40 gallons of horse semen being pumped into your asshole every 4 minutes.
Nah, i'm just fuckin' with you, it's great.
Oooooh, i'm gonna get a lot of hate mail for that one.
:D
fudgemonkeyz79 2 years ago 92
o i was about to say the stuff felt great then from they where puunk to wat they r now is alll good
zalozane 2 years ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 decemberunderground was a terrible album. davey seemed to have lost his powerful singing ability and relies on screamo vocal tricks.
owl316 2 years ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 that's a rate of 10 gallos per minute
gorbitronalpha 1 year ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 No you're right with your first statement. DU IS WANK, bring back the classic
DaveyH123 1 year ago
@DaveyH123 idiot he was just kidding and AFI is still as awesome as before
AFIfan96 1 year ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 you are correct that album sucked ass!
djpamb 1 year ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 It did suck dude. Not even the same band
300Mhz 1 year ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 factual statement.
A FIRE INSIDE is dead.
among faggots international is the new afi. and these pussy tween bitches think they're music is better than ours.
bearblaster420 1 year ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 hahaha why the 49 thumbs up
helloieatchicken 1 year ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 i think the horse semen comment was right on...old school afi is untouchable tho
soldiersaint777 1 year ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 dude, i woild like to pump 40 gallons of horse semen into your ass. prick.
demonkitsune31 1 year ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 ohhh.... youre just kidding... sorry
demonkitsune31 1 year ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 Thats 10 gallons per minute!
SaddestGray 7 months ago 2
@fudgemonkeyz79 your freaken duisgusting
AFIrockshard 7 months ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 dont kid, decemberunderground is that horrible
jalbertbowdenii 6 months ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 dont kid, decemberunderground is that horrible
jalbertbowdenii 6 months ago
@fudgemonkeyz79 you're so funny, everyone likes you now -__-
Aris94 6 months ago
<3 <3
bestswedish 2 years ago
i miss his bsits scream :(
xhavoknightmarex 2 years ago 5
I like davey's new hair style. good look on him.
brokenluciddream 2 years ago
1. Answer that and stay fashionable
2.Shut your mouth and open your eyes
3.very proud of yah
4.art of drowning
5.black sails in the sunset
6.sing the sorrows (i love sing the sorrows but i love the other albums more there isn't an album i hate)
and it's kinda of a tie for crash love and DU i like them but they aren't that good and for all the ones i didn't put (dork, all hollows ep, A fire inside ep, and the others im not sure where to put them but i love them all)
AFIForever1 2 years ago
Amazing song. I just ordered this album online. Hopefully I'll get it soon.
xringarcher1440 2 years ago
where'd you order it from?
AFIForever1 2 years ago
Comment removed
xringarcher1440 2 years ago
daveys greatest piece of poetry right here, in my opinion
yoitssteve 2 years ago 2
catharsis is relieving or expressing emotions through music...something like that.
dash5775 2 years ago
It means to exorcise your dislikes/fears by confronting them.
xburningheavensx 2 years ago
actually it means to be clean.
nothing to do with confrontation.
negativecreep888 2 years ago
It means whatever it means to you :) Davey has said he intentionally writes in a way that isn't very specific, so you can interpret it the way you like. =]
This song is beautiful. One of my favourite albums.
carlybea 2 years ago
what the fucks a catharsis anyway?
MaliceandScars 2 years ago
Look It up in the dictionary
cheezymeltz 2 years ago 4
i think its the thing jesus was killed on or sumthing. or some breed of cactus.
stormcloud0330 2 years ago
that's called a crucifix, haha
beetlebrows 2 years ago 2
relieving emotions
canesrule96 2 years ago 2
i think its like the purging of emotions like canesrule96 said
TeenageDeathGirl337 2 years ago 3
I love the intro! I love all their music but i pefer music from this album and newer.
Darkflame4ever2009 2 years ago 2
and newer? ugh.... OLDER the new shit is ass-rapingly-bad
ColeJones83 2 years ago
hahah true
MaliceandScars 2 years ago
My favorite AFI song of all time.
VITALbeachh 2 years ago 4
lovecandi couldnt of said it better
yoitssteve 2 years ago
one of the best songs ever from AFI,really really touching,thanks for posting this :-))
xAFIxDaveyx22 2 years ago
black sails is the best though
angienicole093 2 years ago
All of AFI's cds have been great. They are an amazing band and everyone who is hating on decemberunderground just needs to understand that they have changed their sound due to the music era we're in now and because of their own life situations. Still no matter what, AFI is uncomparable to any other band.
xXlovecandi4uXx 2 years ago 7
i was going to say that. lol :D
stormcloud0330 2 years ago
einfach nur geiles lied :)
evilkitty310890 2 years ago
FILTHofGOD 3 years ago
We have. It sucks.
AdminDan 2 years ago 2
I can somewhat agree with you Admin.
But you must just like punk and im fine with that...
I liked STS, but DU was just not as good. Most of the songs were badly composed actually....
Afireinside912 2 years ago
You basically gave us the definition of punk- simple, repeating guitar riffs with simple drum patterns. The vocals are often of not much skill. And that's why I like it. Punk bands make music for the love of it, like the way I do with my punk band. It also proves that you can be simple but still sound good. I wrote a really good song using total 5 chords, all E=A+2. It's a type of music that will never die. Don't offend it.
richnfillproductions 2 years ago 3
sts and du were ok i dont hate on them, but please dont try and tell me that its better composed than black sails
canesrule96 2 years ago 7
yeah dude this is their best composed album, maybe not the most versatile, that would be AOD, everything from smile to morningstar in AOD, they are very experimental in that album but this one is best, hence the name
blaqksails92 2 years ago 5
1. Answer That and Stay Fashionable
2.A Fire Inside EP
3. Black Sails In the Sunset
4. All Hallows EP
5 Very Proud of Ya
6. Shut Your Mouth and Open Your Eyes
7. Art of Drowning
8. Sing the Sorrow
I didn't put DecemberUnderground on there because I hate that CD so much.
but thats just my opinion.
drumminfortruth 3 years ago
Dude, why is Art of Drowning so low? I personally think it's better than Shut your mouth...
ljey89 2 years ago 3
i know. i love art of drowning
angienicole093 2 years ago
why'd you put the art of drowning so low, give it more credit than that
canesrule96 2 years ago 5
The only reason I looked up this video is because Dexter Holland from The Offspring sang background vocals. :)
Don't hate though I really liked Miss Murder.
tekkenhalo 3 years ago
and ur tellign us why...?
this was their 2nd best album
Deppah0lic 3 years ago 3
Miss Murder? Really? That's the only one people ever like. It pisses me off. They have so much better stuff.... Like this. I personally prefer Sing the Sorrow, but this one is closely following. All Hallow's or TAOD is next.
totalimmortal11 2 years ago 3
Hell man, this record kicks ass, but Answer was probably their best.
richnfillproductions 2 years ago
Answer was pretty good, that one has to be right after Shut Yo Mouth, which is after TAOD. Very Proud was alright...
totalimmortal11 2 years ago
nah. it goes answer. very proud of ya. shut your mouth. all hallows e.p. black sails. taod. and after that the whole band died in a horrible sex change operation.
deadfordays 2 years ago
Comment removed
canesrule96 2 years ago
Comment removed
tekkenhalo 3 years ago