Thnx for the reply! I too am aware n know that Tumbaknaer is a FOLK instrument. @ opus88888 Old man can be too good but the presentation in the vedio is at all not adding to Tumbaknaer's introduction. Let me tell all on this thread that this is purely a KASHMIRI instrument and the same is still in RAW form it was created. The name sound of this inst is perfectly indicating its ROOTS to the soil of KASHMIR. One can say that it travelled to rest of the world from KAshmir not reverse of it. Aahee!
Seems you have mind what I have posted a year ago. My comment is for the total creation of this video and at few places about the player as well. You have addressed me as an EXPERT so I must tell you that the famous songs from Radio Kashmir: Hatai Vesy Charu Nai Log AshkNaras sung by Arti n Shamima Dev, Amy Yery Karnas Bambarey sung by Vijay Malla n Kailash Mehra and Dyaku Doony Mo Phutrav sung by me with Pakistani singer Malika Pukhraj on DD Srinagar were accompanied by me on Tumbaknaer, Aahi
It's interesting to see a Turkish/Middle Eastern instrument being played in Kashmir. The technique and rhythms are totally different, but I'm fascinated. I wonder how and when this drum made it to this part of the world. The silk rout and the eastern expansion of Islamic culture no doubt.
The creator of this vidoe is requested to invite some appropriate player as this vidoe did not add any charm to this subject instead degrade by the poor performance of the artiste n video creator. Hope you understand this in the best interests of Kashmiri folk music which is otherwise so rich and harmonious. Also some misguided ppl have brought poltics into this page maligns the bright idea of promoting the folk music of Kashmir. Blessings!
sajad great work done. This is a real treasure of kashmir and we need to work really hard to preserve this art. god bless you. it is a wonderful work done.
Thnx for the reply! I too am aware n know that Tumbaknaer is a FOLK instrument. @ opus88888 Old man can be too good but the presentation in the vedio is at all not adding to Tumbaknaer's introduction. Let me tell all on this thread that this is purely a KASHMIRI instrument and the same is still in RAW form it was created. The name sound of this inst is perfectly indicating its ROOTS to the soil of KASHMIR. One can say that it travelled to rest of the world from KAshmir not reverse of it. Aahee!
daliplangoo 6 months ago
Seems you have mind what I have posted a year ago. My comment is for the total creation of this video and at few places about the player as well. You have addressed me as an EXPERT so I must tell you that the famous songs from Radio Kashmir: Hatai Vesy Charu Nai Log AshkNaras sung by Arti n Shamima Dev, Amy Yery Karnas Bambarey sung by Vijay Malla n Kailash Mehra and Dyaku Doony Mo Phutrav sung by me with Pakistani singer Malika Pukhraj on DD Srinagar were accompanied by me on Tumbaknaer, Aahi
daliplangoo 8 months ago
@daliplangoo This is folk music, not semiclassical music. The old man is good on tumbak for folk music.
opus88888 6 months ago
It's interesting to see a Turkish/Middle Eastern instrument being played in Kashmir. The technique and rhythms are totally different, but I'm fascinated. I wonder how and when this drum made it to this part of the world. The silk rout and the eastern expansion of Islamic culture no doubt.
Worldmusicrevolution 11 months ago
Comment removed
opus88888 1 year ago
The creator of this vidoe is requested to invite some appropriate player as this vidoe did not add any charm to this subject instead degrade by the poor performance of the artiste n video creator. Hope you understand this in the best interests of Kashmiri folk music which is otherwise so rich and harmonious. Also some misguided ppl have brought poltics into this page maligns the bright idea of promoting the folk music of Kashmir. Blessings!
daliplangoo 1 year ago
@daliplangoo Expert, why don't you upload a video of you playing the tumbak? Show us your "mastery".
opus88888 8 months ago
Hello from a western beginner. Watching your hands is like going to tumbak-school ;-)
What a difference in sound when played with a natural skin !!!
Cucarachabalear 2 years ago
GUD LAD.GUD JOB KEEP IT UP
abidnajia1 2 years ago
Comment removed
opus88888 3 years ago
i said its folk music of kashmir so why did u said india rules , its not indian music but specifically kashmiri music
devilsdiscipline 3 years ago
Comment removed
opus88888 3 years ago
well geogrophically you are right its in india but we have been fighting for our freedom for past 50 years or more from india , so india is our enemy
devilsdiscipline 3 years ago
Comment removed
opus88888 3 years ago 2
Comment removed
opus88888 3 years ago
sajad great work done. This is a real treasure of kashmir and we need to work really hard to preserve this art. god bless you. it is a wonderful work done.
amit
amitkashmir 4 years ago 2
the ancient society of kashmir, has given much. It has lost much. Share, with all. make it a universal ...zone of peace and progress for all humans.
paperlineindia 4 years ago
nice one
shah0123 4 years ago