Re: Pantene Chrysalis

[desertlindhorst]

who exactly plays this version of canon?

[lhanmar]

we'll hoping for making it as a movie...

[Bairindo]

it wuld be a great movie

[2009estie]

r they goin 2 turn this in 2 a movie or have they already

[beerlover5]

i wish to meet her as i am deaf man

[harris1980]

everytime i eat thai food that happens to be too spicy my diareha erupts gloriously pretty much like D-major canon in 0:19, anyhow nice vid!!

[newshhh]

莫名其妙，有几个广告是100% truth？你懂广告，你懂音乐，你做的广告有人看么？

Who cares if you guys working in advertising think this is good or not. This is a successful ads no matter what you say.

[yybarret]

撇除掉聾人學琴的問題，確實是可以靠琴身振動來判斷音準的～只是­你的音準誤差要極小，琴的等級要夠高！很多事情非你專業我想你還­是閉嘴好！就算這廣告誤導好了，阿你是在不爽啥？這麼有正義感，­你也可以拍一部盲人開車啊！

[co8660]

第一,你是聾人,而且學小提琴

第二,你沒戴助聽器,且都是靠琴身振動來判斷音準

第三,你拉的非常好,從來沒人說過你的音準有問題

那麼,你今天所說的"可以靠琴身振動來判斷音準"就非常有說服力­

[co8660]

阿你是在不爽啥？

我沒不爽啊....只是說出我的看法,

請問犯法嗎？

[co8660]

日劇Orang days裡柴崎幸飾演一名小提琴手,因病失去聽去之後也無法再拉­小提琴（這日劇編劇起碼還有一點常識）,還要相信聾人可以拉小提­琴嗎？

小提琴音準絕對是要靠耳朵聽的,而不是靠震動判別！！

[co8660]

小提琴是一種沒有音準的樂器

完全依賴演奏者的聽力判斷音準,

所以,聾啞人士無法學習小提琴

再者,摔壞的小提琴即使用膠帶黏合

也無法再承受琴弦在琴橋上的張力

根本無法再使用

暫且不論演奏者飛揚的頭髮會不會跟琴弓糾結,也許是為了廣告效果

但廣告可以 拍的很美.....卻不能錯的離譜

如果把女主角改成盲人還合理些

[roytchaikowsky]

你這個一點不懂樂器的人收一收聲吧

我不用耳也可準音，琴的震動足夠調音準....

[co8660]

你光靠琴的震動就能判斷音準......

沒聽過我拉的琴就知道我的音不準

的確是很厲害

想來你應該就是那厲害的聾人吧～～

不然幹嘛不靠耳朵聽而是靠震動判斷音準？

我想這種能力應該是連海飛茲都沒有吧？

People always believe what they believe not only me but you......

JUST SAID WHAT YOU THINK BUT DON'T JUDGE OTHER PEOPLE JUST BECAUSE THEY ARE DIFFERENT FROM YOU!!

[roytchaikowsky]

"你光靠琴的震動就能判斷音準......"

是啊...你不行嗎？

[rachelsu]

完全同意。 這是一個很造作的廣告! 創造人完全失策！需要回校深造。

[co8660]

可惜在這裡說實話只會被吐槽而已.......

大家寧可相信美麗的謊言!!

這個寫劇本的人,應該完全不懂音樂吧

[rachelsu]

不但不懂音樂，還有很平庸的品味。

我的專業是廣告藝術，我跟你一樣，作為一個懂樂器的音樂人， 看完這vid以後，我一直在發抖。 哎, 沒有一點兒常識! 太離譜了!

所謂的美麗是攝影師的構圖，而不是這片子的意義。

but don't worry. no one who works in advertising thinks this is good.... thank god!

[co8660]

Thanks God! I'm not along~~

我更驚訝的是,有學小提琴的人也說他光靠琴身的震動就能判斷音準­....無言啊.....

[co8660]

所謂的美麗是攝影師的構圖，而不是這片子的意義。.......­..這句話,真是一針見血 !!

[micchung]

@rachelsu As long as the ad sells, it's a good ad. As long as customers buy it, then it's a good ad. No matter how beautiful or how logical your ads are, if they can't sell or no one is buying the ideas( I am talking about the idea, you do know that ?) . Then we can confidently say that those ads are useless and complete fiascos.

[micchung]

@rachelsu As long as the ad sells, it's a good ad. As long as customers buy it, then it's a good ad. No matter how beautiful or how logical your ads are, if they can't sell or no one is buying the ideas( I am talking about the idea, you do know that ?) . Then we can confidently say that those ads are useless and complete fiasco.

[philipzk]

fantastic ad. and Thai ad. are all amazing.

[hann21921]

Thanks.

[Lance378]

This doesn't really render justice to the original commercial and the message it was getting across...

[candismovies]

this is absolutely incredible and a huge thank you goes to Pantene for this

[1jentoni1]

lol u fucking faggot this is a commercial

[horsegalO1]

omfg wow that is amazing