hmhm you guys should read what Kelly said on her twitter about Amy:
New goal in life is to sing a duet with @amyleeev from Evanescence. Watching her in concert ....she is so intense, a beautiful vocalist, and has great taste in melodies and music. Wow. I've always liked her but wow, such a beautiful spirit and so great.
eemm ... yo amaba a Ben ._." pero luego de ver esto es bastante raro quererlo .. pero .. David O.O My Godness!!! nunca la habria visto haciendo eso ._." ... estoy en Shock(? ._."
And to think, this whole time, while they're having fun and screwing around Kelly didn't know that dick David Hodges was a cheating on her. Poor Kelly.
ok I kind of get why ben wants to cover amy's house with toilet paper(jerk)but what the hell kelly clarkson doing there?she has NOTHING to do with it!
Gee people this is totally fake, they were trying to make some sort of tv show, but it never got picked up. This was not actually amy lee's house. And I'm sure Kelly Clarkson doesn't have a problem with her.
I do like Kelly Clarkson better, but I can recognise that amy lee has an amazing unique voice. You can't really compare them, because they're so different.
Im sorry but amy who? bitch hasnt had a hit in years. 1) BEN WROTE THAT DAMN ALBUM, SO HE DESERVES TO BE THANKED 4 ANY OF THEIR "HITS". 2) KELLY IS AMAZING.......HIT AFTER HIT AND STILL A GREAT GIRL. MUCH MORE CREDIBILITY THAN AMY, IF ANYTHING AMY IS FAKE TRYING TO KEEP UP WITH THIS ROCK/GOTH PERSONA. SHE IS NOT HARDCORE. LOL
Ben did not write the "damn album". Amy Lee was responsible for Bring Me To Life, Going Under and Everybody's Fool. Shocking, isn't it?
Perhaps the "bitch hasn't had a hit in years" because you're too wuss to listen to metal, which Ev's last album's singles were.
Obviously you don't listen to metal well enough to know what "hardcore" is. Screamo, heavy riffs, double bass. That's hardcore. OFC she can't be and isn't hardcore.
Oh, ben... my sweet ben, here's a hint: Amy stills makes money on her music wile you live in a shitty studio. She still kicks yor ass in her own way, with the music, telling what an idiot you are. Ev, the band that YOU came up with is still living on, without you MOHAHA! And kelly: Yor're so fat and ungly i fell sorry writing something mean down, so please just get a hold of anti-blackheads and you'll be fine. Amy could kick your ass with her bare finger, tiny thing. Love EV and Amy♥
This was ridiculous..what's the point? vandalize amy lee's house because of a pic? she doesn't have the fault its the label who puts the pic in the plaque... and kelly clarkson doesn't know amy lee then why did she went? ...ben was a child ... sad thing for me to see...
They both have such great talent. They're too different to compare. I hate when people do the artist vs artist and argue...especially when they are in different genres.
Was that really Amy's house the teepeed with toilet papa. And what does Kelly have against Amy I also thought Dav. and Amy were friends he left not because he was fired but because he was leading Ev. to more christian standpt.
One final note from me on Clarkbitch,..I thought I was going to puke when she said "I thought I was supposed to be the Diva!" Omfg when did this bitch so fucking high on herself that she thinks she's a diva!? We'll see her in the "Where are they now?" files in 3 years and her cd's in the $2.00 bin at Wal-Mart.(Thank God)PEACE! lmao
Kelly Clarkbitch is the product and a puppet of a television show and record studios. She does what she's told and ALL her songs must be written for her because she has no talent.Amy Lee however writes all her songs,music,plays her own instruments and a much more powerfull voice and makes all the decisions concerning Evanescence and takes no shit from ne 1 don't even speak their names in the same breath...... omfg
You're obviously ignorant when it comes to Kelly because she wrote every single song on her last album My December. Clive Davis even tried to bribe her 10 million $ to take out just 5 songs and she wouldn't do it because she's a true artist, so maybe you should educate yourself just a little before you talk. And Kelly's range far surpasses Amy, really if you're gonna compare something compare their writing ability because there's no competition when it comes to there vocals.
Your the stupid fucking cunt, you seriously think she's going to sit there during a Ben Moody interview and say "Duh ya Amy wrote it." Ben Moody AND Amy Lee both wrote the album Origin and Fallen,..They co-wrote and recorded Origin in his apartment and her basement and recorded it on an 8 track recorder,do your fucking homework "CUNT".Search Fallen on wikipedia you will see who wrote what Asshole.
i no it was staged but kelly clarksons a bitch. at least amy didnt need american idol to make her famous. kelly clarkson just took amys leftovers and now thinks shes "a diva"
How did she take her leftovers????? And Amy was able to make a connection, and that led her to her record label. Kelly managed to do that by wowing Aerica with her vocal ability, was considered the most liked/best singer, and then touched the world by releasing singles that she wrote (like Because of you which she wrote when she was 16. And that's just 1/9 singles that she wrote)
wtf is this? Ben fuck u! u suck! This is totally insulting! Kelly's voice is great, but it's ovbious that she sucks like a person. After this, i erased the songs of Kelly that were in my computer. This is unbelievable :S! I'm totally happy with Ben's departure. Ben,fuck u poor piG! EVANESCENCE ROCKS! Ben sucks!
you do realized that was staged and it wasnt really amy lees house right! this was for a tv show they tried to get on that never worked out but it was some friend of the studios house!! so yeah
I know it wasnt Amys house, but, it was insulting 4 her anyway :S! If thye wanted to get on a tv show they should respect other people :S! specially someone like Amy. They're adults, they're supossed to behave like one. That's my opinion.
yeah i agree with you but people do want stuff like that do you think people would be interested in what im not on the plaque o well see you later people want the action of this video but i do agree they should be more respectful
i agree with u! He's recording now with kelly and avril because of Evanescence. If he left them it was his choice, and he shouldn't be insulting Amy that way. It was so immature, even if it was for a Tv show. Ben really sucks =S!
dude ben rocks, hard, amy rocks hard, adn so does kelly. now enough shouting. enjoy all their talents. AND this was a joke it wasnt really her house. :) enough fingthing
1) O please, Kelly is amazing. No one beats her, and she's 10 times more famous than Amy Lee. Amy has nothing on Kelly :p. 2) Ben wrote basically all the music on Fallen, not Amy, she just wrote the lyrics. And with him not being there, The Open door lacked greatly compared to Fallen. Ben= Excellent Amy= OK, Kelly=Super Amazingly Stupendous !!!!
Just had to respond to your Amy,..Kelly Clarkson,thing...10 times more famous than Evanescence? lmao,....do me a favor do a search on Evanescence then Kelly Clarkson,... then let the hit numbers speak for themselves.
Yes. Kelly has many songs all over the world and her hit nubers are greater. Amy only has a couple songs that reached grat success in other parts of the world.
Hmmmm,...you are clued out. Do me a favor, go here " Kelly Clarkson Vs Amy Lee" read the responses then come back here and tell me Kelly is more popular,..of the 1004 votes I think Kelly got like maybe 10 to 15 votes.
Really, because the bunch of one's I checked Kelly led by a lot. And like I said, how many singles by Amy are known in other parts of the world compared to Kelly. I like Amy and I think she has some amazing lyrics, but I personally have been inspired by Kelly much more
I'm afraid you're going to have to guide me to any site,blog or any channel on You Tube where Puppet girl was clearly voted a better singer than Amy Lee. Share this info with all of us...
Those fucking bastards! I can't believe Ben, David, and Kelly vandalized Amy's house! I'm am so glad Ben left Evanescence. Quote from Amy- "It was the best thing that could ever happen for the band" and I fucking agree! What low-life celebrities Ben, Dave, and Kelly are for vandalizing Amy's house.
well I think everyone should listen to Amy's story!!! Amy is both happy and ashamed about writing about Shaun so dont use that against her! And with the Ben thing Amy is being the adult and Ben is being stupid! The next thing is easy! It is that Kelly sux and Amy rox! This was staged but still Amy is geting alot of this shIt really happening to her people should leave her alone!! SHE IS HUMAN YOU KNOW!!
EVANESCENCE ROX!!!!!!!!!!!!
ROCK ON AMY LEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(HARTZLER)!!!!
Kellys music sucks and her she looks like shit in person, ive seen her at The Nations Apple, and the Pololard Hotel, and no I wasnt there to see her shows.
I don´t think amy lee is more famous or powerfull than kelly clarkson. I don´t know how it is in america, but I live in germany, and the only songs I ever heard from them were My Immortal and Bring me to live. Kelly is much more famous! And I´m not an evanescence hater, I got "Fallen" and I really like it.
i dont care wether it was staged, fake or real, its just sick and disgusting to go and throw toilet paper over a beatiful singers house, i mean, amy lee has so much power over america with fans, not even kelly clarkson can stand up to her, i maen, she had nothing to do with this whole thing.
sorry, that didnt make sense, what i meat to say was, ben didnt write any songs, he just sat down all day listening to them, and i think its a real shame that he demmands credit for something that he didnt write, he is a big reck and ever since he split up with the band hes all drunk and drugged, so some people can believe that amy is a bitch or an emo, but all she is, is a nother singer who doesnt deserve to be treated this way.
Scary ennough amy lee has soo much power she can make anyone that she does not like into well misfortune I mean look at ben living in the studio. he use to be able to live in a house but after the break up fans did not like him the same thing goes for shaun morgan.
and you come off sounding like an Amy Lee fan...not an Evanescence fan. because musically to me they were better and different in fallen and origin and all the unreleased stuff. when there actually was an Ev...not backup players then Amy. but i do like TOD also...it's just a different sound. but i wouldn't go as far as saying they are better off...
i know all about the songs..lyrically yes but there's more to a song than lyrics. And Evanescence is not the same without ben david rocky and john. at all.
and ben has a sense of humor...none of it was actually serious. he was making fun of what the media made out the whole situation to be. it's called sarcasm. and if you guys hadn't notice ben moody is slowly becoming one of the most sought after writer producers in the business. so ben will do very well for himself without amy lee and Evanescence, and in turn Evanescence is doing more than well without ben moody
why is everyone all riled up for? if you look at the credits for fallen ben moody AND amy lee AND david hodges all helped write the whole album except 3 songs...there's not one single song that states any of them wrote it all by themselves. but ever since they split Ben Moody gets no credit...and if you notice, neither does David Hodges. both a huge driving force in the whole fallen album, and origin and even pre-origin (and i'm not saying Amy wasn't either, cause she was.)
No but Hello, was Amy's song she wrote it not ben or david and Everybody's fool was also amy's song. And my immortal was written by ben that was ben's song
i AM SO HAPPY HE DID THAT ALONG WITH KELLY AMY IS A BITCH AND DESEVER TO BE PUT DOWN A FEW PEGS ALL SHE DOES IS WHINE AND CRY AND PEOPLE ARE STUPID ENOUGH TO BUY HER ALBUMS REAllY.
you saying amy suck doesnt mean she does, now, if we stop and watch how people act we can see who suck or doesnt suck, and Ben DEFINITELY sucks. About Kelly Clarkson, i dont give a shit
lol That wasnt Amys house who they tp'd, all of this was staged and this was admitted by everyone but i dont wanna take sides because i like both Kelly and Evanescence though David is a bit of a loser
lol That wasnt Amys house who they tp'd, all of this was staged and this was admitted by everyone but i dont wanna take sides because i like both Kelly and Evanescence though David is a bit of a loser
Ben needs to seriously grow the f up. Evanescence doesn't need him anyway. I personally like the stuff written by Amy and Terry far better!! and at least Amy is courteous enough not to flat out disgrace him or whatever in any way. as for Kelly Clarkson.........American Idol is f'n ridiculous anyway....I'm going to toss her cd's out now..or maybe jump on them until they shatter. and was that David Hodges b/c I thought I read somewhere he was in Amy and Josh's wedding??
all of the pple who are trying to defend kelly you all should shut up...as if it was edited that way. of course kelly knew what she was doing? i suppose they super inposed them smashing the record too...kelly obviously must of not known that they did that either...ya right. shes just a sad bitch who is jealous of amy lee because amy is more beaitiful and talented then she is and she knows it...to amy lee!! you rock..dont let those losers with no lives get you down..
oh my god what a fucking load of losers!! big shit like! get a fucking life ben your ugly...and kelly the only reason you sell records is because of your tits....? amy is beautiful and has talent!!
I don't think she knew they're going to edit it as if they're t'p-ing Amy Lee's house. I watched the video and there wasn't any scene where KC talked about Amy Lee. It's staged anyways :)
i swear if i hear one more person go nuts against kelly and ben for this--it's FAKE! if you know anything about a reality show you know they stage certain things, and this is one of the more poorly acted, edited ones; it's more likely kelly had no idea that they would edit it to say they were TPing Amy's house. AND, of course the plaque is fake--they made it for this segment!
dumbass! Ben did not write the whole albulm he wrote a couple of songs witch were Whisper, Haunted and My Immortal. The Rest of the songs were written by Amy Gets ur facts right
Was that meant for me? o.O I'm saying that Ben did NOT write the whole album. And in this video when the woman says "Ben wrote that whole album" is bullshit.
I know he did not write the albulm, thats what i said he wrote Whisper, going under and Haunted the rest were amy lee and his songs and Hello was not ben's song he wrote
f*** them both...he was the idiot to quit...so why whine like a immature beeotch? and kelly? hahaha she got famous by a reality series....real hard work...loser
It isn't Amys house. But anyway. Just the whole concept. So childish. "He wrote the whole damn record". huh. Excuse me, but Amy did half of the job too. :) And why would it be her fault that Ben wasn't on the picture? You did quit the band, remember Ben?
Yes, I know that. Duh. Both Amy and Ben wrote the music. Everyone was so insecure if Amy would would do fine without him, but you know what? I either think that Ben will struggle with his soloalbum. :) 'Cause they did it together. Both writing and the melodies. Amy have proved the fact that she can make beautiful music, even without Ben. But I doubt he can. (...)
(...) We got songs like My Immortal, who is written by only Ben, and we got Hello and Breathe No More that is all Amy's. But the rest of the Fallen material is written by both of'em.(Except from Tourniquet, which is a cover.)
Amy wrote a lot of the piano, yes. But Ben wrote some of the piano and nearly all of the guitar/bass stuff. Amy couldn't play the guitar very well when they were writing Fallen.
omg why are they doing this? because of a fucking cdcover without ben, well he left the band and evanescence is better now, so let him go suck with avril lavigne or whatever he is doing now, and let evanescence rock :p
You know ben is just fuckin immature whine ass who doesnt deserve to be on the damn plaque anyway. Guess what? He's the one who LEFT evanescence. Who cares.. Ev is way fuckin better without him.
And Ben and Amy did not write My Immortal cause even in an interview she SAID that Ben wrote that song by HIM SELF and that is her least favorite song because of that.
Really? cause I am like a major fan of Ev don't see how I missed that but I knew about the whole staged thing but I read somthing saying he only helped write such in such songs but I looked on the Fallen CD and apperantly he did help with more than one.
Also apparently the toilet paper incident was a fake
"A video exists that shows Kelly Clarkson, Ben Moody, David Hodges, and some other people toilet papering what is claimed to be Amy Lee's house (but really isn't). This video was staged as part of a planned (but not released) reality show/documentary." That quote was from the evanescence reference... make of it what you will.
And the chick on the video said Ben wrote all of Fallen that's a bunch of BULLSHIT! He wrote my Immortal and helped write part of Bring me to life and that's IT! That's fucking cunt faced what they did to Amy. Really immature he wasn't in the band no more there for he shouldn't be on no cover of anything cause he left the band on his own. You think there gonna still put you in on things? NO dumb ass.
Ben, Amy, and David Hodges CO-WROTE Going Under, Bring Me To Life, Everybody's Fool, Haunted (which was actually based on a short story BY BEN) Hello and My Last Breath, Tourniquet (with help from rocky) and Taking Over Me (with help from John). Ben and Amy then wrote My Immortal, Imaginary and Whisper.
Does anybody even get that it isn't even Amy Lee that sent the plaque lmao it was THE RECORD LABEL...
Luke19Wales 1 month ago
Wtf, Ben didn't write the whole record. He only wrote "My Immortal" and Rocky Gray wrote "Tourniquet". Fucking retards.....
TheGothicFaerieQueen 3 months ago
I hate Ben
ozbilege123 4 months ago
hmhm you guys should read what Kelly said on her twitter about Amy:
New goal in life is to sing a duet with @amyleeev from Evanescence. Watching her in concert ....she is so intense, a beautiful vocalist, and has great taste in melodies and music. Wow. I've always liked her but wow, such a beautiful spirit and so great.
Guess she has something to explain first...
michielduis 6 months ago
@michielduis
you do realize this was a joke right? They really didn't do that to her house
TheSmirkingGirl6 4 months ago
DAVID? :O xD
Sele2punto0 6 months ago
Comment removed
Sele2punto0 6 months ago
eemm ... yo amaba a Ben ._." pero luego de ver esto es bastante raro quererlo .. pero .. David O.O My Godness!!! nunca la habria visto haciendo eso ._." ... estoy en Shock(? ._."
KTaEv 6 months ago
Comment removed
Etiros 6 months ago
OOOOOOOOOOH SE ATREVEN A PONER CANCIONES DE EVANESCENCE DE FONDO!
MisSnowhitequeen 6 months ago
ridiculous
amandahartzler 11 months ago 2
This was done for a show like punk'd...or at least that's what i heard. lol
xBrokenxPaperxDollsx 11 months ago
Ooh poor Ben, such an idiot!.
It's a shame that he have broken that treasure because he will never have a platinum record on your own.
EvenInDeath13 1 year ago 3
omg! ¬¬ stupid ben moody!!! son of bitch ->(kelly c)!!! xD ¬¬
4mYk3nuM 1 year ago
And to think, this whole time, while they're having fun and screwing around Kelly didn't know that dick David Hodges was a cheating on her. Poor Kelly.
Cynthsam21 1 year ago
Well That Shows What Ben Fucking Moody Is Made Of !
sooo immature , i really hate you ben reaaaaaaaaaaaaally
have you seen people , how he's like a virus ? everything he touches turns to SHIT
kivancis 1 year ago
ben wrote the hole record my ass lol!
Angeltears12 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
Angeltears12 1 year ago
oh hell no!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! UGH!
PutrescentSoul 1 year ago
ok I kind of get why ben wants to cover amy's house with toilet paper(jerk)but what the hell kelly clarkson doing there?she has NOTHING to do with it!
XxPunkxXxRockerxX1 2 years ago 2
what is the song on the background from 1:21 to 1:43? someone please reponse>>>>
evanescencelu 2 years ago
@evanescencelu it's somebody told me by the killers :]
xBrokenxPaperxDollsx 1 year ago
FUCK YOU BEN MOODY and you kelly clarksen, what fuck witts, how pathetic is he
maliceinwonderland6 2 years ago
what that retarded girl is like cos ben wrote the whole album, he fucking did not he wrote my immortal you dip shits
maliceinwonderland6 2 years ago
Eu gostava tanto dele ='(
MrPuffejp 2 years ago
This isnt the actually amy s house, they just wanna atention, but amy don't wast her time to that!
Son of a bitch!
amylynnleehartzler13 2 years ago
invejosos...
tetebe2149 2 years ago
I HATE BEN MOODY
EVANESCENCE 4EVER !
MiGuXxXaA 2 years ago 2
Gee people this is totally fake, they were trying to make some sort of tv show, but it never got picked up. This was not actually amy lee's house. And I'm sure Kelly Clarkson doesn't have a problem with her.
I do like Kelly Clarkson better, but I can recognise that amy lee has an amazing unique voice. You can't really compare them, because they're so different.
LtKnatt 2 years ago 4
kelly clarkson nd ben moody r a mother fuckers
amy lee has class, nd doesnt waste her time doing bad stuff to anyone, like this two ignorants nd stupid persons do..
they do this cuz they are jelous, that's the truth
malchik17 2 years ago
"ben wrote the whole album" wow hahahaha. I dont care if this is real or not. There losers. Kelly clarkson isnt even serious.
xDaddysFallingAngelx 3 years ago
kelly rocks!
marzbar692001 3 years ago 2
Ben... From Evanescence to Kelly and Avril..... Ha. Hahahaha.
EvNerdd 3 years ago
Comment removed
marzbar692001 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yea fuck ben and kelly they are just a couple of loosers are pathetic humans
you can not compare with amy she could kick yours sorry ases a million times if sjhe wanted
evarefan 3 years ago
Comment removed
marzbar692001 3 years ago
Im sorry but amy who? bitch hasnt had a hit in years. 1) BEN WROTE THAT DAMN ALBUM, SO HE DESERVES TO BE THANKED 4 ANY OF THEIR "HITS". 2) KELLY IS AMAZING.......HIT AFTER HIT AND STILL A GREAT GIRL. MUCH MORE CREDIBILITY THAN AMY, IF ANYTHING AMY IS FAKE TRYING TO KEEP UP WITH THIS ROCK/GOTH PERSONA. SHE IS NOT HARDCORE. LOL
marzbar692001 3 years ago
Ben did not write the "damn album". Amy Lee was responsible for Bring Me To Life, Going Under and Everybody's Fool. Shocking, isn't it?
Perhaps the "bitch hasn't had a hit in years" because you're too wuss to listen to metal, which Ev's last album's singles were.
Obviously you don't listen to metal well enough to know what "hardcore" is. Screamo, heavy riffs, double bass. That's hardcore. OFC she can't be and isn't hardcore.
Love Ben. Hate you.
By the way, have you heard his latest album? <3
HollyTheFireNinja 2 years ago
I could care less about ben, im here to supprt Kelly, people saying Amy is better and Kelly. My opinion is i perfer Kelly, thats all.
marzbar692001 2 years ago
Then why did you talk about Ben and Ben only?
HollyTheFireNinja 2 years ago
Simplismente Filhos Da PUTAAAAAA[...]
Ato infantil
naum tem oque fazer
oO'
douglastrajano2008 3 years ago
ben eres un gran invecil maldito
mejor envenentate infeliz
joelrockamring 3 years ago 2
es que ben ya no estab ahi era un disco de platino parece del anywhere si no me equivoco que ofme :/
zeirlee 3 years ago
is just a little idiot baby, poor ben don`t accept the reality, so IDIOT¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
hibaryannwelling 3 years ago
this is FUNNY!!!
Go Ben! And kelly too!
She fucking ricks!
Dorkymiggys 3 years ago
Oh, ben... my sweet ben, here's a hint: Amy stills makes money on her music wile you live in a shitty studio. She still kicks yor ass in her own way, with the music, telling what an idiot you are. Ev, the band that YOU came up with is still living on, without you MOHAHA! And kelly: Yor're so fat and ungly i fell sorry writing something mean down, so please just get a hold of anti-blackheads and you'll be fine. Amy could kick your ass with her bare finger, tiny thing. Love EV and Amy♥
PowerPuffAnila 3 years ago
ha, u just took everything i was gonna say and phrased it better,
i agree 100%,
mcrevnscnsobsessd 2 years ago
lol, i was pretty pissed, was little too mean (LITTLE :P) XD but it was pretty lowfrom ben and kellyto do that -.-'
PowerPuffAnila 2 years ago
"ben wrote that hole record"
he wishes!!
he only wrote my immortal, whisper and haunted's story
AMY RULES!!
(that wasn't amy's house)
FUCK YOU BEN YOU'RE SOO IMMATURE!!
facu2929 3 years ago 3
waw c trop genial
evanescence06228 3 years ago
OMG!!!
I HATE U SO MUCH BEN !
u look so immature!! and you too kelly
youre so fucking stupid do something
with your lifee but well what
can i expect when ben moody and kelly clarkson get together?? yeahh full angry to amy lee because she is so much better than them
im sorry for u specially for u ben u fat man
paolamusso 3 years ago
YEAH BEN FÜCK YOU!!
facu2929 3 years ago 13
just amy is missing in this vid T_T
then it would be the BenxAmyxDavidxKelly Band?!xD
[in my opionion] that would be great *-*
LUSCii0USxLOLiiP0P 3 years ago
I hate you now ben =(
missingBra 3 years ago 4
You guys are so stupid, that's not really Amy Lee's house.
jamieban 3 years ago
This was ridiculous..what's the point? vandalize amy lee's house because of a pic? she doesn't have the fault its the label who puts the pic in the plaque... and kelly clarkson doesn't know amy lee then why did she went? ...ben was a child ... sad thing for me to see...
noiseinsidethequiet 3 years ago
IDIOTS ¬¬
i think that's very inmature xD
trxshdoll 3 years ago 4
They both have such great talent. They're too different to compare. I hate when people do the artist vs artist and argue...especially when they are in different genres.
youdontseeme2 3 years ago 3
My god ... Disgusting. Where is the respect ?
AMY LEE ROCKS guys, not Kelly Clarkson or Ben Moody.
0verTheHills 3 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
KELLY ROCKS,AMY LEE SUCKS
SurferBoy8708 3 years ago
kelly is the one who sucks not amy, you asshole
AMY LEE ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!
alolo2000 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
AMY SUCKSSS , KELLY ROCKSS...just to clear things up
bro0klyn0riginal 3 years ago
This is funny but weird for me.
I could never see Kelly doing something like that so..i dunno
And I love Kelly Clarkson and Evanescence , especially Amy Lee so..ye..hmmmm
People say its a set up or...like the video has been edited...so im not sure what to believe.
rockfairy1993 3 years ago
just to add,.. this show was tapped in L.A. and Amy lives in New York,....That's a long drive in a shitty Van.
skampybumb 4 years ago
LOL!
Cynthsam20 3 years ago
that was not Amy Lee's house
skampybumb 4 years ago 2
Was that really Amy's house the teepeed with toilet papa. And what does Kelly have against Amy I also thought Dav. and Amy were friends he left not because he was fired but because he was leading Ev. to more christian standpt.
vestige16 4 years ago 2
Kelly Rawks I love it lol
Its funny lol :D
BecauseOfKc 4 years ago
It's just a show guys!!! It's fake get over it!
flauwekulletje 4 years ago
One final note from me on Clarkbitch,..I thought I was going to puke when she said "I thought I was supposed to be the Diva!" Omfg when did this bitch so fucking high on herself that she thinks she's a diva!? We'll see her in the "Where are they now?" files in 3 years and her cd's in the $2.00 bin at Wal-Mart.(Thank God)PEACE! lmao
skampybumb 4 years ago
Kelly Clarkbitch is the product and a puppet of a television show and record studios. She does what she's told and ALL her songs must be written for her because she has no talent.Amy Lee however writes all her songs,music,plays her own instruments and a much more powerfull voice and makes all the decisions concerning Evanescence and takes no shit from ne 1 don't even speak their names in the same breath...... omfg
skampybumb 4 years ago
You're obviously ignorant when it comes to Kelly because she wrote every single song on her last album My December. Clive Davis even tried to bribe her 10 million $ to take out just 5 songs and she wouldn't do it because she's a true artist, so maybe you should educate yourself just a little before you talk. And Kelly's range far surpasses Amy, really if you're gonna compare something compare their writing ability because there's no competition when it comes to there vocals.
BloodyRose3000 4 years ago
seriously you're a fucking idiot
you obviously didn't pay attention to the video when that girl says "Ben wrote the whole album"
you're a fucking disaster who knows nothing.
cunt
repentyourselff 4 years ago
Your the stupid fucking cunt, you seriously think she's going to sit there during a Ben Moody interview and say "Duh ya Amy wrote it." Ben Moody AND Amy Lee both wrote the album Origin and Fallen,..They co-wrote and recorded Origin in his apartment and her basement and recorded it on an 8 track recorder,do your fucking homework "CUNT".Search Fallen on wikipedia you will see who wrote what Asshole.
Fukin amature
skampybumb 4 years ago 3
sorry, you're wrong
FisherPhotos 4 years ago
i no it was staged but kelly clarksons a bitch. at least amy didnt need american idol to make her famous. kelly clarkson just took amys leftovers and now thinks shes "a diva"
killthemodels 4 years ago
How did she take her leftovers????? And Amy was able to make a connection, and that led her to her record label. Kelly managed to do that by wowing Aerica with her vocal ability, was considered the most liked/best singer, and then touched the world by releasing singles that she wrote (like Because of you which she wrote when she was 16. And that's just 1/9 singles that she wrote)
BloodyRose3000 4 years ago
at that time kelly was dating david hodges?
adry1790 4 years ago
wtf is this? Ben fuck u! u suck! This is totally insulting! Kelly's voice is great, but it's ovbious that she sucks like a person. After this, i erased the songs of Kelly that were in my computer. This is unbelievable :S! I'm totally happy with Ben's departure. Ben,fuck u poor piG! EVANESCENCE ROCKS! Ben sucks!
evanesrenz 4 years ago
you do realized that was staged and it wasnt really amy lees house right! this was for a tv show they tried to get on that never worked out but it was some friend of the studios house!! so yeah
m0nM0N22 4 years ago
I know it wasnt Amys house, but, it was insulting 4 her anyway :S! If thye wanted to get on a tv show they should respect other people :S! specially someone like Amy. They're adults, they're supossed to behave like one. That's my opinion.
evanesrenz 4 years ago 4
yeah i agree with you but people do want stuff like that do you think people would be interested in what im not on the plaque o well see you later people want the action of this video but i do agree they should be more respectful
m0nM0N22 4 years ago
Insulting for her, What about ben! He was part of evanessance and wrote part of the album then they took his picture off the plaque!
powermeans 3 years ago
fuck ben fuck david and fuck the bitch.....(not amy)
they were being immature and ben has no idea what evanescence has done for him! they gave him a life!
brdancer11 4 years ago
i agree with u! He's recording now with kelly and avril because of Evanescence. If he left them it was his choice, and he shouldn't be insulting Amy that way. It was so immature, even if it was for a Tv show. Ben really sucks =S!
evanesrenz 4 years ago
dude ben rocks, hard, amy rocks hard, adn so does kelly. now enough shouting. enjoy all their talents. AND this was a joke it wasnt really her house. :) enough fingthing
EmmaWismyhero 4 years ago
1) O please, Kelly is amazing. No one beats her, and she's 10 times more famous than Amy Lee. Amy has nothing on Kelly :p. 2) Ben wrote basically all the music on Fallen, not Amy, she just wrote the lyrics. And with him not being there, The Open door lacked greatly compared to Fallen. Ben= Excellent Amy= OK, Kelly=Super Amazingly Stupendous !!!!
BloodyRose3000 4 years ago
Just had to respond to your Amy,..Kelly Clarkson,thing...10 times more famous than Evanescence? lmao,....do me a favor do a search on Evanescence then Kelly Clarkson,... then let the hit numbers speak for themselves.
skampybumb 4 years ago
Yes. Kelly has many songs all over the world and her hit nubers are greater. Amy only has a couple songs that reached grat success in other parts of the world.
BloodyRose3000 4 years ago
Hmmmm,...you are clued out. Do me a favor, go here " Kelly Clarkson Vs Amy Lee" read the responses then come back here and tell me Kelly is more popular,..of the 1004 votes I think Kelly got like maybe 10 to 15 votes.
skampybumb 4 years ago
Really, because the bunch of one's I checked Kelly led by a lot. And like I said, how many singles by Amy are known in other parts of the world compared to Kelly. I like Amy and I think she has some amazing lyrics, but I personally have been inspired by Kelly much more
BloodyRose3000 4 years ago
I'm afraid you're going to have to guide me to any site,blog or any channel on You Tube where Puppet girl was clearly voted a better singer than Amy Lee. Share this info with all of us...
skampybumb 4 years ago
ben moodddy ı hate you plz die. you are bitch. you are nothinf without amy. amy never love you
evanescenceamylynnle 4 years ago
ben SUCKS he and eeryone else that helped him on this vid are just jealouz of the succes of evanescence without him
2RareToLive2UniqueT 4 years ago
Those fucking bastards! I can't believe Ben, David, and Kelly vandalized Amy's house! I'm am so glad Ben left Evanescence. Quote from Amy- "It was the best thing that could ever happen for the band" and I fucking agree! What low-life celebrities Ben, Dave, and Kelly are for vandalizing Amy's house.
BlueLacrymosa 4 years ago
well I think everyone should listen to Amy's story!!! Amy is both happy and ashamed about writing about Shaun so dont use that against her! And with the Ben thing Amy is being the adult and Ben is being stupid! The next thing is easy! It is that Kelly sux and Amy rox! This was staged but still Amy is geting alot of this shIt really happening to her people should leave her alone!! SHE IS HUMAN YOU KNOW!!
EVANESCENCE ROX!!!!!!!!!!!!
ROCK ON AMY LEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(HARTZLER)!!!!
AmyLeeFan2007 4 years ago
Kellys music sucks and her she looks like shit in person, ive seen her at The Nations Apple, and the Pololard Hotel, and no I wasnt there to see her shows.
dearmissedessa 4 years ago
I don´t think amy lee is more famous or powerfull than kelly clarkson. I don´t know how it is in america, but I live in germany, and the only songs I ever heard from them were My Immortal and Bring me to live. Kelly is much more famous! And I´m not an evanescence hater, I got "Fallen" and I really like it.
I think this video was pretty funny.
LtKnatt 4 years ago 3
i dont care wether it was staged, fake or real, its just sick and disgusting to go and throw toilet paper over a beatiful singers house, i mean, amy lee has so much power over america with fans, not even kelly clarkson can stand up to her, i maen, she had nothing to do with this whole thing.
mechanisumcell001 4 years ago
sorry, that didnt make sense, what i meat to say was, ben didnt write any songs, he just sat down all day listening to them, and i think its a real shame that he demmands credit for something that he didnt write, he is a big reck and ever since he split up with the band hes all drunk and drugged, so some people can believe that amy is a bitch or an emo, but all she is, is a nother singer who doesnt deserve to be treated this way.
mechanisumcell001 4 years ago
Scary ennough amy lee has soo much power she can make anyone that she does not like into well misfortune I mean look at ben living in the studio. he use to be able to live in a house but after the break up fans did not like him the same thing goes for shaun morgan.
AkatsukiLeader02 4 years ago
It was stagewd ok if that was true I would have asked to come along keely clarkson and ben moody rule.
AkatsukiLeader02 4 years ago
of course this is staged, those people who think it's real are idiots
repentyourselfaway08 4 years ago
you know that this was staged, right?
luv2cheer395 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Kelly is a Bitch (Y)
KizakiFlores 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
kelly you are bitch
hauntEd04 4 years ago
what stfu amy lee is a bitch for not adding him when he actually help make that album.
AkatsukiLeader02 4 years ago
he got ou of the band cause he had drink problem, duh!
if u dont know the story then STFU!
IrisVampyria 4 years ago
those who are saying kelly is a bitch, you are the real bitches..
repentyourselfaway08 4 years ago
that's hilarious. "A Moment Like Thissssssss...." lmfao!!
SillyDawnOwnsMe 4 years ago 2
and you come off sounding like an Amy Lee fan...not an Evanescence fan. because musically to me they were better and different in fallen and origin and all the unreleased stuff. when there actually was an Ev...not backup players then Amy. but i do like TOD also...it's just a different sound. but i wouldn't go as far as saying they are better off...
ScandalizeMyName 4 years ago
i know all about the songs..lyrically yes but there's more to a song than lyrics. And Evanescence is not the same without ben david rocky and john. at all.
ScandalizeMyName 4 years ago
and ben has a sense of humor...none of it was actually serious. he was making fun of what the media made out the whole situation to be. it's called sarcasm. and if you guys hadn't notice ben moody is slowly becoming one of the most sought after writer producers in the business. so ben will do very well for himself without amy lee and Evanescence, and in turn Evanescence is doing more than well without ben moody
ScandalizeMyName 4 years ago
evanescence is better off without ben david john and rocky. they are so much better now than ever before
evanescencefan1011 4 years ago
why is everyone all riled up for? if you look at the credits for fallen ben moody AND amy lee AND david hodges all helped write the whole album except 3 songs...there's not one single song that states any of them wrote it all by themselves. but ever since they split Ben Moody gets no credit...and if you notice, neither does David Hodges. both a huge driving force in the whole fallen album, and origin and even pre-origin (and i'm not saying Amy wasn't either, cause she was.)
ScandalizeMyName 4 years ago 2
No but Hello, was Amy's song she wrote it not ben or david and Everybody's fool was also amy's song. And my immortal was written by ben that was ben's song
evanescencefan1011 4 years ago
i AM SO HAPPY HE DID THAT ALONG WITH KELLY AMY IS A BITCH AND DESEVER TO BE PUT DOWN A FEW PEGS ALL SHE DOES IS WHINE AND CRY AND PEOPLE ARE STUPID ENOUGH TO BUY HER ALBUMS REAllY.
AkatsukiLeader02 4 years ago
LMAO it wasnt even her house, they acted like retarded little kids.
broken8life 4 years ago
like you are now writing back to me amy sucks kelly yeah...................
AkatsukiLeader02 4 years ago
you saying amy suck doesnt mean she does, now, if we stop and watch how people act we can see who suck or doesnt suck, and Ben DEFINITELY sucks. About Kelly Clarkson, i dont give a shit
broken8life 4 years ago
iyi ki grupta deil... ne mal olduğu anlaşılıyor işte... >:(
lkmsrl 4 years ago
lol That wasnt Amys house who they tp'd, all of this was staged and this was admitted by everyone but i dont wanna take sides because i like both Kelly and Evanescence though David is a bit of a loser
LaurenJH2007 4 years ago
lol That wasnt Amys house who they tp'd, all of this was staged and this was admitted by everyone but i dont wanna take sides because i like both Kelly and Evanescence though David is a bit of a loser
LaurenJH2007 4 years ago
Ben needs to seriously grow the f up. Evanescence doesn't need him anyway. I personally like the stuff written by Amy and Terry far better!! and at least Amy is courteous enough not to flat out disgrace him or whatever in any way. as for Kelly Clarkson.........American Idol is f'n ridiculous anyway....I'm going to toss her cd's out now..or maybe jump on them until they shatter. and was that David Hodges b/c I thought I read somewhere he was in Amy and Josh's wedding??
metalhead027 4 years ago
all of the pple who are trying to defend kelly you all should shut up...as if it was edited that way. of course kelly knew what she was doing? i suppose they super inposed them smashing the record too...kelly obviously must of not known that they did that either...ya right. shes just a sad bitch who is jealous of amy lee because amy is more beaitiful and talented then she is and she knows it...to amy lee!! you rock..dont let those losers with no lives get you down..
evilfairyxxxx 4 years ago
oh my god what a fucking load of losers!! big shit like! get a fucking life ben your ugly...and kelly the only reason you sell records is because of your tits....? amy is beautiful and has talent!!
evilfairyxxxx 4 years ago
I don't understand...
Why did Kelly Clarkson agree to do something like that?
What does she have against Amy Lee
I know for a fact the Kelly Clarkson would never do something like that.
MrLefty518 4 years ago
I don't think she knew they're going to edit it as if they're t'p-ing Amy Lee's house. I watched the video and there wasn't any scene where KC talked about Amy Lee. It's staged anyways :)
atikah8890 4 years ago
i swear if i hear one more person go nuts against kelly and ben for this--it's FAKE! if you know anything about a reality show you know they stage certain things, and this is one of the more poorly acted, edited ones; it's more likely kelly had no idea that they would edit it to say they were TPing Amy's house. AND, of course the plaque is fake--they made it for this segment!
commonsensei 4 years ago
I love this vid it's soooooo much fun!!!!!!! :D
Jaammy 4 years ago
"Ben wrote the that whole album" - Bullshit!
SylvianS 4 years ago
dumbass! Ben did not write the whole albulm he wrote a couple of songs witch were Whisper, Haunted and My Immortal. The Rest of the songs were written by Amy Gets ur facts right
evanescencefan1011 4 years ago
Was that meant for me? o.O I'm saying that Ben did NOT write the whole album. And in this video when the woman says "Ben wrote that whole album" is bullshit.
SylvianS 4 years ago
I know he did not write the albulm, thats what i said he wrote Whisper, going under and Haunted the rest were amy lee and his songs and Hello was not ben's song he wrote
evanescencefan1011 4 years ago
OH WAIT Ben TP'd his own house.. so all i have to do is BURN IT THE FUCK DOWN
donthateappreciate89 4 years ago
wow.. how mature of them all
ben kelly and that other freak all need to be killed what a bunch of douche bags.. haha i should TP their houses and then set it on fire
donthateappreciate89 4 years ago
i love this vid. i thought it was funny. poor kelly. the whole "thing" between her and david hodges is over! anyway, these guys rock!
kinoexposed 4 years ago
i mean he did so much sh.t to amy- oops
aleeksandra118 4 years ago
I HATE BEN MOODY!!! i did so much sh.t to amy
aleeksandra118 4 years ago
it's not amy's house
and kelly didn't break the cd
who did it was ben
diguinhos2kelly 4 years ago
f*** them both...he was the idiot to quit...so why whine like a immature beeotch? and kelly? hahaha she got famous by a reality series....real hard work...loser
amyleetwin1989 4 years ago
Get vote for Kelly! music dot msn dot com/music/artistofthemonth
Kelly is the queen!
kellbellfan 4 years ago
It isn't Amys house. But anyway. Just the whole concept. So childish. "He wrote the whole damn record". huh. Excuse me, but Amy did half of the job too. :) And why would it be her fault that Ben wasn't on the picture? You did quit the band, remember Ben?
froskest 4 years ago
He wrote most of the music. An album is more than just lyrics, you know.
jamieban 4 years ago
Yes, I know that. Duh. Both Amy and Ben wrote the music. Everyone was so insecure if Amy would would do fine without him, but you know what? I either think that Ben will struggle with his soloalbum. :) 'Cause they did it together. Both writing and the melodies. Amy have proved the fact that she can make beautiful music, even without Ben. But I doubt he can. (...)
froskest 4 years ago
(...) We got songs like My Immortal, who is written by only Ben, and we got Hello and Breathe No More that is all Amy's. But the rest of the Fallen material is written by both of'em.(Except from Tourniquet, which is a cover.)
froskest 4 years ago
Amy wrote a lot of the piano, yes. But Ben wrote some of the piano and nearly all of the guitar/bass stuff. Amy couldn't play the guitar very well when they were writing Fallen.
jamieban 4 years ago
umm...you guys...that video is a fake...that's not amy's house, it's ben's....he just wanted some attention
ditzystef 4 years ago
this video is a joke.
thats not even amy lee's house.....its ben's.
amy lee talked about this vid in an interview. she thought it was hilarious that he would go and TP his own house. then...put it on the internet.
wow..ben is so immature.
SenioritaSprinklebo 4 years ago
omg why are they doing this? because of a fucking cdcover without ben, well he left the band and evanescence is better now, so let him go suck with avril lavigne or whatever he is doing now, and let evanescence rock :p
xenianus 4 years ago
As for kelly, Im sure Ben brainwashed her into doing it. If this video is real, Im sure she regrets it all.
XshattereddreeamsX 4 years ago
You know ben is just fuckin immature whine ass who doesnt deserve to be on the damn plaque anyway. Guess what? He's the one who LEFT evanescence. Who cares.. Ev is way fuckin better without him.
XshattereddreeamsX 4 years ago
you're a bitch, not Kelly!
maggonyka 4 years ago
EVANESCENCE 4EVER kelly bitch
malchik17 4 years ago
WOO HOO GO KELLY YOU ROCK
xxkellyfan4lifexx 4 years ago
ben sucks for what he did to kelly!!!!!!!
BobBarkersLoveChild 4 years ago
meant..david ..sorry
BobBarkersLoveChild 4 years ago
fool kelly and ben
evanesunuy 4 years ago
those aren't Kellys good friends anyway to whoever said that :P especially not um the hodge guy HAHA!!
funnykellymovie 4 years ago
Ben's an asshole.
amyleeforgottensoul 4 years ago
weLL done, KeLLy...
yeah you are the best <3
MyRomance89 4 years ago
Big news! It was announced on 04/26/07 that Kelly is going to tour North America in the Summer of 2007!
gymman1031 4 years ago
FUCK!!!
AMY : THE BEST
Kellyy: shit!!!
anagsv 4 years ago
kelly please get some new friends.
hetjaar 4 years ago
And Ben and Amy did not write My Immortal cause even in an interview she SAID that Ben wrote that song by HIM SELF and that is her least favorite song because of that.
DigiGizzy 4 years ago
But I still say he didn't deserve to be on the cover of that. I mean he's the dumb ass who left the band.
DigiGizzy 4 years ago
Really? cause I am like a major fan of Ev don't see how I missed that but I knew about the whole staged thing but I read somthing saying he only helped write such in such songs but I looked on the Fallen CD and apperantly he did help with more than one.
DigiGizzy 4 years ago
Also apparently the toilet paper incident was a fake
"A video exists that shows Kelly Clarkson, Ben Moody, David Hodges, and some other people toilet papering what is claimed to be Amy Lee's house (but really isn't). This video was staged as part of a planned (but not released) reality show/documentary." That quote was from the evanescence reference... make of it what you will.
LithiumLover80 4 years ago
omg, that's HILARIOUS!!!! :D
i love it!! :D
stampnstom 4 years ago
And the chick on the video said Ben wrote all of Fallen that's a bunch of BULLSHIT! He wrote my Immortal and helped write part of Bring me to life and that's IT! That's fucking cunt faced what they did to Amy. Really immature he wasn't in the band no more there for he shouldn't be on no cover of anything cause he left the band on his own. You think there gonna still put you in on things? NO dumb ass.
DigiGizzy 4 years ago
Ben, Amy, and David Hodges CO-WROTE Going Under, Bring Me To Life, Everybody's Fool, Haunted (which was actually based on a short story BY BEN) Hello and My Last Breath, Tourniquet (with help from rocky) and Taking Over Me (with help from John). Ben and Amy then wrote My Immortal, Imaginary and Whisper.
LithiumLover80 4 years ago