Added: 5 years ago
From: enricovids
Views: 209,896
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (264)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Carrie Underwood does an Amazing job , and Brad Paisley is like her best friend for all the things he does for her <3

  • Wtff

  • @swizzleflip10 How wrong can a person be. Stay pressed honey, it's alright.

  • Brad duet with Carrie can't be better

  • Carrie does such a great job!

  • love this song...

    i got shills when carrie started singing

  • love this song...

  • There Is No Point Of Fighting Over Who Likes Carrie And Who Doesnt ... Its Just A Video , And People Should Be Able To State Their Own Opinion . Great Job Carrie And Brad ! Both Allison And Carrie Did A Great Job On This Song ! [: As Did Brad !

  • shes no allison krauss but she sings it pretty well :)

  • Ms Carrie sings with a lot of passion to her heart... she just does....

  • i am a Filipino, i do love Country music...

    most especially the music of CARRIE Underwood!!!!

  • I'm filipina but I love country music. It's just straight on the way they write songs. I appreciate it alot. :) Whiskey Lullaby is one of my favorites now. :)

  • Morons...the LOT of you, arguing on here like it achieves anything.

    Stop bickering and get on with your lives.

  • OMMMYYGGEEE CARRIE UNDERWOOD!

  • this girl does it for me for sure

  • Sounded great to me...Carrie did great....bias is not fair. Of course Alison is great but Carrie is too.

  • @IbnFawzi Why do you feel the need to sound so ignorant?

  • @joponop48: Because it makes me feel tough, especially doing it anonymously online. Just like all the people who gave me a thumbs down feel better for doing so.

    I don't like her at all and think she's a mediocre singer. She has also ruined Randy Travis's song for me.

  • @IbnFawzi I think Randy ruined his own song, if you're going to call ANYONE mediocre, it should be people like Mr. Travis. Carries voice (my opinion, but Im normally right) is phenomenal, she can blow most out of the water, and shes up there with a lot of the big names that have been around for ages. I think shes a breath of fresh air. Young, beautiful, sweet, down to earth, classy, intelligent, and talented. She does seem a little fake/dry to, but thats fine, everything else makes up for it

  • @joponop48: Your opinion is obviously wrong in this case, and probably every other time you impose your own opinion on someone elses taste. In my opinion, and I'm always right, Carrie couldn't sing her self out of a paper bag.

  • @IbnFawzi You see, the thing is I'm not wrong. Not only could she sing herself out of a paper bag lol (you must be like 80), She sang herself straight to one of the most successful careers in country music ...

  • i agree with you. carrie is majorly talented

  • Well put! Couldn't have said it better myself...Carrie is AMAZING!

  • Opinion is not always right, nor wrong

    Opinion is only a point of view.

    Go look it up in the dictionary if you don't know the exact meaning, idiot. And you call yourself a 35 year old. Disgraceful.

  • @CielPhantomhive1: it seems you don't know what sarcasm is. Why didn't you call 'joponop48' an idiot when he said his opinion is always right?.. You obviously don't read the comments, and that is disgraceful regardless of your age.

  • Your an asshole just because she is good and she won American Idol not like you so you can stop being just a jerk just because your jealous and rude dosent mean you have to bring her down she is still the best ... Melissa :)

  • Who am I jealous of? What are you talking about, it's sad when you need to proof read your comments, because that made absolutely no sense.

  • I'm not jealous. Well actually I am. I wish I could get a loyal following of a bunch of mindless people who don't know what talent is to pay me millions of dollars.

    As far as being rude, since when is it rude to not like the same thing as you? I don't like her singing. That's all there is to it. You're the one being rude calling me an asshole.

    I know what you're jealous of: people who know the difference between "your" and "you're" and know how to use punctuation. :)

  • Yea well I'm being the bigger person here and if my punctuation is wrong that's my problem so GET OVER IT and yes she is good and if she wasn't good enough she wouldn't have won American idol k so stop hating...... Melissa :)

  • I don't give 2 rat's asses if you think she's good. I don't think she's good. So all you fucking losers need to get over the fact that I don't like her and stop replying that I'm wrong because I don't like her. Get over yourselves, you're not an influence in my life. Your opinion doesn't matter.

  • Are you kidding me?

    "Because it makes me feel tough.."

    Are you such a coward, to rely on the internet in order to say bully others?

    Are you a child? Only a constantly bullied child would have a thought like THAT.

  • Wow. So I state an opinion, and I'm an idiot, a jerk and an asshole just because you don't like my opinion. It's your opinion that she's good. It's my opinion that she's not good. I'm always up for a discussion, but you guys are just attacking me because I don't like the same thing as you.

    Funny thing is, if you read my comments, I don't attack anyone. It's you people attacking me just because I don't like her singing. And I'm the childish one? lol.

  • "Because it makes me feel tough" is not an opinion, it's a statement.

    And secondly, did I ever state that I liked Carrie? I personally think Alison's voice was sweeter and gentle, matching the mood more, Carrie's was too powerful.

    No, so I don't actually hate your opinion, I just didn't like it when you said "mindless people who don't know talent". If you hate her, leave it at that, don't go all up against the fans, too. If they like it, they like it!

  • ooh i think Carrie sounds just as good as Alison :D GO CARRIE AND BRAD!!! So amazing!

  • Everyone is good. I don't care. : )

    they're still both my favorites.

    Carrie is still good enought to try.

    Even if the original is good, she's

    just trying. : ) I still love the song.

  • Carrie trying to replace Allison on this song is about like Shania Twain singing From this moment without Bryan White!!! Not many remakes ever compare to the original

  • The only way Carrie does this song better is if she is naked and then who is listening to the voice? If Allison was a knock out like Carrie everyone would appreciate her true talent and would agree that Carrie doesn't make the grade on this song.

  • Carrie and Allison are both amazing. I think the three time female vocalist did a great job with this song though, and I think Alison would agree.

  • carrie underwood is waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay better

  • gotta go with bballhottie01 on this one...no chance of matching Alison on this one...Carrie's good, but cant match Alison's version....I bet she would even say as much.

  • nope, she is not as good as Alison....YOU CAN COMPETE WITH THE ORIGINAL...

  • HA! your funny

  • carrie underwood is my fav singer<3

  • carrie couldn't sing a song badly even if she tried

  • this one is much better bc of carrie underwood

  • nahhh... i love this one much better... Carrie has strength, sweetness, and emotion to her voice... Allison has sweetness and lightness to her voice... and they both sound good... but put together with Brad Paisley with a deep, rich, strong tone...i think it's personally better with Carrie... she's got a voice that goes really well with ANYONE... and it proves true with Oh Love, their other song

  • i loved it :)

  • no to good on Carries part ...shes to like you said , powerful :( and i think shes tryin to be

  • Carrie did a good job but I dont think this song if for her. Dont get me wrong I love carrie and think she's a good singer. But I agree her voice is to powerful for this song. Now when she sang God Bless Thr Broken Road with Rascal Flatts was a good song for her. This song is just about so much hurt and emotion and Allison did a better job with it.

  • Much better duet than w/ Alison. Carrie is the better choice.

  • I totally love Carrie but this song completely belongs to Alison. Carries voice is too powerful for it and Alison rules sweet and solemn.

  • Her husband wasnt coming home from iraq... it was during the WWII era.. duh.

  • I love this song and I love Carrie Underwood. Awesome duet!

  • Wow. This song is amayzing but sad :[

    I mean she has no respect doing that too her husband after he got back from iraq. This song really touched me. id never everr do that,

  • WW II...idiot

  • terribly depressing but brillant. i <3 carrie underwood!!!!!!!! they sound amazing together!

  • they sound really good together.... sad sad song tho:(

  • i love brad and carrie!!!

  • After being in Iraq and having my wife leave me. This song hits home pretty hard.

  • IM SRY DUDE THATS GOTTA BE HARD.

  • Oh my god, I'm so sorry. :( That is probably the lowest thing a "woman" can do...

  • that is b.s. man. What happend to love? What happend to women and passion? All anyone cares about anymore is getting f*cked. I'll never understand. Thanks for supporting our country even though that bitch left you. You're a good man. She's just...who knows....good song though. I cry everytime i hear it just because of the way women have treated me. My soul is barried beneath that damn willow tree because of skanky slutty women. Please ladies, just be true to us....

  • its true, i agree with you.... thats all people want anymore.

  • @DobermansRock

    I'm so sorry to hear that  :(

  • @DobermansRock im so sorry she did that dobermans. My friend's uncle killed himself too so i know the felling of losing someone.

  • @DobermansRock im sorry to hear that but thanku 4 serving

  • @TheTailz1 Thanks means a bunch

  • @DobermansRock ur welcome so wat branch were u n

  • @TheTailz1 Army 10 years

  • @DobermansRock thats so cool

    ARMY STRONG

    ~I WANT TO GO MUD BOGGIN AND MUD WRESTLE~

  • @TheTailz1 I didnt mean to hit that button. I am sorry, lol.

  • @joyestephanieg its ok

  • @DobermansRock God Bless You For What You Did!!!!!!!=]

  • @DobermansRock Good on you for serving and fighting for our freedom, she wasn't right for you anyway, you will find the right person one day :D

  • @DobermansRock awh well she dont deserve u then hun xxx

  • @DobermansRock :Over and over I hear similar stories... So sorry!

  • @DobermansRock Tough. I suppose it is difficult for the ones that are left back home as well. But leaving just because you did what you had to do, that sucks. Hope everything works out for tou. Echo Whiskey One out.

  • @DobermansRock

    Thats horrible to hear. Keep your head up.  Appreciate what you do for our country.

  • This is a geat duet man/

  • this song reminds me of my uncle =[ i miss him

  • uh,uh nope nope nope NOPE alison krauss is better

  • to TheRealMarlena, I also have on a disc, I bought called American Idol, Seasons 1-4, which she was interivew by Paula Abdul and she asked Carrie about being one-take Carrie, she said she doesn't want to waste time of everybody, trying to an album by screwing up everybody, her job was to sing and that's exactly what she did. Plus you got to remember she only 60 days to get the album done and out.

  • Yeah I already knew she was on there and everything. My sister watched it a think. I never like to watch it.

  • I like carries voice combined with his. :)

    They sound amazing together!! :)

    I love it, thanks!!

  • eww, whats up with her eyeshadow anyways, nothing compares to ak

  • jealous much?

  • i love carrie but i think alison k. fits this song better

  • double negative lol "not not"

  • u kidding carrie's voice is so much better.

    her voice seems more energetic and not flat.

  • I think that they both sound good. I think that Carrie would sound better if it wasn't with a a bunch of people screaming and it wasn't echoing so much. If it was her on the album I think that they would both sound as equally as good, but that is just my opinion.

  • I agree, they both sound good, if it weren't for that group screaming and audio be a little better, they didn't set it properly for extreme high vocals Carrie has.

  • Thanks, I totally agree with what you said also. Everybody sounds a little bit better in a recording studio too.

  • With Carrie, it doesn't make a difference in the studio or at concerts or even on her albums, to me she sounds exactly all three ways. She is that good, which I find rare thing with artists.

  • Yeah but in the studio they can take breaks and piece it in together. They can breath easier in the studio so it sounds a just a tad better. I saw Carrie at the WalMart concert and she was great. Although I think that Keith was better but only because he gave away his guitar, it was so cool. Anyways everybody does sound a little bit better in the studio but for Carie it just makes her sound that more perfect! :D

  • They did an interview with Carrie awhile back, I forgot when, in that interview, she said she has a reputation of doing only one time completely, and her producer said she did it that way this album, they didn't have to piece, they could almost do the recording at her concerts, they don't because like hear they have people screaming. Same either way.

  • Are you serious???? I think that she definetly could do it but I have never heard of anyone that has done it. She really does it? Now I could ask my dad because he is a sound man and has recorded albums before. When did she say it?

  • Yes, I am serious, that's what producers of her album, called her, "one take, Carrie, the musicians and technicians were one that kept screwing it out, either hit the wrong button or something else, and producers would get upset, they said once started to sing, she so good its like wow. She said on show called CMT "In the moment", she actually didn't say it, it was producers said it.

  • Cool

  • Unfornuately, you can't CMT's "In the Moment" on Youtube, I used but, they dropped for some reason, in case, you don't beleive me.

  • Okay, I wasn't going to go ahead and look into it. I usually trust people until they break that trust or like a just have a bad feeling about them or something lolz. I kinda allready moved on. lolz :P :)

  • By the way you sounding you don't believe me, the way you said I kinda already moved on. How can you trust people that way, when they can prove and you don't believe them. If I knew how to send that disc to you, I would, but you won't believe anyway, so what's the use.

  • No I believe you, I bet you could prove it. I have just kinda gotten bored, so I learned something new now I am moving on. I wasn't ever saying that I didn't believe you. I was just surprised.

  • For your information, it sounded like Paula was as surprised that producers made that comment, I think Paula was just confirmed that for herself more than anything, because Paula Abdul is singer herself, so she probably taken back by that nickname, I guess for singer to be able to do that.

  • cool

  • Omfg.

    What do you listen to when she sings?

    She is freaking AMAZING!

    Wow, just wow.

    I think Carrie's the best♥

  • fine you don't like her but dont delude yourself of the fact that she cant sing. she can and very very well.

  • you dont know good music then!

  • Simply question? Why do you watch Carrie, if you don't like her, is just to make comments about the fact, you don't like, yes, I know you going to say freedom of speech, yea, yea, yea, whatever, I agree people you don't know good singing voice when you hear it.

  • #1.why do you care i'm just text on a website #2.i wasn't watching it my sister was...

    #3.yes freedom of speech i can say whatever the feck i want to say

  • exact response, I figured you were going to come up and say exactly, what a surprise, haha.

  • Is the whole crowd singing along? lol thats cool that carrie got to duet with this song, her and brad are my two fav's male and female artist's

  • I agree completely with you!

    carrie is so beautiful and so talented it´s almost unbelieveable^^

    and brad is the best, too:D

  • they make a good duo... i almost teared

  • i love them dont get me wrong but i still like Rex Goudie and Melissa O'Neil's version a little better . but anywho i love this i love carrie she's beautiful and talented, etc. etc.

  • HEY THATS MY B-DAY 10-27!!

  • what town and state was this?

  • I love this! :D I LOVE Carrie!

  • I just adore Carrie Underwood. She is such a wonderfully talented artist who never forgot where she came from. Just a little farm girl made good!!!! She deserves all the success that she has achieved 1000 times over.

  • Carrie Underwood is such a great singer. This is my fav country sad song

  • beautifully done

  • Awesome song!i love Carrie Underwood, but i also like Allison. but for this song i like Carrie better.