Room 101 - Phil Collins - Part 5, The Gallagher Brothers.

[PauloTheGeek]

Both used to be absolute cunts. Noel seems to have mellowed and grown up now but Liam is still an absolute wanker.

[oasiswhisper1992]

phil collins is a dick nuff said. i just hate him, no reason for it!!

[mikelheron20]

I assume the 21 dislikes are Oasis fans. I'm surprised there are 21 Oasis fans.

[vashna3799]

I can't think of a band that as blown its own trumpet louder than Oasis .Did very little all in america ,ridiculous beatles comparisons , boring us death about Man city , tiresome sibling rivalry . They did release two great albums definitely maybe & what's the story but noel hasn't written a decent song since 1996.

[chipchipchop123]

Number 2 on billboard aint to bad is it?

[beano1eye]

@vashna3799 LMFAO @ did nothing in America, Morning Glory 4X Platinum, 4 million sales isn't exactly nothing is it? how many records u sold in America, fuck all I bet!

[vashna3799]

@beano1eye Your right ,I sold no records in america but than I never said I was the biggest thing in UK music since the beatles either like Noel & Liam never stopped saying . 4 million , big deal , the beatles , rolling stones , pink floyd ,led zeppelin ,radiohead piss over that their record sales ( and none of them blowed their trumpet either)

[Swanbow]

@vashna3799 Importance of being Idle?

[MegaMermon]

@Swanbow Shit

[Swanbow]

@MegaMermon Well, I like it and it was critically appraised, one of their better songs.

[herefordmsv2]

I think Noel and Liam did use to be horrible cunts. They aint as bad now though.

Sorry Oasis gayboys, uhhh sorry I mean fanboys, but its true.

[chipchipchop123]

Oasis lets be fucking honest......fucking .........QUALITY BAND AND BETTER THAN PHIL COLLINS WITH HIS TWO OR THREE GOOD SONGS.

[thelurker25]

@chipchipchop123 fuck you

[chris25wigan]

Fair play to Phil here, he's said he liked Oasis but Liam and Noel themselves can let themselves down at times. I'm a huge fan of both himself and Oasis... Noel and Liam have both had a go at a few people over the years who they shouldn't of really. When there was all this crappy Spice Girls and S Club Shite knocking about they were too busy having a go at the bands that actually had some talent.

[xXgorillazboosh11Xx]

"They think nobody is as good as them"

.......Well thats...well.....true.

[bensimps123]

@xXgorillazboosh11Xx no its not , idiot

[xXgorillazboosh11Xx]

@bensimps123

I know, i just wanted to make a (shite) joke to liten the mood :D

[dilwich123]

OASIS ARE FUCKING SHITE.

[MrHeslopian]

I've never been fond of even Oasis the band. They're songs are as pretentious and arrogant as them.

[paulrkid]

i meant go then not got

[paulrkid]

get over it collins for fuck sake!! the boys have a got at everyone! just be grateful ur not a fat tap dancer from take that lol!

[PhilSupernova88]

OH I WANT THE GALLAGHERS IN ROOM 101 COZ THEY PICKED ON ME IN THE PRESS :'(..I hate them because they vote Labour and made me leave England.

Get a fucking grip Collins you wanker

[MALONEYCAMFIELD]

@PhilSupernova88 Collins has said on numerous occasions he only left England because he started a relationship with a woman who lived abroad. He has also never been a Conservative Party supporter. Noel, on the other hand, only supported Labour in 1997 because it was fashionable at that time (and they promised not to give rich people like Noel a big tax hike) and later admitted that he became completely disillusioned with them.

[tommylanganator]

@PhilSupernova88 Phil Collins is more talented, more likeable and just generally better than Liam and Noel put together and then multiplied by 10.

[gatolocoverga152]

PC is one biggest cunt ever walked on the earth !! but he was a awesome drummer anyway...i mean Im genesis fan

I reconize the gallagher brothers got balls and the reaason why phil fears them

[MALONEYCAMFIELD]

@gatolocoverga152 I don't know any evidence that Phil is actually a cunt. I've heard from a number of people who've met him that he's actually a very nice, down to earth guy.

[gatolocoverga152]

@MALONEYCAMFIELD I think a nice person and a cunt one is totaly different things ....right?

[MarekPick]

@gatolocoverga152 You don't Know what the hell you' talking about because if somebody is a cunt that's Noel and Liam who go around and talk trash while Phil has never said anything bad about anyone. So....get your facts right man.

[Buszke]

@hazelangus couldn't you try reuploading this without the song? It would really make my day.

[Jazios]

Classic copyright bullshit time to go download the whole discography i think....

[fmaterski]

This sound ban merely adds to the truth that the behaviour of the Gallagher brothers is despicable and shit. I think they are a foul pair that are a bad example to all. I don't care if they are made silent, but I disagree that the rest of this show is. Ban the record company, I certainly will make sure they get bad press from me.

[rottendawg]

So they have to remove all the fucking Audio????? You fucking wankers!!!!

[247otaku]

Ok this is B****cks - how can Virgin UK not mind there being a pretty lengthy take from the "Jesus He Knows Me" vid, references to and (albeit only a few notes) a quick rendition of "In the Air Tonight" earlier on in this programme, but as soon as Oasis is mentioned theres a hissy fit? seriously WTF?

[cybogoblin]

@247otaku Maybe it's because they're bad mouthing the 'artists', while both of the other songs belong to Collins and were talked about favourably. Or something like that.

[chelsea3591]

bastard!

[sbtech01]

OH FUCK THESE COPYRIGHTING CUNTS. I'M GONNA PIRATE THE SONG.. NO THE WHOLE ALBUM NOW JUST OUT OF SPITE.

/capslock.

[SpiroEx]

@Rightclick88

Also you're quoting American law about the audio on a British show. Probably posted by someone in Britain. Copyright Law in the rest of the world differs greatly and there isn't a 'fair use' clause in British law (even though a lot of people THINK there is - because it would make sense)

[SpiroEx]

@Rightclick88 Much as I was annoyed that the audio was disabled I think you're missing that this wasn't posted by the BBC and therefore violates copyright anyway.

"for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright. "

Don't say the law isn't the law just because you're watching something which technically breaks it.

[ELREndLondonRule]

FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF­FFFFFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU­UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU­UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU­UUUUckyou Oasis.

[freiheitsalv]

i cannot read lips!!!!!!

[FortisConscius]

So because of a few seconds of an Oasis clip we have to lipread the whole final 5th of this episode? It's diminished my opinion of Oasis and WMG more than it already had been.

Next up: When protecting copyright backfires hideously on the interests of the company.

[ninjatoothpaste]

What I wanna know is who finds out about it being on here and then decides to report it to the WMG?  I'm a peaceful person, but I would punch repeatedly in the face whichever arsehole reports it! It's the British public that pays for this stuff and it should be our right to put it on youtube if we want!

[AngelgirlTri9]

Hazelangus, wouldn't it be possible to remove the part of the video that contains the Oasis song and reupload? It's perfectly possible to find the song somewhere else, but you're the only on who has uploaded this episode :(

[HeyStacky]

I fully approve of removing the audio. Any powers that prevent those Manc Twats from being heard can only be a good thing.

[ant8tfive]

@HeyStacky you obviously have no taste in music

[blewvelvet]

this needs to be uploaded..the sound doesn't work

[01stursa]

Youtube Audio copyright bans should be put in 101.

[DanRaccoon]

No sound? JEW ATTACK!

[WlatPziupp]

"Hey Warner Musig Group! I'm not gonna give you any money, I can just listen to a fraction of a song here!"

Is this honestly what they believe is going on in our heads?

[053bss]

CAPITALISM IS KILLING MUSIC.

[ant8tfive]

why is there noe sound ????????????

[Schumitastic]

I know lots of youngsters who have picked up a guitar simply because of Oasis and I can see why - many of their songs are full of hope and optimism. The fact that this band has introduced so many kids to playing the guitar is more than enough to make them great.

And Phil Collins has never written a tune as majestic and beautiful as Slide Away or The Masterplan, but then again, the ignorant have only listened to the overrated ones like Champagne Supernova and Wonderwall.

[LlamasOnAcid]

@Schumitastic i totally agree with you. i barley listen to any of the singles

[RMoribayashi]

Serves hazelangus right for mentioning a copyrighted band in the title. He should have known that companies like Sony troll YouTube with bots searching for their artists names.

[18jemini]

Oasis couldn't hold a candle to Genesis. They will never be as big or successful or as respected as Phil Collins.

[TheMrbollox]

@18jemini

Tbh most people don't even know who Phil Collins is.

[18jemini]

@TheMrbollox Well if a quarter of a billion album sales, 8 USA number 1 singles, and oscar, 7 grammys, 6 Brits, Ivor Novellos, working with EC, Quincy Jones, John Martyn and countless other achievements including the male solo artists with most platinum album awards in UK, makes you anonymous, I don't know what that makes Oasis, or you for that matter

[TheMrbollox]

@18jemini

yeah but his music is just plain middle of the road rubbish that sells.

[18jemini]

@TheMrbollox Lats post on this. If you get to his albums, there are many great songs, and I mean many to be found. Great musicianship, songwriting and strong on melody-all his trademarks. He has done some great work with Genesis too as well as Big Band Jazz, film sountracks and a motown album.

Oasis are an ok pub band i suppose, but have had little of the success Collins has had and their music is very simple and boring. Thank God they have swaggered off in to the Manc sunshine for good

[TheMrbollox]

@18jemini

Well i disagree. they're my favourite band.

bye

[lemongrapesfilms]

SONY BMG YOUR CORPORATION ISN'T GOING TO CRASH BECAUSE SOMEONE DIDN'T PAY YOU COMMISSION YOU GREEDY

(caps)

[david130653]

@BritRockOasis Genesis may have been inspired by the Beatles, as were most bands that followed. As for the Smiths, they were formed in 1982. Genesis had been going for at least 13 years and 10 successful albums by then.

[plzhealme]

I will never WMG product. Who the fuck is WMG by the way? fuck them fuck their mother and their great grandmother. Fucking fuck them.

[TheMrbollox]

Phils Collins is a tory nazi cunt

[bigpantsjayke]

@TheMrbollox you know him well then?

[DaveSimonH]

oh for god sake, if they are going to mute the audio they may as well take down the video too

[TheHenryCatman]

Hazelangus, if you still have the video, please add subtitles!

[dulume]

This is soooooooo lame... dislike the brother already, now I honestly hate them. This is bullshit!!

[yetigoose]

This is an easy one. Just don't buy WMG products. WMG go in room 101!

[portgas92]

Yeah, fuck WMG!

[SnuzzDotNet]

Crazy. Only plays the clip for a few seconds.

[v8xp88xc]

WMG into room 101!!!

[janlloyd12]

ha ha ha you should be a comedian cuz your bullshit makes me laugh

[mistacoz]

At least it spares us from listening to Oasis (or 'that shower of shit' as I prefer to call them..)

[Vault101Reject]

hang on,that other guy calls them tossers and gets plus 2,you call them a shower of shit and get negative 2? O_o?

[Rightclick88]

The removal of the audiotrack from this video is a violation of Section 107 of the Copyright Act. (fair use)

[knules2]

@Rightclick88 tell them that then

[Rightclick88]

@knules2 i dont think they will listen. because any decent organisation would have read it before just blatantly removing audio from videos on here.

they dont care about the people. all they want to show is how much "power" they have.

[knules2]

@Rightclick88 it would make a difference if some one sued

[rottendawg]

@Rightclick88 YOu fucking wanker!!!!! So you have to fucking delete the whole fucking audio you cunt???

[TornadoCreator]

@Rightclick88

Only if we where the BBC, because we don't own the Room 101 licence.

[gasek62]

That's because it's a violation of the Gallagher Hatred Act which states that only a Gallagher or a member of Oasis can show hatred to the Gallaghers or Oasis....

[Nexius8]

But surely room 101 had authorisation? Shouldn't that be enough

[ninjatoothpaste]

I agree there bud, surely if we actually wanted this track we'd download an illegal mp3 version! So what are they solving? I think by this point all this copyright law and the like, is only around purely to expand the limits of absurdity!

[boomheadshot75]

what the song at 0:08

[spazzing]

Can you put up subtitles/closed caption, hazelangus?

[rugbystewart]

i agree with Lokireloaded, put feckin WMG into room 101

[PaulRoberts]

WMG = A shower of Bastards.

[DanRaccoon]

They're trolls, dun rise to it.

[ordonarc18]

UGH! I wanted to watch this. What is the point, someone please tell me, of leaving the vid up when the audio is gone? What a tease! Can't exactly watch it now, can we? Not unless we can lip-read, which I sadly can't .

[atveracis]

this sucks... probably the most interesting of all 5 parts! and it's got its audio disabled!

[DaveStrife1]

Oh why, just why? This copyright infringment stuff is getting ridiculous.

[Cleopatrastomb]

This is disgraceful.

[cagedkiller360]

WMG is SHIT

[Lokireloaded]

they should put WMG into room 101

[jeffcrapinthehead]

wank. big fucking wank

[youvebeenthunderstru]

You've got to be fucking joking. FUCK OFF WARNER BROTHER CUNTS.

[jcrawley1]

Phil Collins and Oasis - both legends. Let's leave it there.

[fintanio]

i don't know why the sound has been taken off becasue the BBC has a carpet agreement with the music industry.

[2point4childrentv]

It's not the BBC posting the video.

[pw3uk]

The WMG are a bunch of cunts!

[BLAGASPANTS]

Listen, this is how it is. Phil Collins is ass hurt because he knows he fucking sold out when he was in his band. He was part of one of the most unique forward thinking bands you're ever likely to come across ( Genesis ) and he got rid of Peter Gabriel and Collins then took that band and sold the fuking lot down the river. Well and truly a first class cock smith that deserves to ripped to fuck.

And the balding little turd knows it. Oasis on the other hand are fucking class.

[67crow76]

A: Oasis suck shit through a straw. B: Phil Collins is a legend, and you are an inbred little prick. C: How did Phil Collins get rid of Peter Gabriel exactly? Do your research. Peter Grabriel left the band of his own accord and soon afterwards Phil was chosen to be the lead singer. And as for "selling the band down the river" Phil left because he thought it was time for a change.

Next time you want to comment on something you know fuck all about, check to see if you're a moron first.

[BLAGASPANTS]

LOL @ You ... Phil Collins a legend... Get to fuck... that balding turd turned one of the best bands ever into a fucking pop act and he sold his bald ass to the devil with the tripe he has produced.

Take it you won't be going to see Oasis in a totally packed Wembley this summer... LMAO You'll have to dig out some Phil Collins albums and finally realize how wank he was.

Against all odds... what cheesy as fuck song that is. Sad as fuck. Now get to fuck you old fuck.

[67crow76]

Old fuck? I'm 19 idiot. Remember what I said about doing your research? One click and a bit of reading and you wouldn't sound as stupid as you do (only slightly though). Please, I laugh at your attempt to silence me. Oasis sucks dick... period. They think they're like the Beatles when they're really only on a par with McFly. despite the fact that Phil's work got a bit cheesy, particularly with the movie songs, it still shits all over Oasis.

[67crow76]

And newsflash: Popularity doesn't necessarily mean greatness. Look at the Jonas Brothers, you have to agree that they suck but they're still popular. Packed Wembley or not POPULARITY DOES NOT DICTATE TALENT.

[BLAGASPANTS]

If your 19... then I suggest you go and listen to more music mate. Your on here waffling shit about Phil Collins for fuck sake. Listen he sold out, simple as that. Cheesy as fuck. Good drummer, good vocals etc. But he sold the fuck out and he is bald mother fuck on top of that.

As for Oasis, mate Noel Gallaghers song writing pisses all over Phil fucking Collins.. Thats why at 40 odd years of age Phil had to resort to making shit cheesy songs.

Oasis are the boys lad.

[67crow76]

I have listened to more music. And I've decided that most contemporary music sucks. I'm mostly a heavy metal and prog rock sort of guy but I enjoy eighties pop. Yes, a lot of Phil's later stuff is pretty cheesy I grant you but I find that enjoyable, sort of like a corny eighties horror movie. I don't see how he sold out and I honestly couldn't give a shit.

I hate Oasis, you hate Phil Collins. We've established this, let's leave it at that.

[afromanjack]

if u think oasis imitate the beatles then u obviously haven't actually listened to them u've just read whats in the press. u like 80's metal right? type in ozzy osbourne and oasis into google, even he says that the beatles tag is bullshit, and hes the biggest beatles fan out there

[67crow76]

I've listened to their stuff. I just think they're shit. More contemporary crap that doesn't sound any different from other shit that I hear on a daily basis spewing from some obnoxious prick's Ipod. I could be wrong about the Beatles thing but that doesn't change the fact that I think they're crap.

[WTP2k]

I agree with you wholeheartedly 67crow76. I also think oasis suck. If they are such amazing song writers I've never heard any evidence. And I also agree that just because you can sell out a massive venue doesn't necessarily mean your good just popular. Most pop stars can sell out massive venues but I can't think of any who are quality musicians or song writers. I dont like Phil Collins later work but that doesn't detract from the fact he IS a great drummer, song writer and a pretty good vocalist

[67crow76]

Cheers dude, good to see someone on my side for once!

[WarningDontReadThis]

You've got to be kidding me.

[undergroundcat84]

Can you re-post this minus the song please ? I'm guessin that's allowed by whoever the hell WMG are (hopefully)

[meowmoocat]

That's shit, they turned all the sound off

[725pete725]

that yellow adidas jacket that liam has in the picture is mint

[shitstainedb4lls]

i quite like room 101 but phil collins is a bit of an old cunt and doesnt know enough about rock n roll to see that oasis really are fuckin awesome

[mcfcbanno]

what a shit programme , fuck off colins you four eyed fat old twat

[sammmyp]

Liam didnt know spinal tap was a parody! lol

[ASobsessive]

Liam Gallagher is such an idiot. He thought that Spinal Tap was actually real! HA! HA! Doesn't he watch film credits. What a fool. But still how humilating for him! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA! HA!

[ASobsessive]

i think Noel's bad, but not bad enough to go into Room 101. He's a talented music writer, musician and singer and his sense of humour is quite good.

Liam on the other hand is horrible, stupid and talentless. He is a poor singer in my view.

i think Oasis would be a finished article if they had looked at their song lyrics a bit better, kicked Liam out and got Noel as the sole front man of the band.

[ASobsessive]

I can understand why people like Oasis in terms of their music (they are not that good, in my view), but in terms of the behavior of the Gallagher brothers, mainly Liam, you'd put them into Room 101 10 times out of 10. They are the most charmless dickheads in music. I will say that Noel's not as bad. Liam is a complete twat. He's not that good. He's a poor singer in my view. Liam needs to wake up and join the real world. GROW UP! He needs to stop thinking that he's Lennon reborn when he's not

[somerandomer]

might also be something to do with the fact that it isnt on anymore

[johnmadden1989]

oasis have a number one album, phil collins is doing ads for cadbury's, and paul mercer is doing documentaries on japan on the discovery channel. who has won then?

[hazelangus]

The most read book of all time is the Bible. The second most read book is Quotations from Mao Tse-Tung and the third is the American Spelling Book. Popular certainly doesn't mean great! Britney Spears's song Womanizer went to number 1 even though it is complete cack. Chart position is not a reliable indicator of greatness.

[redman8903]

@johnmadden1989 maybe you should look at phil and Genesis's album sales.

[stu17dfc]

fuck off phil collins, fuck off paul merton and fuck off to the crowd!!!!!! wankers!

[hazelangus]

Can tell you're a fan of the Gallaghers. ;o)

[RufusRamen]

Phil Collins can suck it.

[EuchridEucrow1]

I'm getting a real kick out of reading all these comments defending Noel and Liam Gallagher.

Apparently they have carte blanche to launch personal attacks. Yet, when someone like Phil Collins, who while a shit songwriter remains a fantastic drummer, bites back, he's labeled a 'pretentious prick'.

Sure thing.

[flagga]

Oasis kick the shite out of anything that pretentious prick has done

[tomstumpy]

hahahaha god i love oasis

[Lotte25th5]

oasis are amazing

[shadowpuppet89]

oh and talkin bout record sales, whats the story mornin glory 20 million copies sold, be here now sold over 1 million units within two weeks, stats are just endless

[shadowpuppet89]

fuck off phill collins more records sold, and what, who did phil collins inspire fucking nobody, oasis revived british guitar music, and at the end of the day are the greatest rock n roll band to have ever come out of england.

[MALONEYCAMFIELD]

@shadowpuppet89 Phil Collins is well known to have inspired many artists in the American R&B and hip hop community. Check out the CD Urban Renewal in which many pay tribute to him. In The Air Tonight in particular is one of the most sampled records of all time. He was on the cutting edge of record production in the 1980s. He is also widely acknowledged as one of the best drummers in rock history who pioneered a unique and instantly recognisable sound of his own.

[MALONEYCAMFIELD]

@shadowpuppet89 British guitar music never went away actually. Oasis just made it more popular again in the British charts for a while. As for the best rock and roll band to come out of England, they can't hold a candle to the likes of The Beatles, The Rolling Stones and Led Zeppelin, who are all far more popular around the world than Oasis.

[risteard7]

not as talented as they think they are?cmon phil they would walk all over ya music wise

[jcrawley1]

This is hard for me cos Noel and Phil are my 2 biggest heroes! I'd like to get the pair of them in a room together and make peace!