I think it should have been shot darker, with at least some horror special effects or maybe a fog machine.... It wasn't Death Metal enough. But it sounded pretty close to the original. Nice try!
Since you're being a contemporary music nerd, may I add to the party? I think Cage was more of an experimental composer than a minimalist. That being said, and based on your intro, you could have been a bit more repetitive in your performance to better suite the style of music you hope to play here.
Fucking brutal man! I never imagined John Cage's pieces to ever work with this kind of genre! It's a shame you missed out on a couple of bits though, but I suppose Death Metal is meant to be fast!
Nice shirt! Fanatastic performance, not exactly the same feel as seeing live in concert with out any previous knowledge of it but still good! If you ever decide to do i again try to get some white noise in there like clocks and wind.
@jonfitforbattle In John Cage's notes of the original score, he says that the timing can actually be adjusted to whatever length or tempo the conductor chooses. I think Mr. Edo did a fabulous job.
John Cage was a genius when he wrote this. It was a piece of music to show what music really was. Music is sound. There are sounds made in this. Why did John cage write it to be 4 minutes and 33 seconds? Because the amount of seconds in this piece is supposed to be 273 seconds. Well that just so happens to be the degrees Fahrenheit that absolute Zero is.
@jaretthale78 ehi,man! if this guy says "one of my favourite composers",probably he has to know what he's talking about! well,i'm not a genius but i know cage's not a minimalist!
you can say a lot of things on cage's works,philosophy and all his influence on contemporary music but not that he is a minimalist.. you don't have to be a genius to know this.
it's like saying that marilyn manson is a hardcore punk singer!
I enjoyed it but perhaps you could have given it some more variety? Don't get me wrong, the dynamics were good - I'm thinking more about articulation.
@Millsz42 : yes, there are three movements in this piece, but i like this performance, too, because there is no break in the musical impression of this piece...
You are a disgrace to the ideas of John Cage. Do you have any concept of why or how this piece was composed? I bet without Google, you don't. What a poor attempt at a joke. You only make yourself look like a musically ignorant person. Also, your foot made a sound at 1:50.
in all seriousness, i like it. and also it's a good cover. The "faster" i think is kinda brilliant. but also, the only other time I ever saw 433 covered (i was in the audience live, mind you) was by a rather serious artist who, if you can believe this, fucked it up. The pretentious art audience was like "ooh" and got mad at people making ambient noise because they didn't know what 433 was, and the artist called attention to herself unnecessarily.
@emergencystopping I think this piece might be the most difficult to "play correctly" in front of an audience not familiar with it beforehand. That0s why it translates better on an album than live, lol
It's not even 4'33"...
Lobbelt 2 hours ago
DREAM THEATER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
011235813YEAH 11 hours ago
Your penchant for (funny!) sarcasm and (deserved!) ridicule is awesome! Love your style. Absolutely fuckin' A brilliant!!!
deluge71 1 day ago
Tabs please
ivanscorpse 1 day ago
Do you have tabs for this?
DylanBannan 1 day ago
best parody of it
Bajindah 1 day ago
What a stupid cunt.
thekodalyway 2 days ago
How do you fail at performing 4'33''? Really? HOW?!?!
CrashingChords 2 days ago
Exquisite!
originofnoise 4 days ago
Dream Theater and John Cage fan?
We have so much to talk...
DIEGO7CUERDAS 4 days ago
I like how...
My favorite mortal kombat player. LOL
deanxleong 5 days ago
Isn't this supposed to be in 3 movements??? WTF???
seangdolan 5 days ago
Meh, your interpretation of 4'33" needed less cow bell...
skeezysquirrel 6 days ago 4
My favorite part was when you started. My next favorite part was the end. Bravissimo.
Linkemelee1993 1 week ago
apart from missing the last awesome minute, you got the time signature wrong. Who told you it's a 4/4? :P
FliegendeHollaender 1 week ago
So amazing!!
preppychrisbou 1 week ago
You sped up midway through. Metalheads. :/
RoverSonjasonn 2 weeks ago
It was quite fast sir. Make sure you focus on tempo, dude!
Aureolinmusic 2 weeks ago
it was pretty fast, but i kinda liked it
BrittonDeJong 2 weeks ago
I think it should have been shot darker, with at least some horror special effects or maybe a fog machine.... It wasn't Death Metal enough. But it sounded pretty close to the original. Nice try!
xophersmith 2 weeks ago
Tighten up that snare.
052947065 2 weeks ago
he doesnt do anything....
this is not death metal version at all, nor is it the full piece, you are at least eight measures short....
3dacidglasses 2 weeks ago
Be my master! Teach me! Great cover btw :D f**k haters! And thumbs up!
StratoAVR93 2 weeks ago
youve got some mad skills that was amazing.
fluteplayerlivvy1331 2 weeks ago
Mad props to you sir, not many people can play this, I love the death metal spin on it too, truly inspirational.
paz2001 2 weeks ago
This guy is nothing special. I can do this in my sleep.
hellspawn781 3 weeks ago
This.. is... so... intense...
DIMEND812 3 weeks ago
great job but work on the middle part
ped1232 3 weeks ago
I wouldn't mind if this version of the song was played at my wedding.
flashcode0 3 weeks ago
Wow, I never thought I'd find myself listening to this kind of music! A fantastic piece of work, man! Well done. :)
Yoshark777 3 weeks ago
It would have been funny if during the outtakes, he just busts out some George Kollias shit.
broomybroomybroomy 3 weeks ago
incredible
view1210 3 weeks ago
When i see the toms like that,i know i will be gt trolled by a shithead drummer wannabe...
MandragoraGaming 3 weeks ago
DREAM THEATER!!! GOOD MAN...
PearlBeater4Life 3 weeks ago
fail! EPIC FAIL! you've played it too fast!
mikabuchonosor 3 weeks ago
master!
clauderoubillie 3 weeks ago
How quickly you put the drumsticks back into your lap made me laugh way too hard
Ogrithm 3 weeks ago
love the out takes ...ha ha
TheSpacechaser 3 weeks ago
the video is only 3:21......
gubgub4321 3 weeks ago
Since you're being a contemporary music nerd, may I add to the party? I think Cage was more of an experimental composer than a minimalist. That being said, and based on your intro, you could have been a bit more repetitive in your performance to better suite the style of music you hope to play here.
mprimecoleman 3 weeks ago
SLOW DOWN ASSHOLE!
ItsTheBungle 3 weeks ago 2
It's not 4:33...
metabog 3 weeks ago
Fucking brutal man! I never imagined John Cage's pieces to ever work with this kind of genre! It's a shame you missed out on a couple of bits though, but I suppose Death Metal is meant to be fast!
Dizzyman888 3 weeks ago 3
I like that they actually put the name of the original artist to the bottom right of the video.
AmalgamOfMeat 3 weeks ago
Loved it!
Chickenthecruel 3 weeks ago
You forgot the coughs.
WhatDrySpell 4 weeks ago
You played it too fast.
ljkmpr 1 month ago
....
iheuyuriho 1 month ago
"I don't claim to be the best player." Yeah, after those outtakes you better not.
csl316 1 month ago
that chair he used looks like my g-ma's
CreativeKid02 1 month ago
so much mistakes
Wipu52 1 month ago
Love the solo!! lml
MultiVocalCovers 1 month ago
Nice shirt! Fanatastic performance, not exactly the same feel as seeing live in concert with out any previous knowledge of it but still good! If you ever decide to do i again try to get some white noise in there like clocks and wind.
sharadeth 1 month ago
hahaha. Excellent range and volume, great technique, but watch out for those pesky drums. Don't want to wake the neighbors.
MichaelusMaximus 1 month ago
Just fuckin awesome. My neck hurts now bro!
oldpizzleinthehizzle 1 month ago
This is absolutely the worst performance of 4'33" I've ever seen. You left out the whole last minute, which is the best part.
jonfitforbattle 1 month ago 86
@jonfitforbattle That's where you're wrong, he just performed it faster than usual
theSTATlCgamer 4 weeks ago
@jonfitforbattle In John Cage's notes of the original score, he says that the timing can actually be adjusted to whatever length or tempo the conductor chooses. I think Mr. Edo did a fabulous job.
BeadleBelfry 1 week ago
Pokerface
Mizuushii 1 month ago
You played it a bit fast
EdwardWouldNot 1 month ago
Such a shame you played only the first two minutes...
heavynov 1 month ago
RIP headphone users This was WAY TOO LOUD!
Almondsareodd 1 month ago
If SOPA were passed would you still be able to perform this?
MrDesmondConnor 1 month ago 9
amaze
DesZebre 1 month ago
nerd
worsttasteinvideo 1 month ago
IS THIS A JOKE?
1987ulise 1 month ago
@1987ulise BWHAHAAHAHAHAHAH!!!!
John Cage was a genius when he wrote this. It was a piece of music to show what music really was. Music is sound. There are sounds made in this. Why did John cage write it to be 4 minutes and 33 seconds? Because the amount of seconds in this piece is supposed to be 273 seconds. Well that just so happens to be the degrees Fahrenheit that absolute Zero is.
jjohnwsales 1 month ago
@jjohnwsales Yeah, except it's -273 Celcius.
tonymccourin 1 month ago
So hardcore, I might check out the original after watching how brutal this was.
(ps ICWYDT)
Dreadmonkey1 1 month ago
I was waiting for that MK joke to be made eventually.
lol This joke never ends does it.
P.S. I love that DT album.
NeverAloneForever 1 month ago
Absolutely hilarious. Nice!
joebeampercussion 1 month ago
How did you manage to fit 4'33 into a 3:21 video? Nice job letting your a/c unit handle the most demanding parts.
IepsyI 1 month ago
@IepsyI On the score (yes, there's a score), John Cage specified that the piece may be performed however long necessary.
frankentomato 1 month ago
@frankentomato - so why is it called 4'33 then!?!?
helraizer 1 month ago
@helraizer Because that was how long it was at the original performance.
frankentomato 1 month ago
you made me laugh so hard in the end! "deaaaaaath metaaaaal"
rox1317 1 month ago
I think you did't reach 4'33", but it's a pretty good performance
(oh jeah metal always goes a little bit faster... than classical music)
Rubinoske 1 month ago 39
you need a little work on the refrain. you just barely pulled it off
thrashandburn1022 1 month ago
is that how you play it?! Fuck I messed up on the second movement bad!
DamnedTheMan3 1 month ago
The piece maintains a consistent tone throughout.
QuadfishTym 1 month ago
this is the music i beat off to.
ychockey95 1 month ago
Jesus on a drum-kit, does life get any better?
Mrkaaaaaaaarl 1 month ago
minimalist composer?!
you don't know what you are talking about...
antonvonwebern 1 month ago
@antonvonwebern oh look! a genius.
jaretthale78 1 month ago
@jaretthale78 ehi,man! if this guy says "one of my favourite composers",probably he has to know what he's talking about! well,i'm not a genius but i know cage's not a minimalist!
you can say a lot of things on cage's works,philosophy and all his influence on contemporary music but not that he is a minimalist.. you don't have to be a genius to know this.
it's like saying that marilyn manson is a hardcore punk singer!
antonvonwebern 1 month ago
I dunno, I would call that prog really.
DickNixonArisen 1 month ago
This video isn't 4:33.
manka6 1 month ago
@manka6 But he's playing a faster, death metal cover.
MisterM2402 1 month ago
@MisterM2402 Hurr
manka6 3 weeks ago
where are the tabs??
josearcanjof 1 month ago 3
Could've been a bit more expressive in the middle part, dynamics were good throughout though.
musich10 1 month ago
trollololol
DownWithTheMasses 1 month ago
I enjoyed it but perhaps you could have given it some more variety? Don't get me wrong, the dynamics were good - I'm thinking more about articulation.
luceelizabeth 1 month ago
Do you have the sheet music?
TheGoatface7 1 month ago 3
Jajajajajajajajaja!
skeistan 1 month ago
Real funny (: Loved the outtakes at the end. *Deeeeaaath metalll*
partylikealion 1 month ago
HAHA wonderful, I love it, I totally love the idea :D
satoichi771 1 month ago
31 people are too stupid to understand performance art and should be executed.
johnlichtenberg 1 month ago
Cage was not a minimalist composer. Forshizzle!!
superjules 1 month ago
Be careful, you made a mistake @ 1:48 when you moved your leg.
xkcdHatGuy 1 month ago
@xkcdHatGuy If he made a noise, that's the whole point of the piece. It's not about silence, but what ambient noises happen during the 4'33
TheShredworthy 1 month ago 4
I love the facepalm at the end :D
mariutunio 1 month ago
Comment removed
DIZamudio 1 month ago
holy crap that was.. amazing!!! Where did you learn to play like that?!?
EdgarRazorlip 2 months ago
30 people don't get it
elkvis 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great Performance! I like it! - but a little bit too fast in the second movement
Hyacinthvs 2 months ago
Comment removed
Hyacinthvs 2 months ago
Comment removed
Hyacinthvs 2 months ago
I like the screw-up. OOPPSS accidentally played music!!
gradfark 2 months ago
Brilliant!
KingSn0man 2 months ago
Ahahaha.
kinkykane0607 2 months ago
dream theater :D
MrPianoDan 2 months ago
you totally nailed it, great work!!
eSuEoS 2 months ago
The thing to remember is actually listening.
baldrbraa 2 months ago
You are just a ridiculously sloppy player. 1:50... just inexcusably sloppy. I could play it ten times better than you. lol
stwstl5926 2 months ago
You've got it. ...
Arghopa 2 months ago
...
Arghopa 2 months ago
The original is in three movements- David Tudor (the pianist who premiered the piece) indicated this fact with body language during his performance
The only sense in which you can compare John Cage and Philip Glass is in that they are both Americans
Millsz42 2 months ago
@Millsz42 : yes, there are three movements in this piece, but i like this performance, too, because there is no break in the musical impression of this piece...
Hyacinthvs 2 months ago
I've heard better.
jaxxstraw 2 months ago
You need more cowbell!
Asherov1 2 months ago 2
I could have gotten it down on my 2nd try
pissinmeoff0 2 months ago
i lost it at the foot closeup
spankeriffic 2 months ago
It's awesome to know that at least some people have personalities :D keep on rockin!
death metal......
hennessey1200 2 months ago
You are a disgrace to the ideas of John Cage. Do you have any concept of why or how this piece was composed? I bet without Google, you don't. What a poor attempt at a joke. You only make yourself look like a musically ignorant person. Also, your foot made a sound at 1:50.
BobTheBlender000001 2 months ago
@BobTheBlender000001 You're such a pretentious twat. Cage wrote 4'33" and literally says that he has "nothing to say". It's just chance music.
doctorxsandwich 2 months ago
@doctorxsandwich Exactly... it's raw music without any guidance.
Dreadnaught1985 2 months ago
@BobTheBlender000001 Who the hell are you and what makes you think you're so entitled?
crashedfrigate17 2 months ago
@BobTheBlender000001 that foot noise was part of his interpretation
TubaSmaug 2 months ago
this song always gets stuck in my head when i'm tryna sleep
lmperia 2 months ago in playlist Liked videos 61
-eargasm-
rakimion 2 months ago
Sweet shirt
MrGuy0250 2 months ago
your feet were sloppy...
lesclaypoolthesecond 2 months ago
Awesome.
izzyfosheezy1 2 months ago
At all the people who think he plays too fast: It's death metal. Of course it's faster than the original classical piece.
Freistaat1918 2 months ago 3
This is one of the best things I have ever seen
Amadeus435 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What is it with all of these covers messing up the part between 2:50-3:07? It's not *that* much more difficult than the rest of the piece...
TonisAndreasHallaste 2 months ago
truely art at it's best
2treesandminivan 2 months ago
dont play so fast!!!
808acid 2 months ago
You played it way too fast. All the notes ran together.
EmbraceTheThunder 2 months ago
@EmbraceTheThunder Switch to HD, it will sound better and clearer then.
Freistaat1918 2 months ago 9
4' 33" Also makes for an amusing visual experience.
dabasser4 2 months ago
this has the best guitar solo in
OpenedCanOfWhoopAss 2 months ago
The rage made me involuntarily raise my fists towards the screen. This cover is an Ark of the Covenant-class revelation. My face is melted.
YoursTrulyCharles 2 months ago
in all seriousness, i like it. and also it's a good cover. The "faster" i think is kinda brilliant. but also, the only other time I ever saw 433 covered (i was in the audience live, mind you) was by a rather serious artist who, if you can believe this, fucked it up. The pretentious art audience was like "ooh" and got mad at people making ambient noise because they didn't know what 433 was, and the artist called attention to herself unnecessarily.
emergencystopping 2 months ago
@emergencystopping I think this piece might be the most difficult to "play correctly" in front of an audience not familiar with it beforehand. That0s why it translates better on an album than live, lol
rodcrippler 2 months ago
nice drum solo
madara435 2 months ago
tutorial please
madara435 2 months ago
Needs more cowbell.
WalrusEgo 2 months ago 2
thank you for proving the worthlessness of john cage's 4'33". indeed it is a joke that was never funny
DoctorRazzArea4 2 months ago
Brutal!
darkcorneroftheearth 2 months ago
brilliant.. just brilliant.
comedownoffthecross 2 months ago 2
Intense.
Boredpersons55 2 months ago
love the grooves on this 1 mate! smooth grooves my son!
DanGerrousRobBery 3 months ago
Excellent performance, great acoustics.
ThePulsys 3 months ago
This is my wedding song
Con818 3 months ago
I love the fact that this was in HD
Valcarion 3 months ago
Beautiful
BearInfestedWaters 3 months ago
The original tempo is 60, so it's not a half. It's the full thing played fast as hell. That's the meaning of death metal cover.
guyfromhell666 3 months ago 36
@guyfromhell666 keep trolling troll
Elquiesceace 2 months ago
Why you didn't play the complete piece??? Poor Asshole
pipaspaz 3 months ago
Perhaps a bit uneven around 02:08, but otherwise, very good job!
djeikop 3 months ago 2
Could I use this as a backing track?
010Richard010 3 months ago
this rocks man!
annonimuz2 3 months ago
Best. Cover. Ever!
CharlieF2M 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey everyone check out my video "The Probability of Chance" on my channel! A tribute to John Cage!
Jusstfnsk8 3 months ago
DREAM FUCKING THEATER
SSJkiller 3 months ago 2
Очень быстрый темп, я такого недолюбливаю
RedkeiGost 3 months ago
Bitch I can play this on the triangle.
WackidWally2 3 months ago 2
mmm, you should play a death metal version of Ligeti or Penderecki
henryossarri 3 months ago
ODIOT ARG
Arkaica1 3 months ago
@nighthawk41 is right, the song is in 3/4. And not that it matters for drums, but it's written in F
Rufus2468 3 months ago
Better than Lars.
whymenogood 3 months ago
I have never heard it played so well, even if it is perhaps a little bit to fast.
Schurik72 3 months ago 2
brilliant.
Probe2John 3 months ago
You counted 4 at the beginning. The song is actually in 3/4.
This post isn't a joke... Look up the sheet music
nighthawk41 3 months ago