Added: 3 years ago
From: kevinkun3
Views: 24,046
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (77)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • No cover can add up to the original Pinback song. Absolutely none. <3

  • Better than Saosin, that cover was garbage. All they did was slow it down, so that it would be trendy and emo for all of those poser assholes who like them... At least Playradioplay! made an original version...

  • pinback > copies. this is still good though i like it a lot. you just cant compare .

  • Playradioplay doesn't seem to have the lung capacity that Crow/Smith have. He cuts off on the longer notes. Regardless, this is actually a pretty good version.

  • THIS IS A GUY? pinback FTW

  • @SweatyManChest playradioplay is magnificent... H8RZ GONNA H8.

  • ive heard them all and i think saosins is the best then pinbacks then this

  • @eyecandynaruto13 well some people say it's about Rob Crow's fish dying and him burying it in the forest. But many speculate it's a metaphor for a girl with a drinking problem.

  • I <3 this song, whether it's the original Pinback version, the more emo Saosin version, or the Lo-Fi upbeat PlayRadioPlay (now called Analog Rebellion) version. I love the song and PRP! are a favourite band of mine.

  • anthony green sang it better but i havnt ran into the original yet to compare it to that. originals are usually best though. just knowing its a copy kind of kills it for me.

  • This is a horrible version of Penelope. LOVE PINBACK

  • ive never heard the original. so i wouldnt know.

  • Original song by pinback ass holes

  • This song is about a fish that got killed by a pizza piece thrown into its bowl at a party. Originally it was written for the singer's goldfish.

  • @AkIzayoi no,the original writer of this song owned a fish that had something wrong with it and his band (pinback) recorded it.

  • You are all actually stupid if you really think everyone is going to agree on liking this song. Everyone has different musical tastes so just shut the fuck up.

  • this version is gay ! no music all percuss

  • @eyecandynaruto13 lol never thought of that xD seems 2 be true

  • omfg this sucks...

  • loveeee :3

  • I don't get the same feeling as with saosin or pinback with this one

  • Where did you get this song?!

  • The song is cool, but the quality in this video seems awful.

  • kyle yes

  • Still my favorite song by them

  • i like playradioplay, and i like pinback, but this doesn't sound right to me...

  • PlayRadioPlay's covers are pretty decent.

    He did a cover of "The Way I Feel Inside" by The Zombies, and it wassss... Decent?

    Like this cover.

  • Saosins in the bomb...although the idea of a cover...to make it sound different and ya know mess around with it a bit? No covers i have heard of this song have done that AT ALL! THIS ONE IS ALMOST EXACTLY THE SAME AS THE ORIGINAL!

  • Well, it IS a cover. Meaning, the artist(s) who cover a song can either play the exact thing or change it up.

    And besides, this cover has a lot of differences in it than the original, so I don't know what else was playing on your computer when you heard this...

  • Saosin's is better...... but love playradioplay

  • i think all 3 version are awesome.

  • this is a PINBACK SONG

    Saosin fucked it up haha

    this verion is just ok.

    But Pinback in the shit!

  • Saosins version is soo much better then this one or Pinbacks

  • ur retarded. saosin cant even compare to pinback, hence the fact they are covering pinback. do you see pinback covering saosin?...

  • The newer bands tend to cover the older bands. Your logic's a tad flawed.

  • Haha, I just had an image of Rob Crow looking disgusted. While drinking a beer. Haha.

  • lol love rob crowe and his woodsman look lately lol

  • @whizkid777 i met him :)

  • Comment removed

  • i like this version better than the original and soasins cover mostly because he brought out the base which is kick ass then he took in his own touch of electronic back sounds....

  • base is kick ass

  • that beat is sick.

  • i would have prefered if he had added the extra beat. don't care for his voice.

  • Sorry to break it to the idiots this isn't his song.

    This isn't Saosins song...

    IT'S PINBACKS

  • It's called a COVER moron. Does it matter?

  • @brohana not idiocy, ignorance.

  • @brohana Damn straight man! 

  • haha its so funny its such touchy song, the poor guys fish! aww

  • I like this version, but I still think the orginal is better

  • all the verisons are pretty good.

    saosins cover was pretty dandy to

  • i like all three versions of this song. I was disappointed when Playradioplay took this off his myspace (because i'm too cheap to buy the song/cd).

  • yeah supposedly. haha

  • haha who said saosin?!?!?!....lolz

  • It's not that bad and it's cool how they really put their own PRP! spin into it.

  • pinback version by far is better his voice isnt powerful enough but i do like it i downloaded it on limewire a few months ago, AT LEAST they didnt butcher it and make it sound like some stupid emo song.

  • actual pinback is better,.

    in my opinion.

  • this, so far, is the only good cover of this song. i like it alot. the percussion part is really cool. and the vocals are really good but if i had any complaints it would be that the vocals should be clean and non-raspy then whole song. but anyway, really really good cover. where can i download this?

  • yup, it's good chiefly due to the fact that it's almost IDENTICAL to the original Pinback version, which, in my opinion, is superior anyway, much more emotional.

  • @NotSoBrave you can't. you have to buy it. ;D

  • who originally sings this?

  • saosin ruined it

  • seriously lol

  • Yeah, I like saosin, but not a fan of their cover, they made it sound tooooo melancholic/emo

  • @pizacal saosin and this shit?

  • @pizacal not really... hater.

  • @pizacal .... No. Saosin made the song amazing!

  • @BlackRibbonTV No... Pinback made the song amazing.

  • @BlackRibbonTV lulz

  • @BlackRibbonTV YESS! THESE KIDS R IDIOTS!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more