Added: 3 years ago
From: JohnRaytheon
Views: 4,373
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (164)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • she is a man

  • lol.

  • It will all be over when Comcast get control...

  • Which is leading in the PMSNBC decline?

  • they both suck and i think she uses a strap on, on olberman

  • @uboatcaptain69 I think Olbs needs to use a strap on with her because he has no balls.

  • Why does both Maddog and Olberman both sound like they have a dick in their mouth when theyre speaking their liberal buffoonery?

  • @EastCoastDude99 because they do. LOL!

  • a right winger and or libertarian needs to start another youtube like site that doesnt censor its videos

  • HILARIOUS. Can't stand that BITCH-CUNT mad-hoe.

  • Not very fond of women, then?

  • @OxTheWriter Wrong just can't stand militant femminist man haters.

  • Ah, so a woman who stands up for herself is a "feminist man-hater."

    Bad assumption, but not atypical of sexists.

  • @OxTheWriter. Wrong again i have no problem with strong women here are a few i like - Ann Coulter , Sarah Palin , Laura Ingraham , Michelle Malkin.

  • So, only if they agree with your ideology.

    Sarah Palin and Michelle Malkin: "strong women." Okayyyyyyy...

    Cuckoo! Cuckoo! Cuckoo!

  • @OxTheWriter. Liberalism is a mental illness.

  • Wow, quoting the great and mighty Michael Weiner. Which is better than trying to quote Malkin or Palin, as there you'd have nothing coherent from which to choose.

    Palin: the strong woman who couldn't stand up to Rush Limbaugh the same way she stood up to Rahm Emmanuel.

    Such a strong woman. Apart from her cowardice at offending a powerful man.

  • @OxTheWriter. Now you are being silly. Both Rush Limbaugh and Sarah Palin are on the same page.You are trying to find conflict where there is none.

  • Hello? She didn't like the word "retard" from Rahm, so she shouldn't have liked it from Rush. But apart from a watered-down spokeswoman statement, she said NOTHING.

    So she can't defend her own son except when liberals say something she doesn't like. That's the definition of cowardice.

    Fortunately, she stands no chance in 2012.

  • @OxTheWriter You got it all wrong. It's clear you don't listen to Rush , because if you did you would know that Rush was pointing out what that ASSHOLE Rham said. Rush was NOT calling Sarah Palins son "retard".

  • Nor was Rahm. Both of them used the word "retard," you see; neither in reference to Palin's son. Clearly, you don't watch or listen to anything that doesn't tell you what you wish to hear.

  • @OxTheWriter Given that Rush was just pointing out what Rham said there is no reason for Sarah Palin to "stand up" to Rush.

  • No, he was pointing out what Rahm (spell it right, stupid) said, and then agreeing with it.

    And you accuse me of not listening to the guy.

    Then again, anyone who considers a hysteric like Coulter a "strong woman" clearly has reality-based issues.

  • Opps and boo-hoo i spelled the assholes name wrong. Wrong again Rush did not agree with RAHAM saying what he did as if it's ok. Oh one last thing  ANN COULTER ROCKS. bye-bye.

  • Wow...such a great argument you make while losing face for being subliterate.

    It's okay...go beat your wife.

  • @purple: I'm assuming you are either an idiot or deaf. Maybe both. When the Democrat said "retard," it was behind closed doors. What you would call a closed session. Fat Fuck Rush said it out in the open in front of 20 million listeners. There's a huge difference.

    Palin is also offended by the Family Guy episode using a Down Syndrome person. I'm offended at Palin being offended.

    Palin isn't too particularly bright at using her children to help spike her popularity.

  • @mortalhellion Yep you are right Rush said what was ALREADY PUBLIC KNOWLEDGE about what Rham said. Guess you don't like FREE SPEECH.

  • @purple: What is it with you conservative types are always yakhing about me not liking "free speech"? What the hell is wrong with you? I like free speech. I just don't like when people such as yourself are dead wrong about certain information and lying about it on forums such as youtube. You seem to the type who doesn't do research.

    I've reached the conclusion you're an idiot.

  • @mortahellion To each their own view. bye-bye

  • @purple: Yeah, whatever. You are pretty self-defeating, no?

  • @mortalhellion cocksucker you like spam you cocksucker  oxthelolitapedo wants it up the ass please comply

  • @purple: I like Michelle Malkin because I like Asian women.(would like to marry one someday). Apart from that, she doesn't strike me as strong or very sane. Just because Palin probably puts a gun under her pillow at night doesn't mean she's strong either.

    Not very good choices of women there.

  • @mortalhellion Looks like we are going to have to agree to disagree about the strong women i mentioned.

  • @purple: there's no disagreeing or agreing. You're just wrong about your assumptions about "strong" women.

  • After Scott Brown won the Massachusetts US Senate seat, I decided to watch PMSNBC for the first time in quite some time. I just wanted to get their initial reactions to losing the Kennedy Senate election. I predicted that it would soon turn into an insult fest and Olbermann did not disappoint. What did he blame the loss on? Oh yeah. Olberman blamed it on people who drive pickup trucks because that is secretly a code word for racism. lol. It was Rachel maddow who announced the news. lol

  • i saw a clip of that maddow announce it, she looked depressed haha

  • @starVol Right on! The racists at MSNBC cannot hide their racism any longer. This is the same network that edited a photo to cut out a man's body. This man had a gun in his pocket at a rally. MSNBC portrayed him as a white racist, but it turned out he was BLACK! Google it, it's the truth

  • i hate this nasty cunt,..her and olberman have the same manorisms,..hmmm

  • I cannot stand Rachel Maddow, she is a pig. Frankly I don't know why it is so unpopular to be a succesful mother with a stable family, pretty and smart. God forbid. Again, Europe and the rest of the world is laughing at how americans are going down the toilet with this over-the-top radicals who have to make a point at any cost, even the americans. Please get to the point Rachel stop bullying

  • may be someone should make jokes about Rachel Maddow being a man. Just get back at those libshits & Left-tards who made jokes about Ann Coulter & Palin being a man.

  • Strange how much they look alike, hmm could it be that they are the same person?

    Only Maddow has a deeper voice and more facial hair.

  • lol

  • Music's good. Video sucks.

  • hahaha

  • Rachel Maddow is a pig!!!

  • Yeah this is still one of the worst videos on YouTube, just in terms of the quality of it.

    Any views it gets should be divided by 10 to get closer to the actual number, because probably 1 in 10 actually stick around to watch the entire thing, and those must be the real gas-huffing knuckle draggers who watch FOX.

  • i hate this lesbian queer by the name of maddow-mental disease

  • Looking for substance... looking for substance....

    Nope. There is no substance in conservative "commentary" these days. Just bigotry, outrageous lies, inflammatory slogans and images, and sad attempts at juvenile "humor". Seriously, this video even fails and being funny, let alone convincing anyone who isn't already a brainless religious right extremist.

  • Then why does Msnbc's ratings keep going down? But who cares about that, Obama sure is doing great, hes only quadrupled our national debt, risen umemployment, and is now weakening our national defense.

  • MSNBC's ratings have gone steadily up in the past years. Bush created a national debt out of nothing - US was in a surplus when he started his term, and in addition left Obama with two ongoing wars and an economic crisis, so Obama must spend more government money in order to solve these problems. It was clear even before Obama began his presidency that this is going to be a 2 year long depression at best, so blaimng it on Obama after less than a year in office is absurd.

  • HeyNonyNonymous, how can you say their ratings keep going up year after year...have you checked lately?

    Say what you want, but ratings have no polical bias, it is what it is.

  • As I said - ratings for all News networks dropped after the elections, which is to be expected of course. There is no greater drop in MSNBC's ratings than in Fox' or CNN's. You see, those of us who take their information from sources other than Fox News, choose to see the WHOLE picture, rather than just the bits we like.

  • haha...you didn't say this in the last comment. You said the opposite.

  • No I didn't. Go back to school and learn to read.

  • One comment: "MSNBC's ratings have gone steadily up in the past years."

    Other comment: "As I said - ratings for all News networks dropped after the elections, which is to be expected of course. "

    I went back to school and learned to read tonight and graduated. Idiot.

  • Than perhaps mathematics weren't your strong subject? As you clearly can't tell the difference between a pick and a trend. MSNBC's ratings are on a rising trend in the past few years (Fox, BTW, aren't). They picked during the elections, just like any other news channel. Did they teach you how to read a chart in that school you went to? Or just how to fix cars?

  • Ha well maybe MSNBC has gone up in the past few years, but looking within the past year and the individual months, they have gone down quite some bit. And BTW Fox's ratings have gone up and they are still number 1 because they dont have far left liberal idiots like everyone else.

  • Fox ratings went down after the elections just like everybody else. They are number 1 for the same reason McDonald's are number one: they sell crap that is easy to stomach.

  • ...and I bet you are licking the drive-thru sign, hollering for your McCafe and egg mcmuffin every morning. Twitch.

  • Ha well I work at Mcdonalds and im not fat, i play sports, so dont start making fun of them. And explain how the reporters on Fox are crappy or whatever you said.

  • haha you originally didn't explain "the difference between a pick and a trend". You said simply that their ratings had gone up, and then said later that everything has gone down. Boy, I'd like to see you in a debate with someone. First you'd give vague contradictory information, then insult the opposition and correct yourself by providing the needed, and originally missing, information after the fact...thinking it would save your ass. You sure you learn from FOXnews debates?

  • Yea i dont take it back. Everyones ratings went down after the election, but im saying that MSNBC was rising for a few years until recently, they have started to drop in ratings(lower than before the election times). And yea i supplied the info the second time because that guy was providing false facts. They dont usually debate on ratings anyway, they simply report what is happening like i did.

  • Bush created that debt after 8 years, and Obama more than quadrupled it after only 6 MONTHS. Lets see here, first Obama promised that his stimulus would quickly create new jobs, but ever since he passed it 2 million more jobs have been lost, compared to George Bush who created 10 million jobs over his 2 terms. Lets just see how long everyone can blame Bush on this, because Obama is only going to worsen it as he progresses.

  • The debt is not "quadrupled". I'm sorry, but the laws of math demands something will become 4 times bigger in order to be quadrupled. It hasn't. And it didn't take Bush 8 years to creat it, either. It took a lot less. The only thing Bush created was two wars and an economic crisis. Is it Obama's fault that he still has to finance Bush' wars, the bailout, and the debt's interest? No. It isn't.

  • Well i remember back during the election the democrats kept saying how Bush created the 250 billion dollar debt or about that and then Obama passed his stimulus and some other crap which is well over 750 million if you put it all together, so 250+750=1000 quadrupled.

    I agree that Bush spent way to much money and i dont even know why he held up these wars so long, but it is both Bush's and Obama's fault for the recession.

  • Bush' bailout was 700 billion, so your numbers are extremely inaccurate.

  • Ok, 700 billion for Bush plus like 47 trillion for Obama. Just because the numbers are blown up more than what Maximus said doesn't mean they aren't any less startling for both sides.

  • 47 trillion? Are you thinking of his whole future budget or the money already spent? And where are you getting the 700 billion from Bush?

  • if this station wasnt owned by General Electric which owns MSNBC,NBC,CNBC,it would be off the air,..oh wait,..GE got a few hundred billion in gov. bailout/tarp money,..so we pay tax payers pay their saleries

  • Music is nice. Video and thoughts behind it, not so much.

  • Is MSNBC still a network, Does anyone watch this stuff? Even worse than Campbell Brown on CNN show all bias and bullshit.

  • oh no you might piss off some gay people!!!

    be ready to cover your butt

  • all of you who agree with this video are probably conservative assholes. Most your children will be born with disfigurement because you like to keep it in the family. What about abortion? oh, right you don't agree... you hate blacks, asians, hispanics left winged whites because you were told so or made ignorant assumptions. God does NOT love you. actually he still does but in the way Peter loves Meg on Family Guy. Go on... hate me. I'd love to get a rise. please give me the satisfaction. thanks

  • looks like your the one that gave yourself a rise, you stupid liberal!! go save the fucking world, but do it with your own money, not taxpayers. Obviously you don't think of fiscal conservatives, but only think of the minority of people who are bigots and who happen to be conservative. What about all of hollywood? Thise fuckers have the most money, always get free shit, and don't have to spend their own money> Yet, they are the first to spend everyone elses????

    Doesn't make sense!!

  • obviously i got a rise out of you.

    But WHO spent all the taxpayers fucking money?

    people in hollywood get money because they do things that you would never do or they have something you don't have such as talent, porn, rich parents or just demeaning yourself.

  • Politics aside, the quality of this video is terrible. The music makes me wanna run away screaming, and for the entire first minute it has one image, no one is going to stay around for the entire thing.

  • Its called skipping through the video.

  • Good vid - that Rachel Mandow is everything that is wring with America summed up in one androgynous bespectacaled skank lezzbo. What a peice of trash. I wish she were captured by Taliban so she can see how they deal with her type of scum. She and her commy network msnbc are totally worthless. Her daddy should have shot it in the toilet. I hate her guts.

  • 2 things:

    Just like anybody else, I can see just how unashamed Keith and his girlfriend Rachel are about being blazingly leftist.

    ...however...

    I think all the 'dyke' and 'little boy' references are shameful, and those doing it need to realize that THOSE remarks are the reasons the left thinks the right is bigoted.

    ...just a thought from a centrist.

  • lol

  • That's strange. Happened to me last night too.

  • Don't forget about CNN... pretty biased

  • I fucking hate this stupid dyke.

  • calling her a dyke is an insult to the intelligence to smart lesbians everywhere like Cheney's daughter for example

  • FIRE KEITH OLBERMANN.... if you GOOGLE that, you can sign the petition to FIRE KEITH OLBERMANN.

    Google and look for The Petition site!!!

  • Soon the Worst President Of The United States trophy will be given to Obama.

    Bullsh@t we can believe in.

    Change and Hope.... Nope

    Obama's a Dope

  • As far as im concerned both MSNBC and FOXNEWS are examples of just flat out terrible news and one sided garbage. They are both a disgrace to true news.

    This is why any person with half a brain or anyone that wants to think for themselves will watch CSPAN and decide for themselves what they believe in. Thanks and remember you can think for yourself you dont have to let them do it for you.

  • So its a video making fun of Maddow because she is a lesbian? If you don't like liberals then prove their points wrong, don't call them a boy because they have short hair. That's just homophobic.

    P.S. Obama won, so you can stop calling him a baby killer and work on something that might actually get a republican elected in 2012.

  • In the 25-54 Demographic, which is the one that advertisers care about and largely determines whether or not a show will stay one (Murdoch and O'Reilly call it "the key demo"). They are practically tied it averages out to one clear win a week each for O'Reilly and Olbermann and three ties. Pay attention to what people actually say don't just guess at it.

  • And what "recent studies show more people watch CSPAN or infomercials"? Cuz MSNBC is well ahead of CNN in ratings. This video is just plain bad, in terms of both factual accuracy and production value.

  • Personally, I'd rather have a show get its talking points from the DailyKos and Huffington Post than from the Bush White House like FIXED News, or is it FOX Noise?

  • so glad other people are disgusted with this G.I Jane, she shouldn't be on  the air.

  • MSNBC is the best, Fox news sucks ass

  • I can't stand this dyke bitch. A smug, arrogant kool-aid drinker, just like the rest of them.

  • Holy dykeness batman!

    I was only joking when I first saw her, but I guess it's not stereotyping if she really is what you think she is...

  • Doesn't this guy have a show on MNSBC?

  • Shes just as pathetic as Olberman. HELLOOOO, Olberman & MSNBCs ratings are bottom of the barrel. They fired Chris Mathews & Olberman from political coverage.Hey Maddow you dyke, get out your double donger & stick the other end in Olbermans orifice!!!

  • actually do you know liberals claim countdown has the highest ratings on cable news?

  • hey numbnuts, Maddow and Olbermann are each beating Larry King overall in viewers. And in the demographic of 25-54 (which is the most important of the advertising demographics according to Bill O'Reilly), they're stomping O'Reilly as well as Hannity & Colmes

  • thats not true at all, keep making shit up

  • Explain how that's not true. Check the Nielsen Ratings. This is a FACT. I know you probably don't like facts if you're a FOX Noise fan, but this is demonstrably correct.

  • 8PM - P2+ (25-54) (35-64)

    The OReilly Factor—2,675,000 viewers (532,000) (987,000)

    Campbell Brown—1,078,000 viewers (344,000) (471,000)

    Countdown w/Keith Olbermann 1,511,000 viewers (508,000) (831,000)

    Nancy Grace 1,053,000 viewers (379,000) (564,000)

    ***shini, this is from the 1st week of dec, oreilly be olbermann by a sizeable margin in both categories****

    so actually you are wrong, obviously you are a left wing douche, but there is still hope, get a job

  • 1st week of December:

    25-54 demo:

    11/26 - Tie

    12/1 - Tie

    12/2 - O'Reilly

    12/3 - Olbermann

    12/4 - Tie

    I don't know where you got your numbers from, but that seems pretty even to me.

  • Boy is this a bunch of Garbage GOP propaganda. Mark my WORDS! Both sides WILL raise taxes. Don't BELIEVE the hype. Our deficit grew hugely since Bush was in office and is attributing to the current econimic crisis. So remember when you vote on Nov. 4th that both will raise taxes. Obama wants raise taxes on people who make $250k or more. So if you're rich vote for McCain, but if you are part of the 70% who does not make that you should vote for Obama.

  • Rachel Maddow is living proof that radical feminists don't support the advancement of women in our society. What they support is the advancement of women with a liberal ideology.

  • I think there should be a spot on Sean Hannity's show called "The Maddow Problem" :-)What an asshole she is, seriously.

  • Besides this video being pure crap the worst part is the use of the Derek Flint theme music.

    Shame! Shame! Flint would kick your ass.

  • I was going to comment on the vicious hatred and homophobia inherent in this video (I couldn't force myself to get through it all).

    but,

    these low-life haters aren't worth the effort.

  • MSNBC is full of stupidity! This Maddow woman is obviously an extreme gay liberal. She looks like a man and is bashing Palin. It's people, like she, bowing to worship Obama that makes many of us sane people out here sick at our stomachs. They need to cancel her new show, because she has a personal agenda and that's to have all women cut their hair and join the lesbian bull-dyke club!

  • Most

    Sexist

    Neo-

    Barack

    Channel......Period!

  • How true. May God bless you. Don' let them get to you.

  • Thx u for the video u r a true American. pls keep them coming. thx u JT.

  • Does this video serve any other purpose than spout anti-MSNBC and anti-Obama slander and make the creator of it look like an idiot?

  • Hey Keith,good night and get fucked!

  • ha ha well said. Couldn't happen to a better guy.

  • Heh. Nice.

    I like the text profile of MSNBC.

    It's all true too.

    I wouldn't know who Rachel Maddow is if it weren't for YouTube...because I haven't watched MSNBC in years.

  • Yes, youtube...same here - I cant even get MSNBC on cable. I wouldnt understand people who actually turn to MSNBC on their TV's - those people would be deranged.

  • Come on now, Maddows is a good man.

  • ok ok lets give him a break

  • Rachel Maddows looks like that What the Buck fruit, only not as entertaining or likeable

  • 5stars

  • You'd think he could at least get her name right: it's "Maddow," not "Maddows." But that's the far right for you.

  • Well, it's for legal reasons - don't worry about it clown, its above your paygrade

  • Because she's so worthy of respect??

  • the law is not established because of mr maddow

  • How come Olbermann always looks like he is going to break out in tears? He's such a baby.

  • I see it more like he's doing #2..or farting

  • Well he was a former sportscaster, so that's the "intellect" the left respects...

  • That is the reason I now watch FOX, would not turn it on before the primary started, now it is my favorite news channel!

  • Freakshow comes to t.v.. Puke. It's so in your face liberal bias.

  • Liberals are a national disgrace.

  • Olbermann aka Bathtub Boy...Rachel Maddow-Carpet Muncher. Chris Matthews....Tingle up his leg when he hears NOBAMA speaks. David Gregory...Was a good Washington corresondent now just a mouth piece for the Democrat party... Of them all Scarborough in my opinion is not as biased. None of their programming beats Fox. And since Imus' departure are the true losers. The blame is on Capus and Griffin. What will they speak about after the "Messiah loses in November"?

  • "Chris Matthews....Tingle up his leg when he hears NOBAMA speaks" - I still cannot believe those nerds feel no shame to say something so gay and pathetic...not to mention partisan in a creepy way

  • "Olbermann has systematically taken over the whole MSNBC operation"

    So I guess Joe Scarborough gets his liberal talking points from Olbermann then?

  • lol scarborough is a loser, just like Buchanan, he is only there because he's paid to make it look like MSNBC is actually balanced but they dont have a say at MSNBC - its called window dressing

  • That's a man, baby!

  • 5*****

    They just gave that bull dyke Rachael maddow her own show. I can't stand lesbians, who can watch that hate filled creature. Olberman's show came on after I forgot to change the channel, while I was on my computer late last night, He was acting like a sissy complementing that dyke on getting her own butch dyke show .

  • REPTILIANS AT 5:28-5:30!

  • This is the most ridiculous load of crap I've ever seen. And I've seen lots of crap from Raytheon and the other morally bankrupt megaphones of the corrupt and failed, current administration.

    This post is full of lies, there's no other word for it. Obama is not going to raise the average American's taxes. Bush's war is the reason for the deficit, not to mention that Republicans are the kings of spend now, pay later. We cannot afford 4 more years of Bush dressed up as a little white haired man.

  • shut the fuck up loser. You are garbage and should have been aborted. Usually, since I'm such a moral person I'm against abortion, but I'll allow it in your case because you are worthless!

  • I heard a joke once about MSNBC, it was something like if you are on the run from the law the best place to hide is on air on MSNBC, hahahhaha.

  • lol. Yeah, that was quite a "skewering." *rolls eyes*

  • thx man

  • lol, yeah and there are reptile people living under ground. Get with it man.

  • You can choose to keep your head in the sand. That's your right. Alot of people beleive otherwise.

  • Pigdog liberals (my apologies to both pigs & dogs)suffering from dementia and attempting to inflict their sickness upon us. No thanks bitches, keep your craziness. Love the musical accompaniment.

  • Wow what a bunch of worthless spittle.

  • spittle...? there's no one talking here just typing only. Idiot

  • Uh.. There's plenty of talking during your little anti-Obama advertisement. I understand that your bizarre little arch-conservative jerk-fest is hard to get through, but having posted it, seems like you should know the content. Idiot.

  • Second definition of "Spittle": The frothy liquid secreted by spittlebugs. When abundant, spittlebugs stunt plant growth by sucking the sap from the plant. Mental midgets such as you and your ilk, remind me of this little insect pest, destructive, worthless, and in need of fumigation.

  • Animal planet called. They need a script on slimey slugs. You got the job boreass

  • lmao....... Id love to see Maddow and Olbermann in a love scene, neither would have the faintest idea what to do. And you cant make me believe Olbermann is NOT gay!!!!!

  • he's hetero but he's the type to nervously fumble trying to undress a girl and needs instructions on how to fuck..you're right about that. maddows I think knows how to do foreplay...but only with girls

  • olbermann is a homosexual

  • My God John Raytheon, you must be the single least self-confident person in the history of the world. Half of what you say is a vile personal attack on someone, and the other half is just dead wrong facts. Grow a pair and try to wage an argument based on issues rather than saying Olbermann isn't good at his job because you don't think he can pleasure women. You are a disgrace, your parents are probably wishing they'd gone with an abortion all those years ago.

  • Oh NO. Now I'm gonna have that image stuck in my head all day. Gee thanks...LOL

  • you cant imagine a night of lustful sexual passion with keith olbermann? Or Maddows? lmao

  • Oh gosh let me see.. An ugly ass man with a limp noodle or a brawny lesbo with a strap-on.... can I go throw up now?

  • you're falsely assuming olbermann has a "noodle" hahaha

  • I see Keith with the strap on and Maddow bottoms up

  • baby killer is right. he'll end up spending more than McCain over time and it will be hard to reverse the programs he wants to institute.

  • obama is in a freefall...I just gave him a swiss cheese parachute. hope he lands safely...if he lands on mecca...the hordes of suicide bombers can break his fall...if he lands in America, I hope he gets mugged by a Blood or a Crip

  • Oshitbama revealed his true monster face at the Saddleback Forum..people can see he's a cold calculating soulless fiend who hates american babies...and then after it he lied about his votes, and then accused mccain of cheating. What a piece of work

  • then right after that he makes a speech about how patriotic he is...by again talking about his white grandpa... makes so much sense... and then he threatens McCain lol... Obama unhinged

  • well that's a good sign for McCain...I had also heard on some report...can't remember which...that obama had planned on using the race card but not quite yet...so that means he's getting desperate...probably wanted to have loads of numbers for when they hold the convention. it's backfiring on him though

    : ) lol the race card was probably going to be his october surprise.