Alireza Ghorbani - arjang seyfizadeh - vesal-shiraz 1

[shafagh1980]

kheili ziba , mesle hamishe...

[manoshaida]

Beautiful song, beautiful voice, talented musicians! We need to encourage our dear musicians. Big complements to these "new- comers". If anyone has the talent he/she should first try to sing like him. We always forget how much they have been putting effort to get here. Thanks for sharing this video!

[btala001]

afarin. aliye.

[zoreastre]

They made a beautiful song,wel done.

[Nahoft]

why do you delete negative comments? Dont you need the truth?

[Meaneradicator]

I like Nahoft's constructive criticisms.

He is not mean, he is just knowledgeable and knows what he is talking about.

[afsoos1386]

Unfortunately I find Nahoft's criticism mean and non-constructive, every time. I'm yet to see a single positive, constructive comment from him/her on the entire Youtube Persian music scene, which is the area I browse. The above comment is very typical of him: Negative comments are the truth regardless of its content!!!

Perhaps he's just jealous :^)

[Nahoft]

Singer sounds too much like shajarian in the 1st minute. Shajarian's voice is not exactly a beautiful voice. Then he is out of tune all over the song but particularly around 2':30". The song is just ugly musically and its message is heavy-handed.

[filsoofimusic]

and remember he's a young singer and in live performances there is always stress that can cause those  out of tune singing.

[scorpeyman]

hva sier dere? kuksugere pikk horer fitte sleikere

[filsoofimusic]

Nahoft aziz Shajarian vioce being beautiful or not is something absolutly based on personal taste, like so many people don't like Nazeri or eftekhari....there is no way we can have a statement that someone's voice is not beautiful.

[razmjooie]

ghorbani shagerde shajarian naboode. albate in na hosn hast va na eyb, faghat jahate etela bood.

[salar1365]

nafasesh garm in shagerde layeghe ostad shajarian......