Added: 4 years ago
From: weneedhelp
Views: 1,388,441
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (20,401)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i dont ever salute that redneck, indian killing, sorry excuse of a flag, i cant wait till i move to mexico ! that country gets it done right!

  • FUCK YOU OBAMA! I never really liked you to begin with, but now I have a reason to hate you. You just pissed on every veteran's grave and service they have given to their country. You are not my president and you make it really easy to choose sides.

  • If your "religion" or anything else other than missing two arms prevents you from being able to show the most basic form of respect to the flag guess what? YOU ARE NOT QUALIFIED TO BE THE PRESIDENT OR HOLD ANY OTHER POLITICAL OFFICE OR GOVERNMENT JOB! I don't care if your are a janitor in one of the state offices. It may not be a law, but it is common sense. I know it is not on the books, but no one ever really considered that the elected leader of the US would actually hate his own country.

  • He got Bin Laden. Nuff said.

  • Atleast Obama knows how to stand for something like this. I wouldnt even done that.

  • So... I wouldnt salute it either. Id cover my balls too...

  • Just more proof that Nobama is doing everything he can to destroy My Nation. Thanks for putting him in office people....

  • @dobeywil10 h, Then all Americans should be held to that standard, not just Obama. Ex: watch the latest football & baseball games and the people at the bottom of this video. People fail to understand when you point your finger at someone, 3 fingers are pointed back at you.

  • Comment removed

  • What a horrible rendition of the Star Spangled Banner! Jeez! Don't give up the day job.

  • By the way, NO ONE pictured in this video is saluting! Your hand over your chest is not a salute. More propaganda bullshit!

  • @bass4usall propaganda LMAO.. Lay off the cool-aid there.

  • @bass4usall actually, your hand over your heart is considered a salute for a civilian. Only military salutes at the forehead (well, and scouts). That said, all that is asked for the national anthem is that you "rise and take off your hats" which Obama is clearly doing. Would have been more worrisome if it was the pledge, but it's not. Anyways, just an FYI.

  • Barack Mohammed Sharia Rogue Nation Hussein. This man got in on his oratory skills alone. Duped very dumbed down Americans with the same. A Hussein is a Hussein, his worshippers will soon regret him.

  • ....And now..and ever since,when i see our Flag,i remember that Old Banner that so many were killed and or wounded to make sure the other men could see it through the smoke and din of Battle and not lose heart in the face of the enemy.The flag is a symbol of that heart,of that preserverance to ensure that freedom becomes the birthright of ALL Americans.It is NOT to disrespected.Escpecially by a sitting President!

  • when i was still a child,I once saw an old tattered American Flag up on a museum wall.The Stars and its Stripes were faded and badley worn.It once was the brigade colors of some long ago regiment that fought at Antietam.It was still covered in the blood of the men who carried it that day....

  • Yes, while disgracing the American flag, the President is singing along to the national anthem. This video should be retitled, "Obama: The First Ever Politician Caught Singing on Camera!"

  • Also, REFUSES!? He didn't 'REFUSE' anything! More like, just didn't. Nobody walked up to him with a gun and said, 'SALUTE THE FLAG, BYACH' and he refused... You guys are fucking insane

  • @danerogil lolol ikr!!

  • Did she just say 'We're having poo poo tonight' ?

  • @dobeywill .. come arrest me then, this country is such an abortion i neither stand up or cover my heart any more.

  • @ie750 Then move the hell out!

  • you right wingers say hes not American, and that his birth certificate is a sham. make up your minds because it sounds like ur mad at an illegal alien for not saluting a flag that isnt his. which is a retarded righty thing to do...sorry guys carry on.

  • @ie750 You are a friggin moron.

  • I never put my hand over my heart during the national anthem, but I will when i say the Pledge of Allegiance. I just stand up and listen. I think to remain seated during the playing of the national anthem is disrespectful. I still love this country and I'll never want to live anywhere else.

  • Good God that was the worst rendition of the national anthem that I've ever heard.

  • That singing was as bad as Christina Aguilera's.

  • Was that MOO-chelle trying to sing? I don't know what is worse, the singing/disrespect for the anthem, or the disrespect for the flag.

  • If nobody realized it yet, this is the National Anthem! you put your hand over your heart when you pledge allegiance to the flag.

  • @Darkprince250 RIGHT....DUMB ASS PEOPLE HATING ON OBAMA DAMN WHERE EVERY LIL THANG HE DO PEOPLE ON HIS DICK...NOBODY POSTED THE VIDEO OF BUSH GETTIN SHOES THROWED AT HIM.....OBAMA THE MOST HATED ON PRESIDENT

  • @davontioallen06 I actually saw several videos and renditions of former president Bush getting shoes thrown at him.

    As for the most hated on president, I think Reagan may still have that one. Justly so, I might add.

  • @paranoiaddr Reagan? What in the hell are you talking about?

  • @davontioallen06 Shoes throwed at him? What kind of fucked up English is that?

  • @Darkprince250 United States Code, 36 U.S.C. § 301, states that during a rendition of the national anthem, when the flag is displayed, all present except those in uniform should stand at attention facing the flag with the right hand over the heart;

  • @dobeywil10 Correct, those in uniform will stand at attention and salute.

  • If you voted for Obama the first time to prove you werent racist, Dont vote for his in 2012 to prove your not an IDIOT....Worst president EVER...

  • This is just racist prapaganda politics. Great, inflame people by saying he isn't patriotic, heck he isn't even American because he didn't slaute or place his hand over his heart for a song. As people have been mentioning, they weren't slauting the flag and this wasn't The Pledge of Allegiance. Admit it, you get off on being racist and that's really what thhis is all about.

  • I'm from the south. A 16 year old "redneck" girl. Since everyone has the right to say what they want, I'm going to. I don't agree with this. You should respect your country and those who died so we could be here. And I would say that to ANYBODY. Not all rednecks are uneducated, racist idiots.

  • Yes big fucking deal . Bush murdered millions and indirectly robbed tax payers of billions of dollars. Rednecks, Hillbillies, inbred Southerners shouldn't be allowed to vote.

  • @Fasil777 What do you call the bailout? You dumb fuck!

  • He should have put his hands over his ears...

  • So putting a hand on the chest actually means something to you?

    SHEEP!

    The pledge and anthem are bull shit!

    Just a way for crooks to con stupid people into thinking they care about America.

    The 1st thing every crook does it wave the flag.

  • God DAMN, Hillary Clinton should not sing EVER! lol

  • who ever singing sux ass thats the worst ever

  • None of this matters, really. Fuck him, anyway.

  • THE FIRST KENYAN PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES

  • why shoud he what is america?

  • this disreapectful prick was my commander and cheif when i served this asshole needs a wake up call yet again he fucks up.tyipal i guess for a raggie lover

  • @MegaDoom1985 You're a racist.

  • Unless you've always put your hand on your heart or saluted during the anthem, you're a giant ass and a hypocrite for crying foul at this.

    Must be you're running out of things to bitch about if you're just going to start making up rules and regulations for things like our national anthem rather than find legitimate things that are actually worthy of scorn--like that woman's absolute butchering of our nation's song. 

  • He's not saluting because he can't tell what the hell she's singing.

  • This was the national anthem, there is no requirement that anyone salute or put their hand over their heart during the playing of the national anthem, you're thinking of the pledge of allegiance. The only requirement of an American during the playing of the anthem is to rise and remove their hats. And who is that singing? My Gods, she's no Muse I will tell you that. Sounds horrible. I'd feel too distraught to salute too with that voice around me.

  • @PriestChristopher its just a respectful thing to do for our country.

  • at least he doesn't pretend to be with the constitution unlike the stupid neocons

  • Well technically they are all suppose to be facing the flag as well. At least according to the constitution, so I guess none of them are patriotic. And neither is the audience, because none of them were saluting the flag. I guess the many many pledges he's led over the years with his hand on his heart doesn't count as patriotic because of this one time he was singing the star spangle banner instead of saluting!

  • @MorganTinney Good question. but its just the "right thing to do", isnt it? i mean, doesnt every president, politician or person try to push the envelope a bit anyway? But i dont agree with his lack of respect for our country and those who fight to keep our freedom.

  • He's such a jackass. I wouldn't be surprised if he was a sleeper either.

  • @Polluxdc You're a sleeper.

  • So take your hats off, put your hand on your heart and when you are standing there looking at those stars and stripes, think of all the struggle and strife we have went through as a country. Be PROUD to be American and show it as often as you can! United We Stand. Semper Fi

  • Not required, Forgot, Pitiful rendition of the Star Spangled Banner? Excuses. Bad Excuses. I don't care who you are, if you are an American, you should be saluting or have a hand over your heart.Not because its required, but because you are Proud of who you are and where you live. Yeah we have our problems, just like any other country, but we all still choose to live here.

  • What's worse is that he is friends with Rev Wright and Bill Ayers

  • Star Spangled Banner does NOT require to place your hand over your heart.. This video is made by either (A.) By a racist idiot OR (B.) Just someone who simply don't like Obama in his videos (Republican).... You DO NOT have to have your hand above your heart during the "Star Spangled Banner".... By the way im a republican and I don't agree with Obama's views

  • Your an idiot. It's not required to cover your heart for the Star Spangled Banner. Obama is the only one who knew the difference between the National Anthem and The Pledge of Allegiance (and look who became president)

  • @brianmorel Excatly!!!!

  • Why should a "Black" man salute the flag of the Red necks with White faces and Blue eyes?

    This message was not approved by the producers of mind control.

  • hell i wouldn't acknowledge that pitiful version of the star spangled banner either.

  • @rosamaria43curtis You dumb shit! It's not the singing we acknowledge..

    it's the Flag..

  • Did he refuse or just forget?

  • I don't care for Obama myself but this is the national anthem, you are NOT required to place your hand over your heart for the singing of the anthem. If it were the Pledge of Allegiance, and he did this, I would be upset being that he is supposed to be the leader of this country but thus far has not acted like it.

  • When I share this video, people think it's fake because of that awful singing

  • omg is the singer hasving a seizure

  • It's the Star Spangled Banner.....regardless of if she can sing or not, respect should be shown; for the words are what's important...

  • 1. This singer is shit

    2. Obama should put his hand on his heart. If he was born in this country, WE been doing that since grade school!!

  • This is not the pledge of allegiance, but a very poorly sung rendition of the national anthem. Last time I checked, not many people hold their hand over their hearts all the way through the national anthem. Whoever sang this so poorly is the one who should be accused of not having patriotism.

  • "weneedhelp"? more like, YOUneedhelp. the fact that people focus on this sort of empty rhetoric and don't focus on actually-IMPORTANT things, like ending poverty and hunger, creating jobs, and improving access to health care, is the real tragedy here.

  • He's the Commander and Chief of the Armed Forces and The President of The United States. He should have some god damn patriotism and pride in his country. He's not any other normal citizen that gets choices and freedoms to just do as he pleases. His position and status comes with responsibilities and expectations.

  • Good god someone shoot that alley cat that's wail.. oh shit it's someone actually singing

  • Barrack Obama the man, he shits all over you in front of your faces and you still support him!

  • Who the fucks does anything when the anthem plays? Last I checked this criticism is only partially valid for the pledge of allegiance not the fucking anthem, not to mention there were others standing there doing the same thing because they knew as well how silly it is to do anything during the anthem. Typical reich-wing extremists putting their panties in a wad over the stupidest things.

  • Well, the singing was really bad.... And I am glad someone is showing our "pretender in chief" for what he is...

  • My ears are bleeding so bad that the blood got in my eyes and I can't see the video... could hardly type....

  • that woman can't sing worth shit.

  • This woman screwed up this beautiful song worst than Roseanne Barr!!! And Obama with his hands on his nuts not even pretending to be patriotic. Look where our country is going. This was the greatest country on earth. It is not Obama fault. He is just a stooge that does what he is told. He works for the same people Bush, Clinton, and all the rest of those cock suckers in Washington selling us out. The richest families in the world and their minions I.E. WorldBank own basically all politicians. .

  • Barack Hussein Obama II, illegal President, was born August 4, 1961 at the Coast Province General Hospital in Mombasa, Kenya and NOT in Hawaii as he claims. A high resolution copy of OBAMA’S KENYAN BIRTH CERTIFICATE is available for free download at WasObamaBornInKenya (DOTcom) … Lucas Daniel Smith obtained a certified copy of Obama’s Kenyan birth certificate from the birth hospital in February 2009. His amazing story is told in a VIDEO that is also available for viewing at the same website.

  • there was obviously another flag you fucking idiot

  • people who care about something as stupid as this shouldn't be allowed to vote or have children

  • @smilieboy so respect for our nations flag is stupid?

    

  • @911Inspector He's standing quietly with his hands clasped, in what universe is that a sign of disrespect?

  • During rendition of the national anthem when the flag is displayed, all present except those in uniform should stand at attention facing the flag with the right hand over the heart. Men not in uniform should remove their headdress with their right hand and hold it at the left shoulder, the hand being over the heart. Persons in uniform should render the military salute at the first note of the anthem and retain this position until the last note.

  • He is a fucking joke. It's a good thing that wasn't in soldier territories

  • Jesus Christ in heaven. I could care less how he positioned his hands. No, I take HUGE offense at the BUTCHERY OF THE ANTHEM by that GOD AWFUL PERFORMER!! Good lord, if you do not have the vocal range an skill to sing it as it is written then DO NOT SING IT and allow someone who CAN do so!

  • @MakeupWoot : I doubt English was her(?) mother tongue. Perhaps she was born outside the U.S.

  • i served in the us army for 6 years....all i have to say is..PLEASE GET THIS MORON OUT OF OFFICE!!!!

  • Lol it's not a big deal...he made a little mistake, so what?

  • he prolly had ear plugs in so he wouldnt couldnt her sing and didnt know she had started LOL. that was terrible!!! ...i think william hung would have done a better job. My ears are bleeding!

  • There's your president America. FAIL!

  • Now if his hands would have been over his ears I would of understood that

  • uhm... ok? who cares... maybe he has a certain belief that he believes he shouldnt put his hand over his heart while listening to an incorrect song...

  • WTF is she singing? The real story here should be the remix of the National Anthem.

  • What point are you trying to make by putting his middle name in the title, that you're racist????? Get over yourself obviously the president of the United States isn't a terrorist you IDIOT.

  • @psufan38 Fine. Then lets call him by his birth name, Barry Sorento. Funny, I called George Walker Bush that many times and never got called a racist, but all of a sudden, because he is black, I get called a racist for calling him by his chosen name. A name he chose to embrace his Muslim heritage. Race card FAIL. Cassius Clay ring a bell? pun intended. Go read Dreams of My Father. I have.

  • @weneedhelp Great response!!!

  • @weneedhelp For one, I think where he put his hand is irrelevant. He showed respect in the video. People are merely looking for something to hold against him. Plus, you can't deny that Hussein will inevitably draw comparisons to Saddam. Also, he doesn't have much of a Muslim heritage. His father became atheist and his mother wasn't religious.

  • @weneedhelp go read up on American history, and you will learn why you're a racist.

  • @psunfan38 - Except that his birth certificate states

    "Barack Hussein Obama II"

  • @psufan38 you are probably an unintelligent "african american" that likes to throw the race card out there because yall have nothing better to say than that same stupid shit!

  • @psufan38 Including someone's middle name doesn't make it racist. It's his middle name and its a fact. If you're offended by this, then its clear you're the one making the racist connections

  • @psufan38

    LOL, you suggesting someone might be an "idiot", but I bet you can't give a logical explanation of how putting Obama's middle name in the title makes him racist.

    DERP

  • @psufan38 and obviously you are racist, God you're retarded. And whether or not he is a terrorist isn't under question in this video, not in the title, tags, or the video itself. Where do you get off?? lol, Barry Sorento. You probably thought King Kong was racist too didn't you?? Freaking retard.

  • @psufan38 u my friend are blind.

  • @psufan38 - Are you sure hes not a terrorist ? Is the war in Iraq not illegal and he is planning on attacking Iran a country that has not threatened America . Americans are terrorists plain and simple because if you dont run your own country the way America wants under their rules you are a target . Does that not say terrorist to you ? It does to me ! Fuck your terrorist president Barack HUSSEIN Obama , like Saddam Hussein same name same ruling techniques !

  • George H.W. Bush, a WWII veteran, also had pictures where he didn't hold his hand over his heart during the anthem. Stop being negative by nitpicking a president because you don't like him and try supporting him, because he is the leader of our country. I didn't vote for him but this stuff gets old.

  • @Kyler1029 You are citing GHWB or his son GWB as an example? Because both of them did WONDERS for this country. LOL. I didn't vote for him but this stuff gets old. Yeah you are right. Ltes focus on:

    Obama Administration To Use ACTA Signing Statement To Defend Why It Can Ignore The Constitution In Signing ACTA

    Once Again, The Freedom Of Information Act Is Proving To Be Just That: An Act

    Confirmed: US Was The 'Lone Holdout' In Refusing To Release ACTA Text

    watch?v=KbloFXsumkU

    SOPA PROTECT-IP

  • @weneedhelp I'm not saying Obama is perfect man, I'm just saying you can nitpick every president for something. If you have some issues that you don't agree with, that's cool. That ACTA thing sounds like something that needs opposition. But the message of the video is to somehow show Obama isn't patriotic, and that's not what he is showing here. I was citing H.W. Bush as someone who didn't hold his hand over his heart solely to show that another president has done the same thing.

  • @Kyler1029 nitpick? A presidential candidate not placing his hand over his heart nitpicking? A president that based his campaign on being open, when in turn is worse than Bushie on FOIA requests and goes so far as to flag groups like EFF for extra scrutiny and redaction.

    Justice Department Drops Its Request To Be Allowed To Lie In Response To FOIA Requests

    Court Slams FBI For Saying It's Okay For The Federal Government To Lie To A Court

    Just another 2 of hundreds.

  • He wasn't president during this look at the date

  • @rapture6200 He wasn't president during this look at the date

    What does that have to do with anything? He was a Presidential hopeful, and made his intention clear he was going to run for President., and was still a Senator. Disgraceful in any context.

  • @weneedhelp and a US citizen?? wtf obama...

  • @rapture6200 Neither were any of the other people on that stage , and it seems he's also decided to remove the U S flag from the tail of his 757 plane

  • @rapture6200 So? He was RUNNING for President. Shouldn't you salute the Country you'll be leading if you're going to be the President?! This fool should be out of office. Impeachment, please.

  • @rapture6200 he may not have been President at the time but I have had family visit from across the world and they still show respect to the flag and our nation and salute it. This fool can't even seem to figure out what respect is.

  • @rapture6200 moron does that matter when the date was??? i totally agree with weneedhelp. if he couldnt have respect for our country, flag and how much our soldiers have sacrificed for our country then why run for president? clearly he could give a crap about our country AND he still will NOT face the flag and/or place his hand over his heart when the pledge is said or our countrys national anthem. you will be the idiot to vote him in again huh? hopefully people have come to their senses.

  • @rapture6200 on top of all that, he's a US citizen... wtf Obama??

  • This is a good reason not to vote for Obama.

  • And people wanted to kill Jose Feliciano after HIS national anthem....

    I don't like barack obama but I think the bigger issue here is that fuckin lady.

  • Is the singer having a stroke? I bet half her face was paralyzed by the end of the song.

  • how the hell can someone who don't pay respects to the flag be in the oval office?

  • Patriotism is parasitic, like a religion for the enslaved.

  • Sure it cloud be consider a disrespect to the Nation, yet it doesn't change his position. Instead of observing a sign of honor be more aware of Obamas decisions upon America in wich will soon impact freedom. The economy already went down the drain, the next step will be worst.

  • This is highly disrespectful Our President is a leader and he of all people should not have disrespected our country this way. Our hand should Always be placed over our Heart during the Pledge or National Anthem if not I feel it is disrespectful to our country and the men and woman who fight for our freedom.

  • @driftawaywith69

    Not once did I ever put my hand on my chest during the anthem throughout my life, that is for the pledge not for the anthem!! And the reason the other people are doing it is because just like 80% of our population they are fucking dumb!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • When did we start putting our hand over our hearts during the national anthem? If you notice, the last two people on the podium dont either.. And the camera cuts away from them quick..

  • @MrLealra thankyou for having a brain. Most people on here are bitchen. Never ever have i placed my hand on my chest for this!

  • Anyone with any vocal training knows that if you cant sing well and hit notes properly then you slide around to mask it. The woman butchering the National Anthem in an Obama-nation.

  • forget obama.. im more offeneded by that damn singer.. who authorized THAT?!?! eewww!!

  • Maybe he really needed to go to the bathroom. Look, potty dance at 0:19 - 0:31.

  • omg...i think she said poo poo one time. at (22 sec). best national anthem ever. I think Obama was just in shock of the amazing talent...haha

  • God i mss george w bush!

  • Her singing is horrid, but that's not an excuse for rude behavior...Whoever says he didn't know what was happening didn't watch the video... HE IS SINGING! So tell me again, how he didn't know what was going on.

  • I can clearly here whats singing plain as day bad singing though

  • this singer should have her tongue removed

  • Ok you young leftist fucks, how's that hope and change thing workin out for ya?

  • @9doho9 Things are starting to shape up, thanks for asking. Now if the republicans would stop filibustering any votes from the floor that do not involve redefining a bicycle or deciding on the national moto things would be getting better faster, but sadly it looks like we have a lot of replacing to do in congress to get corporate interests out of the top spot of some politicians attention.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • i don;t think he recognized the song! lol. still ,he should have slauted anyways.....look over at his neighbors and see what they were doing! ;)

  • Oh man, hand not over your heart = not American somehow...

  • we owe the chiniese goverment trillions of dollars we have borowed so much money from china we can pay for them too have the largest badest army in the world i think obama is allies with other countries besides amarica not trien to be raciest but if a white man did that he would be thrown out of office imedeatly i hate him he should never been voted into office and dont let him win next ellection he will destroy amarica he already has screwed us 2012 is end of amarica not the world obama is why

  • @MultiShutthefuckup The only reason the POTUS can be thrown out of office is through impeachment proceedings. These can only be brought up for capital crimes against the country. The color of the skin of the POTUS does not determine if he can or can not be thrown out of office. There was no crime in not putting his hand on his heart.

    I had a hard time recognizing the song myself, knowing what to be looking for. Yes he should have looked around and followed suit, but there was no crime not.

  • th likes bar is so misleading in this video. Do people like the fact that Obama didnt salute this flag? Do they dislike the fact that the title's misleading? Do they like the information of this happening being shown to them on their computer? What is the deal????

  • "I don't get all choked up over yellow ribbons and American flags. I consider them to be symbols and I leave symbols to the symbol-minded." The real crime here is horrific singer.

  • retard presidant he doesnt even like this country enough to salute r national anthem.

  • @sarahaliza12

    ...why should you salute to a flag? It is just a piece of cloth. In fact I think I'd probably did the same if I was in his shoes... just standing there not knowing what to do wondering if it is ok to play games on my mobile or read the news... or simply stare at some cleavage.

  • While i agree that the HERD wants him to do as they do, Obama is probably just a rationalist who finds survile activities like blindly and roboticly putting his hand by his heart to be something that only stupid people do.....and I agree. Fuck saluting the flag. That is for you idiots to do.

  • if someone criticised him because of the economy fair enough, But most of the time including with some of the comments on this video, fucking dumb cunts criticise him for the smallest things ever. 

  • Socialist pig doesn't believe in democracy, that song was butchered, was it karaoke

  • What a dirty King of the Gypsies!

  • Just keeping your mind off whats really going on in the world....

  • maybe he recodnized the woman singing was butchering his countries song and said fuck this shit im not gonna support this dishonorable butchering.

  • hes saluting his big black balls... thats all

  •  LOL...... wtf

  • Comment removed

  • Wtf is she singing???!!!! Desecration and Dishonor! Off with their heads.

  • @AngelStarDust1212 Especially when Whitney Houston sang half of the words of the Star-Spangled Banner. And what's sad is that Obama didn't even salute the flag,he just looked at the flag while everyone else did it. I bet if the Obama followers see this video,they could careless if his hand was over his heart or not.

  • @AngelStarDust1212 She's passing kidney stones, give her a break.

  • Fuckin puke. If it was the Irainan National anthem he would have wipped out his prayer rug, and kneeled on it.

  • @PirateMonkeyFilmz it's like stopping at a red light, some people might think why do I have to stop. Well because it's a red light and that's what your suppose to do! And a man in his position when the national anthem is sung putting your hand over your heart is what your suppose to do! You think soldiers shouldn't salute the flag! I bet when Obama dies he'll have that flag on his coffin!

  • He is just trying to hide his giant boner guys. Can't blame the guy, standing up there with Hillary Clinton.. Shit!

  • what song was that?