American Idol 2011 Top 12 Girls - Pia Toscano

[SOOBE01]

That's just amazing.... Nothing else to say.

[dmp1549]

One of the best performances of the season right here. Considering it was her first live show performance that's saying a lot as there have been over a hundred other performances since then.

The only flaw with this performance is it should have been in the top 3 instead of the top 24. She peaked waaayyy too soon.

[spale79]

Pia you are already a star and you do not need American idol. Many greetings from Central Europe, we are waiting for your album. ;-)

[MsHappygirl23]

I love her singing but she had a atitude. It really turned me off. I want people to Love music, and Who are humble to be blessed with music:) Thats why James ROCKED!!!!

[KayPotter1]

wow when ever i hear her muic I will cry that is so fantastic :)

[pizzachrercksz]

hot.hot.hot

[WARRI0RH0CKEY41]

BEAUTIFUL!!  THE BEST!!!

[hejoacca]

is the BEEEEEEEEST!!!!!!!!!! IS THE AMERICAN IDOL FOR ME..

[firpo021]

pia was the best singer in this season, my votes were for her im from Puerto Rico and she still has alot of fans, i hope she continues to sing and for sureee i will buy her first album hope she includes ill stand by you, because she sings this song as no other, PIA TOSCANO the bestttttt

[AnnieTigerChucky]

Best female of the season. Her elimination was a disgrace! She should of made top 3, while Jacob Lusk should be runner-up to Casey Abrams. Truth is, my gut is telling me that James Durbin will be runner-up to Scotty McCreery.

[werneck1111]

she has a beautiful voice but a bitch atitude. "Be Humble" my dear if you like to be the winner.

[Israelgal]

@werneck1111

What?? She exudes class. You can see she is a truly gentle soul with love for everyone in her heart. I don't know how you can interpret her attitude as 'bitchy'.

[thejam1212]

The reason she went out is because people are 2 lazy 2 phone in!!

[Farpo123]

The only one who comes close this year is Lauren...Pia Should have been allowed to go all the way because she is the "BEST of the BEST!". Just wish America felt that way...Pia, you will be #1 REGARDLESS!!!

[purpleporche]

f the people that didnt vote for this chick since she got voted off. yea f u

[PJCLT]

pia ....this really makes me tears every time i watch you sing this song,i watch ten times and listen your good voice.....i watch this american idol compitition every time i wike up in the morning and excited to hear again pia voice....but she go off!

[090783]

OMG...I thought it was actually a Finale Performance....After watching this I thought the competition was over..

[TheFunnyMinute]

omg this was beautiful! 

[facobos1]

I hope she gets a recording deal! I will be the first to buy her CD!!  She is amazing and she has talent, in my opinion. By the way, I'm a music teacher.

[themoonandthesky1]

Pia,,,, you go on girl, I love you so much, by the way I am a female, not a male, its amazing the way you sing, go on, I just wished if you had a chance to sing the Titanic song, ( love gos on and on. ) please would you try to make the wish of American comes true.

[maystiquek]

haha when i heard her beautiful voice it remended me of how fake rebecca black's voice is!!! thumbs up if you agree

[piezforever]

she got voted off memories

[brrger]

(718) 738-4162 this is her cell number

[kelvinpyaeko]

now that i know she was voted off, i was having nostalgia with this! we love you pia

[TheBaseballfrek]

I AM A PIA FAN! AND SHE WILL ALWAYS BE IN MY HEART! I LOVE YOU PIA. I WISH U WERENT GONE :(

[candycheckx0x0]

i like how she says thank you so so much

[mazms]

where did she go before this season? OMG this is truly amazing

[1nspirator]

I think she's going to win it!!

[Jojo11028]

Pia Toscana !!!!!! Wow You're The Best Luv You :)

[pathetic321]

She's a good singer, but is overrated. I mean the way people go on about her, they really set the bar up to space then when I hear her... it's just disappointing, sure she's great but she's no Whitney or Celine.

I was expecting notes that went on for 10 seconds and a high range of notes... not your average female voice ;S

[TheRessa95]

@pathetic321 what you have against Pia she is maybe best female vocalist ever in this show.

[Justinbeiberesmubein]

she is emotionless

[JimKF]

@Justinbeiberesmubein And you are clueless. Pia does sing with emotion.

[oesdoob]

She's gorgeous and she can sing with emotion. LOVE HER!

[Justinbeiberesmubein]

@oesdoob not!

[oesdoob]

@Justinbeiberesmubein oh wow, you're cool. Obviously you're blind and tone deaf. You may not think she's the best, but come on she is really good. You don't have to love them, but at least respect their performance. Grow up.

[babybrownie88]

love her hope she wins if not then Jacob

[biebersbiggestfan818]

i have to say im carrie underwood;s biggest fan, but she sang this better than carrie, Pia has a chance at winning this

[florienous]

Go Pia !!!!!!!!!!!!!

[twdarj]

She kick the shit out of Carrie Underwood.

[Jacc0s]

I think she's really underestimated in how good she can sing! She might even win American Idol! Much much better than Jacob!

[calgboi]

@Jacc0s But Jacob is still awesome! I don't know, unlike last year when Idol was pretty much predictible by the Top10...lots of great contenders this year!

[interstones]

her left hand is reallly really annoying me.... but i think she should win this season :)

[mazms]

@interstones Could have just imagine that hand is holding my hard dick

[Dallas3212]

@interstones lmao omg these commentz just kill me, how is her laft hand annoying you lmfao?

[TheLOUIE1973]

it was better then original

[Jacc0s]

@TheLOUIE1973 I agree

[jsd1018]

this seriously, after hearing her sing this song, has become a favorite song of mine lol

[SamBOWSSBeauge]

NEW American idol videos from the top 12!!

[forrubin]

wow, good job! total package!

[candydeca8]

yay we have the same name!! plus she has amazing vocal

[yigo671ify]

i think they should just crown her american idol 2011 already! lol!

[Cookielover415]

she had a really pretty voice,:D

[jessatwater]

This should be our next American Idol!!!!

[ThePhenomenalOne23]

Pia has it all - Beauty, talent, style, heart, & one AMAZING voice! Def. the best voice of the ladies this year on Idol & my hands-down lock to win it this year. Pia has all the makings of a star who will go places, break records & hearts, & so much more. After her 2nd straight standing ovation on tonight's show for All By Myself and her first w/ this very performance, I think America's got it's next star. As well, I have my newest crush. Go Pia & good luck. Love you, girl!

[stoutsyt]

There's your American Idol for 2011....no question.

[olivecp123]

Pia.. This year american idol is for you..baby ..love ya

[glennece]

nice voice!!!

[krisTrae]

OH WOW! 1 good performance! Doesn't make her the best out of the girls.

[generalhardhead]

Her voice is sooooo strained. Dunno why she got in. She was nearly screaming the lights out of her head.

[caseyshattuck]

@generalhardhead And youre tone deaf!

[generalhardhead]

@caseyshattuck Mmkay.

[trooper553]

I love her! But I also love Lauren Alaina...between them two and Jacob Lusk...its gonna be a hard year!!!

[lanztenizo]

love it!!!amazing performance:D ( ms Iza calsado's look alike..hehe)

[2dlanor2]

Pia's a Barbie Doll who sings well. Too plastic. Naima Adedapo projects more personality and emotion, has a big stage presence and sings well too, though she's not as good-looking. I vote for Naima.

[Joeymabes101]

Final 2

Lauren Alaina

Scotty

Her

Lauren is winning

[dragontato1]

I have to say 2nd best of the girls and 3rd overall but honestly this is a little over rated its not as good as everione is saying it is

[caseyshattuck]

@dragontato1 Youre opinion doesnt mean squat! Watch your Canadian IDOL and voice your opinions there! I am sick of you Canadians we dont care what you socialists think!

[dragontato1]

@caseyshattuck wow i said she did amazing and 3 rd overall all i said its kinda over rated and i dont even watch candian idol cuz its a joke and wow attack my nation for no reason i nvr attack america but well let see u guys elected a idoit for 2 yrs that ruined ur country and ur ecomony and we dnt pay thousands and thousands dollars just for a visit to the doctor

[dragontato1]

@caseyshattuck sorry not 2 yrs two times in a row

[TheAriesAngel]

if this woman doesn't win, america deserves to be slapped up side the head. she has the whole package, talent, grace, and class. 100% hands down the best talent on this show.

[serveone88]

wow



[MrJeigs]

wow..extra amazin,, i hope thia and her will go through the finals

[Adamabomo]

yeah Pia and Scotty are going straight in the final but Scotty will win the whole thing. The math said on the twitter Scotty will come out on the top. He has already million fans and million viewers on youtube.

[The4Romantics]

@Adamabomo ~ Wait until you hear Pia sing "Bleeding Love"....

This was WOW but if she performs "BL" like I her Pia Perform it "Bleeding Love" will be an even more Amazing Performance then this one....

[Clof1959]

For All Those that just say she can Sing but was not the Best I have only one comment.

"On This Night & With This Performance Pia was 'Head & Shoulders' Above All The Rest".

I'll guarantee anyone Pia was in the Top 2 in Voting when she was announced Thursday as being in the Top 10.

Of couse the Judges added another 3 making the Finals a Top 13

Who Else got All 3 Judges giving them a Standing Ovation.

NO ONE!!!!!

At least give Credit when credit is due regardless of who you're Rooting For.

[florienous]

Go PIA  !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[mrpsa]

@Clof1959 i have one comment for you: your mouth is so BIG and you are so opinionated! Mind your own opinion and close your mouth because it's too big for the human ear! get it?

[yellowmartini]

she's my fave.. she can win ..love the voice..

[and1s4ndoro]

i think all other woman contestant think " how the hell i can beat that voice"

[heartstolenify]

I think she's a look alike of Selena Gomez.... but she's amazing I want Pia Toscano to win american Idol season 10 :)

[nchoneync]

She can sing but i don't think she was the best..

[Kate001SoulNote]

Amazing, especially for a contestant!!!!! She sounds like a pro.

[jackathilton]

I got goosebumps whenever I listen to Pia's voice. She has a total package.. Beauty with voice is the recipe for a win. Look at Carrie Underwood! She will be proud of Pia's rendition.

[SunnyLovetts]

America has bad taste in music...

[Clof1959]

@SunnyLovetts ~ If you don't like this Lady's singing then I'll say the "Bad Taste In Music" lies with you, Sunny,

Not America...But you are entitled to have "Bad Taste"...

[markcasa09]

love her

[tifflope001]

nice!

[bobmarleyja]

Best of the night. She is smart to pick a good song.