One other thing I love about this recording is Paul Goodwin's oboe playing. That pause in the introduction before he begins the downward run at 0:17 is delicious, I can't think of a better word to describe it! And the tension at 0:43 where the oboe climbs up to the high d leaving the soprano in suspension over the harmony is superb, although hard to hear (it's a little better in stereo &fmt=18 at the end of the URL)
what a shame you have these awesome, unique and best recs ever of these glorious english 18th cen. composers and have but a poor opinion of them. I saw live Julia Gooding and she have the most charming and beautiful tone of soprano voice that fits perfectly in this repertoire. cheers!
You misunderstand, I love this recording. I think Julia Gooding is a superb soprano, the "thin" tone I mentioned is deliberate and perfect for this style, as is her intonation with wide leading notes and purer major thirds (and the necessary narrower fifths) and intelligent use of vibrato. I was merely commenting that Youtube doesn't do the recording justice.
No, you're right. Although it's not bad on the CD, Youtube doesn't do the recording any favours. It's infinitely better than any modern recording I've heard - with so much vibrato you can't tell what note is being sung!
I think it's just the style of performance. The 18th Century English soprano sound is characteristically "thin", as for the intonation, this recording is performed with an unequal temperament.
YES!!!! If they turned Tempest into an Opera, this is EXACTLY what Ariel would sound like!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
SopranoKayla1992 2 years ago
One other thing I love about this recording is Paul Goodwin's oboe playing. That pause in the introduction before he begins the downward run at 0:17 is delicious, I can't think of a better word to describe it! And the tension at 0:43 where the oboe climbs up to the high d leaving the soprano in suspension over the harmony is superb, although hard to hear (it's a little better in stereo &fmt=18 at the end of the URL)
TheCrazyCello 3 years ago
what a shame you have these awesome, unique and best recs ever of these glorious english 18th cen. composers and have but a poor opinion of them. I saw live Julia Gooding and she have the most charming and beautiful tone of soprano voice that fits perfectly in this repertoire. cheers!
coaxqueen 3 years ago
You misunderstand, I love this recording. I think Julia Gooding is a superb soprano, the "thin" tone I mentioned is deliberate and perfect for this style, as is her intonation with wide leading notes and purer major thirds (and the necessary narrower fifths) and intelligent use of vibrato. I was merely commenting that Youtube doesn't do the recording justice.
TheCrazyCello 3 years ago
oui mais cela n'excuse pas les notes approximativement...
Emma7Peel 3 years ago
No, you're right. Although it's not bad on the CD, Youtube doesn't do the recording any favours. It's infinitely better than any modern recording I've heard - with so much vibrato you can't tell what note is being sung!
TheCrazyCello 3 years ago
joli mais serré, et quelques aigus un peu faux...
Emma7Peel 3 years ago
I think it's just the style of performance. The 18th Century English soprano sound is characteristically "thin", as for the intonation, this recording is performed with an unequal temperament.
TheCrazyCello 3 years ago