my dog has been put to the ground by other dogs many times.. he never took it personal, he just got up, shaked and was just as happy afterwards.. but now he is older and obedient and doesn't need to be put to the ground by me or other animals anymore, it was just when he was young he allways tried to challenge other more dominant dogs or tried to be all hormone maniac to female dogs, they barked, touched him with their teeth (no biting) and put him on the ground.
@mvgreene Yes I know! Reason why I commented on the skit being hilarious! I was just commenting on everyone else's serious comments! Cesar would think its hilarious as well. But I couldn't help myself to comment in the comment box to the comment below my first comment. Geez, just because I have to be a YouTube Whisperer don't blame me. I still have a sense of humor. But thanks anyways.
@InDogsWeTrust11 Dominance to a dog is when it's striving to outdo you which means YOU HAVE TO TRY HARDER THAN THEM or get them in line with you or do what most people do and give up and let the dog do whatever. Punishment and corrections are totally different, if your angry when you are trying to get something or someone to understand something...that is punishment! You should study leadership much better. Check out the video on my channel Because this is what Cesar is talking about.
@InDogsWeTrust11 Are you joking me? There is no comparison and that's why we get dogs that act the way they do because people like you compare them to humans! There is no strangling or manhandling involved! If so you would see many different fights at the dog Psychology center a dog is a dog, let it be a dog just face it, they are not little furry Teddy bears, yes they are cute but they rely solely on instinct.
How come this turns out be a parody of cruelty against dogs? Seriously people, dogs are NOT HUMAN! Why can't you get it through your thick skulls. Please let your canine sit at your dinner table because making them eat OFF THE FLOOR in most eyes would be cruel so prop em up at the dinner table tonite for sunday supper, after all your children don't eat off the floor why should your dogs. Hitting a dog is not ok. But going against it's nature is very cruel.
@WarriorAngelWings Dogs have every bit the same emotion as humans, and it is not ok to do this to them either. I like how this video shows what it looks like to do it to humans.Your comments about eating at the dinner table are ridiculous, we are talking about strangling and manhandling dogs. This isnt natural, dogs DONT interact this way.. every real behaviourist or ethologist know this. Blaming behaviour on dominance is an excuse for punishment.
OMG, this was awesome. I kept bursting into laughter. The acting is terrific. I can't believe NatGeo continues that harmful program. When people quote CM, I try to point them to Karen Pryor or other real trainers who understand behavioral psychology (across species).
zloradnii, stop word-vomiting about scientific theory & empirical data. Milan grew up w/ dogs on his grandpa's farm, "culling" the ultimate empirical data, from his LIFE. Evidence: innumerable dogs have gone thru rehab, became ppl/dog friendly, & saved from euthanization. His psychology center dogs, some once dangerous, are calm & friendly. I'd trust CM w/ a violent dog than u w/ ur "science" & smart talk any day. So plz, shut up. u sound like an idiot. After all, actions speak loudr than words.
If you want to talk about having "more than enough free time to vent..." why not mention the perfect example, zlorandnii? Maybe a little "Shhht!" might curb his/her seemingly unhealthy and obsessive behavior.
Growing up on grandpas' farm hardly qualifies one as an authority on anything, much less animal behavior. LIfe true, then Charles Manson qualifies as a top surgeon. While it may be difficult to wean yourself from the cult leader Millan, and the charms of TV, extolling your ignorance so recklessly only serves to discredit you.. Do you really take pride in illiteracy? Your refusal to set aside your ego only suggests you don't give a damn about dogs.Sorry, old boy, CM is a fraud.
I admit that I'm ignorant in this area, that growing up on a farm doesn't make anyone an animal expert, and that there are many who blindly worship celebrities. However, it's still hard to believe you due to the extreme nature of your argument.There are always positives and negatives to each side of an issue and your purely one-sided stance is what I've become defensive to. Opposite of what Peddle1986 says, I don't have the time to argue so I'll stop here. Good luck w/ life & thx for the debate.
Um, nope. The behaviour you so naively interpret as "calm" is in fact dogs who have been shut down duie to flooding, learned helplesness, and other archaic methods. No need to take my word for it. Do the work, read the voluminous critiques by bona fide authorities on the subject. Don't be lazy. It is no accident the Humane Society and so many others --vets, behaviorists, scientists - want this dangerous charletan taken off the air. Do the work. Read. What are you afraid of? The truth? .
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Growing up on grandpa's farm hardly qualifies anyone as an authority on animal behavior. It is no accident that the majority of bona fide authorities, including the Humane Society, have demanded CM be taken off the air. Your crude, defensive posture, only serve to extol the breathtaking ignorance of your wholly insupportable position. Why don't you do your homework? Get the facts. What are you afraid of, the truth? Or are you content to follow the CULT leader, no matter the harm he does?
Your remarks would be laughable were it not for the fact that the subject is so serious, and that willingness to remain ignorant is so dangerous. Alas, you are sorely and demonstrably mistaken. What you perceive as "calm" is the behavior of dots who CM has "shut down." Look it up. His archaic methods involve flooding, forced helplessness, stringing, and worse. Once you let TV think on your behalf, as it clearly has in your case, the game is up. Do the work; don't buy into CM's con.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Of course, you will respond, in anger You can't help yourself . But it doesn't matter. You belong to that gullible group of celebrity worshipers who would happily jump off a cliff if CM told you to. There is no reasoning with you; your responses have been hopelessly manipulated and conditioned to remain blind. CM's ersatz "dominance' theories have served to empower you, just as they have millions of naive consumers, so that you can assert your God like authority over an innocent animal.
CM, in his books, confuses critical opinion for scientific theory. A theory is not an opinion, or speculation, but the nucleus of empirical data, culled over many years and innumerable trials, rigorous tests, and examinations, which serve to elaborate, demonstrate, and prove the cause, effect, and efficacy of a phenomenon. Opinion is not even the issue here for any bona fide authority. I'm afraid poor CM is little more than a poseur preaching to the gullible for ratings and money.
In addition to the reams of scientific data from legions of distinguished authorities on canine behavior and training , who protest CM, there are also EDITORIALS calling for the same thing in such august publications as the NY TIMES, ESQUIRE, SF CHRONICLE, HUFFINGTON POST, and dozens of other mainstream publications the world over. It's no joke. CM has created a serious public health hazard that is both influential and well financed. Will legislators please pay attention!
All the university studies of the science of behavior and cutting edge trainers since the late 1830 beginning with Skinner have shown that dominance is an antiquated way of training , Try doing dominace with a whale and see where it gets you when all trust is lost between you !
Mountains of actual research not made up stuff like CM does ... have shown that dominace hurts makes learned helplessness, generalized fear of the environment , aggression , avoidance/ escape and much more ..
Finally a rational, educated person! The research is clear, chasing a scared dog with a toaster doesn't qualify as a respected method of behavior modification!
@angeleasfeathers Your walnut sized spark box failed to take reality into account. Cesar's way works. You circumcise your newborn sons, you pierce your daughter's ears in the name of beauty yet, you think it unethical to discipline an unruly dog. You are insane.
I love Ceasar so much, he's the best :) And this is really funny. I know Ceasar would think so too. He thought that teh South Park parody was hilarious. It's great that he doesn't get offended :)
too bad you think using punishment and outdated training techniques that harm dogs and humans is 'the best'. This video is great because it reveals the idiocy of his 'techniques'.
Excellent job on the video. The outtakes on is even better!
The 'outdated' techniques and 'idiocy' you speak of are employed by wolves and other wild dogs, all over the world, EVERY DAY.
Dogs are dogs; they are not humans. It is far more logical and even kinder to use communications and punishments that they actually UNDERSTAND rather than to expect your dog to learn the same way a small child might.
That said, the parents of bratty, spoiled children might also do well to observe Millan's technique.
Still waiting for an educated rebuttal. You certainly didn't provide it. Dogs are not humans, dogs are not wolves either! They do not have the same behaviors. Neither species puts the other on the ground in most cases. The dog puts himself/herself on the ground as an appeasement signal. A vast amount of research directly opposes CM method, NONE support it. CM has been invited to demonstrate his 'technique' on human socialized wolves. Wonder why he won't accept? He would be dead, that's why.
I never meant to present you with an 'educated rebuttal' as, unlike you, i cannot survive while stuffed so far up my own arse. Youtube is no place for responses of an 'educated' nature.
As for dogs not being wolves - clever observation. I'm sure no one else noticed that. However, this doesn't mean that their methods of communication are necessarilly any different.
Millan has spent most of his life working with and studying dogs. Who are you - casual observer - or i, to critisize his work?
As for research supporting or disproving Millan's method - show me. You can't go around throwing figures and survey results at people when you can't cite them as evidence.
In fact - don't waste your time. I'm not likely to continue this conversation as, surprisingly, i have educational studies to attend to. As a college graduate and university undergraduate, i'd appreciate you respecting my 'educated rebuttal' (as you put it) a little more.
I'd respect your 'educated rebuttal' more if it was actually educational! Entertaining, certainly, educated not even close. Professionals far more intelligent and experienced than you or CM, or me for that matter, rebuke his methods based on ethics and science. You are the one that made the ingenious observation about dogs not being human, guess no one else knew that either. If you are an undergraduate, then you should be able to use your university library to pull up studies.
Have you had enough, Nak? Or would you like me to provide you, happily, even more? I can keep you busy for a year with the sheer volume of relative data that dismisses CM and his cruel , faux-methodology. I've read thousands of pages so far, in journals and in books, but there is so much of it that I haven't even scratched the surface. Care to join me? You asked for the evidence and data; I have provided it, though there is a far more where that came from. Be careful what you wish for!
I'd be happy to show you. Hundreds of articles in dozens of publications, scientific and mainstream media, from all over the world, by the leading animal behaviorists, scientists, professional trainers, and vets, all unanimous in their condemnation of CM and his cruel and dangerous ideology.and methods. It seems, though, that YouTube does not allow the posting of URLs, so anyone who wants them can write me and I'll be happy to send them. And theres a lot more where they came from.
Ynnn,, wolves and dogs parted company on the behavioral sphere some 14,000 years ago. You really ought to do a little reading, Nak. Just remember this: when (not if) you get hurt followin CM's cruel methods, though you may deserve it for having failed to be responsible, your dog , who has no choice, does NOT deserve it. Try thinking of whats best for him, not for you.
So sorry, Nakasayu, but CourteousCats is absolutely right, and you are dead WRONG. CM's techniques are antiquated, and extremely dangerous. Even the Humane Society is lobbying to have his show taken off the air. Just do your homework. Read. Research. I will post a tiny sample of what's available out there: Thousands of articles from the real authorities: behaviorists, etholgists, vets, and trainers in journals , books, and major newspapers all over the world. Links en route...
Dogs everywhere thank you! Did you post to Nakasayu? I know he/she is probably busy with actual university assignments (obviously not in the Psych dept, Zooology or current behavioral research dept) but maybe he/she will actually look at even one of your links.
To equate dogs with wolves is not only incorrect, but naive. Their behavioral differences are far greater than their similarities, given the influence, over some 14,000 years (which is when the two parted company), of the domestic environment in which dogs now thrive, , survive, and engage with humans and other dogs. Domesticated dogs no longer scavange for dead animals for food; they rely on the resources of their human hosts; they like it that way. Read the extant literature, if you care.
In his books and shows CM incorrectly asserts that wolves and wild dogs engage in alpha roles to force submission . This is based on a faulty study from the 1940s long ago disproved. Actually, it is the SUBMISSIVE wolf that presents this behavior as appeasement. There is no force involved. In those rare cases where a wolf did "alpha roll" , it did so ONLY if it were planning to kill the other. Do you want YOUR dog to feel, when you follow CM's dangerous advice, that you want to kill him? Hm?
Here is the position of the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavor, the most prestigious organization of its kind:
"The ASVAB recommends that veterinarians not refer clients to trainers or behavior consultants who coach or advocate dominance hierarchy theory and the subsequent confrontational training that follows from it"
Extrapolating a training posture that mimics animal to animal relationships is naive and dangerous. In fact, it only suppresses aggression thus codifying the latter as a form of punishment, without regard to underlying causes, and in the end makes matters much worse. Warning postures, ritual dominance, and submissive displays inform dominant-submissive relationships among dogs. No human can mimic this complex network of communications or interact with a dog as another dog would.
Oh jesus. Dog whisperer is my favorite show, I watch it on my computer, like, every day, and this, was freakin hilarious. The guy playing cesar was good, if a little too gay(but maybe that's what made it so funny), also, Cesar always leaves out "a" and "the" alot, so he doesn't say "The human has to train the dog", he just says "Human have to train dog". But besides that, this was awesome.
I watched it all - twice. And it just wasn't funny. The people who played Pam and Roman did very well, but the person who did Cesar overacted something fierce.
I think this shows very well how Cesar is, this is about as amusing as his real show is, cept this is made even funnier ;) There's no nature in putting dogs on the ground, in fact, dogs prefer to avoid conflicts at all costs, dominance is unecessery in training dogs, motivation is the most important thing, and with the right motivation you can get your dog to do anything you wish for. I'm showing all my irl friends this one, cause this one's so hilarous, and touches the right spots ;)
how undereducated of you!ALL trainers show the importance of being the pack leader,even though they dont do it ceasers way,they all have one thing in common,your dog cannot be allwed to be dominant,because then your not in full control.dominant dogs are possibly dangerous and unpredictable.motivation wont help you on its own.i am not stickin up for ceaser,just common sense!there is definitely nature in putting dogs in submissive pose!its bred into them.its common sense,dogs do it to each other!
I know you posted this a year ago, but I had to say thank you for making accurate statements. There are so many misinformed posts here, it is really disappointing that people can't read up on current research with wolves/domestic dogs. Dogs are not wolves, they do not have the same behaviors. Neither species puts the other on the ground in most cases. The dog puts himself/herself on the ground as an appeasement signal. An enormous amount of research directly opposes CM method, NONE support it.
@CourteousCats really not trying to call you out and start anything here..but your are misinformed on what you are hearing rom some people..dogs do put dogs on the ground here and there, but always correct eachother with their mouths and bodies..you can find this on a regular basis at any dog run etc. While they ar not wolves and have been domesticated..that does not change the fact that they are still animals and cant be domesticated into humans
I hope people dont misunderstand Cesar's Way if seeing this first. Cesar puts dogs on the ground because thats their way in nature, while humans have words for communication and body language too, but the main idea of remaining Calm, Assertive (not angry or impatient) setting rules boundaries, limitations with other humans as well as with dogs, pets.. is valid practice. I assume you DO respect and admire Cesar's methods. His success rate is proof he is right!! 8-)
That's very good. My partner was one of two people who fought to have Cesar on Nat Geo and was the only proponent of putting Cesar in primetime instead of fringe. He's really become a pop culture phenomenon since then, and deservedly so.
No, sorry, I meant at Nat Geo. The original series has become such a phenomenon that it's been parodied on South Park, this series you've included, SNL and other references in pop culture. She knew it was going to be a hit for them, but I'm not sure even she knew it was going to be so wide spread.
If you watch the entire vid and then wish to comment (+ or -), that's cool. But to watch 30 secs of a 4 min vid and make that kind of comment... is hatin'.
my dog has been put to the ground by other dogs many times.. he never took it personal, he just got up, shaked and was just as happy afterwards.. but now he is older and obedient and doesn't need to be put to the ground by me or other animals anymore, it was just when he was young he allways tried to challenge other more dominant dogs or tried to be all hormone maniac to female dogs, they barked, touched him with their teeth (no biting) and put him on the ground.
Rabiesist 6 months ago
its not funny!!!
ilove06JB 8 months ago
HAHAHAHA this just cracked me up
hebasaid 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Meet beautiful Russian girl now gettop5.info
rhonamolinardhc 9 months ago
yep, primeval - it best explains the hostile undertones, from a psychological viewpoint
katowanda 9 months ago
Actually, pathetic. Maybe misunderstanding a message instilled some primeval fear to produce this sort of slanted error.
kasobie 9 months ago
@kasobie Yeah, yeah, yeah... it's a parody... not meant to be taken so seriously... primeval??? REALLY???
mvgreene 9 months ago
It's FunNYYY! I wish he's not nodding his head right and left like an India merchant though..
lova368 1 year ago
soooooooo funny!!!!!!
TheOno888 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
We provide best Latino women marriage service rockmycity.info
sarathroniyal 1 year ago
It's really hard beign submitted.. by another man.. XD ♥♥♥
crispycrab 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
We have thousands of profiles about girls naneedj.info
sindianyubd 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Nice hair Russian women ** leefoxnow.info **
LeliaLkjhg 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Try to meet your dream girls from Russia gettop5.info
natashiaminglech 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey guys join to have a fun **rockmycity.info**
jwelmajohana 1 year ago
@mvgreene Yes I know! Reason why I commented on the skit being hilarious! I was just commenting on everyone else's serious comments! Cesar would think its hilarious as well. But I couldn't help myself to comment in the comment box to the comment below my first comment. Geez, just because I have to be a YouTube Whisperer don't blame me. I still have a sense of humor. But thanks anyways.
WarriorAngelWings 1 year ago
@InDogsWeTrust11 Dominance to a dog is when it's striving to outdo you which means YOU HAVE TO TRY HARDER THAN THEM or get them in line with you or do what most people do and give up and let the dog do whatever. Punishment and corrections are totally different, if your angry when you are trying to get something or someone to understand something...that is punishment! You should study leadership much better. Check out the video on my channel Because this is what Cesar is talking about.
WarriorAngelWings 1 year ago
@WarriorAngelWings & @InDogsWeTrust11 & everyone else who is taking this WAAAAAYYYYYY to seriously. It's a parody. It's a joke.
mvgreene 1 year ago
@InDogsWeTrust11 Are you joking me? There is no comparison and that's why we get dogs that act the way they do because people like you compare them to humans! There is no strangling or manhandling involved! If so you would see many different fights at the dog Psychology center a dog is a dog, let it be a dog just face it, they are not little furry Teddy bears, yes they are cute but they rely solely on instinct.
WarriorAngelWings 1 year ago
BTW the skit is hilarious!
WarriorAngelWings 1 year ago
How come this turns out be a parody of cruelty against dogs? Seriously people, dogs are NOT HUMAN! Why can't you get it through your thick skulls. Please let your canine sit at your dinner table because making them eat OFF THE FLOOR in most eyes would be cruel so prop em up at the dinner table tonite for sunday supper, after all your children don't eat off the floor why should your dogs. Hitting a dog is not ok. But going against it's nature is very cruel.
WarriorAngelWings 1 year ago
@WarriorAngelWings Dogs have every bit the same emotion as humans, and it is not ok to do this to them either. I like how this video shows what it looks like to do it to humans.Your comments about eating at the dinner table are ridiculous, we are talking about strangling and manhandling dogs. This isnt natural, dogs DONT interact this way.. every real behaviourist or ethologist know this. Blaming behaviour on dominance is an excuse for punishment.
InDogsWeTrust11 1 year ago
Thank you thank you thank you!! This is so true...
I really hate Cesar. REALLY hate him.
The number of dogs that are tortured because of people watching his shows... it makes me sick.
elenainnapeartree 1 year ago
Perfect! When the guy showed up with the "cone of shame," I lolled.
JiveDadson 1 year ago
The guy playing Cesar simply sucks, plays overly feminine version of who knows who. Do a youtube a favor, and stop, please :)
packovic 1 year ago
I riabeltey dogs. Haha.
sid851 1 year ago
I found it extremely funny! "Can I try that?"...Hahahaha
tazhi333 1 year ago
boring, don't waste your time, came across it by mistake
phabbiola 1 year ago
OMG, this was awesome. I kept bursting into laughter. The acting is terrific. I can't believe NatGeo continues that harmful program. When people quote CM, I try to point them to Karen Pryor or other real trainers who understand behavioral psychology (across species).
ServiceDogPartner 1 year ago
@ServiceDogPartner The next time you have a thought just let it go. Seriously.
SkyPie3 1 year ago
Too funny :D
MeaghanEdwards 1 year ago
brilliant! thankyou :D
Gemmaandthedawgs 2 years ago
man this my shit love it lmao
16Eboni 2 years ago
this is a terrible rendition of Cesar.. better acting is required!!
HoVa094 2 years ago
lmao!!!
oz22verizon 2 years ago
lmao haha
favm360 2 years ago
Hahaha good impression of CM, some moments it could actually BE him. Totally brilliant.
bundleHastings 2 years ago
It's too unreal, he's not acting crazy and big eyed with people. LIKE an owl.
FuckFuck80200 2 years ago 2
Word Alizais...word
drivenbyfate 2 years ago
zloradnii, stop word-vomiting about scientific theory & empirical data. Milan grew up w/ dogs on his grandpa's farm, "culling" the ultimate empirical data, from his LIFE. Evidence: innumerable dogs have gone thru rehab, became ppl/dog friendly, & saved from euthanization. His psychology center dogs, some once dangerous, are calm & friendly. I'd trust CM w/ a violent dog than u w/ ur "science" & smart talk any day. So plz, shut up. u sound like an idiot. After all, actions speak loudr than words.
Alizais 2 years ago 2
Finally, someone who realizes that experience and practice is worth far more than any mere theory.
Nakasayu 2 years ago 2
Don't worry about zloradnii, this person has a serious issue and more than enough free time to vent through other comment boxes on youtube.
Peddle1986 2 years ago
If you want to talk about having "more than enough free time to vent..." why not mention the perfect example, zlorandnii? Maybe a little "Shhht!" might curb his/her seemingly unhealthy and obsessive behavior.
Alizais 2 years ago
obviously zloradnii is not a pack leader...
theprezlcc 2 years ago
Comment removed
zloradnii 2 years ago
Growing up on grandpas' farm hardly qualifies one as an authority on anything, much less animal behavior. LIfe true, then Charles Manson qualifies as a top surgeon. While it may be difficult to wean yourself from the cult leader Millan, and the charms of TV, extolling your ignorance so recklessly only serves to discredit you.. Do you really take pride in illiteracy? Your refusal to set aside your ego only suggests you don't give a damn about dogs.Sorry, old boy, CM is a fraud.
zloradnii 2 years ago
Comment removed
Alizais 2 years ago
I admit that I'm ignorant in this area, that growing up on a farm doesn't make anyone an animal expert, and that there are many who blindly worship celebrities. However, it's still hard to believe you due to the extreme nature of your argument.There are always positives and negatives to each side of an issue and your purely one-sided stance is what I've become defensive to. Opposite of what Peddle1986 says, I don't have the time to argue so I'll stop here. Good luck w/ life & thx for the debate.
Alizais 2 years ago
Um, nope. The behaviour you so naively interpret as "calm" is in fact dogs who have been shut down duie to flooding, learned helplesness, and other archaic methods. No need to take my word for it. Do the work, read the voluminous critiques by bona fide authorities on the subject. Don't be lazy. It is no accident the Humane Society and so many others --vets, behaviorists, scientists - want this dangerous charletan taken off the air. Do the work. Read. What are you afraid of? The truth? .
zloradnii 2 years ago
Thank you!!! THUMBS WAYYYY UP!!!!
1SOF1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Growing up on grandpa's farm hardly qualifies anyone as an authority on animal behavior. It is no accident that the majority of bona fide authorities, including the Humane Society, have demanded CM be taken off the air. Your crude, defensive posture, only serve to extol the breathtaking ignorance of your wholly insupportable position. Why don't you do your homework? Get the facts. What are you afraid of, the truth? Or are you content to follow the CULT leader, no matter the harm he does?
zloradnii 2 years ago
Your remarks would be laughable were it not for the fact that the subject is so serious, and that willingness to remain ignorant is so dangerous. Alas, you are sorely and demonstrably mistaken. What you perceive as "calm" is the behavior of dots who CM has "shut down." Look it up. His archaic methods involve flooding, forced helplessness, stringing, and worse. Once you let TV think on your behalf, as it clearly has in your case, the game is up. Do the work; don't buy into CM's con.
zloradnii 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Of course, you will respond, in anger You can't help yourself . But it doesn't matter. You belong to that gullible group of celebrity worshipers who would happily jump off a cliff if CM told you to. There is no reasoning with you; your responses have been hopelessly manipulated and conditioned to remain blind. CM's ersatz "dominance' theories have served to empower you, just as they have millions of naive consumers, so that you can assert your God like authority over an innocent animal.
zloradnii 2 years ago
zlorandi ur a retard
bougie740 2 years ago 2
Would you like to know what following CM's dangerous advice can lead to? I suggest you read a piece in the SF Chronicle
"Man Who Bit His Dog Must Stand Trial" (by
Jaxon Van Derbeken, Nov 7) This individual attributed his cruel act to "mimicking the primal instincts of dogs." That is pure CM.
zloradnii 2 years ago
Comment removed
zloradnii 2 years ago
CM, in his books, confuses critical opinion for scientific theory. A theory is not an opinion, or speculation, but the nucleus of empirical data, culled over many years and innumerable trials, rigorous tests, and examinations, which serve to elaborate, demonstrate, and prove the cause, effect, and efficacy of a phenomenon. Opinion is not even the issue here for any bona fide authority. I'm afraid poor CM is little more than a poseur preaching to the gullible for ratings and money.
zloradnii 2 years ago
In addition to the reams of scientific data from legions of distinguished authorities on canine behavior and training , who protest CM, there are also EDITORIALS calling for the same thing in such august publications as the NY TIMES, ESQUIRE, SF CHRONICLE, HUFFINGTON POST, and dozens of other mainstream publications the world over. It's no joke. CM has created a serious public health hazard that is both influential and well financed. Will legislators please pay attention!
zloradnii 2 years ago
All the university studies of the science of behavior and cutting edge trainers since the late 1830 beginning with Skinner have shown that dominance is an antiquated way of training , Try doing dominace with a whale and see where it gets you when all trust is lost between you !
Mountains of actual research not made up stuff like CM does ... have shown that dominace hurts makes learned helplessness, generalized fear of the environment , aggression , avoidance/ escape and much more ..
angeleasfeathers 2 years ago 5
Finally a rational, educated person! The research is clear, chasing a scared dog with a toaster doesn't qualify as a respected method of behavior modification!
Thank you!
CourteousCats 2 years ago
@angeleasfeathers Your walnut sized spark box failed to take reality into account. Cesar's way works. You circumcise your newborn sons, you pierce your daughter's ears in the name of beauty yet, you think it unethical to discipline an unruly dog. You are insane.
SkyPie3 1 year ago
This was great!!!
shonuff9 3 years ago
That was hilarious!!
Rasputina101 3 years ago 2
Bubbles from the wire!
chicityboi2345 3 years ago
That was the so funny!!!! He took that guy down! lol lol lol
Calminmind 3 years ago
Um...no that's not funny at all. You people are stupid.
GodotheInfantry 3 years ago
gggagahahhahahaha
flosula 3 years ago
I love Ceasar so much, he's the best :) And this is really funny. I know Ceasar would think so too. He thought that teh South Park parody was hilarious. It's great that he doesn't get offended :)
EMCK1990 3 years ago
too bad you think using punishment and outdated training techniques that harm dogs and humans is 'the best'. This video is great because it reveals the idiocy of his 'techniques'.
Excellent job on the video. The outtakes on is even better!
CourteousCats 3 years ago
yeah because rewarding everything your dog does is great for its behavior
kodokwai 2 years ago
your response doesn't make sense.
CourteousCats 2 years ago
it's called being ironic
kodokwai 2 years ago
do you mean sarcastic?
CourteousCats 2 years ago
AMEN! CourteousCats! CM is not fit for man nor beasts!!!
TayPooh 2 years ago 3
The 'outdated' techniques and 'idiocy' you speak of are employed by wolves and other wild dogs, all over the world, EVERY DAY.
Dogs are dogs; they are not humans. It is far more logical and even kinder to use communications and punishments that they actually UNDERSTAND rather than to expect your dog to learn the same way a small child might.
That said, the parents of bratty, spoiled children might also do well to observe Millan's technique.
Nakasayu 2 years ago
Still waiting for an educated rebuttal. You certainly didn't provide it. Dogs are not humans, dogs are not wolves either! They do not have the same behaviors. Neither species puts the other on the ground in most cases. The dog puts himself/herself on the ground as an appeasement signal. A vast amount of research directly opposes CM method, NONE support it. CM has been invited to demonstrate his 'technique' on human socialized wolves. Wonder why he won't accept? He would be dead, that's why.
CourteousCats 2 years ago 2
I never meant to present you with an 'educated rebuttal' as, unlike you, i cannot survive while stuffed so far up my own arse. Youtube is no place for responses of an 'educated' nature.
As for dogs not being wolves - clever observation. I'm sure no one else noticed that. However, this doesn't mean that their methods of communication are necessarilly any different.
Millan has spent most of his life working with and studying dogs. Who are you - casual observer - or i, to critisize his work?
Nakasayu 2 years ago
As for research supporting or disproving Millan's method - show me. You can't go around throwing figures and survey results at people when you can't cite them as evidence.
In fact - don't waste your time. I'm not likely to continue this conversation as, surprisingly, i have educational studies to attend to. As a college graduate and university undergraduate, i'd appreciate you respecting my 'educated rebuttal' (as you put it) a little more.
Nakasayu 2 years ago
I'd respect your 'educated rebuttal' more if it was actually educational! Entertaining, certainly, educated not even close. Professionals far more intelligent and experienced than you or CM, or me for that matter, rebuke his methods based on ethics and science. You are the one that made the ingenious observation about dogs not being human, guess no one else knew that either. If you are an undergraduate, then you should be able to use your university library to pull up studies.
CourteousCats 2 years ago
Cite your evidence. If you're making a point, then that's your job. Not mine.
Now, i'm off to have a life. Have a nice time telling everybody just how clever and correct you are! <3
Nakasayu 2 years ago
Comment removed
zloradnii 2 years ago
Have you had enough, Nak? Or would you like me to provide you, happily, even more? I can keep you busy for a year with the sheer volume of relative data that dismisses CM and his cruel , faux-methodology. I've read thousands of pages so far, in journals and in books, but there is so much of it that I haven't even scratched the surface. Care to join me? You asked for the evidence and data; I have provided it, though there is a far more where that came from. Be careful what you wish for!
zloradnii 2 years ago
I'd be happy to show you. Hundreds of articles in dozens of publications, scientific and mainstream media, from all over the world, by the leading animal behaviorists, scientists, professional trainers, and vets, all unanimous in their condemnation of CM and his cruel and dangerous ideology.and methods. It seems, though, that YouTube does not allow the posting of URLs, so anyone who wants them can write me and I'll be happy to send them. And theres a lot more where they came from.
zloradnii 2 years ago
Ynnn,, wolves and dogs parted company on the behavioral sphere some 14,000 years ago. You really ought to do a little reading, Nak. Just remember this: when (not if) you get hurt followin CM's cruel methods, though you may deserve it for having failed to be responsible, your dog , who has no choice, does NOT deserve it. Try thinking of whats best for him, not for you.
zloradnii 2 years ago
So sorry, Nakasayu, but CourteousCats is absolutely right, and you are dead WRONG. CM's techniques are antiquated, and extremely dangerous. Even the Humane Society is lobbying to have his show taken off the air. Just do your homework. Read. Research. I will post a tiny sample of what's available out there: Thousands of articles from the real authorities: behaviorists, etholgists, vets, and trainers in journals , books, and major newspapers all over the world. Links en route...
zloradnii 2 years ago
Dogs everywhere thank you! Did you post to Nakasayu? I know he/she is probably busy with actual university assignments (obviously not in the Psych dept, Zooology or current behavioral research dept) but maybe he/she will actually look at even one of your links.
CourteousCats 2 years ago
Comment removed
zloradnii 2 years ago
To equate dogs with wolves is not only incorrect, but naive. Their behavioral differences are far greater than their similarities, given the influence, over some 14,000 years (which is when the two parted company), of the domestic environment in which dogs now thrive, , survive, and engage with humans and other dogs. Domesticated dogs no longer scavange for dead animals for food; they rely on the resources of their human hosts; they like it that way. Read the extant literature, if you care.
zloradnii 2 years ago
In his books and shows CM incorrectly asserts that wolves and wild dogs engage in alpha roles to force submission . This is based on a faulty study from the 1940s long ago disproved. Actually, it is the SUBMISSIVE wolf that presents this behavior as appeasement. There is no force involved. In those rare cases where a wolf did "alpha roll" , it did so ONLY if it were planning to kill the other. Do you want YOUR dog to feel, when you follow CM's dangerous advice, that you want to kill him? Hm?
zloradnii 2 years ago
Here is the position of the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavor, the most prestigious organization of its kind:
"The ASVAB recommends that veterinarians not refer clients to trainers or behavior consultants who coach or advocate dominance hierarchy theory and the subsequent confrontational training that follows from it"
zloradnii 2 years ago
Extrapolating a training posture that mimics animal to animal relationships is naive and dangerous. In fact, it only suppresses aggression thus codifying the latter as a form of punishment, without regard to underlying causes, and in the end makes matters much worse. Warning postures, ritual dominance, and submissive displays inform dominant-submissive relationships among dogs. No human can mimic this complex network of communications or interact with a dog as another dog would.
zloradnii 2 years ago
Sorry, it's tomorrows word of the day!
GETTINGTOKNOWSHYRA 3 years ago
This is really funny! I posted it as the matching video to the word of the day on my blog @ shyra(.)wordpress(.)com. Thank you so much!
GETTINGTOKNOWSHYRA 3 years ago
am a huge fan of Cesar, but this is hilarious
veranasti 3 years ago
very very very funny i wonder what dog whisper really thinks but really funny. being summit by another man!!!!
daddyjq31 3 years ago
That was genuinely funny ...GREAT!!!
But the Ceaser expression is a bit gay... it would have been as funny without the gay bit as well
oneTwoKaa4 3 years ago
Oh jesus. Dog whisperer is my favorite show, I watch it on my computer, like, every day, and this, was freakin hilarious. The guy playing cesar was good, if a little too gay(but maybe that's what made it so funny), also, Cesar always leaves out "a" and "the" alot, so he doesn't say "The human has to train the dog", he just says "Human have to train dog". But besides that, this was awesome.
unopepito06 3 years ago
lol i noticed that too!! the lack of "the" and "A"'s in his speech
stitchgrl777 3 years ago
hahaha its kind of hard for me to talk about it right now. lol favorite part, by far. lol
JesusFreak1john17 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wat the fuck is this!!!!!!!!!
msingh16 3 years ago
hahahaha
sannystud 3 years ago 3
WOW. But I think the word you are searching for would be immature.
mvgreene 3 years ago
LOL
nickegbg 3 years ago
Really??? Are you serious???
mvgreene 3 years ago
lol i love this video, and i love the dog whisperer.
shame on you people who just overact.
PunkSocks 3 years ago
i've finally watched it!!!
although i think i might watch dog whisperer this morning if it's on
HuGaEmO 3 years ago
I watched it all - twice. And it just wasn't funny. The people who played Pam and Roman did very well, but the person who did Cesar overacted something fierce.
Kaelinda 3 years ago 2
Well that's kind of the point. Two straight people and one who overacts... eh, so I guess you got it.
mvgreene 3 years ago
haha this is funny
martaajoku1 4 years ago
i love the dog whisperer, but this is funny...
fatumiti 4 years ago
omg!!! how funny!!! i love the dog whisperer too
michiebishi 4 years ago
Cesar's methods work for my dogs AND my husband! Thanks God....
cockblockermadre 4 years ago 3
CopyCat, LOL, that was a real episode of the Dog Whisperer.
Djoe2 4 years ago
dont dis cesar...he's immenseness!
OOOuise 4 years ago 4
um this is dumb, they cant act, cesar doesnt act like that or sound like that, and its rediculous!!
colorheartedgirl 4 years ago 3
do me a favor and make an episode with the infamous Cesar rollerblades lolol
xcelxp 4 years ago
ITS BUBS!!! hilarious lol
xcelxp 4 years ago
Rolling on the floor funny!!!!!!!!!!!
brotherkarloz 4 years ago 2
hilarious!!! the video is over & i'm still laughing!
stkensinger 4 years ago
Ssshhht!!! TOO HILARIOUS!!! Nice touch at the end with the red dog thing around the neck. Will try on my husband! LOLOL MORE! MORE!!!!!
its4amletmein 4 years ago
OMG!! This is so funny! I love the Dog Whisperer.
JadedRuby 4 years ago
this is a funny parody of him, the real cesar milan could commit assault and battery if he did this.
gregorkrause 4 years ago
this is definitely a parody the real Cesar Milan could commit assault and battery if he did that to a human.
gregorkrause 4 years ago
I think this shows very well how Cesar is, this is about as amusing as his real show is, cept this is made even funnier ;) There's no nature in putting dogs on the ground, in fact, dogs prefer to avoid conflicts at all costs, dominance is unecessery in training dogs, motivation is the most important thing, and with the right motivation you can get your dog to do anything you wish for. I'm showing all my irl friends this one, cause this one's so hilarous, and touches the right spots ;)
Carmoliana 4 years ago
Thanks for the comment. Please show Part 2, which deals with PMS to your girls as well - I'm sure they'll relate.
mvgreene 4 years ago
how undereducated of you!ALL trainers show the importance of being the pack leader,even though they dont do it ceasers way,they all have one thing in common,your dog cannot be allwed to be dominant,because then your not in full control.dominant dogs are possibly dangerous and unpredictable.motivation wont help you on its own.i am not stickin up for ceaser,just common sense!there is definitely nature in putting dogs in submissive pose!its bred into them.its common sense,dogs do it to each other!
michiebishi 4 years ago
I know you posted this a year ago, but I had to say thank you for making accurate statements. There are so many misinformed posts here, it is really disappointing that people can't read up on current research with wolves/domestic dogs. Dogs are not wolves, they do not have the same behaviors. Neither species puts the other on the ground in most cases. The dog puts himself/herself on the ground as an appeasement signal. An enormous amount of research directly opposes CM method, NONE support it.
CourteousCats 2 years ago 6
@CourteousCats really not trying to call you out and start anything here..but your are misinformed on what you are hearing rom some people..dogs do put dogs on the ground here and there, but always correct eachother with their mouths and bodies..you can find this on a regular basis at any dog run etc. While they ar not wolves and have been domesticated..that does not change the fact that they are still animals and cant be domesticated into humans
DreamComeTrueK9 9 months ago
this is hilarious
DreamComeTrueK9 9 months ago
I hope people dont misunderstand Cesar's Way if seeing this first. Cesar puts dogs on the ground because thats their way in nature, while humans have words for communication and body language too, but the main idea of remaining Calm, Assertive (not angry or impatient) setting rules boundaries, limitations with other humans as well as with dogs, pets.. is valid practice. I assume you DO respect and admire Cesar's methods. His success rate is proof he is right!! 8-)
linday77 4 years ago 3
If someone watches Cesar Millan, they get the parody. We love his show, that's why we did it! Thanks for the comment.
mvgreene 4 years ago
Do you like Rescue 911, how about parodying scenes from the intro like computer screen gone crazy with The "BLUE JEANS ROOM ON FIRE" scene?
gregorkrause 4 years ago
lol
vega92 4 years ago
Cesar Milan - Respect !! ;D
annalena73 4 years ago
I have respect for the guy but this skit got me laughing lol....good job.
IntenseR1 4 years ago
hahahahaha. Great production! You guys are on TV???
hosseher 4 years ago
nice but the shirt should have been tighter
theitmoo1 4 years ago
great!
clsalvaggio 4 years ago
Very funny, wow. My thoughts exactly! I almost screamed when I saw him for the first time. I totally love this VID. Scary isn't it?
DBRVNH 4 years ago
That's very good. My partner was one of two people who fought to have Cesar on Nat Geo and was the only proponent of putting Cesar in primetime instead of fringe. He's really become a pop culture phenomenon since then, and deservedly so.
kicka61 4 years ago
Yeah, he's great. Are you Scott H's friend who works on CM's show? Thanks for the comment and watching.
mvgreene 4 years ago
No, sorry, I meant at Nat Geo. The original series has become such a phenomenon that it's been parodied on South Park, this series you've included, SNL and other references in pop culture. She knew it was going to be a hit for them, but I'm not sure even she knew it was going to be so wide spread.
kicka61 4 years ago
Fantastic!!!! Loved it!
charlie91683 4 years ago
haha, really funny! would love to get some feedback on the clips i put up, send me a comment! it would really help me out.
this isn't the show itself, it's just four short clips that'll tell you a bit about me, the show and a sample of what might be in it.
cheers dan
DomesticGod 4 years ago
First thirty seconds boered me into a coma. Then I was done with it.
pokethebear 4 years ago
Wow, and you snapped out of it just in time to hate on our vid.
mvgreene 4 years ago
Can't lie to make you happy. If you need to project that as "hatin'", that's on you. Just wasn't funny.
pokethebear 4 years ago
If you watch the entire vid and then wish to comment (+ or -), that's cool. But to watch 30 secs of a 4 min vid and make that kind of comment... is hatin'.
mvgreene 4 years ago
who did this where did this come from
theitmoo1 4 years ago
a LAUGH BUREAU production... we subsidize laughter
LaughBureau dot COM
Thanks for watching and check out our other sketches on our YouTube channel.
mvgreene 4 years ago
maybe if you had more of an attention span than a gnat then you would have watched the rest and seen how funny it got. pffffftttt!
michiebishi 4 years ago
Hysterical! So glad you are finally working with people! You rock Cesar!
Stone007 4 years ago
hahaha the dog whisper is such a joke. I love this.
thentro 4 years ago
"He's being a gladiator.. RRrrr"
lmao
suspectgmc 4 years ago
this shit is funnyshit period
andrelroyo 4 years ago
Looks great! Geo and Dre - you guys rocked it!
kelliegreene 4 years ago
What's up with the cone??? LMAO.
TheBDD 4 years ago
OMG!!! this is hilarious! That's Bubbles???
funnyauditions 4 years ago
Yes... good eye. That is Andre Royo from HBO's "The Wire."
mvgreene 4 years ago