fair comment and each to their own but it's called traditional music for a reason. It's keeping tradition alive and not deviating from the original traditional melody. That just doesn't apply to music but also to everything else Scottish, otherwise it will change out of all recognition and we don't want that do we?
This is what the song should sound like
watch?v=cS3z713P9n8
bloobear1 2 years ago
I personally like both versions
scoutquinn 2 years ago
fair comment and each to their own but it's called traditional music for a reason. It's keeping tradition alive and not deviating from the original traditional melody. That just doesn't apply to music but also to everything else Scottish, otherwise it will change out of all recognition and we don't want that do we?
bloobear1 2 years ago
Nonesense and really off the original melody. Try listening to the Corries version. This is terrible
bloobear1 2 years ago