but make sure the melody stands out a bit more than the accompaniment at times--ie, when the melody is in the LH, try making RH softer and vice versa.
Ever so peaceful. Like your adagio tempo. Ever such an encouragement to see your video alongside giants such as Myra and Mr. Weissenberg. Cheers. Keep it up.
very nice, you played awesome, and this arrangement by Myra Hess is absolutely beautifull, the firs time i listened was in the evangelion film, the end of evangelion, and since then i'm in love with this song, i don't believe too much in jesus, but this songs fill my heart with pure joy. Thanks again Bach, and Myra, and of course benjamin for uploading this video
I've been listening to Bach for a year now, and I never heard this piece before. But I must say Bach did it again, and you played it beautfully. The slow tempo makes it very intense.
I've listened many times. Like this version better....no the 'dressing gown'.....no this one. OK maybe it depends on my mood. Somehow I usually prefer this slower tempo. They both make my mind dance and my spirit soar. Thanks for posting. You're very talented.
Very very beautiful. I am playing this for my violin and I needed an accompaniment. When I found your performance, I was literally "wowed"!!. Your tempo is just right and it is very constant. It made it really easy for me to follow along with. THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!
Your timing is really consistent - impressively so. I really want to try and learn this. So challenging on the right hand! Ouch...but you are giving me some inspiration.
I know how hard this is to play-I've been working on it for a year, and I don't play it nearly as well as you do. And, by the way, I'm old enough to be your grandmother. Thanks for an enjoyable video.
Apologies my friend. I haven't been paying attention to my youtube mail recently...video response has been posted. I shall comment on your video in due time.
That's not quite what I meant, though I'll welcome any comments you may have on my video. :) Maybe my memory is mistaken.... I had thought I had posted my recent repost of this piece as a video comment on this posting & was disappointed not to see it here. (YouTube is not without its technical glitches however, so who knows.... maybe it got lost!)
Thankyou to everyone for all the lovely comments. I am planning today to upload a new version (hopefully better sound quality, different piano and slightly quicker) so stay tuned!
Very nice!, be careful with the sostenuto, remember that in the baroque period there weren't those pedals and the piano didn't exist, it was the clavicord and harpsichord
It's a very difficult arrangement (and the performance indication is 'simple and flowing yet!). The tempo is a little slow for my liking, at least initially, but on the other hand, the slower tempo does allow for the notes to 'sing' more contentedly. I'll give the piece a try approaching it from that angle. :) I can relate to your sound quality woes; I have the same problem with my videos (must get better recording equipment...)
EXCELLENT JOB|!!!!
215762157 7 months ago
This guy rocks
bigbob1061 1 year ago 2
great job!
but make sure the melody stands out a bit more than the accompaniment at times--ie, when the melody is in the LH, try making RH softer and vice versa.
singmeanythingx 2 years ago
Good Job.!! :]
Im playing this song at a concert.
And i cant wait till the world heres it.
Its a really lovely and peaceful song.
:D
XxGymFreak09xX 2 years ago
Ever so peaceful. Like your adagio tempo. Ever such an encouragement to see your video alongside giants such as Myra and Mr. Weissenberg. Cheers. Keep it up.
12rosebud12 2 years ago
A beauty of a job!
Maritimer2009 2 years ago
Dude, i love this song, i have to play it for band class this year and im lovin it dawgs
BassClariFtwz 2 years ago
Nice=)
hdiylove7 2 years ago
I love this piece i am finishing a concert arrangment of jesu joy of mans desire. great job!
NickKovich 2 years ago
very nice, you played awesome, and this arrangement by Myra Hess is absolutely beautifull, the firs time i listened was in the evangelion film, the end of evangelion, and since then i'm in love with this song, i don't believe too much in jesus, but this songs fill my heart with pure joy. Thanks again Bach, and Myra, and of course benjamin for uploading this video
dumbstep 2 years ago
Beautiful. You have an amazing gift that I would kill to have!
AnnaCullen122 2 years ago
I've been listening to Bach for a year now, and I never heard this piece before. But I must say Bach did it again, and you played it beautfully. The slow tempo makes it very intense.
KlaasABCD 2 years ago
very nicly played, shame the quailty of the recording leaves a little to be disired, but your playing is wonderfull
swampy36 2 years ago
I've listened many times. Like this version better....no the 'dressing gown'.....no this one. OK maybe it depends on my mood. Somehow I usually prefer this slower tempo. They both make my mind dance and my spirit soar. Thanks for posting. You're very talented.
cherryclan1 2 years ago
Beautiful song, awesome version! You did great, thanks for posting!
camilalugui 2 years ago
Beautiful, I rated it 5 stars!
Cali4Obama 2 years ago
THIS version is more powerful - the piano in the dressing gown version is not the same as this one - the reedy-sounding piano we all learned upon.
Your timing in this version is also more deliberate and powerful...this is a song not to be hurried.
What a gift this version is !
Plowhandle 2 years ago
Perfectly well!!!)
s22s55s88 2 years ago
Very very beautiful. I am playing this for my violin and I needed an accompaniment. When I found your performance, I was literally "wowed"!!. Your tempo is just right and it is very constant. It made it really easy for me to follow along with. THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!
SerenityLyn 2 years ago 2
the dressing gown feature is much powerfully.
Though its very nice.
drjekyll66 2 years ago
This is nice music......
machinimarr011025 2 years ago
This is such an insanely beautiful song. Thank you so much for the amazing performance.
imboredsoshutup 4 years ago 27
This has been flagged as spam show
you got sexy arms lol...
clowdbreak261 4 years ago
That's the same version from The End of Evangelion, isn't it? (best version ever)
AloisioYang 4 years ago 16
beautiful, made me cry... thanks!
ThePiano1991 4 years ago 2
Good arrangement of Dame Myra who used both hands tremendously well.
luvuall07 4 years ago 2
This song is so easy to relax and enjoy to!
mdtester 4 years ago 4
Well done Ben. Anyone who succeeds in playing this as you have is pretty darn good.
curlysue27 4 years ago
Thanks for saying so :-)
If I ever got round to it, I'll upload a new version of it with better sound quality, less note slips and slightly quicker! Watch this space!!!
benjaminlathbury 4 years ago
How long did it take you to get to this level?
Your timing is really consistent - impressively so. I really want to try and learn this. So challenging on the right hand! Ouch...but you are giving me some inspiration.
curlysue27 4 years ago 2
Hey, Boss, this was pretty cool; if there's better to come, I eagerly await!
NeedleDoctorCane 4 years ago
very nice
unalegeli 4 years ago 2
Listen to dinu lipatti playing this. it was the last thing he played before dying of leukemia at 33yo. it is pure bliss!
adaswet 4 years ago
im listening to it right now... great
youngdroppa9 4 years ago
Pure beauty. Thankyou.
songpidgeon 4 years ago
Although the sound quality isn't great, your playing certainly is.
wmd10 4 years ago
I know how hard this is to play-I've been working on it for a year, and I don't play it nearly as well as you do. And, by the way, I'm old enough to be your grandmother. Thanks for an enjoyable video.
mairzyd 4 years ago
Disappointed you apparently refused my video comment on this. Oh well.
Bye.
Kamibambiraptor 4 years ago
Apologies my friend. I haven't been paying attention to my youtube mail recently...video response has been posted. I shall comment on your video in due time.
benjaminlathbury 4 years ago
That's not quite what I meant, though I'll welcome any comments you may have on my video. :) Maybe my memory is mistaken.... I had thought I had posted my recent repost of this piece as a video comment on this posting & was disappointed not to see it here. (YouTube is not without its technical glitches however, so who knows.... maybe it got lost!)
Kamibambiraptor 4 years ago
hello..may i know where did you get the piano score? could you send it to me? thanks a lot or if you know where to get it online? thx loads
charlsma 4 years ago
I wish you recorded the "how to play on piano" of this song, please I'd be so thanked
bubinho11 4 years ago
The piano sounds like a harpsichord which is really nice.
beebeequail 4 years ago
Thankyou to everyone for all the lovely comments. I am planning today to upload a new version (hopefully better sound quality, different piano and slightly quicker) so stay tuned!
benjaminlathbury 4 years ago
Very nice!, be careful with the sostenuto, remember that in the baroque period there weren't those pedals and the piano didn't exist, it was the clavicord and harpsichord
mountrolomonio 4 years ago
I wish I could play this well! Very nice video.
flgiglio 4 years ago
Excellent job! Worshipful playing of the score..just as intended.
Fine execution!
Plowhandle 4 years ago 2
excellent!
emizaelmoura 4 years ago 2
I like it at this tempo. The lyrics are worshipful, which is the way you played it. I hope someday I will be able to play as well as you!
validopinion 4 years ago
This would sound better slightly faster...
jannokas85 4 years ago
This song supposed to be this tempo
Sexycat369 4 years ago
this?
eligarf 4 years ago
i think it sounds best at any tempo.
i play it faster but this is sweet. NICE playing, very relaxed. just donT play it backwards!
eligarf 4 years ago
It's a very difficult arrangement (and the performance indication is 'simple and flowing yet!). The tempo is a little slow for my liking, at least initially, but on the other hand, the slower tempo does allow for the notes to 'sing' more contentedly. I'll give the piece a try approaching it from that angle. :) I can relate to your sound quality woes; I have the same problem with my videos (must get better recording equipment...)
Kamibambiraptor 4 years ago
im playin this song soon (if i get the peice from my piano teacher)
nativegerry335 4 years ago
Well played
grodob 4 years ago