I've seen 2 versions of this with different background music. I was wondering if anyone knew anything about the piano sheet music for the piano background version. Thanks!
I cried from the very start, still crying and can;t stop, no wonder this little film won a global filmmaking contest for aspiring directors. It's titled "Tell It Your Way"...it is so touching... thank you. A friend shared it with me too... people can have their own minds and be individual thinkers without following maniak leaders, they just need some compassion and heart.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Ok people, 2 world war ended looong time ago we remember that war and milions of Poles, Russian and other killed in that war . NOW we need to see izraeli gestapo terrorizing Palestinian people !
@rachellseesstars These tears are the cleansing kind--that come from the soul. It's wonderful to not be alone, too, because of your asking that question. I'm so grateful that a friend shared this video with me, and I'm sharing it with others, too. (Chase)
OMG this is amazing from start to finish. It is so captivating. The music is perfect for the film and the young children look so much like the older actors. So well done! I can't stop watching it. What a worthy winner. The judges got it spot on!
As a writer I am humbled by your storytelling ability, it is going to make me rethink the way I am writing my screenplays, to see if I can use less, to gain so much more.
Thank you for sending this exceptional movie to my wife Trudi (who is German) and myself. We are new filmmakers, and we were inspired by your remarkable work! I never thought that you could create such a compelling story in 3 minutes. You are a gifted storyteller. We look forward to seeing your other films!
The best films always tell their stories with the images they portray. Had it not been a prerequisite, they could have told this story without using a single word.
you should turn this into a movie about ww2 and the holocaust it would pay to see it not only that it would an educational experience and a great movie just saying and god bless all victoms of the holocaust
@ferreirafsa That is an insult to homosexuals, who were also killed and prosecuted by Nazi's. I hope you thought about that before you laid your hands on the keyboard to type. That is the same as saying they were "repressed Jews."
Man this was incredible. When I heard about the contest I thought about how much they wouldn't be able to say but what really blew me away was how much they could say without any words at all.
This is a beautiful video. It captures the innocence of children even in horrific circumstances. My prayer for all of us is that we would have compassion for each other and seek to love our neighbors as ourselves. May G-d Bless all of us who were affected by WWII. I pray for the holocaust survivors who are still suffering from the torture they received that G-d will give them a great reward both now and in the next life. Paul Moore Host and moderator of Your Guide to a Happy Life.
Thank you for telling a story through eyes and lens and heart. You remind us that hate may crush us, but love can repair the past. The 716 woman in Auschwitz would have cheered your vision, for she often said, "I do not hate. To hate is to let Hitler win."
I've watched a 3 hour film and experienced less emotion. There was no need for the Jewish Nazi point - this would be moving whatver the belief system portrayed. Beautifully made.
Nitpick: Doesn't the caption "Germany, 1943" count as a line? And how can "Get away, get away" count as a single line of dialog when it's in two separate shots of the scene? I would have scored this as eight lines.
@rpresser Depends on the specificity of the rules. If they only allow those six lines of spoken dialogue the caption would be fine. Also I don't know if they had to use exactly six lines and those were them or if they had to use those lines but not necessarily once each.
@Catmonk201 Ok did some further research on the contest. The only two rules were it had to be the same six lines of dialogue that Philips Cinema used in their parallel lines project. I'll assume that means they can use the same line again because in The Gift, which was part of the project they also use get away twice. And as for the caption it says six lines of dialogue and that isn't dialogue. The other rule being the films had to be 3 minutes or less so obviously not relevant.
at first i thought they were speaking japanese. well, it's probably because i'm german. so much cliché in so little time ... but seeing it from the cinematic point of view it was just wonderful with very few words. i also thought the accents were adorable. :D especially the girl's one. aaaw. :)
@FancyChaos Well, I'm a German who speaks Japanese fluently (Level 2 according to the Japanese Proficiency Test) and can assure you that it doesn't sound like Japanese at all. And no, the German spoken in this little jewel of a film doesn't sound that bad at all. Yes, for Germans it is obvious that those people aren't German, but it sounds much better than in many American movies I've watched so far (and that were many). If our spoken English sounds like that I'd be happy indeed.
To all the people that complained about the German "accuracy", maybe you should have donated thousands of dollars to the filmmaker, so he could have flown "real" Germans to the U.S., and put them up for a week during filming, or paid for the crew to go to Germany, for more "location/accent accuracy".
Be REAL people!! Did you "GET" what was going on in the film?!?!
I think the thing I find most ridiculous about this film is most of the other canidates were probably shot by amateurs and low budget film makers… this film was clearly shot by an already employed film maker with a very expensive camera..infact google says he is an established director AND producer…way to shit on the little guys buddy
It's not a "cute story". It's a heartfelt portrayal of unselfish empathy and compassion for another human being. It can apply to any ethnic group, any language, any time. We can be "that boy" to someone else - what is wrong with that message?
Philips ran a contest called Parallel Lines in which they asked people to create a three-minute short film using only six lines of dialogue: :”What is that?”, “It’s a unicorn”, “Never seen one up close before”, “Beautiful”, “Get away, get away”, and “I’m sorry”. After more than 600 entries were submitted, director Ridley Scott selected the above film, titled “Porcelain Unicorn”, as the winner.
Entrants in the Philips-sponsored constrained cinema competition Tell It Your Way were restricted to just six lines of dialogue: “What is that?,” “It’s a unicorn,” “Never seen one up close before,” “Beautiful,” “Get away, get away,” and “I’m sorry.”
Keegan Wilcox’s stunning Porcelain Unicorn was hand-picked as the Grand Prize Winner by director Ridley Scott( via +Tabitha O'Melay)
I'm the kind of person that loves short films and movies about explosions and shooting and guns and killing...but I do have a soft side, and this touched it.
I wish more people would immediately thumbs-down ANY comment they see asking for thumbs up, or discussing the number of people who disliked the video. We can all see that, and have no reason to validate you. Let ACTUAL comments get the thumbs.
its really nice but sad that they try to speak german if they are not german. me, as a native german, hears that... it would be okay if they speak english, but for me it destroys the feeling a bit...
The predictability of Nazi/Third Reich films winning prizes is a total blow to real creativity and contemporary style and content in cinema. Even if well ment and well done, this can only be called exploitation.
Not only is the spoken language hardly recognisable as German, but this is another example of a reproduction of cultural and historical stereotypes for the sake of instant emotion that wears off quickly and leaves a bad hang over of shallowness.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@kurwinsky I really wonder if you actually believe that a three minute short film full of historical and cultural inaccuracies (costumes, language, locations, etc.) can keep the memories of the horrifiying events in Auschwitz alive...
Only education and actual historical documents can help to never forget. I don't need a bad short film to remember what happenend during WWII.
@kurwinsky You are again mixing up my formal criticism of a 3 minute short film made in 2011 with actual historical events.
But if you like to go down that road, I will tell you the difference: The (at least) 6 million victims of the holocaust didn't wear costumes, weren't actors and were not Americans. To them it would be sheer mockery, if they had known that some 70 years later a bunch of young Americans use their actual suffering and exploit and distort it for a cute story in a short film!
The elders look similar to the kids!!
jmoney4918 2 days ago
very nice...!congratsulations!!!!!
mantzelen 3 days ago
Comment removed
charlesrollet42 3 days ago
♥ we keep tiny pieces of love and they live forever in the beautiful moment carrying the tide of time back with just a small token.
iamours 5 days ago
bouleversant , et en 3 mn on arrive à créer une telle émotion!
2bpalou 1 week ago
Anyone camera gear?? Lenses?
Superbustr 1 week ago
Just Beautiful - Bravo!
cmtuhro 1 week ago
I've seen 2 versions of this with different background music. I was wondering if anyone knew anything about the piano sheet music for the piano background version. Thanks!
DrPizzazz0 2 weeks ago
I cried from the very start, still crying and can;t stop, no wonder this little film won a global filmmaking contest for aspiring directors. It's titled "Tell It Your Way"...it is so touching... thank you. A friend shared it with me too... people can have their own minds and be individual thinkers without following maniak leaders, they just need some compassion and heart.
BytomGirl 2 weeks ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ok people, 2 world war ended looong time ago we remember that war and milions of Poles, Russian and other killed in that war . NOW we need to see izraeli gestapo terrorizing Palestinian people !
balbin23 3 weeks ago
Kindness matters
tomsbiz 3 weeks ago
Am I the only one that cried a little bit? .-.
rachellseesstars 4 weeks ago
@rachellseesstars >.> Nope
MrZacSpurgeon 3 weeks ago
@rachellseesstars These tears are the cleansing kind--that come from the soul. It's wonderful to not be alone, too, because of your asking that question. I'm so grateful that a friend shared this video with me, and I'm sharing it with others, too. (Chase)
Chase4everChase 2 weeks ago
Excelente história contada em apenas 3 minutos.. fantástico....
JosaTheRipper 1 month ago
This is lovely. Thank you. :)
urawesomestperson 1 month ago
OMG this is amazing from start to finish. It is so captivating. The music is perfect for the film and the young children look so much like the older actors. So well done! I can't stop watching it. What a worthy winner. The judges got it spot on!
suzanne50383 1 month ago
The beauty and pure innocence from children untouched by ingrained thinking of prejudice
…..Loved it♥ ✿•*¨`*♥ •.❤♫❤.•♥*¨`*•✿ ♥
awitione 1 month ago
As a writer I am humbled by your storytelling ability, it is going to make me rethink the way I am writing my screenplays, to see if I can use less, to gain so much more.
Thorrgils 1 month ago
Thank you for sending this exceptional movie to my wife Trudi (who is German) and myself. We are new filmmakers, and we were inspired by your remarkable work! I never thought that you could create such a compelling story in 3 minutes. You are a gifted storyteller. We look forward to seeing your other films!
BobandTrudiMovies 1 month ago
loved it
lostinmusic89 1 month ago
I watched it without sound and could follow it very well. pure cinema.
artfrankmiami 1 month ago
Still better love story than twilight
FannarzHD 2 months ago 23
The best films always tell their stories with the images they portray. Had it not been a prerequisite, they could have told this story without using a single word.
Fantastic work!
Sirspawnn 2 months ago
you should turn this into a movie about ww2 and the holocaust it would pay to see it not only that it would an educational experience and a great movie just saying and god bless all victoms of the holocaust
imaphantom29 2 months ago
i watched this in skool today
imaphantom29 2 months ago
This is such a beautiful short film. Thank you so much for the inspiration you have given me!
AMockTurtle 2 months ago
Amazing. Very touching.
wbrowns4762n66 2 months ago
very good !!!!!!!!!!
shitchops 2 months ago
Traurig und schön zugleich gemacht. Klasse!
SchattensengelPatze 3 months ago
amazing!
dudy52 3 months ago
Brought tears to my eyes. Great work.
cscdigitalgraphics 3 months ago
i saw this in school!!!
SnowCat2000 3 months ago
So sweet
Donutlilyflower 3 months ago
Amazing :)
Creepzza 3 months ago
thank you for posting this
smilingmick 3 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
hi
STONEMAKERCANADA 3 months ago
@STONEMAKERCANADA If you have nothing intelligent to say, please leave.
22FixedGear 3 months ago
That was beautiful. Just... wow.
LdyJedi 3 months ago
This has more substance in 3 minutes in many blockbusters. Sad really.
aestusmaris 3 months ago
Beautiful....
JOHYish 4 months ago
Wow. so good.
mooshkinana 4 months ago
really beautiful and heart warming
loftyawesomedude 4 months ago
Wow
YolandaGuadalupe 4 months ago
Goosebumps.
adshameen 4 months ago
This is really beautiful and touching..And given the restrictions. You should really make a full-length movie based on that story.
TheMoviesFanatic 4 months ago
Beautiful
TheDMart93 5 months ago
Profoundly moving, I cried.
EdLoveFilms 5 months ago
@ferreirafsa That is an insult to homosexuals, who were also killed and prosecuted by Nazi's. I hope you thought about that before you laid your hands on the keyboard to type. That is the same as saying they were "repressed Jews."
Chasatani 5 months ago
I cried
TwixSaer 5 months ago
Nazis are nothing but repressed homosesuals.
ferreirafsa 5 months ago
Amazing.
practicalwhacktical 5 months ago
beaultifull
Vilelinhaaa 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What IS the difference between what Anti-racists say about white people and what Hitler said about Jews?
Anti-racists/Hitler say, The Jews or whites are especially evil.
nti-racists/Hitler say, whites or the Jews are purely exploiters of others.
Anti-racist is a code word for anti-white.
Veritatis61 5 months ago
Man this was incredible. When I heard about the contest I thought about how much they wouldn't be able to say but what really blew me away was how much they could say without any words at all.
spartanman123 5 months ago 9
@spartanman123
Soooo true!!! That's the magic of film making.
LaMilby 5 months ago
I like this, giving the lines they had to use it was creative.
mysticwave 5 months ago
I like this, giving the lines they had to use it was creative.
mysticwave 5 months ago
Neil Strauss aka Style posted this on facebook so I checked it out. Very creative!
smo1765 5 months ago
Silly Germans, always starting world wars and losing. At least their music is decent.
TheREALDanontheMoon 5 months ago
AWESOME!
jozilife 5 months ago
Why the frick is a 8year old boyscout wearin a lighter? lots of herb in germany
ankslajna 5 months ago
Artfully made bit of anti-White propaganda.
Veritatis61 5 months ago
@Veritatis61 All white people are nazis? Fuck you. Everyone in this flick is white.
TheREALDanontheMoon 5 months ago
wow.... amazing story telling with so few words
chills up my spine
dman3334 5 months ago
Amazing Story
I'm so glad that they all survived.
qoohome2007 5 months ago 2
You can say a lot without words :)
her003 5 months ago
Beautifully done! The entrants in this competition "Tell It Your Way" were restricted to six lines of dialogue........but oh what a story this tells!
priceles0718 5 months ago
This is truly one beautiful short cinema piece.
ErickHatesYou 5 months ago
Made me cry...ahhhhhh!
basicbear2 6 months ago
This gave me shivers.. Simply amazing.
DirtyJewbz 6 months ago
Goosebumps..........
cbitner1 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!!!!!!
TheDonnaz 6 months ago
Cool! :o)
LukasVideosify 6 months ago
I honestly cried.
kitsunegirl14 6 months ago
BEAUTIFUL!
Nor1961 6 months ago
had to watch this the second timeeeeeeee
T3hTroll 6 months ago
This is a beautiful video. It captures the innocence of children even in horrific circumstances. My prayer for all of us is that we would have compassion for each other and seek to love our neighbors as ourselves. May G-d Bless all of us who were affected by WWII. I pray for the holocaust survivors who are still suffering from the torture they received that G-d will give them a great reward both now and in the next life. Paul Moore Host and moderator of Your Guide to a Happy Life.
pchalmersmoore 6 months ago 21
incredible film
TheAshesAreFalling 6 months ago
So beautiful... I had tears in my eyes by the end.
MissLynx 6 months ago
AMAZING...
Joao1234lsd 6 months ago
Superb - a heart warming and positive story. We need more of this humanity in everyday life.
pippahogan 6 months ago
A beautiful story. thank you
audreysim1 6 months ago
Wow.
djposhea 6 months ago
Thank you for telling a story through eyes and lens and heart. You remind us that hate may crush us, but love can repair the past. The 716 woman in Auschwitz would have cheered your vision, for she often said, "I do not hate. To hate is to let Hitler win."
renaspromise 6 months ago
Beautiful!
73tubedude 6 months ago
I am so moved by this. Brilliant. Words so often get in the way.
mnemko 6 months ago
is this UP 2 ?
anythinggoesjoe 6 months ago
Someone just sent me this at work...now I'm crying at work...
hosersupreme 6 months ago
wow. That was amazing. Great work!
C1MM3R1AN 6 months ago
I've watched a 3 hour film and experienced less emotion. There was no need for the Jewish Nazi point - this would be moving whatver the belief system portrayed. Beautifully made.
AGR281HR 6 months ago
Nitpick: Doesn't the caption "Germany, 1943" count as a line? And how can "Get away, get away" count as a single line of dialog when it's in two separate shots of the scene? I would have scored this as eight lines.
rpresser 6 months ago
@rpresser Depends on the specificity of the rules. If they only allow those six lines of spoken dialogue the caption would be fine. Also I don't know if they had to use exactly six lines and those were them or if they had to use those lines but not necessarily once each.
spartanman123 5 months ago
@spartanman123 they could only use 6 lines and each one was given to them "get away. Get away." was one line btw
Catmonk201 5 months ago
@Catmonk201 Ok did some further research on the contest. The only two rules were it had to be the same six lines of dialogue that Philips Cinema used in their parallel lines project. I'll assume that means they can use the same line again because in The Gift, which was part of the project they also use get away twice. And as for the caption it says six lines of dialogue and that isn't dialogue. The other rule being the films had to be 3 minutes or less so obviously not relevant.
spartanman123 5 months ago
@spartanman123 thats because get away get away ws the line not get away was being used twice
Catmonk201 5 months ago
beautiful!
esjeprinsesje88 6 months ago
59 persons are heartless or neo-nazis
adonfffcom 6 months ago
Apparently can't type either. Too much emotion right now.
Had to watch it a second time. Couldn't see that well through all the tears the first time.
yuxiaobi 6 months ago
Had to it a second time. Couldn't see that well through all the tears the first time.
yuxiaobi 6 months ago
i'm speechless.
LoveBugx11 6 months ago
Awesome!!
topsoulinbox 6 months ago
Wow.. so powerful
asiegel1202 6 months ago
Amazing.
CDaveHarvey 6 months ago
This was stunning and emotional.
MusicofGreen 6 months ago
Even though the German didn´t sound so well, this short film was just wonderfull
I had tears in my eyes at the end of the video
Carnivoira 6 months ago
great movie, but the germans dont sound real german they sound more like americans, that try to speak german
bra2210 6 months ago
That was an amazing short movie
SeanGordonXRX 6 months ago
PONIES
GiromCalica 6 months ago
Clad to be a jew
TheWaluigiman1 6 months ago
at first i thought they were speaking japanese. well, it's probably because i'm german. so much cliché in so little time ... but seeing it from the cinematic point of view it was just wonderful with very few words. i also thought the accents were adorable. :D especially the girl's one. aaaw. :)
FancyChaos 6 months ago
@FancyChaos Well, I'm a German who speaks Japanese fluently (Level 2 according to the Japanese Proficiency Test) and can assure you that it doesn't sound like Japanese at all. And no, the German spoken in this little jewel of a film doesn't sound that bad at all. Yes, for Germans it is obvious that those people aren't German, but it sounds much better than in many American movies I've watched so far (and that were many). If our spoken English sounds like that I'd be happy indeed.
comen83 5 months ago
Wonderful. So much said with so few words.
lkspin 7 months ago
Hitler - the very first modern Brony.
BoogsterSU2 7 months ago
Very moving and inspiring reminder of the good in everyone in us.
jlophil 7 months ago
Youtube Godwin's law violation #222,542, 381
Fail.
Pangolinx1 7 months ago
ending was a little hokey, due to poor music choice
pizzathehut488 7 months ago
wow
classickjr 7 months ago
This made me crie! For me the most sad part is that all that hate and pain was true
Hellendeppsptfan 7 months ago
This is absolutely spectacular.
ThanatosInc 7 months ago
such a touching concept for a video
lazarra101 7 months ago
That made me cry...........
phobercrar 7 months ago 34
This gave me goosebumps.
PRoDiiGYox 7 months ago 21
I love this!!!! Does anyone know what camera was used?
mochajim1 7 months ago
Oh....oh my....I'm speechless, and tearing up. Amazing...
tehutika 7 months ago
wow. this made me cry. heartfelt man..
BloodyCatastrophee 7 months ago
very well filmed. congrats.
trTfecta 7 months ago
To all the people that complained about the German "accuracy", maybe you should have donated thousands of dollars to the filmmaker, so he could have flown "real" Germans to the U.S., and put them up for a week during filming, or paid for the crew to go to Germany, for more "location/accent accuracy".
Be REAL people!! Did you "GET" what was going on in the film?!?!
I thought so: Then it did it's job fine..
TheNeoamor 7 months ago 3
I think the thing I find most ridiculous about this film is most of the other canidates were probably shot by amateurs and low budget film makers… this film was clearly shot by an already employed film maker with a very expensive camera..infact google says he is an established director AND producer…way to shit on the little guys buddy
FernandoLuis191 7 months ago
@FernandoLuis191 lol no he's not. he's small time. i just googled him.
rOmeVERoNe 7 months ago
amazing!
ThePivotPirate 7 months ago
@Krissnix Firefox + AdBlock + NoScript - Go Fight Win
BurninFingerTipz 7 months ago
pretty amazing for just three minutes.
allbn 7 months ago
cheeesy
Dpesh7 7 months ago
It's not a "cute story". It's a heartfelt portrayal of unselfish empathy and compassion for another human being. It can apply to any ethnic group, any language, any time. We can be "that boy" to someone else - what is wrong with that message?
thevmomster 7 months ago
53 people who disliked this are heartless.
Bluelantern 7 months ago
@Bluelantern -- "They have neither head nor heart." -- Nietzsche
htwhyppe 6 months ago
@htwhyppe sympathy is a weakness according to Nietzsche so your comment makes NO SENSE
OZDE32 6 months ago
And seriously how can you dislike this?!
Squigglez89 7 months ago
Fantastic !
Squigglez89 7 months ago
poetry in motion.
mw2havoc 7 months ago
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW
The000URBANSHADOW 7 months ago
And so it goes on.
cherrywest1 7 months ago
woah.
SoBeIt1454 7 months ago
Philips ran a contest called Parallel Lines in which they asked people to create a three-minute short film using only six lines of dialogue: :”What is that?”, “It’s a unicorn”, “Never seen one up close before”, “Beautiful”, “Get away, get away”, and “I’m sorry”. After more than 600 entries were submitted, director Ridley Scott selected the above film, titled “Porcelain Unicorn”, as the winner.
kakashikakashisensei 7 months ago
That was incredible. I'm in tears right now </3 Thank you so much!
murtwcullen964life 7 months ago
chills
jessayrocksout 7 months ago
Quite possible one of the most beautiful short films I have ever watched! Kudos to all involved with the making of this film :))))))
ChristopherNetanyahu 7 months ago
This was amazing. Thank you.
mishakaz 7 months ago 2
i'm crying. this was beautiful.
polyesterwindow 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
pathetic! how can ppl buy this shit!
Aalarikk 7 months ago
they shouldnt have talked at all, the very bad german ruins the movie for everyone who can speak german.
molbac 7 months ago
excelente
superfedex14 7 months ago
oh my god x.xxxxxxxxxxxxFUCKING
AMAZING
T3hTroll 7 months ago
Entrants in the Philips-sponsored constrained cinema competition Tell It Your Way were restricted to just six lines of dialogue: “What is that?,” “It’s a unicorn,” “Never seen one up close before,” “Beautiful,” “Get away, get away,” and “I’m sorry.”
Keegan Wilcox’s stunning Porcelain Unicorn was hand-picked as the Grand Prize Winner by director Ridley Scott( via +Tabitha O'Melay)
cyberdoyle 7 months ago 64
What's German for, "You did a shitty job of putting this back together?"
utahphunk 7 months ago
Wow, that was wonderfully done.
ErichoTTA 7 months ago
I'm the kind of person that loves short films and movies about explosions and shooting and guns and killing...but I do have a soft side, and this touched it.
shupea18 7 months ago
There should be more videos like this on Youtube. It's just breathtaking
Uzuchihua 7 months ago 2
I wish more people would immediately thumbs-down ANY comment they see asking for thumbs up, or discussing the number of people who disliked the video. We can all see that, and have no reason to validate you. Let ACTUAL comments get the thumbs.
fuduzan5562 7 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wtf is this? it's so cliche and corny.
Retardid 7 months ago
its really nice but sad that they try to speak german if they are not german. me, as a native german, hears that... it would be okay if they speak english, but for me it destroys the feeling a bit...
TheMcSaf 7 months ago 2
50 nazifucktards arround here…
0xAFFE 7 months ago
Whatever. I thought it was great.
BrickNazi 7 months ago
So were 48 people mad that hitler lost the war?
PhillipBroussard 7 months ago 2
1)Unicorn
2)Jews
3)Spielberg
Watch Tintin
boutousique 7 months ago
@Dalmos85 Bravo ! It's encouraging to see that now and again intelligent and sensitive people also make comments..
lechami49 7 months ago
Awesome. Very well done! :-)
Punterfpc 7 months ago
@Dalmos85 My sentiments exactly.
TheMarcoEsquandolas 7 months ago
The predictability of Nazi/Third Reich films winning prizes is a total blow to real creativity and contemporary style and content in cinema. Even if well ment and well done, this can only be called exploitation.
Not only is the spoken language hardly recognisable as German, but this is another example of a reproduction of cultural and historical stereotypes for the sake of instant emotion that wears off quickly and leaves a bad hang over of shallowness.
Daimos85 7 months ago
@Daimos85 We should never have enough of this films, for the eternity, so this would never happen again! Go cry to Auschwitz!
kurwinsky 7 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@kurwinsky I really wonder if you actually believe that a three minute short film full of historical and cultural inaccuracies (costumes, language, locations, etc.) can keep the memories of the horrifiying events in Auschwitz alive...
Only education and actual historical documents can help to never forget. I don't need a bad short film to remember what happenend during WWII.
Daimos85 7 months ago
@Daimos85 What does an accurate costume makes for a difference in a mass murder situation? It´s not about acting nor costumes my dear, your just sad!
kurwinsky 7 months ago
@kurwinsky You are again mixing up my formal criticism of a 3 minute short film made in 2011 with actual historical events.
But if you like to go down that road, I will tell you the difference: The (at least) 6 million victims of the holocaust didn't wear costumes, weren't actors and were not Americans. To them it would be sheer mockery, if they had known that some 70 years later a bunch of young Americans use their actual suffering and exploit and distort it for a cute story in a short film!
Daimos85 7 months ago
Propaganda films are so much fun!
MrSammo1 7 months ago