Bach - Concerto for Two Violins in D Minor BWV 1043 Part 2. (3rd mvt.)

[aryamanstefan]

tämmlich fix - oh - assai speedamente, I like it slower - may be because I´m so old.

[masterymany]

increhible!

[robynsalain]

de l'émotion à l'état pur !

[GokanTube]

Creo la mujer toca mucho mejor que el hombre, supongo que tiene el segundo violín por sun propia elección.

[hommefriday]

Katica is amazing!! Just listen to her playing "Four Brothers"

[danielbtwd]

play it PROPERLY this is a pure genius piece of music by Bach but it changes key. Wow they can play the first half woopy! and we all watch this and think ok. If you are going to copy a master do it right!!!!!!!!

[soulechene]

magnifique, quel enthousiasme de la part des interprètes

[TuriTiago]

Beautiful!

[Tom1Stein]

This look like Katica Illenyi - but it sounds awful.

[Ticklishlittlefellow]

Favorite classical piece!!

[mjb565656]

Spirit is really great,the sound quality horribly bad! why???This music diserves  very much better

[eolianwold]

Why is it so hard to find small Baroque ensembles that have decent intonation...

[gerhold101]

Sincerely, for my own education, I'm intrigued by what you mean by the phrase "decent intonation". As a 'non-cognoscento' with regard to music and especially 'classical' music I'm nonplussed as to whether this is a negative or positive comment. The recording is dubious but that's not what you meant and the lack of a question mark indicates a rhetorical statement rather than an interrogative. Clarification - please...

[eolianwold]

Intonation is the ability of a musician to hit the note they intend to hit. Baroque groups often sound out of tune because they have picked a non-standard tuning in order to be more "authentic"; however, given the number of completely wrong notes in this recording, I think the performers here are just sloppy.

[gerhold101]

Thank you for your elucidation. To my untrained ear it sounded good, great even - but the music itself (I mean the score) is so emotionally moving that perhaps one's objectivity is compromised. This I guess is the disparity in perception between the cold, dispassionate critic and the aficionado. Had I gone to this concert I would have been absolutely happy with what I had heard and witnessed. Thank you again.

[Bartholomew75]

bach is is one of my favorite composers.

Abselutely amazing!

[kyuupii]

...and here it is...the 3rd and last movement of the BWV1043...I hope to hear this live sometimes during my life...

[OrianaDiazL]

I love it!!

[tievans1]

I really loved!!! The notes at 3:20 were straight from the heart, amazing.

[guirexyz]

Hard working Katica!

[octum]

the melody in :43 is just beautiful.

[opsasa]

This is not 1043 part 2. This is part 3.

[kovezett]

This is the 3rd movement and part 2 of the video. You can find the 1st and 2nd movements in part 1.

[opsasa]

Oh sorry. And thank you! :)

[Aresholewins]

can't u see (3rd mvt.)?

[opsasa]

that was written by sender after my message

[natzjustlookinaround]

this is definitely my favorite movement! AWSUM!

[johneleven25]

Awesome! Bravo!

[antw07Z]

Wow! this outstanding!!!!

[vitisfera]

delicious. bach would be proud

[whenultra]

Is it my speakers, or is there a watermark on this recording, very solid performance.

[phazon4]

can some tell me what position do they play in at 1.19 -1.31

and again at 3.47-4.00

please tell me if you can help thank you

[chidori8291]

I'm assuming maybe 3rd or 4th posistion, but I don't feel like sounding it out, hope it helps

[equineface]

Amazing.... Thanks soo much. Beautifully done:)

This will always be one of my favorites.... also love your jazzyviolin site, Katica. both of you are so gifted....

[75serendipity]

I'm sorry but I don't like it. There is no interpretation (only tecnique), a kind of individualism that is not the intent of a concert for "two violins"! I can ear also some resounding false notes. It's a group of sounds that are not the divine aim of every Bach's work. It's my opinion...

[degenericni]

Too much interpretationism destroys the integrity of the composition. Job of the player/performer is ONLY to present composers work. As great Richter said:"The interpreter is really an executant, carrying out the composer's intentions to the letter. He doesn't add anything that isn't already in the work."

And they did BRILLIANT job here.

[wcbroccoli]

This is fine, if you don't mind metal strings and heavy vibrato.

You have modern expectations of a concert performance, and you expect a live performance to have the engineered perfection of a recording.

In Bach's time, there was no quest for a definitive or personal "interpretation." There was no "divine aim."

It would have been more like what we'd call a "reading."

But we hear the same pieces again and again in recordings and concerts, so our expectations are higher.

[tsno13Z]

Thrilled. I thought they played this so well together, complementing each other perfectly.

[equineface]

Your performance gives the me the goose bumps! This was magnificent... truly amazing... very lovely! Thanks soo much I really enjoy this... Bach rocks my world!!!

[bernardocox2]

BOM!

[piricsiandi]

ki ez a ferfi?borzalmasan jatszik,borzalmas a jobb kez technikaja..

[Arpimagyar89]

Totál jó a jobb kéz tehnikája,maradj te a Joplinnál XD ,majd ha eljátszasz 1 Bramsz vonósnégyest ezen a zenei szinten mind ők,halgasd meg mégegyszer őket.

[piricsiandi]

majd ha megtanulsz helyesen irni,akkor kommentalj

[Arpimagyar89]

Az ember amikor folbaszódik akkor a helyesirásra nem nagyon figyel föl,különben nagyon is jól megértetted amit üzentem,a valaszod pedig csak annyit mutat h nekem van igazam.

[piricsiandi]

nem tudom mi a bajod van,miert kell felbaszodni azon ha nem ertek egyet veled? szerintem tenyleg szar a pasi,nezd meg mennyire mereven jatszik a jobb kezevel,vallbol huzza a vonot,olyan mintha cernaval rangatnak. Amugy a joplinos video nagyon regi es szorakozottan utcazeneltunk,nem szinpadon jatszottunk,es amator fenykepezogeppel.maradj te az okoskodasodnal,basztassal maokat es szallj le rolam.ja,es tanulj meg irni.

[piricsiandi]

ja,es hallgasd meg Perlmannal ezt!

[Arpimagyar89]

Még csak annnyi h,egész idő alatt csak ugrattalak : ) remélem h nem haragszol XD,nekem se tetszik h h játszanak,Üdv

[Arpimagyar89]

Totál jó a jobb kéz tehnikája,maradj te a Joplinnál XD ,majd ha eljátszasz 1 Bramsz vonósnégyest ezen a zenei szinten mind ők,halgasd meg mégegyszer őket.

[indigoblue555]

May I ask for a short translation of your debate ? I guess you're discussing this rendition.

Thx a lot.

[Gizmoenut]

I've seen a ballet using this music. It was excellent music, but with the dancing added...

OMG it was gorgeous

[orangelacko]

Nagy sz.. Kedves Illényi Katica...nem kéne égetni a magyar "komolyzanei" életet...vannak akik nem veszik észre, hogy amit bevállalnak az már sok...és messze nincs szon a színvonalon amin kéne lennie...szégyenletes....mint az Edwin Marton...csak olyan zenét kell játszani amit tudunk...amit nem tudunk azt meg kell hagyni másnak...van bőven aki százszor jobban lejátsza...

[tzuiop]

Ki lehet állni és eljátszani jobban, ha tudod! A Grapelliket is, megpróbálhatsz énekelni, táncolni is mellé! De mivel I.K. kívül nem csinál ilyet senki(legalábbis nem hallottam eddig),ezért kétlem, hogy menne neked, akkor meg?

[leg2107]

Bach Power!!!!!!!!!!

[BalletQueenA]

Amazing. I've been at this concerto and it's really nice to hear it again!

[cherifo83]

Nice, but the woman plays in a very different style (better than the guy in my opinion. Better articulation and respiration).

[theviolinist19]

lovely:)

[nomisichi]

it's very, very good !!!

[marianna48]

GRATULALOK!!!!!!!